Hitting a pedestrian
Author
Discussion

Cbull

Original Poster:

4,483 posts

202 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
This morning on my commute I managed to hit a pedestrian. I was overtaking traffic (on the wrong side of the road) preparing to move back into the que for a right turn in Manchester city centre. Suddenly a bloke had walked out of the road in front of me not paying attention (he had headphones on). I slammed the front brake, took him out and I went sliding. Lucky it was a low speed incident and both of us are only a little shook up.

He admitted fault straight away and apologised. It’s just one of them things, sht happens. After taking his name and number I assumed he would help foot the bill of the minimal damage but he said no. To be fair he was a gentleman in all of this but just said he couldn’t afford to help out with the bill. It’s probably £1-200 worth from Ebay if I do the work plus getting it home (doesn’t go into 1st gear).

What do I do? I’ve pushed the bike to work, I doubt the banks break down cover will take it home (usually nearest garage). Do I pursue a claim OR am I at fault? Just not sure. Has anyone else been in a similar scenario?

Thanks.

V40Vinnie

863 posts

150 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Open to correction here but i always thought in a Vehicle versus Pedestrian collision the vehicle was at fault by default? I am just guessing here but if you claim it will be similar to hitting an animal on your insurance i.e. your fault so its up to you if you want to risk a NCD. i would report the incident anyway just incase the pedestrian decides he doesnt feel well and fancies some free money.

Cbull

Original Poster:

4,483 posts

202 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Oh right, never knew that. Suppose thats why I asked. Yeah, it's a strange situation, I don't really blame him because it's hard for people in vehicles to think about bikes never mind pedestrians. Forgot to mention he walked out from between stationary vehicles.

V40Vinnie

863 posts

150 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
Oh right, never knew that. Suppose thats why I asked. Yeah, it's a strange situation, I don't really blame him because it's hard for people in vehicles to think about bikes never mind pedestrians. Forgot to mention he walked out from between stationary vehicles.
Its the problem with being plugged into an Iphone or whatever. Pedestrians exsist in a private bubble not caring about the outside world...

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
What bike is it?

If its a 125 a new lever (and worst case hanger bracket) should be sub £100 and is easy enough to change yourself. A bent handlebar end is ~£20 and again can be fitted easily yourself. Double/triple the numbers for other bikes.

For the sake of a few hundred quid I'd just fix it myself using pattern parts and carry on

Cbull

Original Poster:

4,483 posts

202 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Yeah 09 CBF 125. As far as I can see the side panel has cracked, , gear lever wobbly, the front light works but is dangling (I suspect a bolt has snapped from underneath), front wind shield crack at a few bolts and the gear lever (down at the foot) has been pushed in. It seems to go from 2nd to N OK but doesn't want to go into 1st gear fsr (maybe because it's bent in). Not really diagnosed it properly. I did really hit from the front and I've not checked to see if the suspension to the bars are bent in anyway.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
V40Vinnie said:
Open to correction here but i always thought in a Vehicle versus Pedestrian collision the vehicle was at fault by default? I am just guessing here but if you claim it will be similar to hitting an animal on your insurance i.e. your fault so its up to you if you want to risk a NCD. i would report the incident anyway just incase the pedestrian decides he doesnt feel well and fancies some free money.
I think you are confusing fault with where the claim is made.

It is very easy for the pedestrian to be at fault by doing things like walking into the road without looking. As most pedestrians don't have insurance then the only insurance to claim against is that of the driver/rider. You could try to recover the costs from the pedestrian via a civil claim but my guess (and it is a total guess) is that you'd have a lot of hard work and expense with a significant risk of not getting anything.

Fleegle

16,710 posts

207 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I would be thankful the pedestrian hasn't made a song and dance about it

Suck it up and put it down to experience

freddytin

1,184 posts

258 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Why can't you ride it in 2nd gear ?

Or am I being a little thick smile ?

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
2 options, one just leave it & stand bill yourself.

The other is to have a sensible chat with the chap, explain you're not in a position to repair bike yourself & need it for work etc. Ask if he has home contents insurance as the liability cover here will cover his negligence.

The second option though, once insurance is mentioned, may give him ideas about pursuing a claim against you & your bike insurance.


On a final point, think you may need to report the incident to the police, my understanding used to be hitting anything dog size or bigger(!) requires reporting to the police.

