Test passed. Opinions sought.
Test passed. Opinions sought.
Author
Discussion

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Hello all,

For those who would rather not read the full post, here is my question, what are you views/thoughts/first hand experiences:-
For a round commute of 80 miles from Hertfordshire, A1(M) and into the City, so this will comprise of motorway riding and city riding

As a new rider, what would, fair better (pun intended) A supersport( ala Kawasaki Ninja 650) or a naked (ala Yamaha MT07/Kawasaki z650).


Full post

I have passed my motorcycle test recently.
I have been driving for nearing on 16 years ( not sure how this matters in this situation)
I am risk averse.
I am looking to use the motorcycle for commuting and to enjoy at the weekends, mainly former, thus I am willing to err on the side of comfort and a more upright riding position.
The commute would comprise of motorway and roads leading into the City from Hertfordshire.
I am 5ft 7, hence why I was keen on the Z650 especially, 790mm seat height.
As a new rider, what would, fair better (pun intended) A supersport( ala Kawasaki Ninja 650) or a naked (ala Yamaha MT07/Kawasaki z650). I guess im trying to establish whether a faired bike or naked is the more suitable, given the circumstances I intend to use the bike.
Perhaps, a supersport with its more aggressive riding position, may give me a just a little more protection from the elements, especially on the motorway?

I came across the following while searching the threads and, while an interesting read, I didn’t feel quite was the same as im asking above.

Many thanks in advance guys and I look forward to your comments, views, thoughts and experiences.






kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Very similar position, passed my test 4 weeks ago and now commute into the city on a Honda CBR600F, although mine was cheap and needs a little work doing to make it 100%

Does everything I need it to do, feels absolutely mentally fast (for now) and can filter through most gaps my CBR125R could (had this for 2.5 years previously). However the turning circle isn't great, having to change filtering lanes around stationary cars can some times result in multiple shuffling if its possible at all. In fairness if I was looking for my bike again I'd likely go MT-09 or a Street Triple R but I'd need a far bigger budget than the £1k I spent!

MotorsportTom

3,343 posts

192 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
40 miles each way will be much more pleasant with some fairing, especially for dual carriagways/motorways.

Naked will be fine when it's nicer weather, but if you are serious about commuting it's the crappy weather you need to be happier in.

If it were me I'd be considering an SV650, pretty low seat height, a very fun bike, good for a beginner as they use them in training schools and have good (enough) weather protection.

Can be had as cheap as £1k for a curvy bike and they still make them now so the worlds your oyster.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
What.s your budget?

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
@kurt

im thinking maybe 5k mark, maybe push to the 6k mark,as the Z650 would be.

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Thanks to all so far..

so, it would seem there would be a an aversion to a naked bike, based on the length of the commute, 40 miles. A nod towards the faired bike?

Interesting.

One thing that did concern me and having seen many a video on youtube and would be substantiated on here is the turning circle on the supersports in traffic. Now given i am a new rider and vertically challenged, this does somewhat concern me. Stacking it in traffic.

Harji

2,224 posts

192 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
The new Ninja 650, an updated ER6F from Kawasaki. The seat height is lower than the ER6F, lots of low down torque so perfect for urban commutes. I use mine on all sorts of road (I have a er6f) and find it perfect.

Also you own a bike called a Ninja, that's a plus.

I too am a newbie and the ER6F is a very good handling machine, very good for the new comer to biking, but it has plenty more than just being capable as a new bike, it handles very very well. The new ninja 650 is even better by all accounts.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
That's a whole hunk of change.

For a daily commute I'd consider;

- Japanese
- ABS
- Traction (if possible)
- At least half faired
- upright
- heated grips
- something that you don't mind losing a 2-2.5k on in several years when it has 'x' 1000's of miles on it.

I'd add you won't go wrong with any of the big 3 but I'd probably lean towards a Honda, although they are more expensive in the first place.

Finally, I'd suggest auto trader bikes is your friend. Lots to choose from once you input your variables. For a commuter id happily buy a bike with 5-10k on it already as well on the basis shed loads more are to come!

Berz

406 posts

223 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Harji said:
The new Ninja 650, an updated ER6F from Kawasaki. The seat height is lower than the ER6F, lots of low down torque so perfect for urban commutes. I use mine on all sorts of road (I have a er6f) and find it perfect.

Also you own a bike called a Ninja, that's a plus.

I too am a newbie and the ER6F is a very good handling machine, very good for the new comer to biking, but it has plenty more than just being capable as a new bike, it handles very very well. The new ninja 650 is even better by all accounts.
To add to this as a fellow ER6F owner, you aren't hunched over the tank like you might think OP. It's actually a very upright riding position. Good all round bike I am finding.

