Autobox changing up on its own while in MANUAL mode
Autobox changing up on its own while in MANUAL mode
Author
Discussion

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Hi guys. I've got a bit of a problem with my Z4 Coupe (Auto). About a fortnight ago I was out hooning, using the car in manual+sport mode (shifter pushed to the left) when I noticed the car was changing up on its own. This is expected behavior if I was red-lining the engine but I wasn't, I was only part throttle and revs no higher than about 4,000.

I was advised that I should get the gearbox serviced, so I took it to a BMW specialist who have done the work, but the problem remains.

I can't find much about it online and when I mentioned to the specialist he'd never heard of this before but did say if the oil was bad / too low in the gearbox it can cause issues.

The car drives absolutely fine in auto as far as I can tell, I am only having the issue in manual mode. The car clearly knows that it's in Manual as it shows M on the dash with the number gear it's in so I don't understand what the problem could be. Has anyone else ever seen this problem before?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Doesn't that box have some sort of fuzzy logic that vaguely learns how you're driving it? Maybe a run in manual using the full rev range through all the gears a few times might persuade it to hang on longer.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
I thought that would have been in auto mode though, prior to this, it has always hung on to the selected gear in manual unless you take it to the red line, or slow down to the point where the revs drop very low.

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
I'd have thought that 4k at light throttle should need a change up??? Full throttle would be different but half throttle shouldn't take you to the redline IMO.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
You may be right but both of the cars I have with auto/manual/paddle shift (530d and SLK) seem to stay in manual longer and change up/down more responsively the harder theyre driven in the manual mode, especially the Merc.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
eybic said:
I'd have thought that 4k at light throttle should need a change up??? Full throttle would be different but half throttle shouldn't take you to the redline IMO.
It would in automatic mode yes, but in manual, the whole point is it hangs on to the gears until you change gear (unless you over or under-rev the engine) regardless of throttle position, at least, that's how it worked previously. Otherwise it's not really a manual mode at all is it?

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Isn't when you push the lever across to the left, all its doing is putting the 'box into "DS" - ie sport mode as opposed to pure "D" - it's not a pure manual mode.

From "DS" you can change gears manually, but if you leave it for x seconds it will override back into "DS" - if it thinks it should change up, it will.

I don't think there's anything wrong with your gearbox at all, but I stand to be corrected!

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
Yep you are correct about that, however, if you push or pull the shifter after you do this, the dash display changes to "M#" (# = whatever gear you're in) and it then operates in full manual mode, or at least its supposed to.

I've done a fair bit of googling and come up with a possible cause - the wiring beneath the switcher becoming frayed, leading to the possibility of bare wires touching one another. I took the car out before, and it was doing it still but it was intermittent - once going around a corner. When it happened, it changed up to top in quick succession. Then a few minutes later it did the same around a very low speed corner, it went into 5th, at a speed far lower than the autobox would have normally done it causing the revs to drop to about 1,000. Its as though it is getting rogue signals.

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Yep you are correct about that, however, if you push or pull the shifter after you do this, the dash display changes to "M#" (# = whatever gear you're in) and it then operates in full manual mode, or at least its supposed to.

I've done a fair bit of googling and come up with a possible cause - the wiring beneath the switcher becoming frayed, leading to the possibility of bare wires touching one another. I took the car out before, and it was doing it still but it was intermittent - once going around a corner. When it happened, it changed up to top in quick succession. Then a few minutes later it did the same around a very low speed corner, it went into 5th, at a speed far lower than the autobox would have normally done it causing the revs to drop to about 1,000. Its as though it is getting rogue signals.
That's right - but when in "DS", when you override it to manual, unless you keep manually changing it will automatically default back to "DS" after not very many seconds. That's why I don't think you do have a problem (possibly!) - its not really a true manual mode - it allows manual down or upshifting, but it wants to revert back to Auto when it can.

ds666

3,184 posts

210 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
In my f31 if I push the leaver across to the left it goes into manual and does no automatic changes ( actually may do at the redline but never tried ) . It stays in manual

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Tuesday 15th November 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
That's right - but when in "DS", when you override it to manual, unless you keep manually changing it will automatically default back to "DS" after not very many seconds. That's why I don't think you do have a problem (possibly!) - its not really a true manual mode - it allows manual down or upshifting, but it wants to revert back to Auto when it can.
That's not the way it's behaved for the previous 10 months though. I could leave it in one gear indefinitely unless I over or under revved it.

Mr Tidy

31,893 posts

158 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
That's not the way it's behaved for the previous 10 months though. I could leave it in one gear indefinitely unless I over or under revved it.
That's why my Z4C is a manual! laugh

It does what I tell it to do!

But I hope you don't have a problem with yours OP. thumbup

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
GTEYE said:
That's right - but when in "DS", when you override it to manual, unless you keep manually changing it will automatically default back to "DS" after not very many seconds. That's why I don't think you do have a problem (possibly!) - its not really a true manual mode - it allows manual down or upshifting, but it wants to revert back to Auto when it can.
That's not the way it's behaved for the previous 10 months though. I could leave it in one gear indefinitely unless I over or under revved it.
Hmm, I can't speak for yours but on my E93 (with the same box) moving the lever left puts it in sport mode ("DS") - but effectively still in Drive, its not a manual mode. You can then override that to manual mode using the +/- but it automatically defaults back to "DS" under certain conditions - and that sounds like what yours is doing?



TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Wednesday 16th November 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
Hmm, I can't speak for yours but on my E93 (with the same box) moving the lever left puts it in sport mode ("DS") - but effectively still in Drive, its not a manual mode. You can then override that to manual mode using the +/- but it automatically defaults back to "DS" under certain conditions - and that sounds like what yours is doing?
No. Mine has never defaulted back ever until now. Yours is a much newer car, they may have changed something. I don't understand why they would engineer that in. Its MANUAL mode, not manual until Mr BMW decides to override it!

Also, surely if it over-rode back to automatic, it would say so on the dash, but it clearly states it's still in manual mode.

Mr_Yogi

3,288 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
With both my E39 and F11, once the lever was/ is pushed to the left ("M/S" mode) and a gear selected manually then the dash displays "M" and it will not change gear automatically until the engine hits the red line is hit or is laboured. So sounds like something is up.

Blu3R

2,380 posts

230 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
Do you have steering wheel paddles? Its possible the clock spring on the steering column is at fault. I've heard of erratic behavior like this on other makes before, and as you say it happens when turning...

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
Mr_Yogi said:
With both my E39 and F11, once the lever was/ is pushed to the left ("M/S" mode) and a gear selected manually then the dash displays "M" and it will not change gear automatically until the engine hits the red line is hit or is laboured. So sounds like something is up.
Thank you, and agreed!

Blu3R said:
Do you have steering wheel paddles? Its possible the clock spring on the steering column is at fault. I've heard of erratic behavior like this on other makes before, and as you say it happens when turning...
I do have the "paddles" - more like buttons though IMO, but it sounds like that could be a possibility. What is the "clock spring" ? Only thing is if it was paddle related, would it happen when in auto as using the paddles will override automatic mode briefly, but I've not noticed this

Blu3R

2,380 posts

230 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Blu3R said:
Do you have steering wheel paddles? Its possible the clock spring on the steering column is at fault. I've heard of erratic behavior like this on other makes before, and as you say it happens when turning...
I do have the "paddles" - more like buttons though IMO, but it sounds like that could be a possibility. What is the "clock spring" ? Only thing is if it was paddle related, would it happen when in auto as using the paddles will override automatic mode briefly, but I've not noticed this
Yes it would, but I find on my 335i DCT its usually in the highest gear it can be at any given moment on light throttle. Is it possible you just haven't noticed?

Clock spring is basically the part that allows the steering wheel mounted electronics to connect to the fixed end of the column instead of having to have a curly kettle lead between the two.

If I'm being honest I think the first thing I'd do in your situation is disconnect the battery for a while to reset all adaptives and see if that alone sorts it. It's a simple and free first step before you have to head to a garage for help.

And FWIW you are correct in your explanation of how they work - 'D' changes automatically, 'DS' changes automatically, 'Mx' hangs in whichever gear is selected until either the revs bottom or top out.



Edited by Blu3R on Thursday 17th November 15:24

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
Blu3R said:
TameRacingDriver said:
Blu3R said:
Do you have steering wheel paddles? Its possible the clock spring on the steering column is at fault. I've heard of erratic behavior like this on other makes before, and as you say it happens when turning...
I do have the "paddles" - more like buttons though IMO, but it sounds like that could be a possibility. What is the "clock spring" ? Only thing is if it was paddle related, would it happen when in auto as using the paddles will override automatic mode briefly, but I've not noticed this
Yes it would, but I find on my 335i DCT its usually in the highest gear it can be at any given moment on light throttle. Is it possible you just haven't noticed?

Clock spring is basically the part that allows the steering wheel mounted electronics to connect to the fixed end of the column instead of having to have a curly kettle lead between the two.

If I'm being honest I think the first thing I'd do in your situation is disconnect the battery for a while to reset all adaptives and see if that alone sorts it. It's a simple and free first step before you have to head to a garage for help.

And FWIW you are correct in your explanation of how they work - 'D' changes automatically, 'DS' changes automatically, 'Mx' hangs in whichever gear is selected until either the revs bottom or top out.



Edited by Blu3R on Thursday 17th November 15:24
Maybe mine is different (but I really don't think so), but if after a period of time in 'Mx' if you don't select either a +ve or -ve gear, it does revert back to 'DS' - its not just on the revs bottoming or topping out, it seems to be time based on inactivity (of changing gear).

That's the way my E46, E90, E92, E93 and F30 and F32 worked anyway...

Maybe the Z4 is different...

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,649 posts

303 months

Thursday 17th November 2016
quotequote all
Blu3R said:
If I'm being honest I think the first thing I'd do in your situation is disconnect the battery for a while to reset all adaptives and see if that alone sorts it. It's a simple and free first step before you have to head to a garage for help.
I'll give that a try first, after all, as you say, its a free fix (if it works).