Specialist garages, a story of good versus evil.
Discussion
Had a good experience and a bad experience in the last fortnight.
I've been planing on selling my 330D at about this time because I have a company car coming just before Xmas and don't fancy selling my car during the expensive time of the year (hmm, I'm sure mid I've never is no better right!) so thought I'd take it to my local BMW specialist in Taunton (Garage A) to get the engine light turned off.
I expected about £3-400 cost, it had already been code read at my servicing garage who informed me the glow plugs needed replacing along with something to do with the EGR which could be diagnosed upon removing.
Had the phone call from Garage A that the bill would be £2,090 because it needed a new turbo, and there was no point doing the rest of the work until it was done. To say I was shocked was an understatement, I decided I'd be better off cutting my losses and getting an appointment with webuyanycar. Garage A put the car back together, showed me a photo of the Inlet manifold with oil in and told me the oil was a telltale that the turbo had gone, and charged me £200 for the privelage.
As it transpired, WBAC wanted to knock off more of the price than I was happy with so I started frantically ringing around to find a cheaper turbo replacement option so I could at least sell the car as a runner. I also spoke with a mate of mine who assured me the garage were speaking b
ks and that there's always in the inlet of such diesels and not to worry, he's a pretty knowledgeable chap so I was happy to go with it. Spoke to a few other garages who agreed with my mate, and told me they would be amazed if it was the turbo but a 20min inspection would reveal if anything was wrong with it. I was very much feeling that either the place I'd taken it to were either trying to have me on just plain didn't know what they were doing.
Having heard plenty about them, I called Forza GB in Caldicot, South Wales, and spent about 20mins on the phone with Stuart there. It was clear he knew all sorts about these engines and described numerous things that would fail before the turbo including a few things I'd experience myself which hadn't been identified by Garage A in Taunton, so I booked the car in with FGB and sorted myself a round of golf with my dad who lives nearby to keep me occupied during the day.
I collected the car today, it's perfect, repairs on the job sheet are exactly what Stuart diagnosed over the phone and he even remarked that the turbo is quieter than most at this age, final cost including removing the swirl flaps for future safety was less than a quarter of the original price from Garage A.
I just wish I'd trusted my instinct in the first place and taken it there originally to save me £200. It's only because I needed a day off work and they're 50 miles away that I even looked elsewhere.
So there we go, car is sorted and ready for sale.
If in doubt, take it to Forza GB in Caldicot.
I've been planing on selling my 330D at about this time because I have a company car coming just before Xmas and don't fancy selling my car during the expensive time of the year (hmm, I'm sure mid I've never is no better right!) so thought I'd take it to my local BMW specialist in Taunton (Garage A) to get the engine light turned off.
I expected about £3-400 cost, it had already been code read at my servicing garage who informed me the glow plugs needed replacing along with something to do with the EGR which could be diagnosed upon removing.
Had the phone call from Garage A that the bill would be £2,090 because it needed a new turbo, and there was no point doing the rest of the work until it was done. To say I was shocked was an understatement, I decided I'd be better off cutting my losses and getting an appointment with webuyanycar. Garage A put the car back together, showed me a photo of the Inlet manifold with oil in and told me the oil was a telltale that the turbo had gone, and charged me £200 for the privelage.
As it transpired, WBAC wanted to knock off more of the price than I was happy with so I started frantically ringing around to find a cheaper turbo replacement option so I could at least sell the car as a runner. I also spoke with a mate of mine who assured me the garage were speaking b
ks and that there's always in the inlet of such diesels and not to worry, he's a pretty knowledgeable chap so I was happy to go with it. Spoke to a few other garages who agreed with my mate, and told me they would be amazed if it was the turbo but a 20min inspection would reveal if anything was wrong with it. I was very much feeling that either the place I'd taken it to were either trying to have me on just plain didn't know what they were doing. Having heard plenty about them, I called Forza GB in Caldicot, South Wales, and spent about 20mins on the phone with Stuart there. It was clear he knew all sorts about these engines and described numerous things that would fail before the turbo including a few things I'd experience myself which hadn't been identified by Garage A in Taunton, so I booked the car in with FGB and sorted myself a round of golf with my dad who lives nearby to keep me occupied during the day.
I collected the car today, it's perfect, repairs on the job sheet are exactly what Stuart diagnosed over the phone and he even remarked that the turbo is quieter than most at this age, final cost including removing the swirl flaps for future safety was less than a quarter of the original price from Garage A.
I just wish I'd trusted my instinct in the first place and taken it there originally to save me £200. It's only because I needed a day off work and they're 50 miles away that I even looked elsewhere.
So there we go, car is sorted and ready for sale.
If in doubt, take it to Forza GB in Caldicot.
It is very difficult to find a true specialist who is an expert on a marque and very easy to find a garage who thinks that if he mostly works on marque A, he is now a specialist.
I've had all sorts of fun with specialists including one that couldn't diagnose a leaking radiator on an E39 - probably the most obvious and common fault ever - and instead played 'swap the part at random' billing me each time. Another asked me if my E39 had air conditioning.
It became such a lottery to find a place you could trust that it contributed to be beginning to tire of running the E39.
I've had all sorts of fun with specialists including one that couldn't diagnose a leaking radiator on an E39 - probably the most obvious and common fault ever - and instead played 'swap the part at random' billing me each time. Another asked me if my E39 had air conditioning.
It became such a lottery to find a place you could trust that it contributed to be beginning to tire of running the E39.
Monty Python said:
In cases like these, always ask for the parts replaced to be boxed up and left in the car for possible further inspection.
How would that have helped me? I wouldn't know a working turbo from a non working one when it's in a box having paid £2k for it. It would just be a metal shell with some turbines and a seal in, I'd have no idea of whether it needed doing or not. Will just report to trading standards as either inconmpetent or a dodgy dealer.
Fox- said:
It is very difficult to find a true specialist who is an expert on a marque and very easy to find a garage who thinks that if he mostly works on marque A, he is now a specialist.
Take the point. In this case Stu is an ex BMW master tech, knows his onions and keeps a good coffee machine in the waiting area.Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



