Generator Advice Please
Discussion
Hi All,
After a few years of getting up in the middle of the night to avoid the endless, stressy, bun-fight that is trying to secure a garage at track days, I've decided to get a generator. As a trial run, a mate lent me one for our day at Snetterton yesterday, but I guess it wasn't man enough to run two sets of warmers as in the rush to get on track in the first session I forget to check how warm my tyres were and then low-sided shortly afterward. And also because I'm a penis.
Anyway, initially it felt like the genny was cranking out heat, and I suppose I had assumed that if it wasn't up to the demand we were placing on it, it would just stall out, but after a day of testing it turns out that it just heated our tyres up a bit (but kept running). In fact, even when we ran only one set at the end of the day, they never really got hot so I'm guessing it just isn't man enough for the demand.
So, I'm guessing I'll need one that's 2.2kv or above (I don't know what my mates was, it was old and had no labels) and ideally it'd be one of those quiet inverter types, but what do people reccomend that will be up to the job and not eighty million pounds, please?
Thanks in advance for any ideas, you lot.
After a few years of getting up in the middle of the night to avoid the endless, stressy, bun-fight that is trying to secure a garage at track days, I've decided to get a generator. As a trial run, a mate lent me one for our day at Snetterton yesterday, but I guess it wasn't man enough to run two sets of warmers as in the rush to get on track in the first session I forget to check how warm my tyres were and then low-sided shortly afterward. And also because I'm a penis.
Anyway, initially it felt like the genny was cranking out heat, and I suppose I had assumed that if it wasn't up to the demand we were placing on it, it would just stall out, but after a day of testing it turns out that it just heated our tyres up a bit (but kept running). In fact, even when we ran only one set at the end of the day, they never really got hot so I'm guessing it just isn't man enough for the demand.
So, I'm guessing I'll need one that's 2.2kv or above (I don't know what my mates was, it was old and had no labels) and ideally it'd be one of those quiet inverter types, but what do people reccomend that will be up to the job and not eighty million pounds, please?
Thanks in advance for any ideas, you lot.
I had the same dilemma and measured the current drawn by a few sets of tyre warmers, Constands, Holdroyd and another(?). They were all in the same ball park. 2 amps for the front 3 amps for the rear so this would be 1.2kVA per set. Unless there are any out there with a higher current draw.
Scraggydog64 said:
I had the same dilemma and measured the current drawn by a few sets of tyre warmers, Constands, Holdroyd and another(?). They were all in the same ball park. 2 amps for the front 3 amps for the rear so this would be 1.2kVA per set. Unless there are any out there with a higher current draw.
Gotcha. Thanks. That's excellent. Mine are HWW so 2.4kv it is then. I'm guessing this probably means even more pricey? I know this isn't ideal in terms of size/ noise/ convenience, but I'm guessing it's ok for power output? I've left a bit of slack and the price seems ok.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
nervous said:
I know this isn't ideal in terms of size/ noise/ convenience, but I'm guessing it's ok for power output? I've left a bit of slack and the price seems ok.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
Is that a rebranded Chinese no-name type? I'd personally rather buy a S/H Honda or similar.https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
I guess so.
I would too, but they're in excess of £1200 for Honda or Hyundai ones. Given that it'll likely only get used 10 times max this year, at the price of the eBay one it'll have paid for itself if it's powerful enough, but it's obviously not ideal and will be massive and weigh a tonne.
Does anyone know if it's up to the job in terms of power, please? I'm getting all kinds of conflicting advice on how much 'room' I need to leave in terms of output and demand.
I would too, but they're in excess of £1200 for Honda or Hyundai ones. Given that it'll likely only get used 10 times max this year, at the price of the eBay one it'll have paid for itself if it's powerful enough, but it's obviously not ideal and will be massive and weigh a tonne.
Does anyone know if it's up to the job in terms of power, please? I'm getting all kinds of conflicting advice on how much 'room' I need to leave in terms of output and demand.
Krikkit said:
SGS gear is generally good, I've had a couple of their non-electrical bits now and been impressed. At £160 it's not a massive investment if it dies quickly, I'm sure they'll honour the warranty.
Thanks K. That's helpful. Am I about right with the power on that, or is it massively over-powered (and therefore likely to be bigger and heavier)?nervous said:
I know this isn't ideal in terms of size/ noise/ convenience, but I'm guessing it's ok for power output? I've left a bit of slack and the price seems ok.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
That looks a lot like the 2.2kw unbranded thing my brother bought me off his own back. I had mentioned generators at some point but had not mentioned that I would have been more entertained by a 5kw Wolf jobbie.https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181361373840
Thoughts anyone?
Anyhow, if I plug the 1200w Henry vacuum into it, then if I turn the vacuum on the generator either stalls or nearly does, so if you halve the power claim for it you'd be nearer the truth.
In summary, don't buy it. Open your wallet and buy something you know will work or don't bother.
cmaguire said:
That looks a lot like the 2.2kw unbranded thing my brother bought me off his own back. I had mentioned generators at some point but had not mentioned that I would have been more entertained by a 5kw Wolf jobbie.
