X3 35d or 30d
X3 35d or 30d
Author
Discussion

Freds

Original Poster:

947 posts

168 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
A pal of mine is going road testing one each of the above, a 2016 X3 35d and also a 30d. Unfortunately I haven't the time to take him up on his offer of going with him.
I'm curious as to the real world performance difference the 50+ hp makes as both cars are identical specs but the 35d is £ 3.5k more money. Has anybody experience of both ?

Wiggwam

92 posts

232 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
I have just taken delivery of an X3 35D and have test driven the 30D. To be honest the 30D is plenty quick enough for real world driving, but coming from an M135i and a Z4mc, was a bit underwhelming. The 35D is comically quick for an SUV and feels much quicker than the 30D and that is with just 200 miles on the clock for the 35D, compared with c.5000 miles for the 30D I test drove, so this is likely to become even more apparent. We had to 'upscale' our mode of transport as expecting our second child and whilst the 30D was perfectly capable, the 35D does make me chuckle when fully lit, which i was not expecting..! The engine is also a lot more responsive. Fuel consumption is similar for both in the real world.

So in summary, if you want a 'sensible car' that will put a smile on your face the 35D should tick that box, the 30D is 'just' a perfectly capable car and all you really need. Depending on how you are purchasing, i found the extra residual value of the 35D meant the monthly payments weren't that far apart, so became a no brainier.

Hope that helps.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
Having a fair bit of experience with both the 30d and 35d engines in various BMWs, I agree with Wiggwam. The key difference to me is low in the rev range where the 35d feels a great deal more lively. To me it behaves like a very large petrol engine with torque available from 1000 rpm, whereas the 30d needs the revs to rise before the single turbo spools up. At the top end the 35d keeps pulling to higher revs too, which again makes it more petrol-like.

They are both excellent engines, and are very smooth. I'm sure it would be quite possible not to notice whether it was a 30d or 35d under the bonnet when driving in a relaxed way. When pressing on, the difference becomes quite apparent.

On a forum like Pistonheads, I can't imagine many recommending you go for the lower power option wink

Freds

Original Poster:

947 posts

168 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the quick and informative responses, he actually called me 10 minutes ago and has bought the 35d, he said it put a smile on his face so it must be impressive, he's a miserable chuff at the best of times. Will look forward to a ride out in it now smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 13th October 2016
quotequote all
Very much the correct decision, and I say that as a 30d driver biggrin