Back to bikes - London commute- help me choose
Back to bikes - London commute- help me choose
Author
Discussion

TNJ

Original Poster:

434 posts

193 months

Sunday 12th March 2017
quotequote all
Having got fed up with cancelled trains, strikes, tube problems etc, I have decided to ride into work. Will be 10 miles each way from south east London to NW1.

I have not had a bike for 10 years so want something user friendly but which I am not going to get bored with after 6 months.

I have done the sports bikes thing in the past but not really suitable for my expected use.

I am thinking of either a Triumph Street Triple or a BMW F800R Sport. Both similar price and easy on the insurance group. A lot of other appealing bikes are simply uninsurable - probably for a good reason.

I know that the new Street Triple is released in a month or so, but that means some great deals on the outgoing model. Bearing in mind that I am highly unlikely to notice a difference between the old and new models, and I need some kit which I can get thrown into the deal with the old model, I would choose that over the new one.

If there are any opinions as to the better bike - or anything I have not considered - I would be happy to hear. Also, reliability will be important - I do need to get to work every day.

I am test riding the BMW next weekend and hopefully the Triumph as well.

Anyway, happy to get back onto a motorcycle again - hopefully many enjoyable safe miles ahead!

gavgavgav

1,569 posts

260 months

Sunday 12th March 2017
quotequote all
where you are going to park it will have some impact on the choice, if you want to keep it.

TNJ

Original Poster:

434 posts

193 months

Sunday 12th March 2017
quotequote all
True - garaged at home and private car park at work. Security should not be a problem I hope

Tribal Chestnut

3,001 posts

213 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
I'd get a sports bike for a commute like that. The narrower bars make a massive difference in terms of filtering ability.

tjlazer

875 posts

205 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
I ride a street triple for the same purposes you have in mind. They are great bikes and a lot of fun when things open up and really easy to filter with when it's a bit stickier.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
Pretty much any bike you want will do the job so pick the one that works for you. One thing I’ve found surprisingly important for a London commute is folding mirrors. Being able to fold in the mirrors can open up the options to a surprising number of gaps in stationary traffic, especially when filtering past larger vehicles.

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
I went for a Ducati Monster 821 in the end. I liked the idea of a Street Triple, but as I was coming from a Monster (M600) I wanted to stick with Ducati.

upsidedownmark

2,120 posts

166 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
IME:

Street triple is a rather desireable bike. It may be the same insurance group, but anecdotally I hear a lot about insurance being a bit frightening for them because they're more prone to walking off than most.

I would disagree with the 'benefit' of a sportsbike having narrower bars. They also tend to have sh**e lock, which can matter a lot if you want to jump lanes in near stationary traffic. Had a lot easier time filtering around london on my upright ER6 with wide-ass bars than I did on the 848 or the R6.

Mirrors ditto - lots of folks riding around with them folded in / never paying any attention to what's going on behind.. but I found mirrors were usually went over/under anything I was passing, and rare that the mirrors either side of you are in the same place, so a bit of a left/right rock got around it. YMMV.

I'd go for something decent to ride, but a bit unsexy and don't wash it biggrin

tjlazer

875 posts

205 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
If the OP has secure parking both ends then, like me, you're in luck and can ride a street triple. Leaving it on the street is not advisable though (oh the irony) and the insurance will be punative.

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
As others have said keeping it will be the main problem if it's remotely desirable.

I'd get a nasty looking old Fazer or V-Strom and not worry about it getting nicked or scratched or bumped.

TNJ

Original Poster:

434 posts

193 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments - insurance for the Street Triple is ok at £650 fully comp. BMW was quoted at £75 less so not much between them. Will test ride both and then choose - but heart says Triumph so that is favourite at present

I have discounted sports bikes - I used to have an R6 and a 748S - and never enjoyed riding them through London.

Very depressing to hear that thefts are so common - never really think about it when leaving the cars parked when out and about.

chrisste

1 posts

122 months

Monday 13th March 2017
quotequote all
Supermoto all the way, WR250X or something along those lines.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
upsidedownmark said:
Mirrors ditto - lots of folks riding around with them folded in / never paying any attention to what's going on behind..
Correct approach:

Arrive at gap with mirrors out.
Fold mirrors in to go through gap.
Return mirrors to out position once through gap.

