likely for main thermostat & EGR stat to be faulty so soon
likely for main thermostat & EGR stat to be faulty so soon
Author
Discussion

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
Is it likely for main thermostat & EGR stat to be faulty within months? BMW E90 330d M sports.

Hi all..
A about four or five months ago I had the main thermostat & EGR 'stat replaced due to low running temperature, max 65c on the motorway and in town / traffic was around 70c to about 78c.

Once they were changed everything was good running temps were high 80/90+

To cut a long store short after changing them parts months down the line I'm starting to get the same signs.. Not getting above 76c on the motorway and in town about 77/78c also the back box remains to smell like it needs to rengen after every use.

Do you think that one of these parts could be faulty already? Both parts were from main dealer not copies.

Today I took the EGR 'stat off to try and blow through it and it wasn't easy to blow through but you could feel air passing only slightly with cheeks puffed out. Now should I be able to blow through like this or not?

I'm sure that I read to different bits of info on this.. one saying that you should be able but only slightly and other saying you shouldn't be able to blow through.

Or maybe in missing something else that may cause this temperature to be low with other parts that may need changing.

Any info on this would be greatly appreciated. Cheers


Edited by Tell boy on Wednesday 28th December 19:43

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
Is it likely for main thermostat & EGR stat to be faulty within months? BMW E90 330d M sports.

Hi all..
A about four or five months ago I had the main thermostat & EGR 'stat replaced due to low running temperature, max 65c on the motorway and in town / traffic was around 70c to about 78c.

Once they were changed everything was good running temps were high 80/90+

To cut a long store short after changing them parts months down the line I'm starting to get the same signs.. Not getting above 76c on the motorway and in town about 77/78c also the back box remains to smell like it needs to rengen after every use.

Do you think that one of these parts could be faulty already? Both parts were from main dealer not copies.

Today I took the EGR 'stat off to try and blow through it and it wasn't easy to blow through but you could feel air passing only slightly with cheeks puffed out. Now should I be able to blow through like this or not?

I'm sure that I read to different bits of info on this.. one saying that you should be able but only slightly and other saying you shouldn't be able to blow through.

Or maybe in missing something else that may cause this temperature to be low with other parts that may need changing.

Any info on this would be greatly appreciated. Cheers


Edited by Tell boy on Wednesday 28th December 19:44

m996tt

407 posts

242 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
I personally think that both the main and egr thermos fail quite regularly.

I have replaced my main three times, originally got one from ecp, that failed
within four months, got another and that failed within 6 months, So went
ahead and got one from bm. It has been ok for about 2 years, touch wood.

The egr has been replaced twice. If you can blow through it, it is a fail.

I at least do all the work myself, so save on labour.

SebringMan

1,774 posts

217 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
What brand?

Unless it is genuine cheap stuff does go. If you can't face paying dealer prices look out for Wahler and BEHR thermostats. People think I am nuts when I buy thermostats from a dealer but I look at it another way. If you buy cheap you buy twice. But I am also a person who works on my own cars. I have better things to do than continuously fix cars, and TBH I'm too busy to afford to do so!

But you were lucky. Most of the time pattern stuff barely gets up to the temperature I want! I could quite examples but I'd put most to sleep. Let's just say I avoid Circoli & First Line bits alot! In some cases I'd had the car overcool more on a Firstline item!

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
SebringMan said:
What brand?

Unless it is genuine cheap stuff does go. If you can't face paying dealer prices look out for Wahler and BEHR thermostats. People think I am nuts when I buy thermostats from a dealer but I look at it another way. If you buy cheap you buy twice. But I am also a person who works on my own cars. I have better things to do than continuously fix cars, and TBH I'm too busy to afford to do so!

But you were lucky. Most of the time pattern stuff barely gets up to the temperature I want! I could quite examples but I'd put most to sleep. Let's just say I avoid Circoli & First Line bits alot! In some cases I'd had the car overcool more on a Firstline item!

It's a genuine BMW part. The main thing I was looking for was can you blow through the EGR 'stat when it's been taken off / from cold. I think the above answers that.

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Wednesday 28th December 2016
quotequote all
m996tt said:
I personally think that both the main and egr thermos fail quite regularly.

I have replaced my main three times, originally got one from ecp, that failed
within four months, got another and that failed within 6 months, So went
ahead and got one from bm. It has been ok for about 2 years, touch wood.

