Puncture - Unlucky ?
Puncture - Unlucky ?
Author
Discussion

alanshaw

Original Poster:

195 posts

114 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
Had my 718 Cayman just 2 weeks, this morning, nice day, thought I'd take it for a spin down to Goodwood. Jumped in the car, got to end of driveway & tyre pressure warnings went off...............Puncture !
Porsche assistance to the rescue, taken to local OPC for new tyre...........lucky had Full wheel/tyre insurance - excess £10, so got my money back after just one claim !
A screw was to blame................
Was I Unlucky or is this normal for 20inch 265/35 R20 ( 95Y) tyre to get punctured ??

JayK12

2,369 posts

223 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
alanshaw said:
Had my 718 Cayman just 2 weeks, this morning, nice day, thought I'd take it for a spin down to Goodwood. Jumped in the car, got to end of driveway & tyre pressure warnings went off...............Puncture !
Porsche assistance to the rescue, taken to local OPC for new tyre...........lucky had Full wheel/tyre insurance - excess £10, so got my money back after just one claim !
A screw was to blame................
Was I Unlucky or is this normal for 20inch 265/35 R20 ( 95Y) tyre to get punctured ??
Your were unlucky, normally only 195/55/15 get punctured.

supermono

7,457 posts

269 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
Haha (at reply not OP)

Sometimes tradesmen are knuckle draggers and let screws and nails fall out of the back of their vans onto your drive. It's quite common if you've had work done to suddenly find you get a puncture.

No idea if this is the case for you, but it might be worth having a sweep up of the driveway if you've had work done.

Polome

592 posts

146 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
You've got a good point re screws on driveway...take care in B & Q carparks too ...these slack tradesmen open the back doors of the van and all the screws floating about on the floor fall out onto the tarmack. My last two punctures were after a visit to DIY stores...take care and look around where you park.

Edited by Polome on Tuesday 11th April 21:00

HoHoHo

15,363 posts

271 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
JayK12 said:
alanshaw said:
Had my 718 Cayman just 2 weeks, this morning, nice day, thought I'd take it for a spin down to Goodwood. Jumped in the car, got to end of driveway & tyre pressure warnings went off...............Puncture !
Porsche assistance to the rescue, taken to local OPC for new tyre...........lucky had Full wheel/tyre insurance - excess £10, so got my money back after just one claim !
A screw was to blame................
Was I Unlucky or is this normal for 20inch 265/35 R20 ( 95Y) tyre to get punctured ??
Your were unlucky, normally only 195/55/15 get punctured.
laugh

For a moment I thought it was an April fool from the OP wink

Rockster

1,515 posts

181 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
alanshaw said:
Had my 718 Cayman just 2 weeks, this morning, nice day, thought I'd take it for a spin down to Goodwood. Jumped in the car, got to end of driveway & tyre pressure warnings went off...............Puncture !
Porsche assistance to the rescue, taken to local OPC for new tyre...........lucky had Full wheel/tyre insurance - excess £10, so got my money back after just one claim !
A screw was to blame................
Was I Unlucky or is this normal for 20inch 265/35 R20 ( 95Y) tyre to get punctured ??
Unlucky. Real unlucky, actually. My experience over the years is a puncture in a new tire is rather rare. New tires are more immune to punctures. You want a puncture take the car on a longish road trip with the rear tires just shy of the wear bars.

I'm pretty mindful of the amount of trash on the roads and shoulders and parking lots. On road trips I just avoid pulling over for a picture. When driving on a parking lot, even pulling into and out of one, I drive very slow around 5mph or a bit less. What often happens is the front tire kicks up a nail or screw and the rear tire runs over it and gets the puncture.

Thus if you drive slow while the front tire may still kick up the object it will have fallen over again before the rear tire runs over it and thus you probably avoid a puncture.

tree7777

333 posts

140 months

Tuesday 11th April 2017
quotequote all
Just got puncture 250 miles into ownership of a Macan turbo performance pack. Took tyre cover luckily!! £300

red997

1,304 posts

230 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
just luck of the draw

last Panamera had 3 punctures in the space of 6 months !
and all of them 100 + miles from home

Luckily car under OPC warranty, so easy recovery each time & I also had tyre insurance, so just £10 per go.

Had the GT3 for coming up to 2 years now - not a single puncture.

ikonic

404 posts

219 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all

I've done some statistical studies on this actually and your particular tyre size is statistically 2.7x more likely to get a puncture than a 195/45/16 tyre.

