Accident discussion -Motorbike overtaking car turning right
Accident discussion -Motorbike overtaking car turning right
Author
Discussion

Ivanov

Original Poster:

8 posts

117 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
Hi guys, i'm new to the forum, so i hope I didn't start this thread in the wrong place!

I've been riding my motorbike(s) in London for a few years now, and have had my fair share of near misses, along with a second accident now. First one was almost identical, but had no injury, and luckily had a motorbike policeman as a witness, so that whole thing went well and got my bike paid out fully.
I have been reading discussions in the forum, but most of the ones that i found seem a bit outdated, so I wanted to share my experience for other people in the same situation.

I've read a bunch of case files, and the one that seems close is the Davis v Schrogin (2006), except there was no line of traffic and the driver was not doing a u-turn, just a right turn. I'll just spit everything out, and hopefully you guys can give advice/opinions.
I will also add any decisions by police/insurance/solicitors as soon as I get them. Hopefully this can help others.

So.... Coming back from work, I was driving southbound on Bedford Rd (20mph limit). There was a white minivan driving very slowly in front of me(10-15mph). No other vehicles in front of him. I looked at the other lane and there were no incoming vehicles. I looked in my mirror and there were no vehicles immediately behind me. I once again looked at the minivan and there was no signal indicator on, so this is when I decided to filter past the minivan on the right hand side. I was travelling at about 15mph and had used my right signal light, as I usually do. As I was overtaking the minivan, and was already passing the driver's doors, the driver made a sharp right turn (towards Tremadoc Rd). I tried to evade the minivan and went further to the right, but got knocked off my motorbike. I was travelling at around 20mph at the time of the collision.
After falling and rolling on the ground along with my motorbike, I ended up on the sidewalk where 2 people who saw me go down approached me and called the ambulance, and I was taken to hospital.
Fire brigade cleaned up the 'blood' from my bike and put it on the sidewalk. Police took a statement at the hospital.
So I have details of 2 witnesses, but don't know what they are going to say.
Also got a parking ticket before I asked a friend to re-position and chain the bike the next day! Will contest that...

Road names are correct, so google street view can give a clear picture of the roads

Injuries (other than pride) : broken left foot - bruised metatarsal bones, 3rd metatarsal bone fractured; neck pain (became severe when i woke up next morning), bum pain, shoulder pain

bike damage - possible write-off... engine casing broken with some guts out; radiator smashed; footpeg gone, mirrors, etc.

First thing insurance people said - oh...it's probably going to be 50/50... (of course they will... they want me to be at fault so I pay more onward) but I'm not happy with that because had he only indicated intent to turn, i could have stopped in no time, or if he had looked in his mirror, or even through his window, he would have seen me and my hi-viz jacket. I am very careful when overtaking and do my checks, so i'm not happy being injured and having to pay for damages

i think that sums it up... go on now... crush my dreams or make me sleep better until i get news from the insurance/solicitor



Andy XRV

3,930 posts

211 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
You overtook a slow moving vehicle coming up to a right turn...? nono

Glad you're not too badly hurt and I wish you a speedy recovery.

Tango13

10,203 posts

207 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
When I was taught how to ride many, many years ago I had the 'Unlucky thirteen' places to overtake drummed into me.

One of them was never overtake across/at a junction.

tr7v8

7,629 posts

259 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
Doesn't the Highway Code say don't overtake at junctions? It did when I did my test.

trickywoo

14,288 posts

261 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
It's a lesson learnt op. I'm super cautious even filtering past stationary traffic if there is a right turn nearby. It's almost guaranteed that a car will jump out even a number of car lengths short of the junction.

With anything moving it's not worth overtaking on a junction. Being 100% safe you would apply this to driveways and even field entrances although with these I'm sure most of us play the percentages to some degree.

ambuletz

11,806 posts

212 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
Andy XRV said:
You overtook a slow moving vehicle coming up to a right turn...? nono

Glad you're not too badly hurt and I wish you a speedy recovery.
this. I am always wary of a slow moving vehicle, especially when approaching a turn. i always think that they're unsure of their surroundings so trying to read off the street signs.

BigLion

1,497 posts

130 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
I wouldn't do that manoeuvre in a car let alone a bike.

Lesson learnt, move on.

Ivanov

Original Poster:

8 posts

117 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
I understand what you guys mean... It'll definitely be a lesson to remember...
anyways, for insurance purposes, do you think it makes any difference that he was pulling out into a residential side road from the main road? and also that there are no signs on the main road that there is a side road coming up?

RicharDC5

4,194 posts

158 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
On balance I'd say 50/50 seems about right. But that will be for your insurers to negotiate (obviously).

You shouldn't be overtaking across junctions, but the driver should mirror signal etc. A vehicle is supposed to give way to others on the carriageway when turning though, so that should work in your favour somewhat.

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
50/50 at best IMO. Overtaking past a junction is asking for it. Lack of signs or not, if the speed was as low as you say it was then there should have been plenty of time for you to see the turning.


