BMW and/or Gearbox Specialist nr Oxford
BMW and/or Gearbox Specialist nr Oxford
Author
Discussion

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
I have a 330ci e46 2005 with what seems to be an automatic gearbox oil leak. A friend's garage has ruled out the engine but doesn't want to open up the auto box.

Any idea where to take it? A gearbox specialist or a BMW specialist (or both of you know of one).

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
There not a lot to leak on these, what's leaking?

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
John Darby is based in Banbury, north Oxfordshire, if that's close enough?

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
The leak is coming from the centre of the car, well behind a dry looking engine. It drips onto the exhaust and burns. Appears to be transmission fluid (looks a bit red).

Other than that... that's all I know so far

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
PS - is it really not common (or at least not very rare)? There seem to be a few discussions I've found by a google search, just not things I can check myself and need a specialist to check.

Gunk

3,302 posts

190 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
Mark Purcell in Cowley is very good.

http://good-garage-guide.honestjohn.co.uk/garages/...

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Sunday 6th November 2016
quotequote all
This should have the ZF 5HP19, I seen slight leaks from the sump gasket but that's about it. PAS pipe leaks are more common on these. The ZF atf is more clear than red.

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Saturday 12th November 2016
quotequote all
Took it to Mark Purcell. It is gearbox oil, seems to be coming from the torque converter seal and they reckon it's going to be expensive. It was like it from the day i bought it last week, so it's going back to the indie dealer, wish me luck with them

Gunk

3,302 posts

190 months

Saturday 12th November 2016
quotequote all
ishay said:
Took it to Mark Purcell. It is gearbox oil, seems to be coming from the torque converter seal and they reckon it's going to be expensive. It was like it from the day i bought it last week, so it's going back to the indie dealer, wish me luck with them
Under the consumer rights act you do have some rights

Which website said:
If you bought the car after 01 October 2015, you only have 30 days to reject a second-hand car and get a full refund

Returning a second-hand car

If you're past the first 30 days but a problem has arisen that you think would have been present at the time of purchase, then you're entitled to ask for a repair or replacement free of charge.

During the first six months after purchase it's the responsibility of the seller to prove the fault wasn't there, not for you to prove that it was.

But after the first six months, the onus will be on you to prove that the fault was present from the day you purchased the car.

If the attempt at a repair or replacement is unsuccessful, you're entitled to a refund.

But the car dealer can make a deduction from the refund after the first 30 days for 'fair use'.

When you buy a second-hand car from a dealer, you have the right under the Consumer Rights Act (which replaces the Sale of Goods Act from 01 October 2015), to expect the car to:

be of satisfactory quality (taking into account its age and mileage)
meet any description given to you when you were buying it (whether in the advert or in discussions prior to sale)
be fit for purpose (for example, to get you from A to B safely)

If the second-hand car does not meet these requirements, you have the right to claim against the dealer for breach of contract.

If something you buy is not 'as described', or if the seller is guilty of misrepresentation, you're entitled to:

give the second-hand car back and get your money back
if you want to keep the car, ask for compensation (usually the cost of any repairs it needs)

But if you buy a second-hand car that was not described as being in excellent condition or good working order and it breaks soon after you buy it, you don't have any right to reject it or to claim compensation.


ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Saturday 12th November 2016
quotequote all
Thanks that's the plan. The guy seems set on getting out of some of it and has only talked of "contributing", so far. Until he's seen it I'm ok that he's non-committal but once it's back there next week I'll be pushing those full rights.

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
This is getting a bit strange. The car went to two auto specialists who diagnosed the seal had failed due to a worn torque converter bush. £1000 later (paid by the dealer) for refurbished replacement bits and it's back and it sounds better, but it's still got oil burning off the exhaust. Potentially still old oil at this stage, but I fear not, given how much smoke. Stranger still, having looked through all the old receipts I've found one for £2200 for much the same problem and repairs just two years and 20k miles ago, from another gearbox specialist.

If it is leaking still why would two expensive repairs from two specialist gearbox garages be struggling so much to sort it? Could there be another root cause??

Edited by ishay on Saturday 26th November 14:47

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
Is the cam cover gasket leaking onto the exhaust manifold (sometimes only visible from underneath)?

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
ishay said:
This is getting a bit strange. The car went to two auto specialists who diagnosed the seal had failed due to a worn torque converter bush. £1000 later (paid by the dealer) for refurbished replacement bits and it's back and it sounds better, but it's still got oil burning off the exhaust. Potentially still old oil at this stage, but I fear not, given how much smoke. Stranger still, having looked through all the old receipts I've found one for £2200 for much the same problem and repairs just two years and 20k miles ago, from another gearbox specialist.

If it is leaking still why would two expensive repairs from two specialist gearbox garages be struggling so much to sort it? Could there be another root cause??

Edited by ishay on Saturday 26th November 14:47
The TC sits in the front pump seal, there is no bush. The front pump seal itself is pennies, the money is in the labour.

ishay

Original Poster:

145 posts

129 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
They have replaced the complete pump body and pump gears as part of it. They also fitted a reconditioned TC and replaced C and F clutch pack assemblies, pan gasket and filter

Pretty sure this has nothing to do with any engine leaks, too far back. The valve cover gasket has been given a clean bill of health by three garages now. It looks like the same TC seal leak, but how after all that work?! (somewhat rhetorical question)

Maybe just all the old oil? I'm hoping so, but how long might that smoke for (it is pretty covered)??

Edited by ishay on Saturday 26th November 19:25