Anyway..... how much did people pay for tyre insurance out of interest?

I think our OPC packages it up with alloy insurance too (so includes repairs for kerbing etc.) so I recall it being pretty hefty over a 3 year period (c£600 sticks in my mind but can't quite remember).


alanshaw

Original Poster:

195 posts

114 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
ikonic said:
I've done some statistical studies on this actually and your particular tyre size is statistically 2.7x more likely to get a puncture than a 195/45/16 tyre.

Anyway..... how much did people pay for tyre insurance out of interest?

I think our OPC packages it up with alloy insurance too (so includes repairs for kerbing etc.) so I recall it being pretty hefty over a 3 year period (c£600 sticks in my mind but can't quite remember).
I paid £300 for 3yrs for alloy & tyre combined, with 4 claims per year

ikonic

404 posts

219 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
Ohhh

That seems pretty good. Did that require some negotiation to get it down to that or was it the OPC's opening gambit?

HoHoHo

15,363 posts

271 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
alanshaw said:
ikonic said:
I've done some statistical studies on this actually and your particular tyre size is statistically 2.7x more likely to get a puncture than a 195/45/16 tyre.

Anyway..... how much did people pay for tyre insurance out of interest?

I think our OPC packages it up with alloy insurance too (so includes repairs for kerbing etc.) so I recall it being pretty hefty over a 3 year period (c£600 sticks in my mind but can't quite remember).
I paid £300 for 3yrs for alloy & tyre combined, with 4 claims per year
4 claims per year or 4 claims over the life of the policy?

nsm3

2,831 posts

217 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
I got a punctured FNS and ROS from woodscrews (unrepairable) within 10 days at around 9k miles.

It appears that I was the knuckle dragging tradesman, as it happened on my Daughters driveway at her house, which I was doing up at the time.

getmecoat

red997

1,304 posts

230 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
mine is £400 for 3 years cover, tyre and wheel, 6 claims per year per wheel ; same for tyre
991 GT3

alanshaw

Original Poster:

195 posts

114 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
HoHoHo said:
4 claims per year or 4 claims over the life of the policy?
policy says " max 12 claims in 36mnth policy, no more than 4 in any 12mnth period" did not get thru opc as they only offered gap £899/3yr I got £189/3yr with 1yr deferred.

I went to a Sainsbury's car park, close to B&Q, could be rogue tradesman or jealous car cleaner as was hovering near car asking how much ! not that looks great !!

Gorsh

329 posts

126 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
red997 said:
mine is £400 for 3 years cover, tyre and wheel, 6 claims per year per wheel ; same for tyre
991 GT3
Was that from your OPC ? I was quoted £649 from my OPC (991.2 GTS)

davidc1

1,616 posts

183 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
i took out the tyre and alloy ins , when i got my spyder last march , 400quid for 3 years.

on the road i park my staion car on for the train there are always 2 to 3 extensions on the go , and the amount of nails & screws i see in the kerb side is unreal. i am always doing the decent thing and picking them up. karma i hope....

engineermk

96 posts

148 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
alanshaw said:
Had my 718 Cayman just 2 weeks, this morning, nice day, thought I'd take it for a spin down to Goodwood. Jumped in the car, got to end of driveway & tyre pressure warnings went off...............Puncture !
Porsche assistance to the rescue, taken to local OPC for new tyre...........lucky had Full wheel/tyre insurance - excess £10, so got my money back after just one claim !
A screw was to blame................
Was I Unlucky or is this normal for 20inch 265/35 R20 ( 95Y) tyre to get punctured ??
The same happen to me, a week old car and 10mm bolt (?) in the tyre... unfortunately no tyre insurance. A lesson learnt.

ANDERS MICHENEK

74 posts

110 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
Just some questions on the alloy and tyre insurance
Re turbo wheels ..... Are they classified as alloys
With these bolts and screws going in tyres and it being in repairable is that because the damage was to the side wall as on my old cat ( not Porsche and small tyres) provided the nail was in the tread the tyre was repairable . Is a 20" tyre repairable if damage is in the tread ? Thanks
Also at 189 for insurance who was tgat with

lucido grigio

44,044 posts

184 months

Wednesday 12th April 2017
quotequote all
JayK12 said:
Your were unlucky, normally only 195/55/15 get punctured.
I have tyres this size.......frowngetmecoat