This has got me through gaps that many bikes with non folding mirrors have avoided.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Correct approach:

Arrive at gap with mirrors out.
Fold mirrors in to go through gap.
Return mirrors to out position once through gap.

This has got me through gaps that many bikes with non folding mirrors have avoided.
There are times when I miss my NR750 spring loaded car style mirrors Honda also fitted to my old Blackbird - the mirrors on that bike were the widest part and I generally used them as width indicators. However most of the time it really isn't an issue on a speed triple which is a tiny bike in comparison I'm using standard mirrors on stalks retrofitted from a V4 Tuono and the bar end ones the bike came with were truly useless and not good for filtering due to added bar width. Its generally the sticking out Luton/flatbed transit mirrors which are the issue now when you are filtering down the middle traffic and you have two of these vans directly side by side. You get used to which gaps you'll fit through very quickly. In most cases its slowing down enough to allow you to dip the offending mirror below the vans and you're off again.

Tribal Chestnut

3,001 posts

213 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
upsidedownmark said:
IME:
I would disagree with the 'benefit' of a sportsbike having narrower bars. They also tend to have sh**e lock, which can matter a lot if you want to jump lanes in near stationary traffic. Had a lot easier time filtering around london on my upright ER6 with wide-ass bars than I did on the 848 or the R6.

Mirrors ditto - lots of folks riding around with them folded in / never paying any attention to what's going on behind.. but I found mirrors were usually went over/under anything I was passing, and rare that the mirrors either side of you are in the same place, so a bit of a left/right rock got around it. YMMV.

I'd go for something decent to ride, but a bit unsexy and don't wash it biggrin
We'll have to agree to disagree on the sports bike! I find the R1 so much better than my old 950SM and a fair bit better than the FZ1. It's rare that I get stuck in a cul-de-sac and need that amount of lock, however on occasions it can be beneficial, as can a little more suspension travel for those occasional pesky obstructions.

Mirrors are often at white van/SUV mirror height, so folding does help.

As for unsexy and not cleaning it - I agree whole heartedly.

Globs

13,847 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
TNJ said:
Will be 10 miles each way from south east London to NW1.
Sounds like < 300cc scooter territory.
Anything nice will be stolen.
Forget the ideal Vespa 300 - you'll still be in the lift to the office when that gets taken.
A SYM300 and £40 eBay 50L topbox will give heaps of narrow (filterable) storage and it has folding mirrors.

I'd recommend a loud alarm + GPS tracker as London now seems to be open season and nothing I've seen will change that.

fred bloggs

1,379 posts

231 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
Lol at suggestions.
I'm a bike mechanic in London for over 20 years.

That journey will be completed in the same time which ever size bike you'll take. The traffic light phasing determines journey times.
As commuting through London is not an exercise in fun, id be using a Geared 125. YBR125, CBF125 or something like that. They don't go missing(as much as a scooter) easier to ride in traffic, and cheaper to run. Perfect tool for the job, unless you care about cred, if so get the biggest BMW you can and fit massive panniers so you block all the proper riders from filtering.

tjlazer

875 posts

205 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
Re filtering I have the tuono mirrors on my street and they work much better than the stock items and have the height to clear car mirrors. I generally take the view if I have to fold my mirrors it's probably a bit too tight to go anyway and just hold back. It probably stops me less than once a week, the street is pretty narrow and light so very easy to manoeuvre at low speed past the traffic when needed.

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
fred bloggs said:
Lol at suggestions.

That journey will be completed in the same time which ever size bike you'll take.
Indeed but given the possibility the OP might use some dual carriageways or NSL roads on his commute I reckon a ratty old 600cc+ bike of the type nobody wants to steal might be a better bet than a gutless 125.
Still ultra reliable given the correct maintenance and as alluded to will survive a lot longer than a large capacity scooter which will be gone possibly before he even steps off it!

edit to add: crappy old bandit would also be a good shout.

Edited by Motorrad on Tuesday 14th March 18:19

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 14th March 2017
quotequote all
20 mile round turn? my contribution:

to steal dan walsh's quote, you need a 'st bike'

or

the piaggio a three wheeler.