Enduro riding - what bike?
Enduro riding - what bike?
Author
Discussion

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
All,

It's coming to the time where i will be pulling the trigger on a off-road play bike/second bike.

After trying out the Yamaha off road experience, some things i know -

I know i enjoy enduro green lanes, quarrys, and off road trails.

I don't enjoy MX tracks.

I know i want a 250cc, anything bigger is to heavy for me.

I know i want an electric start, but do i want a kick start as well?

I know i will be riding on roads to get to places, and doing green lanes - so i know i need to be road registered/legal. I'll also trailer it.

I know i will be riding in quarry's for play days - Cowm Quarry is a good example.

I think i will want to compete in the odd enduro events. But, i wont be riding competitively, just something to do to get out of the house.

I have 3.5k-4k to spend - 2nd hand, it's my first off road bike.

I don't want something time intensive to maintain - but happy to spanner an evening a week after a ride.. nothing complex - i am mechanically inept, but can follow a manual/youtube. Happy to spend money on consumables - it is a hobby.

What bike am i wanting here?

CRF250L
KTM EXC 250
WRF250F

TIA.


308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
BobSaunders said:
All,

It's coming to the time where i will be pulling the trigger on a off-road play bike/second bike.

After trying out the Yamaha off road experience, some things i know -

I know i enjoy enduro green lanes, quarrys, and off road trails.

I don't enjoy MX tracks.

I know i want a 250cc, anything bigger is to heavy for me.

I know i want an electric start, but do i want a kick start as well?

I know i will be riding on roads to get to places, and doing green lanes - so i know i need to be road registered/legal. I'll also trailer it.

I know i will be riding in quarry's for play days - Cowm Quarry is a good example.

I think i will want to compete in the odd enduro events. But, i wont be riding competitively, just something to do to get out of the house.

I have 3.5k-4k to spend - 2nd hand, it's my first off road bike.

I don't want something time intensive to maintain - but happy to spanner an evening a week after a ride.. nothing complex - i am mechanically inept, but can follow a manual/youtube. Happy to spend money on consumables - it is a hobby.

What bike am i wanting here?

CRF250L
KTM EXC 250
WRF250F

TIA.
3 good options there. Put the KTM at the top end of the scale for capability and likely maintenance time and costs. Put the Honda at the bottom for maintenance time required but will also be a bit more agricultural in terms of performance of engine and suspension. The WR falls bang in the middle, possibly more towards the KTM end. Realistically, you can't go wrong with either of the three, it's just dependent on your priorities. For your use case, I'd say Yamaha.

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Thanks.

Anything i am missing out on?

Anything i have not considered? Or ill thought out?

Do i really want a MX bike which has a "no lights" MOT but with speedo etc?

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Enduro and MX bikes may look the same, but they are very different bikes. An MX bike is much angrier to ride. Pretty well everyone seems to be on KTMs these days. Any bike with an electric start will also have a kick start on it. When buying, don't buy on how shiny and pretty it looks, plastics are very cheap and easy to replace, look at the mechanicals. Expect to damage the bike too, so don't be precious about it.

Cowm is a very tricky place to ride and getting injured is very easy. Make sure you buy some high quality protection for your knees, wrists, elbows, chest, back, neck and head. Do not skimp on this, as you'll understand why after your first fall.

foxsasha

1,469 posts

166 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
I'd go for a KTM 300 EXC. There is a reason why KTM absolutely dominate the enduro market. Dont consider an mx bike.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
You'll need to decide whether you want a two or four stroke bike as well.

curlie467

7,650 posts

232 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Ktm exc250 2 stroke enduro bike.

Yes you do want lights, just in case you get caught out.

Like gavia says, get good gear.

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Re. gear - Yes, agreed & noted, i came off a few times on the experience day. Good protection is a must.

Re. MX - i had pretty much discounted it, but wanted to check. Thanks.

Re. stroke - Ah i have just realised, the 250 EXC is a 2-stroke. Opinions wanted guys? two stroke or four stroke?

2-stroke requires more maintenance? shorter service timeframes? oil mixing? or am i missing something here?

I think 4-stroke ideally, less faff from what i have read.

Thanks



Edited by BobSaunders on Sunday 5th March 16:09

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
husqvarna?

I think KTM is where it is at...

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
A 250 or 125 4 stroke would be my recommendation. Do not go for anything bigger than a 250. A 250 2 stroke is a powerful bike compared to a 250 4 stroke, so bear that in mind.

