Insurance claim banter
Insurance claim banter
Author
Discussion

Myles Peraua

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Just bantering here but thought I'd share.

I was knocked off my R1200RT a couple of weeks ago, very low speed, almost all the damage was cosmetic apart from a dented-in exhaust header. I picked the bike up and continued my ride into work the day it happened, and rode it home again. From 10ft away you probably wouldn't be able to see any damage, and if liability was down to me and I wasn't involved in a claim, I'd probably bolt a new setoff headers on and ignore everything else. I got hit on one side which pushed me over onto the other side.

Damage amounts to:

Scuffed front mudguard
Scuffed front fairing panel
Scuffed fork leg
Scuffed/bent crash bars and head protectors
Tiny scuff on edge of mirror
Couple of other tiny marks here & there
Scuffs to swing arm/shaft drive housing.

I've just been told that the repair estimate is a little over…….are you sitting down?…… FIVE THOUSAND POUNDS eek Yes, £5,000. £5k. 5 large. 5 bags.

I would post all the pictures up but it'll bore you.

So now, notwithstanding that the 3d party is disputing liability (but I have a 100% positive witness), it's borderline write-off. They write off at 60%, I pad £9k for the bike in August, so that's 55% before any depreciation and any other costs (replacement bike, etc) are taken into account.

I know I can buy the bike back, or someone else will, and it'll live again I'm sure but that just seems such a waste to me, a perfectly good bike with a few marks on it and suddenly it's a write-off.

Once I have the final decision In going to have to work out what to do, the bike is on PCP (my first-ever PCP on any vehicle) so I don't own it, but the options and complications of how that could play out will need some thought.



Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Hey nice to see you back, I would be even nicererer if you used your old forum name.

Myles Peraua

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Biker's Nemesis said:
Hey nice to see you back, I would be even nicererer if you used your old forum name.
Fair cop guvnor, I think I might just change it back. I've been MrC for very many years and I thought perhaps it was time for a change, but hey, we are who we are!

CAPP0

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
How long does it take for me to become me again? Ah, I'm back!

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
CAPP0 said:
How long does it take for me to become me again? Ah, I'm back!
That's better.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I though the write off level was even higher than 60%, ie about 75%, as that was what insurance companies could reasonably expect to get on the "open market" for a damaged bike.

I think £5k is almost criminal, but I can understand how a small bump can end up as such a huge claim. The cost of parts, particularly plastic parts, is the problem!

As the bike is a commuter, I'd be very tempted to get it written of, buy it back then run it with minimal repairs.

CAPP0

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
As the bike is a commuter, I'd be very tempted to get it written of, buy it back then run it with minimal repairs.
Must admit that's certainly a strong contender for the outcome.

Tall_Paul

1,915 posts

258 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Replacement swingarm, replacement fork... Yeah, I wonder why the repair cost is so high? tongue outlaugh

Can't see BMW labour costs being cheap either, and they'll need to strip a good bit of the bike down to do the above I'd imagine.

supercommuter

2,169 posts

133 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Tall_Paul said:
Replacement swingarm, replacement fork... Yeah, I wonder why the repair cost is so high? tongue outlaugh.
This...I don't think it is surprising at all!

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
OP this is a prime reason why insurance premiums are so high.. theft then the actual 'repair costs' to the bike if you need to claim with each part of the chain taking their cut.
Probably explains why there are so many Cat D bikes about.

Hope you get it sorted.

Edited by sjtscott on Tuesday 7th March 13:40

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Yeah, ideal result is to let them write it off and then just buy it back.

All the bikes I've owned have been cat-D plastic damage and I've just continued to use them as before with no/minimal repair. Also the scuffs mean it appears less desirable to thieves when parked up in the City all day!

Can make a tidy profit on it too! - the old bike was a CBR125R, bought for £1,200 as a cat-d from a salvage yard at 6 months old with 3k miles. It was written off at 3.2 years old with 15k miles, I was paid out £2k! retained the bike for £400 and sold it on again un-fixed (forks were banana'ed) for £750!

