bmw 1200s or Triumph ST
bmw 1200s or Triumph ST
Author
Discussion

sshenton1975

Original Poster:

805 posts

252 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Hi guys

Currently riding an SV1000 which I love thanks to its low down grunt. Plenty fast enough and I am addicted to the torque
Have had my license for 10 years but only really got the bug in last 12 months

I quite like doing a few longer trips but the SV is not ideal for that being quite unfaired

Ive been looking at two bikes quite.closely:

BMW K1200s - I like the.looks especially in black, 170hp, quite big, panniers

Triumph ST - again nice balance between sports and touring, good looks, cool triple engine

What would you choose of these two? Anything I need to look out for?

What will I miss about the SV.compared to these?

thanks!

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Triumph gets my money; much more exciting, much more character, much less likely to play up and cause hassle/cost a fortune.

Others will disagree and before long someone else will be here waffling about BMW's legendary reliability; just don't forget that they're talking bks.

hehe

yellowstreak

638 posts

183 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
There is a 45 bhp gap between the two but I have found the triumph a great bike. The triple is a lovely engine, sounds fantastic though an off road exhaust.

Ceeejay

505 posts

182 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
The Beemer gets my money... I've had two in the past...

Not legendary reliability... I had to have a ball joint replaced on the front suspension, and a new injector.

Personally I preferred the K12s to the K13s... it felt a little more alive.. the front suspension is different to what you'll be used to. The K12s has the funny BMW indicator setup which I like.

In fact you've now got me looking for another one! I had the early ones in the interesting colour scenes, blue&white and black&yellow. The plain black ones look very stealthy...

Electronic suspension is a nice toy, but I suspect at their age now may suffer reliability issues, so stick with a standard setup.


Someone will be along in a minute to say the triple is full of "character"... load of tosh

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
Surely the biggest factor is shaft vs chain.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
This is an easy question to answer, the BMW K1300S!

Yes, I know it's not on the list but the logic to my answer is as follows:

The K1200S is quicker, faster, more powerful, better handling, more economical and more comfortable than the ST. While the Triumph motor has immense character it still can't match the sheer brute force of the BMW lump.

The K1200S can do everything the ST can, but better where the ST can't do everything the K1200S can.

That said, it's very likely that the K1200S will need a significant amount of money spent on it just to keep it on the road. Most suffer failures of the ABS braking pump, the coils and the ball joints and none are cheap to put right. the radiators rot and need replacing on a reasonably regular basis. Add to that a number that suffer clutch failure and other issue such as switch gear issues and hot start issues which should be fixed for free by BMW but often aren't. While there are a few good bikes out there the vast majority will end up costing a lot of extra money.

Most, although not all, of the issues in the K1200S were addressed in the K1300S. Add to that an extra 5bhp, 15% more mid range torque, ESA2 and a quickshifter and the decision becomes pretty easy The extra purchase cost over a K1200S is likely to be less than the cost of repairs and replacements in the first 2 years of K1200S ownership.

The K1200S is a stunning bike to ride. It's blisteringly fast, handles very well (in the sport touring class) and is very easy to ride slowly, fully loaded, around town, across continents or through the Alps/Pyrenees. The K1300S is the same - but better, much better!


ETA

A direct, real world comparison between a K1200S and a K1300S here (second from last post).

http://www.eurokclub.bike/index.php/topic,578.30.h...


Edited by black-k1 on Friday 31st March 10:26

ianrb

1,644 posts

171 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
Just sold my K1200 R Sport (the slightly more upright version of the K1200S). To be honest it wasn't a bike I ever bonded with. Yes very fast, and the Duolever suspension gave a soft ride but little or no dive under braking, but it always felt slightly clumsy. The panniers, which I believe are common to both models, have an odd shape, are not waterproof, and are not very big. I had failures of the fuel pump controller (£300) and the ABS pump (£1100). There have been lots of recalls, for rear suspension (two of those I think), a cam chain guide (if it goes wrong it can wreck the engine), and the rear wheel mounting flange, which can crack.

I have had a test ride on the Triumph, and it felt quite dated even 10 years ago, so can't imagine it would be better now. A Tiger Sport would be a better bet, but I don't know if it would suit your budget.

K12beano

20,854 posts

306 months

Tuesday 4th April 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
This is an easy question to answer, the BMW K1300S!
As another K12 owner, I can agree with nearly everything - much as it pains me to have to agree with black-k1 tongue outwaveyhehe

But I have DMed as my black K1200 has just found its way on to the Classifieds - and I can confirm what work that has been done on a late 2008 bike to keep it tip-top if you want a chat.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
K12beano said:
black-k1 said:
This is an easy question to answer, the BMW K1300S!
As another K12 owner, I can agree with nearly everything - much as it pains me to have to agree with black-k1 tongue outwaveyhehe

But I have DMed as my black K1200 has just found its way on to the Classifieds - and I can confirm what work that has been done on a late 2008 bike to keep it tip-top if you want a chat.
wavey

What are you planning on getting next Ron?

Here's a farewell picture from your K1200S ... biggrin



K12beano

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Ha!

Just in the dealer today getting last couple of things perfect on it.

Might arrange a test ride on Friday after all!

K12beano

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
And here's something interesting - and being quite candid as a drawback to the BM....

My first enquirer has Japanese bikes and runs a little "back street" type garage workshop where he is mostly involved in VW/VAG from camper vans to Beetles and modern as well. He's handy at fixing stuff.

But having spent all weekend doing his homework, he concluded that the Beemer wasn't such a good choice for home maintenance. Mine has had big service and some tweaks to get it pretty perfect and shouldn't be needing anything "big" for a while (20-30k, I'd hope) - but that might be a deciding factor for some people ....