All the bikes will need a lot of maintenance to keep them working well. For 4 strokes regular oil and filter changes, ideally every other ride. For all bikes, the air filter will need cleaning and re-oiling every ride and replaced regularly, chains, sprockets and tyres need to be swapped regularly too, as they get worked very hard.

The good news is everything is dirt (pun intended) cheap compared to roadbikes.

You want a slower bike to learn on, not a powerful one.

crusty

765 posts

251 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
BobSaunders said:
husqvarna?

I think KTM is where it is at...
If it's in the last couple of years they are the same bike just with a different look

OP - perfect bike for you is a ktm 250 freeride

308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
If you're starting out and not much of a mechanic, get a four stroke. Two stroke takes more skill (wait for it), more gear changes and although it's cheaper to maintain because you can rebuild them yourself, if you're not mechanically minded that benefit is negated anyway.

You don't want an mx bike. The mx variant is usually a more highly strung motor that needs more maintenance, will have stiffer suspension and different power delivery. Many enduro events will insist on having some enduro bits fitted anyway, including lights.

The KTMs can be had in two or four stroke in the enduro range. Husqvarna is literally a premium KTM (think Lexus vs Toyota), to be honest I doubt you'd see the value from the extra spend. KTM is no doubt flavour of the month in the enduro scene and they are good. If you're somewhat competent on a bike in general, I would recommend you try a 350 exc four stroke. For me it's the ideal blend of power and weight and you're less likely to be wanting more power after 6 months.

Andybow

1,177 posts

149 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
I have a excf350 great bike, out of what you want personally I'd go for the new WR250F, maybe a bit above your budget , there is a couple for sale second hand, forget the crf250l it's not a offroad bike, unless you spend money on it, the crf250x or xrl are though, again both good bikes but the newer 2015 on wrf is a cracking bike. Get good gear as said above

curlie467

7,650 posts

232 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
BobSaunders said:
husqvarna?

I think KTM is where it is at...
The exc 250 is a 2 stroke.
The exc f 250 is a 4 stroke.


2 strokes are ace, that's what I would go for but they are very different machines to each other.

BusLane

45 posts

128 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Hi Bob,

A 250cc (MX) two stroke will be a beast. I love them. I've had a couple.
In my experience if well looked after, two strokes are reliable, not really major maintenance as 1) easy to work on 2) cheaper in some respects.

You might not have to do valve clearance checks on a 2 stroke MX bike unlike 4 strokes, but in competition rings are replaced fairly regular. Although not so regular when not racing. That's not a hard job though with no cams etc.. Service intervals are what they are.

Unless you're into riding on bumpy fields or dirt roads, a focused (MX) two stroke can be quite a handful (which I like) but wheeling and spraying dirt everywhere is not the most efficient way to make progress.

If I was good enough I'd have a two stroke for enduro, but I'm not.
I have no idea how much more ride-able an enduro two stroke is?
My YZ250WR, WR = wide ratio, was factory road reg'd, it had head lights, so had a generator & heavier flywheel and bigger fuel tank.
It was more tame than my KX250...so maybe a good for enduro but not a good MX bike.

If you take away that 2 stroke MX wildness, I'd probably choose a 4 stroke anyway. MX is obviously not enduro.

Hence, I am still wondering If I have bought the right bike for me. I've just bought a brand new KTM (450) exc.
Low down grunt so you can ride it slower easier, but the weight means it is less BMX like.
Although a two stroke (enduro bike) is probably still fine at slow speeds, it's the way these bikes make power..

4 stokes = regular valve clearance checks.
Although as above, most I speak too don't competitively race and haven't needed to adjust them yet (KTM).

If you believe google, some models / owners Honda CRF seem to need more regular adjustment. I think my freinds had water pump issues. The WR has pros and cons too. I think some have less gears 5 not 6? Most people I know ride KTM now.

KTM, I think newer than 2013 are injection (4 stroke) and some come with electric start and kick start, some the kick start is an extra.

Engine rebuilds are more expensive than 2 strokes, (valves) but again if not racing, are not as frequent.
It seems KTM might suggest 120hrs. Some who do enduro are still going at 450hrs with no new parts..
Google shows some silly KTM(exc) owners with mileage, a bike road bike would be into engine rebuild territory.

I'm not suggesting a 450cc 4 stroke, it's quite a big bike.

