Should my X1 be doing the braking for me?
Should my X1 be doing the braking for me?
Author
Discussion

DJMC

Original Poster:

3,606 posts

134 months

Thursday 15th December 2016
quotequote all
Yesterday, I was travelling along the A426 single carriageway at around 50mph. My 2016 X1 was in the centre of its lane with about 3ft to the kerb and 3ft to the centre marking. I noticed a truck coming in the opposite direction. It was perhaps 1ft from the centre marking.

As we closed on each other I didn't react, or intend to react, in any way. The passing gap was wide enough and the truck would clear my car by 4ft. Then... "beeeeeep...be...beeeeep" as the forward collision warning alarm went off and a split second later my X1 thrust on the brakes so hard the ABS was activated. I was thrown forward in my seat with a "F**K!!" coming from my mouth.
Another second later and I'm carrying on my way again, somewhat flustered!

If the road had been icy this manic braking may have thrown me off the road.

I'm guessing this is all perfectly normal and I should just get used to autonomous driving?

This is why driverless cars will not work. We'll all be dead from the car crashing for us, or giving us heart attacks.

patmahe

5,924 posts

235 months

Thursday 15th December 2016
quotequote all
DJMC said:
Yesterday, I was travelling along the A426 single carriageway at around 50mph. My 2016 X1 was in the centre of its lane with about 3ft to the kerb and 3ft to the centre marking. I noticed a truck coming in the opposite direction. It was perhaps 1ft from the centre marking.

As we closed on each other I didn't react, or intend to react, in any way. The passing gap was wide enough and the truck would clear my car by 4ft. Then... "beeeeeep...be...beeeeep" as the forward collision warning alarm went off and a split second later my X1 thrust on the brakes so hard the ABS was activated. I was thrown forward in my seat with a "F**K!!" coming from my mouth.
Another second later and I'm carrying on my way again, somewhat flustered!

If the road had been icy this manic braking may have thrown me off the road.

I'm guessing this is all perfectly normal and I should just get used to autonomous driving?

This is why driverless cars will not work. We'll all be dead from the car crashing for us, or giving us heart attacks.
Christ that sounds scary, system must be faulty or misaligned somehow, how dangerous it it to slow suddenly and unexpectedly like that, surprised no-one drove into the back of you.


DJMC

Original Poster:

3,606 posts

134 months

Thursday 15th December 2016
quotequote all
I just phoned BMW and the dealer chief technician said it can react to shadows and differing lighting situations, but he'd not heard of one reacting to oncoming traffic, and never himself experienced an imminent collision so bad the system brakes, although it IS supposed to do this. He's doing some checks with BMW GB.

In reality, I'm sure it's just doing its job but has become confused. You know, like computers sometimes do?

And as we see more autonomous cars on our roads there will doubtless be more confusion, more scared drivers, more crashes, more deaths (TESLA), more negative press, more pressure on MPs to reverse the decision to allow them on the roads, more control given back to drivers, and more, no ALL autonomous cars being ordered to the breakers yard. What a waste of time. It was never going to work.

Even the X1's auto wipers have a mind of their own. Coming to a rest the other day in light rain the things were going at full speed!
All these driver "aids" are becoming rather tiresome.

rockford22

362 posts

163 months

Thursday 15th December 2016
quotequote all
Wow that sounds horrendous, lucky that no-one rear ended you!

Have never heard or known it to react so violently (and certainly not when I've been driving a BMW with it fitted)

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Thursday 15th December 2016
quotequote all
Change the sensitivity of the collision warning system. It has three settings.

Mr Tidy

31,893 posts

158 months

Friday 16th December 2016
quotequote all
Sounds pretty scary, but as Microsoft said isn't that what windows are for?

Sorry to hear about the truck "coming" towards you - you may need to swerve or that will be a massive clean-up job!

But if you need any car to do the braking for you, please just use buses or trains - it will be better for everyone!

darker grapefruit

377 posts

131 months

Friday 16th December 2016
quotequote all
Zod said:
Change the sensitivity of the collision warning system. It has three settings.
If this was the cause then to think that the OP's life was at risk for not choosing the correct setting is shocking.

dartissimus

954 posts

205 months

Friday 16th December 2016
quotequote all
Possibly something to do with the sensor, it's very low down on my 3 series.

Occasionally it's been fooled by a parked car on a bend, but generally it's very easy to live with, far less intrusive than my XC70, which was forever bleeping and flashing.

I've had the light on once or twice, but never had emergency braking activated,

Age has something to do with a reduction in car drama.

DJMC

Original Poster:

3,606 posts

134 months

Friday 16th December 2016
quotequote all
The camera is at the top of the windscreen...



Not sure if it uses other sensors?