E46 330ci Rough Idle Help
Discussion
Hi all,
Was wondering if anyone could help or point me in the right direction for the problem with my car. It's an E46 330ci facelift. I've had a rough idle for 2 weeks now. Upon first inspection I noticed a tear in the lower Boot intake so I had that changed. Still no luck and while the rough idle isn't as bad its still there. It drives fine under load however once off load the slight misfires occur.
My Mechanic read the codes and they are as follows:
P0304 - Cylinder 4 misfire detected
P0171 - System too lean bank 1
P0174 - System too lean bank 2
P1620 - Map cooling Thermostat control circuit signal high
Any ideas on what the cause could be? My Mechanic believes it could still be a vacuum leak judging by the codes and that fact he can hear an air leak noise around the throttle body intake. My suggestion was to take it apart to there and inspect for leaks. Any particular hoses to look for or areas a leak could develop?
Or could it be something different which is causing the problem?
Thanks in advance
Was wondering if anyone could help or point me in the right direction for the problem with my car. It's an E46 330ci facelift. I've had a rough idle for 2 weeks now. Upon first inspection I noticed a tear in the lower Boot intake so I had that changed. Still no luck and while the rough idle isn't as bad its still there. It drives fine under load however once off load the slight misfires occur.
My Mechanic read the codes and they are as follows:
P0304 - Cylinder 4 misfire detected
P0171 - System too lean bank 1
P0174 - System too lean bank 2
P1620 - Map cooling Thermostat control circuit signal high
Any ideas on what the cause could be? My Mechanic believes it could still be a vacuum leak judging by the codes and that fact he can hear an air leak noise around the throttle body intake. My suggestion was to take it apart to there and inspect for leaks. Any particular hoses to look for or areas a leak could develop?
Or could it be something different which is causing the problem?
Thanks in advance
Thanks Helix. Are the aftermarket Thermostat as good as the oem? I'm going to be selling the car as soon as it's fixed so as long as it doesn't die within a year I'll be happy. Do you think that misfire is related to the air leak or could it be separate?
Im going to assume that if the misfire code for cylinder 4 is present again when I take it back in that there may be an issue with coil pack or injector. And a air leak maybe another problem again. Or it could be a hose that feeds to cylinder 4 may be the fault. Im not aware of the engine set up after the throttle body intake. Any ideas if they are most likely related or separate?
I also have a heft oil leak around the front the engine, my Mechanic and I suspect it's the valve cover gasket that's leaking. Could if affect the misfire?
Im going to assume that if the misfire code for cylinder 4 is present again when I take it back in that there may be an issue with coil pack or injector. And a air leak maybe another problem again. Or it could be a hose that feeds to cylinder 4 may be the fault. Im not aware of the engine set up after the throttle body intake. Any ideas if they are most likely related or separate?
I also have a heft oil leak around the front the engine, my Mechanic and I suspect it's the valve cover gasket that's leaking. Could if affect the misfire?
Swap the coilpack on 4 with another cylinder and scan the codes again, obviously if it's moved that's your problem.
It's also worth checking both the intake boots removed from the car, mine looked fine on the car but had big splits only obvious when they had been removed.
As for the oil leak, could be rocker cover but if it's at the front of the engine could also be the oil filter housing.
It's also worth checking both the intake boots removed from the car, mine looked fine on the car but had big splits only obvious when they had been removed.
As for the oil leak, could be rocker cover but if it's at the front of the engine could also be the oil filter housing.
I had very similar symptoms/codes on my old 330 Ci, and it eventually got to the point where the car stalled when coasting towards junctions.
I found a massive split in the rubber ducting between the MAF and throttle body. You couldn't see it from a cursory glance, because it was on the underside. There are two bits of ducting that are joined together. There's a jubilee clip securing the actual join, and on mine, that was where the split was.
I found a massive split in the rubber ducting between the MAF and throttle body. You couldn't see it from a cursory glance, because it was on the underside. There are two bits of ducting that are joined together. There's a jubilee clip securing the actual join, and on mine, that was where the split was.
AB57 said:
Thanks Helix. Are the aftermarket Thermostat as good as the oem? I'm going to be selling the car as soon as it's fixed so as long as it doesn't die within a year I'll be happy. Do you think that misfire is related to the air leak or could it be separate?
Im going to assume that if the misfire code for cylinder 4 is present again when I take it back in that there may be an issue with coil pack or injector. And a air leak maybe another problem again. Or it could be a hose that feeds to cylinder 4 may be the fault. Im not aware of the engine set up after the throttle body intake. Any ideas if they are most likely related or separate?
I also have a heft oil leak around the front the engine, my Mechanic and I suspect it's the valve cover gasket that's leaking. Could if affect the misfire?
A lot of the pattern thermostats and poor, Mahle are good, it's actually a Behr thermostat in the box normally. The air leak and misfire will have separate causes.Im going to assume that if the misfire code for cylinder 4 is present again when I take it back in that there may be an issue with coil pack or injector. And a air leak maybe another problem again. Or it could be a hose that feeds to cylinder 4 may be the fault. Im not aware of the engine set up after the throttle body intake. Any ideas if they are most likely related or separate?
I also have a heft oil leak around the front the engine, my Mechanic and I suspect it's the valve cover gasket that's leaking. Could if affect the misfire?
Those lean codes suggest an air leak as well, OR the AFM's playing up.
Have you tried unplugging that and seeing if it still runs rough? if it smooths out, means the AFM's gunked up or dead, so worth trying to clean it up if there's gunk on the sensor wire inside.
As for the misfire, could be blown coil, best do as previously mentioned and see if it moves by swapping round from plug to plug and see if the fault moves with it. Though it maybe worth swapping all 6 considering one may be faulty (and if proven) the rest may well be not far off going as well.
Have you tried unplugging that and seeing if it still runs rough? if it smooths out, means the AFM's gunked up or dead, so worth trying to clean it up if there's gunk on the sensor wire inside.
As for the misfire, could be blown coil, best do as previously mentioned and see if it moves by swapping round from plug to plug and see if the fault moves with it. Though it maybe worth swapping all 6 considering one may be faulty (and if proven) the rest may well be not far off going as well.
Most likely a failed CCV system, need to replace the valve and the hoses (all underneath the intake manifold). Had this fail on a X3 before with the same symptoms (minus the thermostat code). Check the intake hose from the MAF to the Tb also, these are well known to get tears/holes in them over time.
Hi all,
Thanks for all the advice, it was much appreciated. After taking everything off it turns out it had a FUBAR DISA valve. The flap had sheered and was hanging on by a pin. A replacement one has been fitted, at an eye watering £250 part, and the engine is once again running silky smooth. In fact it's running better than when I first got it. I guess the next few days will be a test if anything has been missed. An initial test drive proved to be great. Now to deal with the thermostat!
Thanks for all the advice, it was much appreciated. After taking everything off it turns out it had a FUBAR DISA valve. The flap had sheered and was hanging on by a pin. A replacement one has been fitted, at an eye watering £250 part, and the engine is once again running silky smooth. In fact it's running better than when I first got it. I guess the next few days will be a test if anything has been missed. An initial test drive proved to be great. Now to deal with the thermostat!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