Mike600F

1,049 posts

187 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
RicharDC5 said:
On balance I'd say 50/50 seems about right. But that will be for your insurers to negotiate (obviously).

You shouldn't be overtaking across junctions, but the driver should mirror signal etc. A vehicle is supposed to give way to others on the carriageway when turning though, so that should work in your favour somewhat.
I thought that an overtaking vehicle assumed all responsibility for the maneuver according to the highway code? Could be wrong though.

OP - feel you pain with the lack of signalling etc, but alarm bells are always going off if I'm following a slow vehicle. Until I know why, or I've been behind long enough to satisfy myself that they're just going slowly, I stay behind and a way back in case they do something stupid. From experience, they normally do - like dive into a turn/driveway/parking spot with no notice.

I'd have to say I think a 50/50 is probably what you'll have to settle for.

CubanPete

3,820 posts

219 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
OP, you have my sympathy, but I have more for the driver you have crashed into the side of. The fact you have done this twice now suggests there is a learning point that needs to be seriously considered. Regardless of lack of signs, you not seeing indicators or any other options to blame someone else as the vulnerable road user you need to start considering your own safety

You may get 50/50 as technically he should check his mirrors, i guess it depends if you really were doing 15mph...


Edited by CubanPete on Monday 13th February 21:31

Ivanov

Original Poster:

8 posts

117 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
i might have actually been doing less than 15mph before starting the maneuver. at the time of the collision i must have been up to 20. I finished work early so was in no rush and i wasn't speeding at all
if you have a look at the map - we both came out of Aristotle Rd, and i rode behind him for a good distance all the way up to maybe about 100ft before the side road, until I decided to overtake. I believe I was reasonably patient and careful with overtaking
It was pretty much only me and him on the road, as there were road works at the beginning.
Anyways, I'm not saying i'm perfect, but I do take reasonable care when on the bike. We shall see what the insurers come up with. I will surely post updates when i have some news.

spareparts

6,796 posts

258 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
Top marks for choice of handle... 'Ivanov' smile

GWS thumbup

Jujuuk68

364 posts

188 months

Monday 13th February 2017
quotequote all
Ivanov said:
First thing insurance people said - oh...it's probably going to be 50/50... (of course they will... they want me to be at fault so I pay more onward)
Not this st again! Yeah, 50/50 means that they'll pay you out in full if your comp, to only get half of it back, and will end up paying half of his claim too. If he claims even a minor whiplash, storage, recovery, legal fees and a hire van and still only recovers half his claim, your insurers will probably have to load you for about 15 years before you get close to paying back in raised premiums what you just cost them.

Anyway, as everyone else has suggested, why weren't you on warning about the slow van. People don't drive at 15mph unless they;re badly lost, looking for somewhere or otherwise distracted, and so you can expect unpredictability. Someone else driving crappily isn't a green light for you to try and match them in the lack of skills game. Given the proximity of a junction, you just weren't thinking, were you? No plan - You don't *have* to overtake if you don't feel it's safe and all the warnings were there. Still happily he didn't see you til it was too late so he's just as much to blame as you. 50/50. Davis is so completely different as to not be relevant to you.

Anyway enough of the harshness, everyone makes mistakes, and I'm pleased your not badly injured. Hope you recover soon.

RicharDC5

4,194 posts

158 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Mike600F said:
I thought that an overtaking vehicle assumed all responsibility for the maneuver according to the highway code? Could be wrong though.


I'd have to say I think a 50/50 is probably what you'll have to settle for.
I don't think situations like this are generally black and white. In cases where a someone pulls out to overtake when someone is also overtaking, the person pulling out would be deemed responsible. Also, turning left and hitting someone who is driving on the wrong side of the road would be seen as the fault of the person turning.

It can only be speculated on how this is going to go, but generally it is the responsibility of the person turning across a lane and making sure that lane is clear, regardless of what side of the road the other person is on.



Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
no line of traffic behind, none in front, and none coming the other way...?

that wasn't 'filtering' that was just overtaking

in a 20 zone, at a junction, I think you're out of luck

Biker 1

8,617 posts

150 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
WaferThinHam said:
50/50 at best IMO. Overtaking past a junction is asking for it. Lack of signs or not, if the speed was as low as you say it was then there should have been plenty of time for you to see the turning.
Agree with this.
Furthermore, filtering in slow moving traffic, I am always very wary of vehicles coming out of side roads to the left. Many times, cars in the traffic will let people out who are turning into the opposite direction to you. I've had too many near misses in this scenario....

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
''Rule 167
DO NOT overtake where you might come into conflict with other road users. For example approaching or at a road junction on either side of the road.''

if a student attempted such a manoeuvre on their DAS test it would be an instant fail and marked as 'serious'. I would expect their legal team to apportion 100% on you.

They would also probably argue that you didn't plan or consider hazards detrimental to the progress of other traffic or yourself, therefore putting all parties at risk.

mgv8

1,657 posts

302 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
I would talk to a good bike lawyer and find out where you stand. I think you are correct and it should not be 50-50 but you need someone that knows recent case law.