Is it really worth ditching RFT to improve ride quality?
Is it really worth ditching RFT to improve ride quality?
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
I'm interested to hear anyone's experience with this? Some people say run flats are much improved on the earlier ones but I'm just not convinced.

I got a new X3 30d back in May. I deliberately chose non-Msport trim and 18" wheels for comfort as I cover 80 miles a day on some pretty poor roads. I find the ride quality... just about acceptable but not as good as I'd hoped. I also don't know if it's my imagination but it seems to be worse now that the tyres have covered nearly 10k miles. The car soaks up potholes and major bumps just fine but on the motorway it feels a bit 'twitchy', it tramlines, and I seem to feel every road imperfection.

It's got the standard Pirelli Cinturato P7 245/50R18s. I'm happy with the level of grip and wear rate (loads of tread left) but will changing to a traditional non-RFT make a worthwhile difference to the ride/drive of the car? I'm considering something like Goodyear Eagle F1s.

Any advice appreciated.


ryallm

114 posts

259 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
Yes, it definitely is. The standard Bridgestone run flats on my F31 are nothing like as bad as the earlier generation of runflats I had on my E91, but the car is till nicer to drive on standard tyres - improved ride certainly, but the biggest benefit for me is much reduced road noise on coarse surfaces.

aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
Sidewalls are just too stiff with the RFT's even the newer gen ones.....as the extra thickness and strong sidewall construction is what is required for them to work as run-flat's.

You have to decide which is of the greater benefit to you, RFT tech in an emergency or comfort/road manner/NVH etc...?

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
Im on Normal Michelin PS3 and they are night and day compared to the Bridgstones that were fitted when I boutght it in 2014 however with the miles I do I am going to try these newest generation see how they go http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/Bridgestone-D...

Edited by smashy on Friday 28th October 21:18

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

187 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
In my experience, it's now quite marginal.

Latest gen of RFTs have come on a long way from the ghastly rubber found on BMWs a decade ago.

I wouldn't look to swap given the safety benefits of RFTs.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
My winters are 20" RFT, Summers are non RFT. I don' t look forward to winter...

Every RFT equipped BMW I have had, has seen them binned for a better ride.

ds666

3,185 posts

210 months

Friday 28th October 2016
quotequote all
I couldn't wait to ditch the run flats on the wife's 135 convertible (2008) but on my most recent car (335d) with them they don't seem half as bad as they used to . No back to back comparison to refer to but the current pirelli p zeros feel fine to me . They must have improved over the years because they used to be really bad .

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
Firstly don't ditch the tyres you have on until it is time to change be it age/perishing or tread depth wear.

Secondly as new cars don't have spare wheels don't discount the benefit of being able to drive home (@50mph). I've only had one tyre blow out in the last decade (touch wood) but that time of year and the terrible traffic meant I was stood at the side of the motorway for 3hours freezing cold and raining.
Also a benefit of you've kids in he car too sitting waiting for hours will be a nightmare.
If a non run flat blows out it could cause an accident a run flat will cause no issues.

Duration I used to think they lasted less than non run flat that's not the case as I'm finding out.

Tyre noise IMHO is indifferent.

Stopping and lateral G seem very similar

Cost is more, but I value that added safety and being able to drive it to safety

abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
On 50 profile tyres, it might not make such a difference.

I got shot of my runflats on the E90 330i due to too many punctures. For some reason they seem to puncture really easily. I got three punctures within a year on the Bridgestone RFT tyres. Pretty much zero on previous cars and none on the 330 in the five years that follows (on conventional rubber). This seems to be a common thing, not sure why.

The ride was massively improved, quieter too and much better traction over sharp bumps / ridges in the road. Big improvement on that generation of BMWs anyway.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
abarber said:
On 50 profile tyres, it might not make such a difference.

I got shot of my runflats on the E90 330i due to too many punctures. For some reason they seem to puncture really easily. I got three punctures within a year on the Bridgestone RFT tyres. Pretty much zero on previous cars and none on the 330 in the five years that follows (on conventional rubber). This seems to be a common thing, not sure why.

The ride was massively improved, quieter too and much better traction over sharp bumps / ridges in the road. Big improvement on that generation of BMWs anyway.
Mine are 35 & 45 profile RFT.

abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
40 and 35 profile on my 330i E90 with the factory 18" wheels.

Speed addicted

6,336 posts

258 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
Changing to normal tyres certainly improved the ride quality on my 645 as well as making it a lot less fidgety on small imperfections. I noticed that traction was improved, but that may have been old tyres vs new ones.

I carry the BMW inflation kit (compressor and goo) that should be enough to fix most things the runflat would have dealt with.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
Changing to normal tyres certainly improved the ride quality on my 645 as well as making it a lot less fidgety on small imperfections. I noticed that traction was improved, but that may have been old tyres vs new ones.

I carry the BMW inflation kit (compressor and goo) that should be enough to fix most things the runflat would have dealt with.
This is the odd thing - in 30k with the 535d not once on the road have I had traction loss. I did get stuck in the mud at a campsite and needed 4 hotties to help push me out.

