someone give me a lesson in economics.....
someone give me a lesson in economics.....
Author
Discussion

leighz

Original Poster:

473 posts

163 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
  • why isn't the market flooded with spiffy near-as-dammit-new-but-second-hand superbikes for little cash as the 'renters' have handed them back to the dealer at the end of the PCP deal having decided they need the new shiny thing someone waved in front of them?
* apologies if this has been covered before - in detail

eddd1e

499 posts

199 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
Not everyone hands it back after the PCP has ended. You have the option to buy it at the guaranteed valuation price. (which is less than it's worth 99% of the time).

Also, it sounds like you have a problem with PCP? IMO It's a good way of owning a new bike with warranty for a set monthly price. As above, you also have the option to purchase it at the end too.

Edited by eddd1e on Saturday 11th February 20:10


Edited by eddd1e on Saturday 11th February 20:12

bogie

17,109 posts

303 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
I think there are plenty of 2-3 year old bikes out there ? a quick search on used Ducati over 600cc shows more than half are 3 year old or less. Maybe the UK big bike market is not as big as you imagine ?

...and sports bikes are a small percentage of sales compared with adventure bikes/naked/tourers

Tall_Paul

1,915 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
You mean 3 year old bikes with one owner? Given that most PCP deals are over 3 years...

Likes this http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/YAMAHA-YZF-R1-/132026394...

or these...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SUZUKI-GSXR600L3-/222195...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Suzuki-GSXR-750-ZL4-/142...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/2014-Suzuki-GSX-R600-599...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Honda-CBR1000RR-Fireblad...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Ducati-899-Panigale-ABS-...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Yamaha-YZF-R-BIG-BANG-CR...
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Kawasaki-ZX10R-/27242734...

In fact it's hard to find a 2013/14 bike from a dealer that isn't a one owner from new bike, 80% of them seem to be. Look at the first used dates, they're all late 2013 or or early 14.

Edited by Tall_Paul on Saturday 11th February 20:44

Janluke

3,129 posts

189 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
Where PCPs for bikes that popular 3 years ago? Seems a more recent thing

Biker's Nemesis

41,489 posts

239 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
Janluke said:
Where PCPs for bikes that popular 3 years ago? Seems a more recent thing
Remember when the S1000RR's came out? There was a clut of them for sale after 3 years when people couldn't afford the final payment etc etc.


Some sold their old nails for the initial deposit then they were left with fk all when they handed their low mileage bikes back. All well and good if you have the fyunds to keep shelling out every month.

leighz

Original Poster:

473 posts

163 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
I don't have a problem with PCP as such - but regard the return to buying things 'on tick' or 'the never never' as a retrograde step. It suggests to me that for a lot of people their standard of living - or ability to buy things has plunged. Or they feel enormous pressure through marketing (reinforced through message boards like this one) to 'keep up with the joneses'.

Maybe I am over-estimating the impact on the sale of second hand bikes that I expect this manufacturer-led tactic to eventually realise.

SteveSteveson

3,209 posts

194 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
It won't change anything. It's the same people who have always had bikes for three years, just funding them in a different way. To me bikes on PCP make sense. I can understand why some people don't like cars, but for a bike? It costs the same over all as buying pretty much, but you don't have a big chunk of cash tied up in a toy. At least in a car you are going to need a new one when it goes. With a bike you can get to the end of the PCP and hand it back after knowing how much you are going to pay every month.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
Ii checked out a pcp deal on an xsr900 after reading this thread. what a way to dump 5k's worth of cash.

its obviously encouraging people to rent their bikes in the same way the car market has done but it's adding to inflated sales numbers that cannot go on forever as people's personal debt climbs.

when your grandparents start taking out pcp cars and motorbikes it will be time to hit the ejector seat cos there will nobody left for the companies to sell credit to....




bogie

17,109 posts

303 months

Saturday 11th February 2017
quotequote all
There are so many variables as to how you can fund your toys, it really depends on your personal financial strategy. What is right for one person may not suit another.

One things for sure, the manufacturers love the PCP and getting people onto to that 3 year new vehicle cycle....a bit like 35 year interest only mortgages, the PCP allows people to "own" higher priced assets than they would have done with the regular loan style finance. The motoring press promote PCP on every page and for "just" £150 a month you can ride that dream £15k superbike.