Wyvern971

1,507 posts

239 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Glad that neither of you are hurt.

I doubt you will be able to claim off them, I'd just fix the bike yourself.

They might put in a claim to your insurer at a later date, so inform them now, even just a notification and not a claim.
(If you don't this can really come back to bite you if they put in a claim later on (usually after being told that it wasn't their fault by friends and family), and you have not informed your insurer).

Best of luck in any case.

JQ

6,892 posts

210 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Did you get the details of any witnesses? If so get a statement off them as soon as possible. A colleague hit a drunk pedestrian who'd run into the road and totally admitted fault at the scene. 6 months later and the personal injury lawyers made a claim.

I witnessed an accident and gave my details to the non-fault party and thought nothing of it. 9 months later I was contacted for a statement and really struggled to remember the exact details and I ended up not being of much help. Therefore contact any witnesses now and get them to write down what happened and send it to you, just in case it does come back to bite you at a later date.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
V40Vinnie said:
Open to correction here but i always thought in a Vehicle versus Pedestrian collision the vehicle was at fault by default?
No such thing as default. Pedestrian can be at fault if not paying attention and acting in a manner in which a person driving (or riding) in a reasonable, legal fashion could not be expected to avoid a collision with them. Key points are whether that definition applies to the OP.

Cbull

Original Poster:

4,483 posts

202 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice.

I guess I'll just foot the bill and struggle getting it home. A bit dubious about a 30 mile trip home in second gear though, will have to see.

Not sure about reporting it though. Police are only usually interested if someone is injured and I'm not overly keen on letting the insurance know as you hear the stories of peoples insurance going up when they simply enquire about potential small claims. Saying that, I am now worried about the potential backlash.

Renn Sport

2,761 posts

240 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Fleegle said:
I would be thankful the pedestrian hasn't made a song and dance about it

Suck it up and put it down to experience
This.

Just be thankful you are not being pursued for injury. Being a biker you'll get done.

imdeman87

946 posts

138 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Have you reported/are you going to report the incident to your insurer?

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
Thanks for the advice.

I guess I'll just foot the bill and struggle getting it home. A bit dubious about a 30 mile trip home in second gear though, will have to see.

Not sure about reporting it though. Police are only usually interested if someone is injured and I'm not overly keen on letting the insurance know as you hear the stories of peoples insurance going up when they simply enquire about potential small claims. Saying that, I am now worried about the potential backlash.
I know it's not nice, but I would just chalk it up as a loss.
The pedestrian could have easily made a massive fuss out of it and it could have (still could!) get very messy very quickly.

I'm sure you'll be fine getting home with 2nd and above, just give it a bit of a scoot! laugh

Glad you and the bike aren't badly injured.

supercommuter

2,169 posts

133 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I nearly had a similar situation the other day albeit I was on the road doing 30 mph when a jogger ran out from behind a parked lorry ac cross the road in front of me, It was almost a very messy situation.

I would ride the bike home in second, it will be fine. Then just fix it myself and don't hit any more pedestrians.

Devils advocate:
If somebody ran me over as I was walking to work and then asked me to fix their vehicle I am not sure i would be forthcoming in payment.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
Thanks for the advice.

I guess I'll just foot the bill and struggle getting it home. A bit dubious about a 30 mile trip home in second gear though, will have to see.

Not sure about reporting it though. Police are only usually interested if someone is injured and I'm not overly keen on letting the insurance know as you hear the stories of peoples insurance going up when they simply enquire about potential small claims. Saying that, I am now worried about the potential backlash.
Do you normally do the 30 mile trip in 1st?

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
supercommuter said:
I nearly had a similar situation the other day albeit I was on the road doing 30 mph when a jogger ran out from behind a parked lorry ac cross the road in front of me, It was almost a very messy situation.

I would ride the bike home in second, it will be fine. Then just fix it myself and don't hit any more pedestrians.

Devils advocate:
If somebody ran me over as I was walking to work and then asked me to fix their vehicle I am not sure i would be forthcoming in payment.
If it was me, and I accepted that my stupidity/lack of observation had caused damage (and thus cost) to someone else’s property then I think I would offer to at least contribute to the cost of repairs.

It’s a sad day when people can’t own up to the fact they’ve made a mistake, and contribute towards the costs of that mistake.