XMT

3,948 posts

178 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
Helicopter123 said:
In my experience, it's now quite marginal.

Latest gen of RFTs have come on a long way from the ghastly rubber found on BMWs a decade ago.

I wouldn't look to swap given the safety benefits of RFTs.
I would agree with this.
I have had a e90 2009, e92 2012, F10 2011 and currently have F30 2015 and e93 2011

Older gen run flats really were harsh the newer ones are much much better - further to this it depends on the brand and what version you have of their RFT.

the E90 period stuff with the low profile 30 sidewalls is actually quite bad. The F30 and F10 I had were very good.

Same as others the added safety of them should not be overlooked or sniggered.

Edited by XMT on Saturday 29th October 21:04

rayyan171

1,298 posts

124 months

Saturday 29th October 2016
quotequote all
xDrive on the X3 is permanent all wheel drive, so good tyres should be used. Previous owner of my car complained of lots of grumbling coming from the car (X5) when he put standard tyres on. He ended up returning to star-marked run-flat tyres before we bought, which was a good idea as the car makes no bad noises when moving.

I have heard of transfer box issues from not using star-marked tyres, but I can't be certain. Our X5 does run on 20" RFT's with M-sport suspension and while you can feel every single bump on the road it is a very good ride when at reasonable speeds.

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Friday 4th November 2016
quotequote all
abarber said:
On 50 profile tyres, it might not make such a difference.

I got shot of my runflats on the E90 330i due to too many punctures. For some reason they seem to puncture really easily. I got three punctures within a year on the Bridgestone RFT tyres. Pretty much zero on previous cars and none on the 330 in the five years that follows (on conventional rubber). This seems to be a common thing, not sure why.

The ride was massively improved, quieter too and much better traction over sharp bumps / ridges in the road. Big improvement on that generation of BMWs anyway.
Odd you mention this as my wife had endless punctures in her run-flat equipped E92, plus the fact that the ride was hideously hard. Hitting even a small pothole felt like it had ripped the wheel off! Swapped to normal Contis and not a peep in four years, plus it drives like a different car. I recall a thread on here where for no good reason, anecdotally it seemed that run flats sucked up more nails and screws than normal tyres.

FordMadAndy

18 posts

120 months

Friday 4th November 2016
quotequote all
I have had 3 BMW's in the last 3 years all had a different make of RFT

2014 420d Bridgestone on 18's
2015 318d Conti on 18's
2016 440i Goodyear on 19's

I read a lot about how noisy they are and the ride is rubbish bla bla bla.......

They are noisy depending on the road surface, but I would say they are only marginally noisier than normal tyres, ride comfort is horse for courses, personally if you have an m-sport without adaptive suspension then it can be a bit choppy on bad roads but I dont think its all down to the tyres, my current car feels really good in comfort and ecopro and whenI feel like putting my foot down through the twistys then it feels great in sport mode but it has never felt uncomfortable.

As I said its horses for courses.

final thought, adaptive suspension does make a difference and if I buy another beemer it will be an option I would go for.

FordMadAndy

18 posts

120 months

Friday 4th November 2016
quotequote all
I have had 3 BMW's in the last 3 years all had a different makes of RFT

2014 420d Bridgestone on 18's
2015 318d Conti on 18's
2016 440i Goodyear on 19's


They are noisy depending on the road surface, but I would say they are only marginally noisier than normal tyres, ride comfort is horse for courses, personally if you have an m-sport without adaptive suspension then it can be a bit choppy on bad roads but I dont think its all down to the tyres, my current car feels really good in comfort and ecopro and when I feel like putting my foot down through the twistys then it feels great in sport mode but it has never felt uncomfortable.

As I said its horses for courses.

final thought, adaptive suspension does make a difference and if I buy another beemer it will be an option I would go for.

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

187 months

Friday 4th November 2016
quotequote all
FordMadAndy said:
final thought, adaptive suspension does make a difference and if I buy another beemer it will be an option I would go for.
+1

This now makes a bigger difference than ditching the RFTs IMO.

JMBMWM5

2,409 posts

229 months

Friday 4th November 2016
quotequote all
Sten. said:
I'm interested to hear anyone's experience with this? Some people say run flats are much improved on the earlier ones but I'm just not convinced.

I got a new X3 30d back in May. I deliberately chose non-Msport trim and 18" wheels for comfort as I cover 80 miles a day on some pretty poor roads. I find the ride quality... just about acceptable but not as good as I'd hoped. I also don't know if it's my imagination but it seems to be worse now that the tyres have covered nearly 10k miles. The car soaks up potholes and major bumps just fine but on the motorway it feels a bit 'twitchy', it tramlines, and I seem to feel every road imperfection.

It's got the standard Pirelli Cinturato P7 245/50R18s. I'm happy with the level of grip and wear rate (loads of tread left) but will changing to a traditional non-RFT make a worthwhile difference to the ride/drive of the car? I'm considering something like Goodyear Eagle F1s.

Any advice appreciated.
I have the michelin primacy run flat tyres on my 2016 F10 535D M Sport they are just great all round, very low noise too.


Edited by JMBMWM5 on Friday 4th November 14:06