Articles predicting various credit doom scenarios have been circulating for a few years now.....who knows what is around the corner in the crazy world of brexit, Trump and Putin LOL smile

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2017/feb/10/are-...


Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
Ii checked out a pcp deal on an xsr900 after reading this thread. what a way to dump 5k's worth of cash.

its obviously encouraging people to rent their bikes in the same way the car market has done but it's adding to inflated sales numbers that cannot go on forever as people's personal debt climbs.

when your grandparents start taking out pcp cars and motorbikes it will be time to hit the ejector seat cos there will nobody left for the companies to sell credit to....
The flip side of that is that I'd rather not tie up capital in a depreciating that I can use more effectively elsewhere and watch it appreciate. I've recently looked at a number of new cars and each one is depreciating at £10000 a year consistently. It makes more sense for me not to tie up a large cash sum in that. Bikes are even easier to justify on a PCP as they are a pure luxury.

I know some will now say that it's better for them as they own a lower value car / bike that's already done its depreciating. However, I prefer to drive / ride things that aren't worn out and with 10,000s miles on the clock already.

Fleegle

16,710 posts

207 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
kurt535 said:
Ii checked out a pcp deal on an xsr900 after reading this thread. what a way to dump 5k's worth of cash.

its obviously encouraging people to rent their bikes in the same way the car market has done but it's adding to inflated sales numbers that cannot go on forever as people's personal debt climbs.

when your grandparents start taking out pcp cars and motorbikes it will be time to hit the ejector seat cos there will nobody left for the companies to sell credit to....
The flip side of that is that I'd rather not tie up capital in a depreciating that I can use more effectively elsewhere and watch it appreciate. I've recently looked at a number of new cars and each one is depreciating at £10000 a year consistently. It makes more sense for me not to tie up a large cash sum in that. Bikes are even easier to justify on a PCP as they are a pure luxury.

I know some will now say that it's better for them as they own a lower value car / bike that's already done its depreciating. However, I prefer to drive / ride things that aren't worn out and with 10,000s miles on the clock already.
Makes sense when you don't know how to drive/ride them hard

BobSaunders

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
I think the good ones pop up and go very quickly - dealer sales, dealer to dealer sales, dealer to customer, customer to customer sales. Or people who decide to re-finance.

https://www.howmanyleft.co.uk/vehicle/bmw_s_1000_r...

Andybow

1,177 posts

149 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
It's not all bad with pcp. What I think a lot of people don't realise is at the end of the day it's just finance, you don't have to keep the bike 3 years or what ever term you have, you can trade in against something else whenever you want to. Or like quite a few friends who have had pcp, they refinance at the end of there term so it's there's at the end.
If you buy new with cash, it's still going to depreciate massively for the first 2 years anyway so you don't really win in the finance department.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
Andy, in the case of the XSR900, if you have the cash, a dealer demo with 500 miles on the clock can be £1500 below the retail price. what id be curious to know is the future value of an XSR at the end of the pcp agreement.

Mandat

4,658 posts

269 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
leighz said:
*why isn't the market flooded with spiffy near-as-dammit-new-but-second-hand superbikes for little cash as the 'renters' have handed them back to the dealer at the end of the PCP deal having decided they need the new shiny thing someone waved in front of them?

* apologies if this has been covered before - in detail
If you give it a bit more thought, you will realise that whatever route the bike is acquired, there will always be a cost of ownership of £x per month (i.e. like a rental). Yes, even it you purchase outright with cash.

powerstans

353 posts

228 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
Its a question of attitude you can borrow on a PCP and never own the bike, you pay the depreciation and potentially hand it back. You never own anything unless you pay the final balloon payment. I haven't always found the % rates competitive and you often cant haggle on the bike price.

What happens when you come to getting your next bike? If you stay with the same dealer/manufacturer they say it may have enough retained value for your new deposit, what if you want to go else where and hand your bike back?

So one way you own nothing (No asset) but you commit less of your savings/pay less on a monthly basis, but are tied in for 3 years and potentially walk away having paid the lion share of the depreciation. Using a traditional loan bank loan you use the same deposit, potentially negotiate a discount, potentially a better interest rate and you own the bike a the end of the loan so you have an asset. This can be further compounded if you buy a 1 or 2 year old bike where someone has paid the lion share of the depreciation.

