Beemer Conundrum
Discussion
So i'm looking for a little bit of guidance and advice from those who know such things...
Ok, So i'm in the market for a proper bike and i'm leaning towards a BMW. Reason? Only BMW and Ducati have official dealers here and i'm not sure i fancy the MTS 1200. But I might be wrong???
So the choice is boiling down to 3(maybe 4) possible contenders...
Usage will be 85% city riding. By City I mean getting stuck in amongst the cut & thrust of scooter life, buzzing from traffic light to traffic light, ducking and weaving and basically squeezing through gaps bikes shouldn't go.
That's what I have the Superfour for but it's just too small for me & the Missus to run around on.
Next up is 10% weekends away. Leave town on a Friday night with a dry bag packed and back Sunday night.
5% longer trips, 300 Km plus including a full 2300km North to South ride at some point or trips to Laos and Cambodia.
Bike 1. GS. Yep, there's no escaping it. The GS has to be on the list.Nothing to say about this Comes with everything. Keyless go, LED lights, nav prep etc....
Bike 2. XR1000R. 4 cylinder superbike engine, stupendously quick (fairly pointless here!!!) suspect issues with vibes and a rock hard seat from first sititng.
Bike3. Left field choice. R1200RS. Looks a cracking bike. Same electronics as the GS. Great ergos, comfy seat.
Bike 4 (Wildcard) R1200GSA. Big old bus but comes fully equipped including BMW luggage and top box and actually cheaper than equivalently speced GS 1200.
Possibly monstrous around town (scooter and option) but no doubting its credentials.
Each makes a compelling argument for itself... Ok is a simple cas eof Go big or Go home and GSA the feck out of it!!
And get a Hernda Winner 150 for daily duties
Over to those who knows....
Ok, So i'm in the market for a proper bike and i'm leaning towards a BMW. Reason? Only BMW and Ducati have official dealers here and i'm not sure i fancy the MTS 1200. But I might be wrong???
So the choice is boiling down to 3(maybe 4) possible contenders...
Usage will be 85% city riding. By City I mean getting stuck in amongst the cut & thrust of scooter life, buzzing from traffic light to traffic light, ducking and weaving and basically squeezing through gaps bikes shouldn't go.
That's what I have the Superfour for but it's just too small for me & the Missus to run around on.
Next up is 10% weekends away. Leave town on a Friday night with a dry bag packed and back Sunday night.
5% longer trips, 300 Km plus including a full 2300km North to South ride at some point or trips to Laos and Cambodia.
Bike 1. GS. Yep, there's no escaping it. The GS has to be on the list.Nothing to say about this Comes with everything. Keyless go, LED lights, nav prep etc....
Bike 2. XR1000R. 4 cylinder superbike engine, stupendously quick (fairly pointless here!!!) suspect issues with vibes and a rock hard seat from first sititng.
Bike3. Left field choice. R1200RS. Looks a cracking bike. Same electronics as the GS. Great ergos, comfy seat.
Bike 4 (Wildcard) R1200GSA. Big old bus but comes fully equipped including BMW luggage and top box and actually cheaper than equivalently speced GS 1200.
Possibly monstrous around town (scooter and option) but no doubting its credentials.
Each makes a compelling argument for itself... Ok is a simple cas eof Go big or Go home and GSA the feck out of it!!

And get a Hernda Winner 150 for daily duties

Over to those who knows....
Edited by Steve Bass on Sunday 14th May 12:15
2wheelsjimmy said:
Are you planning on going off road?
I'd get the GS in your shoes. Proper bike to go exploring.
Who knows... We're planning a trip up to the Chinese border and trips into Laos & Cambodia, possibly Thailand... Which is why I added the GSA.I'd get the GS in your shoes. Proper bike to go exploring.
Whilst it's a monster, cutting around HCMC on it will be like parallel parking the Cutty Sark would be a challenge and a giggle...
Steve.
If the roads are good then get an RS as it can hustle as well as cover big distances in comfort.
If the roads are poor then get a GS or Rallye as these just cannot be beaten over poor surfaces.
Both are all day comfy and there is a whole industry out there for Farkles that improve things. I have 3 piece genuine luggage and genuine Nav5. Ade has Nav6 cos he is gadget man. We both have SW Motech tank bags as these just work so well on the tank ring snap connectors.
Ade has hard fixed luggage mine is detachable in seconds.
The big bars on the GS make slow speed easier but the RS has lower narrower bard to make threading between cars and their mirrors easier.
I love my RS.
A
If the roads are good then get an RS as it can hustle as well as cover big distances in comfort.
If the roads are poor then get a GS or Rallye as these just cannot be beaten over poor surfaces.
Both are all day comfy and there is a whole industry out there for Farkles that improve things. I have 3 piece genuine luggage and genuine Nav5. Ade has Nav6 cos he is gadget man. We both have SW Motech tank bags as these just work so well on the tank ring snap connectors.
Ade has hard fixed luggage mine is detachable in seconds.