Try some other bikes out for comfort though. You know what sort of riding you will be doing so you know to aim for something faired (ideally) for comfort which obviously helps narrow it down. Set a budget to narrow it down further. Then go see some potential bikes and ride them for half an hour or so to get a feel for comfort.

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Its is a shed load of change. It was governed by the fact I read all the motorbike review they rave about the MT07 and that is about 6k..new..

Maybe I should consider the, “bangernomics” approach and get something still decent. It would seem £2.5k can still get me something decent that meets my requirements? The er6f is a good suggestion and I had looked at those. Ill be honest, the low (wet) weight of the mt07 really appealed to me, not mention as mentioned before it’s a naked and upright, which should aid maneuverability in and around town in traffic, when filtering.

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
test drive would be good, to get an idea of how uncomfortable on your wrists, neck, back it would be

commuting can be a lot more uncomfortable than 'normal' riding on a sports bike

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
fatboy2002 said:
Its is a shed load of change. It was governed by the fact I read all the motorbike review they rave about the MT07 and that is about 6k..new..

Maybe I should consider the, “bangernomics” approach and get something still decent. It would seem £2.5k can still get me something decent that meets my requirements? The er6f is a good suggestion and I had looked at those. Ill be honest, the low (wet) weight of the mt07 really appealed to me, not mention as mentioned before it’s a naked and upright, which should aid maneuverability in and around town in traffic, when filtering.
i just put into my auto trader app:

- honda
- up to £5k
- from 600cc
- up to 10k miles
- abs

and 86 bikes came up. i haven't gone through them though!

mgv8

1,657 posts

302 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Anything Honda around 600cc and does not have RR in the name. Pay 2k to 3k and change after a year.
Give you time to make up your mind what you really want, should not break down, and easy to sell off at the end. Last of all if it does hit the ground, no big deal.

2wheelsjimmy

624 posts

128 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Just get something cheap and boring to commute on. Faired or half faired and abs.

Then when you've a few miles under your belt, consider a nicer bike as 2nd bike.

No point spending 6k on your first bike just to commute it.

Sv650 would be a good choice.

Gusto

608 posts

264 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Street Triple R has the turning circle of a fully laden oil tanker. Nice bike, though very windy on motorways.

RizzoTheRat

29,172 posts

223 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
2wheelsjimmy said:
Just get something cheap and boring to commute on. Faired or half faired and abs.
There's a lot to be said for this approach, a Bandit or Fazer make a decent commuter and can be picked up pretty cheaply.

Personally I prefer a more upright riding position, something like a Versys (same engine as the ER6 in a more upright frame) might be worth a look but I'm not sure how high the seat is.

If you're planning to commute in all weather then don't skimp on decent kit. Nothing puts you off riding like being wet and cold. So you might be better off going with a cheaper bike and spending the rest on some good goretex kit.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Due to the increased protection leather will always offer, we ended up riding around with a fleece and/or goretex outdoor jacket over the top of them.

It also meant washing and re-activating the goretex could be done on a regular basis during periods of high road crud and worked out significantly cheaper than buying a heavy textile jacket for half of the year and leathers for the other.

It was also a lot easier to carry the goretex all year round under the seat or in the pannier.

heated waistcoat a godsend too.

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all

@2wheelsJimmy, indeed you raise a good about splitting my budget so its more weighted towards decent gear.

@kurt, point taken and noted. A good tip.

Biker 1

8,618 posts

150 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
fatboy2002 said:
It was governed by the fact I read all the motorbike review they rave about the MT07 and that is about 6k..new..
I've read stories about MT07s dissolving over winter.......
Perhaps nearly new one of these: http://www.honda.co.uk/motorcycles/range/adventure...

I've had Hondas before, & they are very well screwed together.

fatboy2002

Original Poster:

10 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th February 2017
quotequote all
Ah, yes the ubiquitous NC range. I have read that they are great commuting bikes. Indeed, I have seen a few around town and had the chance to speak to a few of the riders, when a approached. The abiding thoughts were the outstanding fuel economy..

I liked them, when researching initially, though over a period of time, they have been bumped further down my list..mainly due to the, “sexier” models that I have in comparison. Not to mention, the MT is more engaging and fun to ride, according to several reports.

Also, my justification for the Mt07 was, if I can obtain 50-60mpg( this would seem an obtainable real world figure, reading the MT forums, it would not be too far off the actual mpg figures of the NC, not to mention the MT07 looks a meaner.

Some of the prices of a used NC750 are attractive, circa £3k, when I looked last.