Servicing Options
Servicing Options
Author
Discussion

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
So my BMW 320d - F30 is coming has done about 65k and coming up for a 4th service

Previously, up until the 3rd service I had a BMW service pack, but sadly that option is no longer available

I have been quoted upwards of £400 by main dealer

My local garage quoted me £120 but when I suggested I want to use BMW original stuff, the cost of the oil, filters etc alone is about £250

What would be the best option? The car is no longer under BMW warranty but I do have a warrantydirect warranty.

If I were to opt for the "OEM' option would it affect the warranty or the car in general

Any advice would be most helpful


Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
If the dealer is quoting £400 versus £120 at a local place then the local place hasn't worked out that the car is on the cycle whereby it now needs more than just the oil service.

This is the issue with random places, they seem to have little interest in finding out what the car is actually due.

bitchstewie

68,496 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
goodfella7777 said:
What would be the best option?
Have you tried an independent BMW specialist?

Shaoxter

4,617 posts

155 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
goodfella7777 said:
My local garage quoted me £120 but when I suggested I want to use BMW original stuff, the cost of the oil, filters etc alone is about £250
Lol...

MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
Did you look at the cost of the BMW/Mondial warranty before paying for the Warranty Direct "warranty"?

pattyg

1,385 posts

258 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
Problem with CBS is you don't know exactly what needs replacing until you go to BMW. On my E90 it showed oil service so I booked it in for a basic oil service. When the key was read it needed all filters replaced etc. and having looked at my service book it had been a few services since those were done. As an F30 owner you wont have access to a service book so will have no idea what is actually due.

That may well account for a vast difference in quote.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
pattyg said:
Problem with CBS is you don't know exactly what needs replacing until you go to BMW.
Yes you do - it still follows a schedule. For an F30 for example, every second oil service is air and fuel filter, too.

pattyg said:
On my E90 it showed oil service so I booked it in for a basic oil service. When the key was read it needed all filters replaced etc. and having looked at my service book it had been a few services since those were done.
Exactly, I think it's every 3 on the E90.

pattyg said:
As an F30 owner you wont have access to a service book so will have no idea what is actually due.
You simply go into iDrive, view service history and it's all there for you explaining exactly what has been done allowing you to know whats needed next time.

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
Did you look at the cost of the BMW/Mondial warranty before paying for the Warranty Direct "warranty"?
Yea, Mondial was coming out to be too expensive.

I paid about £400 for a fully comprehensive warranty - no excess, with any work to be done at the main dealer. Like for like mondial was twice as expensive. apparently if you go over 60k mileage, the premium goes up exponentially

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
pattyg said:
Problem with CBS is you don't know exactly what needs replacing until you go to BMW. On my E90 it showed oil service so I booked it in for a basic oil service. When the key was read it needed all filters replaced etc. and having looked at my service book it had been a few services since those were done. As an F30 owner you wont have access to a service book so will have no idea what is actually due.

That may well account for a vast difference in quote.
I do have a good idea, it will need all the filters changed, so its quite expensive

The thing is, even if I use an independent garage the cost of the consumables ( original BMW) alone is a massive £240.

So If someone wants to use original consumables, there is little point using an independent garage as the cost differential is minimal.

Shaoxter

4,617 posts

155 months

Thursday 6th October 2016
quotequote all
goodfella7777 said:
The thing is, even if I use an independent garage the cost of the consumables ( original BMW) alone is a massive £240.

So If someone wants to use original consumables, there is little point using an independent garage as the cost differential is minimal.
There's no such thing as "original BMW" oil, they don't manufacture their own oil or filters. Check what the OEM oil is and buy it from Eurocarparts, Opie etc.
BMW branded oil from the dealer is the same oil with a BMW sticker and 100% markup.

ninjag

1,985 posts

150 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
I've always found it strange how having a main dealer service history is meant to be better towards the value of the car in so many buyers eyes. In my experience main dealers are the worst at maintaining your car.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Whereabouts in the "north west" are you? I know of two very good independent BMW specialists in the Warrington/Widnes area.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
ninjag said:
I've always found it strange how having a main dealer service history is meant to be better towards the value of the car in so many buyers eyes. In my experience main dealers are the worst at maintaining your car.
All garages are highly variable - including main dealers.

What dealer history does is give the impression that when maintaining the car, saving money was not priority 1. The percentage of people who elect to choose a 'specialist' because they know them, trust them and realise the work they do is of greater quality than anyone else they've found is negligible compared to the percentage of those who do so because they want to pay as little money as they can to maintain the car.

These percentages on a forum like this will be reversed - many people here will pick a specialist because they believe they'll do a better job - but this isn't representative of the car market as a whole.

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
Whereabouts in the "north west" are you? I know of two very good independent BMW specialists in the Warrington/Widnes area.
Im in manchester/ salford quays so not too far from warrington

Any recommendations would be helpful

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
goodfella7777 said:
Im in manchester/ salford quays so not too far from warrington

Any recommendations would be helpful
David Paul (http://davidpaulofwarrington.co.uk/) and Graham Martin (http://grahammartinautomotive.co.uk/)

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
My wife's leased F30 330d went back in June having been serviced twice by the local garage - not BMW specialist.
Brake pads changed, oil service and brake fluid change.
This worked out much cheaper and also because BMW couldn't book it in for 2 weeks.
They updated the car's computer and the lease company had no issue with it.

That car was still on the AUC site at Barons last week.

Swervin_Mervin

5,013 posts

269 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
goodfella7777 said:
Im in manchester/ salford quays so not too far from warrington

Any recommendations would be helpful
David Paul (http://davidpaulofwarrington.co.uk/) and Graham Martin (http://grahammartinautomotive.co.uk/)
Or Darren Wood in Bredbury. http://www.darren-wood.com/

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
David Paul (http://davidpaulofwarrington.co.uk/) and Graham Martin (http://grahammartinautomotive.co.uk/)
thank you

goodfella7777

Original Poster:

52 posts

157 months

Friday 7th October 2016
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
Or Darren Wood in Bredbury. http://www.darren-wood.com/
thanks