More than paid for itself!

CAPP0

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Tall_Paul said:
Replacement swingarm, replacement fork... Yeah, I wonder why the repair cost is so high? tongue outlaugh

Can't see BMW labour costs being cheap either, and they'll need to strip a good bit of the bike down to do the above I'd imagine.
I think they're either being lazy, or trying it on. The swingarm damage, as far as I can see, is a cover and two grommet-things, on the final drive. 10 minutes tops to change. But a while lot more if you spec a new complete swingarm/drive unit. The damage is TERRIBLE:






The fork leg I guess, to put back to A1 condition, requires a new one, but only the fixed part. I guess they (a) have decided it needs a whole fork and (b) have decided they'd better fit both sides.

Maybe they found damage I wasn't aware of, but it rode home perfectly post-accident.[url]

UnluckyTimmeh

3,698 posts

244 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Yep, that final drive unit will be £1000 on its own. Fork leg probably around the £400 if memory serves me correctly. Headers £8-900 etc etc.
We're always told to estimate them to how they were before the damage occurred. So, if it's the tiniest of marks, it gets noted and marked for replacement.

We're told that write-off value is 2/3rd of retail market value.

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I had a slow low side on ice at the start of last year. Friendly garage it happened outside of took it in for the day bodged up my shifter and front brake res so I could get home and done me a report on the damage in case I wanted to go through my insurance.

Bearing in mind this is a 12 year old SV at book prices the repairs came back around the £500 mark which is around a third of what the bike is worth. Everything was fixed up for less than £100 with better than OEM parts in some cases and an afternoon in the garden.

They were quoting to replace absolutely anything that had the smallest hint of damage, so a tiny scratch on the end of my lever and bar end meant I was being quoted to replace them both as a set same with my crash bung. It's not surprising you're looking at a write off of some sort unless you're running something very exotic and worth saving.

308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Did you happen to take gap insurance when the nice man offered it? scratchchin

Tall_Paul

1,915 posts

258 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
That's the main issue, they repair anything with damage on it so the bike is back to 'as new' where as most of us would be content with a scratch here and there.


CAPP0

Original Poster:

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
308mate said:
Did you happen to take gap insurance when the nice man offered it? scratchchin
Now there's a thing - he was such a nice man that he never offered it, and it obviously never occurred to me…..

The insurance guy was throwing various options out at me for how it could play out, but I'll wait until they confirm and throw out some figures then I'll talk to Coopers.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Tall_Paul said:
That's the main issue, they repair anything with damage on it so the bike is back to 'as new' where as most of us would be content with a scratch here and there.
Would we though? If someone damaged my bike, or car then I'd expect it back in the condition it was before, or better. I certainly wouldn't accept the odd scratch here and there.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
Tall_Paul said:
That's the main issue, they repair anything with damage on it so the bike is back to 'as new' where as most of us would be content with a scratch here and there.
Would we though? If someone damaged my bike, or car then I'd expect it back in the condition it was before, or better. I certainly wouldn't accept the odd scratch here and there.
For an accident which is someone elses fault yes I want it back perfect! Had this exact thing happen to myself in 2000 but it seems the place making the repair were somewhat more reasonable in their quote and it was around 1/4 of the bikes value.

I have since realised in most cases its not worth claiming on the insurance unless 1. its 100% someone else's fault and they or their insurance is paying or 2. its just easier to spend a few hundred quid getting it fixed for minor stuff to make it roadworth and safe if its a commuter that you own outright avoiding claiming off your insurance. or 3 the bike is totaled and you'll get your monies worth out of the fully comp claim and you'd like a bike to ride.

Brummmie

5,284 posts

252 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I was rammed of my 1150GS (2 wheeled compressor) in a road rage incident, bike went over in no more than a gentle tumble, scuffed rocker cover etc, i went over wing and bonnet, bike got wrote off, it essentially ended up for free, and i sold it for the same again.
Can you buy it back?