Also as stated where are we in the economic cycle? Bike sales fell off in the recession, depressed sales 2008 till 2012 then picking up with the increased number of bikes coming onto the second hand market likely to increase!

Golgarth

398 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
powerstans said:
Its a question of attitude you can borrow on a PCP and never own the bike, you pay the depreciation and potentially hand it back. You never own anything unless you pay the final balloon payment. I haven't always found the % rates competitive and you often cant haggle on the bike price.
0% finance and £700 off my bike, I like that deal, it's better than a cash deal a friend also managed.


powerstans said:
What happens when you come to getting your next bike? If you stay with the same dealer/manufacturer they say it may have enough retained value for your new deposit, what if you want to go else where and hand your bike back?
Exactly the same deal as someone that buys with ANY form or finance. It doesn't matter whether you buy using HP or PCP a new bike depreciates. Unless you pony up for cash there will always be the eternal depreciation vs future value issue.

powerstans said:
So one way you own nothing (No asset) but you commit less of your savings/pay less on a monthly basis, but are tied in for 3 years and potentially walk away having paid the lion share of the depreciation. Using a traditional loan bank loan you use the same deposit, potentially negotiate a discount, potentially a better interest rate and you own the bike a the end of the loan so you have an asset. This can be further compounded if you buy a 1 or 2 year old bike where someone has paid the lion share of the depreciation.
Or, as is the case in MANY cases, you pay less over the same term as a loan, and you come out the end with a smaller amount of money. OR, you use the fact that you saved on interest on the PCP deal and then loan the rest of the amount, or pay cash, at the end of the PCP deal. YOU ARE NOT TIED IN FOR THREE YEARS, I wish people would understand that, it's a loan, like most others, you just have a deferred payment at the end, that's it.

If you sign up to PCP or loans with interest rates over 5%, then your spending more, if your lucky enough to get something as lower, or even better 0%, crack on. Why would I put circa 10k down for my bike when I could loan it interest free?

Life has had to change, prices ARE higher. If your one of the lucky ones that has managed to have a bike with zero depreciation over the last few years, well done! I want to ride a new bike, I like NEW, I could just as easily ride older, and probably, sensibly, should, but I like new, I like it to be mine, others don't, we are all different, we just need to learn to accept that.

Also as stated where are we in the economic cycle? Bike sales fell off in the recession, depressed sales 2008 till 2012 then picking up with the increased number of bikes coming onto the second hand market likely to increase!

mak

1,445 posts

257 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
leighz said:
*why isn't the market flooded with spiffy near-as-dammit-new-but-second-hand superbikes for little cash
Why would they be sold for little cash? They will be sold at market value.

upsidedownmark

2,120 posts

166 months

Sunday 12th February 2017
quotequote all
Supply/demand drives price - if there is an oversupply, the price will crash; apparently this isn't happening.

WRT to tying up capital, forget the depreciation, that's irrelevant; depreciation will happen however you finance the bike. The question needs to be; can I make more (appreciation) off the capital than the cost of the loan?

- If the answer is yes, and in the current climate, that basically means that the cost of the loan is <1%, INCLUDING all fees, ballon payments, settlements, whatever, NOT JUST THE HEADLINE RATE.. then get the loan and INVEST the cash.

- More likely, the answer is no. In which case you're 'better off' giving up the cash; 'I'm better off having the cash' normally falls under man maths/lies to self wink

As a general rule of thumb, pretty much any form of borrowing (other than a mortgage maybe) is going to cost more than you are going to get in interest. Why on earth do you think everyone is so keen to lend you money (at the risk that you may default, or be problematic to get it back from)? It's because they can make money!

Why do the dealers push credit, and do deals to get you on credit? Because they get a cut.. Of course it gets complicated when they start taking a hit on the finance to move sales and vice versa.. you never know what the retail cost of the bike is, or where they money is coming from, but rest assured it is smile

In short, pretty much all credit is an opportunity cost. Unless you're Warren Buffet, you're very very unlikely to make more investing than it costs to borrow. You generally borrow because you can't afford to give up, or don't have the liquidity, because you don't understand what you're paying, or because it makes life simpler and you don't care.

ETA: I know I'm talking about borrowing, rather than PCP per-se.. but it amounts to the same thing; you pay for the use of someone elses money. PCP just arranges it differently.



Edited by upsidedownmark on Sunday 12th February 17:32