M140i with no RWD experience?
M140i with no RWD experience?
Author
Discussion

badgerbank

Original Poster:

5 posts

188 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
Hi All.

I'm looking at changing my Cooper S to something a bit more practical, with 5 doors, and have pretty much narrowed things down to the M140i and the Golf R. I haven't driven either yet, but I seem to be leaning towards the 140i as being slightly more "special" (or as special as a 5 door hatch can be).

The one thing that gives me pause is that everything I've owned to date, including my track car, has been FWD. Although I've a reasonable idea of what I'm doing in a FWD car, I'm by no means a driving god and wonder about how much trouble I could get into being a bit ham fisted/lead footed in the wrong conditions.

Am I overthinking this (it is after all a mainstream hatch with all the stability bells and whistles) or do 135's and 140's have the potential to get a bit feisty in the wet? Looking for a bit of advice from those who owned/driven them.

Krisj88

25 posts

142 months

Sunday 2nd October 2016
quotequote all
Check out centralukvehicleleasing.co.uk. They're the cheapest on the net for both cars you're interested in. I've got a Golf R at the moment and have ordered a 5dr M140i. The golf is a great car. Fast, practical and fun but, it's only fun when you're driving in the lanes above "acceptable" speeds. It's grip is awesome!! But you can get it sideways when the traction control is completely turned off. The interior quality is slightly better than the BMW in my opinion but to be honest the exhaust note compared to the BMW is st. Especially that horrible dsg fart. Go for a manual on the golf. It makes it more involving. Either car you go for will be good no doubt. Test drive both and see what suits you mate

MikeTFSI

6,091 posts

133 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
High power RWD is not a problem unless you make it one. Get to the know the car before pushing it too hard and you will be fine. The stability control is excellent on these cars.

I have sat in both a m135i and a golf R and much preferred the BMW inside. I found the Golf to be 'just a Golf', pleasant with quality materials etc, but not really special. The BMW was a bit different and the idrive system is much better when driving than a touch screen.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
I had an extended test drive of M135i, when they came out; I already had RWD but it in a old 325, so hardly comparable on power, and didn't find it a problem in the wet.
I then bought a 335i and didn't find that big leap in power caused me any problems in icy mountain conditions, you name it.

I actually had a drive in Mini Cooper S, the other day - it was probably my first experience in a fast FWD car and I did find it very different to a RWD car. I hated it, really much prefer RWD but I soon managed the differences and I'm sure you will too. Don't worry aboutit , just be sensible to sarts as MikeTFSI said.

I have never driven a Golf, but read only awesome things about the 40i engine, in all iterations, 1,2,3,4 so a good choice. The face-lifted 1'er also looks so much better than the car I drove wink

Maxf

8,444 posts

272 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
You'll be fine - the first 1200 miles should be under 4500 rpm anyway, and not under full load - so you've got a while to get used to it!

The biggest danger is crashing while you're playing around with the idrive!

Just dont turn the traction off for a while and try to never say 'watch this'!

5678

6,146 posts

258 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
I've got a 135i and you'll be fine as long as you don't drive like a dick.

The traction control is pretty good. Kicks in nice and early and won't let you put too much power down. The DSC mode is good and allows a bit of slip before calming things down too.

nickfrog

25,471 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
The M140i is set up to understeer, like most road cars. It even push understeers under a moderate throttle.

Only brutal on/off use of the throttle with a bit of lock on will break traction, which will usually be caught by the "electronic crutches".