E46 Swirl flaps
E46 Swirl flaps
Author
Discussion

steve320ise

Original Poster:

159 posts

174 months

Monday 19th December 2016
quotequote all
I know there has been a lot of discussion on these but, I have a 330d, went to remove the swirl flaps and it looks like the engine thought of it before me, one is missing, the engine runs well, I have run it without the inlet manifold on and no back pressure from the inlet. before I start to remove the cylinder head, has anyone had the same issue and resolved it without a strip down, I dont see how else the flap can be removed , cheers Steve

mark.c

1,090 posts

211 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
Having removed a set from a E39 525d I can't imagine an engine could ingest one of the flaps and still be running in a normal fashion, it's a huge piece to inhale. One of mine was literally hanging off so caught just in time. I suspect someone has been in there before you and removed it.

steve320ise

Original Poster:

159 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
Hi, There were 4 intact one hanging off and one missing, these things are far too big to go straight in the engine so I presume they start to break up then go in, get stuck in the valve, etc, there is plenty of information on the damage caused, and about taking them out, has no one had a similar thing happen, Im not sure someone would just take one out, I cant just leave it to chance, cheers

CarsOrBikes

1,158 posts

215 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
Perhaps sitting just above the valve? Seen that before, wedged in. Also seen them having gone through, all the battle scars inside but no debris.

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
mark.c said:
Having removed a set from a E39 525d I can't imagine an engine could ingest one of the flaps and still be running in a normal fashion, it's a huge piece to inhale. One of mine was literally hanging off so caught just in time. I suspect someone has been in there before you and removed it.
Bugger, are they defo on the E39 525? I thought the 6 cyl engines were exempt from this monstrosity.

I ask as someone who has a 155k E39 525d on an 02 plate...... If that's the case, they are coming off next week.

steve320ise

Original Poster:

159 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
Thanks, I have that one in mind, stuck around the valve, I cant imagine the once one has been through and left its mark it would run ok

mark.c

1,090 posts

211 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
bearman68 said:
mark.c said:
Having removed a set from a E39 525d I can't imagine an engine could ingest one of the flaps and still be running in a normal fashion, it's a huge piece to inhale. One of mine was literally hanging off so caught just in time. I suspect someone has been in there before you and removed it.
Bugger, are they defo on the E39 525? I thought the 6 cyl engines were exempt from this monstrosity.

I ask as someone who has a 155k E39 525d on an 02 plate...... If that's the case, they are coming off next week.
There were definitely there in all their potential disaster causing glory! This was on an auto, I had heard that a manual may not have them but that's not a hard a fast rule by all accounts. Well worth a look since destroying an engine on one of these turns it into a skip unless you really love it.

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
I repaired a E90 320d the other day with a swirl flap problem. You'd be surprised at how well it ran with 2 valves missing. The swirl flap from No2 cylinder had been sucked into No3 piston funnily enough.
I replaced the timing chain on it while I was at it (Engine out job), as well as the oil drive and pump (not included in the chain kit), and the DPF, but didn't do the turbo. The DMF and pain in the arse self adjusting clutch had been done 2 months before. Big bill for that one. (And never worth it in total, but it came at different times). I couldn't bear to do that work on my own. But you're right, I seem to remember now the the auto's had swirl flaps, but the manual didn't (Manual here).

steve320ise

Original Poster:

159 posts

174 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
Thanks, I will take the head off and have a look at the state of it, like I said there are no signs of any damage no smoke from exhaust, so fingers crossed, cheers

steve320ise

Original Poster:

159 posts

174 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
I have done 5 or 6 swirl flap removals and this is the first auto, all e46's