The egr has been replaced twice. If you can blow through it, it is a fail.

I at least do all the work myself, so save on labour.
I bet now you wish you popped down to BMW to get the bits in the first place wink I'm sure the prices are not far off between genuine and non. I haven't heard much of the genuine thermostats ones going duff so soon tho? You read more of them being replaced after 50/60,000+? Just a hit and miss I guess. I just didn't want to waste £40 like the click of the fingers to then fine out that you can blow through the 'stat (slightly) and for it to still be ok. So no air should pass through the 'stat unless when hot opening to let coolant out? Sorry if this is basic to know but if you don't know you don't know

SebringMan

1,774 posts

217 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
This becomes a little trickier for me to answer as some friends reckon diesels will run alot cooler at this time of year. But I would have thought you should not blow through it either. Is the seat where the thermostat sits look OK?

Likewise I would not expect genuine parts to fail so soon! Were there any gaskets that needed changing? These make quite a difference regarding stuff and can be the difference between a working item and non working item.

As for genuine vs. no genuine it depends. On ebay I can get a genuine thermostat from BMW for the same price near enough as a Gates item. C3 BMW are probably the cheapest on thermostats and sell a Wahler item for around £10 less than BMW.




Prinny

1,669 posts

130 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
I replaced mine (335d) 2x in 12 months / 18,000 miles, so I'd certainly say it's possible. My overall opinion is that they're just designed poorly. Luck of the draw for time they last.

possible things to look at:

1- how old is the coolant? If you changed it with the 'stats, then ok, but if not, could be a contributory factor (crud in system?)
2- how are your glow-plugs/ plug controller? If one or two have failed, that makes the engine run rich all the time (afaik), and can also prevent a regen, I think.
3- don't think it's temperature related per-se, but if your red boost hose is split/leaky, that's worth around 3-4 mpg too.

Finally, when mine was running well, it'd be at 93-95 once warm, and up at 105 when running a regen. If you're down in 70-80, then for sure, you're clogging that DPF gradually.

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
Prinny said:
I replaced mine (335d) 2x in 12 months / 18,000 miles, so I'd certainly say it's possible. My overall opinion is that they're just designed poorly. Luck of the draw for time they last.

possible things to look at:

1- how old is the coolant? If you changed it with the 'stats, then ok, but if not, could be a contributory factor (crud in system?)
2- how are your glow-plugs/ plug controller? If one or two have failed, that makes the engine run rich all the time (afaik), and can also prevent a regen, I think.
3- don't think it's temperature related per-se, but if your red boost hose is split/leaky, that's worth around 3-4 mpg too.

Finally, when mine was running well, it'd be at 93-95 once warm, and up at 105 when running a regen. If you're down in 70-80, then for sure, you're clogging that DPF gradually.
Cheers prinny!

Since having the 'stats done I'd say I've only covered about 2,500 miles but as we know it's luck of the draw how long these things last.
Yes the coolant was changed I know of that. The glow plugs I'm not sure about them, I will get my mechanic to check them over and also to have a look at the red boost hose too. Your right there, I've had a drop of about 3/4mpg. Yes, every time I use the car you can smell the stink building up. I'm trying to use the car as little as poss until the mechanic decides he want to come back to work so in the new year. Thanks again for a reply.

Prinny

1,669 posts

130 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
You're welcome. Drop of 3-4 mpg in last month or two could also be entirely attributable to extra road traffic due to crappy weather, and/or winter diesel mix. Don't write it off just yet! If glow plugs & controller check out ok, then with your temperatures where they are, I'd say you're back to 'stats...

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
Well I didn't know about this winter Diesel mix thing.. I take it a few penny's are added on for that, for sure!

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
Another thing that I have noticed and just remembered (you can tell that I use my car much) is a rough idle. Not from switch on as you can see the needle still, That warm up period must be. When after a ten min drive and stopping you see the needle bouncing a bit not constantly but on off. This isn't right , right. Signs of glow plugs.

Tell boy

Original Poster:

27 posts

158 months

Thursday 29th December 2016
quotequote all
Another thing that I have noticed and just remembered (you can tell that I use my car much) is a rough idle. Not from switch on as you can see the needle still, That warm up period must be. When after a ten min drive and stopping you see the needle bouncing a bit not constantly but on off. This isn't right , right. Signs of glow plugs.