Anyhow, if I plug the 1200w Henry vacuum into it, then if I turn the vacuum on the generator either stalls or nearly does, so if you halve the power claim for it you'd be nearer the truth.
In summary, don't buy it. Open your wallet and buy something you know will work or don't bother.
Oh. Way to dampen my erection. Anyhow, if I plug the 1200w Henry vacuum into it, then if I turn the vacuum on the generator either stalls or nearly does, so if you halve the power claim for it you'd be nearer the truth.
In summary, don't buy it. Open your wallet and buy something you know will work or don't bother.
I take it the power can't be upped by increasing idle speed when under load then? That's what we did yesterday. When there was draw, we upped the idle to keep it going with the lever. Is that not common to all gennys?
nervous said:
Oh. Way to dampen my erection.
I take it the power can't be upped by increasing idle speed when under load then? That's what we did yesterday. When there was draw, we upped the idle to keep it going with the lever. Is that not common to all gennys?
If you're going down the Chinese route and you need 1500w then I would get a 3000w (claimed) one so you have a fighting chance.I take it the power can't be upped by increasing idle speed when under load then? That's what we did yesterday. When there was draw, we upped the idle to keep it going with the lever. Is that not common to all gennys?
On a separate note the quality generators are also full-wave, which means they directly replicate the mains supply. A lot of the cheaper ones (like mine) are half-wave because it's cheaper and they will not run certain things with electronic circuits.
This is going to be one of those things where I can't cut corners, isn't it? I'm not super keen to lug another impossibly heavy thing the length of the country, just for it to give off as much joy as the wife I'm so clearly setting up as the joke in this sentence.
Edited by nervous on Tuesday 4th April 22:12
cmaguire said:
If you're going down the Chinese route and you need 1500w then I would get a 3000w (claimed) one so you have a fighting chance.
On a separate note the quality generators are also full-wave, which means they directly replicate the mains supply. A lot of the cheaper ones (like mine) are half-wave because it's cheaper and they will not run certain things with electronic circuits.
By the way, most people reckon I need 2.6kva, so are we saying I need a 6.2kva Chinese version? That's going to take a support team to lift isn't it? On a separate note the quality generators are also full-wave, which means they directly replicate the mains supply. A lot of the cheaper ones (like mine) are half-wave because it's cheaper and they will not run certain things with electronic circuits.
Worse yet, you have one 6.2kva Chinese generator, and half an hour later you want another one.
cmaguire said:
You might be fine, but I would say 'try before you buy' is a must to be sure it'll work. You'll be pretty cheesed off if you buy it and it doesn't give you what you need.
Where are you anyway?
You know when people say 'the middle of nowhere'? Well, I'm in the middle of that. Where are you anyway?
Dereham. Don't worry, I don't know where it is either.
Trying before you buy is something I'd love, but I've no idea how I could achieve it. After all, based on the test we did in the garden with my mates genny on Sunday, both sets of warmers appeared to get hot to the touch. What I didn't realise is that it wasn't hot enough, or perhaps didn't sustain it for long enough.
Story of my life, basically.
nervous said:
You know when people say 'the middle of nowhere'? Well, I'm in the middle of that.
Dereham. Don't worry, I don't know where it is either.
Trying before you buy is something I'd love, but I've no idea how I could achieve it. After all, based on the test we did in the garden with my mates genny on Sunday, both sets of warmers appeared to get hot to the touch. What I didn't realise is that it wasn't hot enough, or perhaps didn't sustain it for long enough.
Story of my life, basically.
If it's the Dereham I know then it's near SwaffhamDereham. Don't worry, I don't know where it is either.
Trying before you buy is something I'd love, but I've no idea how I could achieve it. After all, based on the test we did in the garden with my mates genny on Sunday, both sets of warmers appeared to get hot to the touch. What I didn't realise is that it wasn't hot enough, or perhaps didn't sustain it for long enough.
Story of my life, basically.
OP, in regard to the post about the vacuum cleaner, electric motors have a pretty demanding inrush current so it's not too surprising it was ask (about 5x steady current). A heater will be a lot smoother.
You could bodge clean AC off a cheap Genny with a 12v battery charger, a 12v and a true Some inverter for a lot cheaper...
You could bodge clean AC off a cheap Genny with a 12v battery charger, a 12v and a true Some inverter for a lot cheaper...
Evanivitch said:
OP, in regard to the post about the vacuum cleaner, electric motors have a pretty demanding inrush current so it's not too surprising it was ask (about 5x steady current). A heater will be a lot smoother.
You could bodge clean AC off a cheap Genny with a 12v battery charger, a 12v and a true Some inverter for a lot cheaper...
I don't understand much of this, but I officially like the cut of your jib. You could bodge clean AC off a cheap Genny with a 12v battery charger, a 12v and a true Some inverter for a lot cheaper...
How would I do this? Without going on fire, that is.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



