Poor mpg on (2011) BMW X5 I-Drive diesel sport.
Discussion
I am the proud owner of a 2011 BMW X5 I-Drive 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox.
I P/X this with my '55 plate X5 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox around two weeks ago.
All was going well until I checked the MPG.
My previous X5 regularly delivered 29-30 mpg; slightly more in the summer.
This new one, same journey type etc., but with me being considerably more careful because as it is still new to me, delivered just 27.7 mpg.
Very disappointing as this is well short of BMW's reported MPG figures.
Any thoughts as to why the mpg is so poor?
I P/X this with my '55 plate X5 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox around two weeks ago.
All was going well until I checked the MPG.
My previous X5 regularly delivered 29-30 mpg; slightly more in the summer.
This new one, same journey type etc., but with me being considerably more careful because as it is still new to me, delivered just 27.7 mpg.
Very disappointing as this is well short of BMW's reported MPG figures.
Any thoughts as to why the mpg is so poor?
Are you calculating this or going off the computer?
Might be a function of how it's been driven in the past, sometimes if a car's been run in too gently it can end up worse in fuel, it seems to apply more to diesels really though.
Also don't forget it's winter and a 5% or more drop in consumption is not unexpected.
Might be a function of how it's been driven in the past, sometimes if a car's been run in too gently it can end up worse in fuel, it seems to apply more to diesels really though.
Also don't forget it's winter and a 5% or more drop in consumption is not unexpected.
As it happens, I did exactly the same move this summer, even a 55 plate to 61 plate, both 3.0d autos, the latter being 8 speed. Both 19" wheels with same sized tyres.
My trips didn't change, but mpg did.
- Short journeys, my shortest being 8 miles, new car is 4 mpg better, but I know the first mile is significantly better than the old car when cold.
- Long journeys on A class roads, new car 2mpg better or so.
- Oddly, motorway speeds is slightly worse in the 8 speed, despite the rpm's sitting a lot lower. Must be less aerodynamic, I would have thought the 8 speed would give the biggest gains here....
Overall average 4mpg better, went from 28. something to 32. something. So unless your trips are all motorway, then something must be up
Have you gone from 19's to the wider 20's?
There is a way to reset the throttle and gearbox adaptation which may help, quick google should turn something up
My trips didn't change, but mpg did.
- Short journeys, my shortest being 8 miles, new car is 4 mpg better, but I know the first mile is significantly better than the old car when cold.
- Long journeys on A class roads, new car 2mpg better or so.
- Oddly, motorway speeds is slightly worse in the 8 speed, despite the rpm's sitting a lot lower. Must be less aerodynamic, I would have thought the 8 speed would give the biggest gains here....
Overall average 4mpg better, went from 28. something to 32. something. So unless your trips are all motorway, then something must be up
Have you gone from 19's to the wider 20's?There is a way to reset the throttle and gearbox adaptation which may help, quick google should turn something up
Edited by scz4 on Monday 19th December 20:37
I have a X3 3.0 d 263 bhp ( 2014 ) and in summer you can get 45 to 49 mpg on a gentle run but around town in winter its dropped to 35 to 39 and when it was really cold with loads of electrical items on ( 4 x heated seats , rear window etc ) it can get down to a all time low of 29 mpg on shorter trips . Due to the brick shaped aerodynamics it you are pressing on on hilly motorway it will not give good results at all ! . But when you think about it you are heating up a huge engine block from cold its fantastic economy for a 3 ltr auto with auto box and permanent 4wd and all that performance potential .
I own a 2011 X5 40d and I am afraid to say the mpg you report does not surprise me. Its kind of roughly what they do I think. Disappointing given the claimed efficiency. I guess you might think that your car ought to be more efficient than a 40d but Im not really sure that is how it works, they are much of a muchness I think...
Vee said:
There is a way to check the coolant temperature in the car - google search say how.
There are 2 thermostats which often fail.
If it is running cold economy will suffer significantly.
This. and it's pretty crucial you get them replaced if they're broken as your DPF won't be regenerating.There are 2 thermostats which often fail.
If it is running cold economy will suffer significantly.