Personally I find a 250cc 4 stroke too slow for (me) for some riding I do. A 250cc 4 stroke would probably be perfect for me for hard enduro (logs etc) or not.

For £4500. It's quite possible to get a private sale very low miles 2016 KTM, or get a slightly older trade in one (2014) from KTM with low hours where they know the bike.

If you buy used look at the spec, some bits are extras.

I just bought a new bike because I've had too many used bikes that I've had to throw money at.
I might be a little bit ocd, or some owners have completely different standards:

The trouble is, now I've raced (cars) and have a few road bikes with better suspension, suspension life/use can be relevant too, even throttle cables etc... I'd guess the point is, sometimes a bit more initial out lay of cash is cheaper than being bitten in the ass, then spending money on something, that might need more bits sooner. Unless of course you know the previous owner & the bike.

In some respects I'd be a bit less concerned buying a used road going 1000cc sports bike than a used off road bike.

My old (pre owned) YZ250WR, needed a new head, replate the bore. I think I had to get new crankcases too, despite the fact it ran perfect when I got it. It was still cheap to rebuild that motor (paid someone to do it) and it would have been fine for a long time then, with regular up keep. The last owner(S) must have been using and abusing it, not maintaining it.

The only exception, I got lucky when I bought a KX250 from a race engine builder.
The best bike I have ever owned for smiles, but not something I'd ride in the woods.


PS. some new bikes have traction control and different maps. Sorry if too much info?

Have fun.



Edited by BusLane on Sunday 5th March 19:05

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
curlie467 said:
BobSaunders said:
husqvarna?

I think KTM is where it is at...
The exc 250 is a 2 stroke.
The exc f 250 is a 4 stroke.


2 strokes are ace, that's what I would go for but they are very different machines to each other.
Brilliant, thanks - i do not think i came across the difference between them, and just assumed they were all 4-stroke.

BobSaunders

Original Poster:

3,110 posts

186 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
BusLane said:
Hi Bob,

<stuff>

Sorry if too much info?

Have fun.
Hey, all good - i asked for opinions and information. This is all something to think about! thanks.

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Couple of points from above...

Don't use an MX bike for enduro. Different engine characteristics, flywheel weights, gearbox ratios and most critically, totally unsuitable suspension. likewise, an enduro bike will struggle when pushed on an MX course.

Keep your elbows up. makes turning easier
Stand up AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. You're centralising your weight, you have far better balance and control and the bike is easier to control.
love your back brake. The front is nice but the rear is an aid to control.
Love the throttle. A spinning rear wheel has a greater gyro effect and makes the bike more stable. learn to get the back spinning up to control the bike.
master the clutch. You can forget gears if you can master the clutch, back brake & throttle
Relax. Let the bike move around under you. Don't hang on for dear life. Arm pump will set in and you'll be speeding your way to the scene of your accident.
Master slow speed control. balance. technique is vital and finding or maintaining traction is a skill worth learning. Don't just pull the cable and hope....
gear. DO NOT SCRIMP. good knee braces are vital. It's easy to destroy a knee in a silly low speed off so get the very best stuff. BUPA is not a viable alternative biggrin
Keep your knees bent and supple. think of them as additional suspension units.

as for a bike, the Beta 300RR is a bike you can grow into. Same motor as the KTM 300 but the PV is adjustable to allow a nice mellow delivery going through to a savage arm ripping monster. Don't be scared of a 300 btw. usually the same power as a 250 but with a fatter bottom end and softer delivery. Still strong on top but not as revvy.
4 strokes are for gheys...

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
I know you said an Enduro bike will struggle on an MX track when pushed hard, but it's really unlikely a novice will be able to push it too hard.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Start with a 250 4 stroke from Yamaha or Beta (or KTM but I dont like the PDS rear suspension as it kicks back hard over logs/fallen trees)

When you're wringing its neck and hankering for more speed then buy a 300 2 stroke.

I went ttr250 (not powerful and not an enduro bike but still capable), Beta 450 (torquey beast), Beta 300 (the nuts).

You will encounter a lot of people who think they are Graham Jarvis, they are not though.

You will encounter a lot of MX guys at enduros, they tend to tire out after about an hour though.

Keep a good steady pace get the bike properly set up and finish the races, once you have got your technique and your bike set up sorted then aim to get good places.

I mostly came mid placed in the races I entered - because I have work on Monday and I need to be injury free!