What are the MPG figures. Half of the figures most manufacturers quote are ambitious to say the least, unless you drive everywhere with a tail wind behind you.
Otherwise, it could be anything. I've even had a basic oil change given me an MPG improvement on a car, and that was on a car doing 22MPG constantly.
Otherwise, it could be anything. I've even had a basic oil change given me an MPG improvement on a car, and that was on a car doing 22MPG constantly.
Something not quite right here . My X3 with 3.0 engine is just 240kg lighter than the X5 with the same driveline and the X5 has a better drag factor . Look at the first two photos from todays run : at the halfway stage is was just shy of 50mpg and might have stayed that way had I not go caught up in heavy traffic on the way home . Last shot is trip across europe with a75 mph driving average over 586 miles it still did 38mpg !



Edited by Charlie Croker mk2 on Tuesday 20th December 22:14
Charlie Croker mk2 said:
Something not quite right here . My X3 with 3.0 engine is just 240kg lighter than the X5 with the same driveline and the X5 has a better drag factor . Look at the first two photos from todays run : at the halfway stage is was just shy of 50mpg and might have stayed that way had I not go caught up in heavy traffic on the way home . Last shot is trip across europe with a75 mph driving average over 586 miles it still did 38mpg !



Depends on the driver.Edited by Charlie Croker mk2 on Tuesday 20th December 22:14
I'll see 30MPG on the motorway in my E46 M3 and 23MPG around town. My friend in his new M4? 23MPG on a run. His driving style is very different to mine ; he'll stay in 5th where 6th could be used at 70|MPH, doesn't tend to drive on at roundabouts etc. I have no doubt that his car could be far more economical than mine and a few posts on here would agree with that.
He reckons that style is fine. It possibly is but the point is two drivers can deliver massively different MPG results. When I told him a while ago that my 944 Turbo with around 300BHP was getting 21MPG and 30MPG on a run he thought I was lying ; his Citroen DS21 EFI Manual could not touch it much to my surprise!
unclemunkle said:
I am the proud owner of a 2011 BMW X5 I-Drive 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox.
I P/X this with my '55 plate X5 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox around two weeks ago.
All was going well until I checked the MPG.
My previous X5 regularly delivered 29-30 mpg; slightly more in the summer.
This new one, same journey type etc., but with me being considerably more careful because as it is still new to me, delivered just 27.7 mpg.
Very disappointing as this is well short of BMW's reported MPG figures.
Any thoughts as to why the mpg is so poor?
Can't help with your problem but epic lurking! I P/X this with my '55 plate X5 3.0D Sport with automatic gearbox around two weeks ago.
All was going well until I checked the MPG.
My previous X5 regularly delivered 29-30 mpg; slightly more in the summer.
This new one, same journey type etc., but with me being considerably more careful because as it is still new to me, delivered just 27.7 mpg.
Very disappointing as this is well short of BMW's reported MPG figures.
Any thoughts as to why the mpg is so poor?
jboy72 said:
I own a 2011 X5 40d and I am afraid to say the mpg you report does not surprise me. Its kind of roughly what they do I think. Disappointing given the claimed efficiency. I guess you might think that your car ought to be more efficient than a 40d but Im not really sure that is how it works, they are much of a muchness I think...
I have the same model as you with 20" wheels and struggle to get below 30mpg average. This is mostly made up of short, congested town rides and then longer motorway cruises. On a recent trip to France with the car fully loaded, sitting between 80-90mph, I was getting 32mpg.Pretty happy with that
The Stiglet said:
I have the same model as you with 20" wheels and struggle to get below 30mpg average. This is mostly made up of short, congested town rides and then longer motorway cruises. On a recent trip to France with the car fully loaded, sitting between 80-90mph, I was getting 32mpg.
Pretty happy with that
I would be - I actually have 21" inch wheels (OEM BMW), inherited with the car. They look great but no doubt do have an impact on mpg as well given that the width of the rears would show up a McLaren P1 (I just checked to make sure I wasn't making that up!) and so the rolling resistance must play a part. Decent traction from a standing start though, as you might expect...Pretty happy with that
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