The big bars on the GS make slow speed easier but the RS has lower narrower bard to make threading between cars and their mirrors easier.
I love my RS.
A
Chipchap said:
Steve.
If the roads are good then get an RS as it can hustle as well as cover big distances in comfort.
If the roads are poor then get a GS or Rallye as these just cannot be beaten over poor surfaces.
Both are all day comfy and there is a whole industry out there for Farkles that improve things. I have 3 piece genuine luggage and genuine Nav5. Ade has Nav6 cos he is gadget man. We both have SW Motech tank bags as these just work so well on the tank ring snap connectors.
Ade has hard fixed luggage mine is detachable in seconds.
The big bars on the GS make slow speed easier but the RS has lower narrower bard to make threading between cars and their mirrors easier.
I love my RS.
A
Cheers Allan, must say I'm drawn to the RS. Especially in the Matt Grey. Bit of the K1300 about it I think.If the roads are good then get an RS as it can hustle as well as cover big distances in comfort.
If the roads are poor then get a GS or Rallye as these just cannot be beaten over poor surfaces.
Both are all day comfy and there is a whole industry out there for Farkles that improve things. I have 3 piece genuine luggage and genuine Nav5. Ade has Nav6 cos he is gadget man. We both have SW Motech tank bags as these just work so well on the tank ring snap connectors.
Ade has hard fixed luggage mine is detachable in seconds.
The big bars on the GS make slow speed easier but the RS has lower narrower bard to make threading between cars and their mirrors easier.
I love my RS.
A
So I'm told the roads up to the border are good, all tar which is a tick in the RS box.
The roads further afield are an unknown which is where the GS(A) would be the wiser choice.
The GSA comes with the BMW alu panniers and top box. Panniers are detached in seconds so it's just the huge front to deal with!!
I have a friend back in SA who has an adventure shop so getting the bits an bobs is easy enough. Looks like Nav5 is a must!!!
Already go the obligatory SW Motech tank bag so only need the tank ring (they're made here !!)
The only reason the GSA is in the mix is $$$
It's a fully loaded bike, keyless, Halogens, ESA, shift pro luggage bars & spots etc. The normal GS is not far behind but to include crash protection and luggage pushes the price higher than the A.
So really I;m torn between the A and the RS
The bike for city riding and the bike for riding to China or Laos are two different bikes.
Edit: I just remembered you are in SA. I'd say a lighter bike if you really want to take it long distance. Loading a GSA onto an 18 foot long boat to cross a river wouldn't be much fun.
Edit: I just remembered you are in SA. I'd say a lighter bike if you really want to take it long distance. Loading a GSA onto an 18 foot long boat to cross a river wouldn't be much fun.
Edited by creampuff on Sunday 14th May 13:29
creampuff said:
The bike for city riding and the bike for riding to China or Laos are two different bikes.
Edit: I just remembered you are in SA.
Vietnam now mate.. Ho Chi Minh City....Edit: I just remembered you are in SA.
Edited by creampuff on Sunday 14th May 13:29
And the tours will be 2 up... Ideally I'd look at something middle weight like the GS 800 or Triumphs. But Triumph aren't here and BMW don't bring in the smaller models as the taxes make them too costly compared to the 1200's
Do you have a Vietnamese A2 (>175cc) licence? They are a major PITA to obtain and personally I would not ride a bike I'm not licenced for in VN. I have heard getting an A2 licence is easier in Vung Tau than HCMC. (I've had a Vietnamese A1/<175cc licence for about 9 years).
You still need two bikes. Riding a GSA around HCMC would be a major PITA and IMHO a lot less fun than riding a $800 Honda Wave as a city bike. With the cost of consumables for a big bike, you would get the Wave for free if you used it for city riding.
You still need two bikes. Riding a GSA around HCMC would be a major PITA and IMHO a lot less fun than riding a $800 Honda Wave as a city bike. With the cost of consumables for a big bike, you would get the Wave for free if you used it for city riding.
creampuff said:
Do you have a Vietnamese A2 (>175cc) licence? They are a major PITA to obtain and personally I would not ride a bike I'm not licenced for in VN. I have heard getting an A2 licence is easier in Vung Tau than HCMC.
You still need two bikes. Riding a GSA around HCMC would be a major PITA and IMHO a lot less fun than riding a $800 Honda Wave as a city bike. With the cost of consumables for a big bike, you would get the Wave for free if you used it for city riding.
Yep, fully A2'd up. Doddle to get in HCMC. Helps having local office girls and a proper UK license You still need two bikes. Riding a GSA around HCMC would be a major PITA and IMHO a lot less fun than riding a $800 Honda Wave as a city bike. With the cost of consumables for a big bike, you would get the Wave for free if you used it for city riding.
. But for $60 you can get an A2 with no previous entitlement
ask my scheduling manager 
If you ever get back I can point you in the direction of getting a legit A2 in about 4 days with no test if you have full UK entitlement...
But regarding bikes, your thinking is where I'm heading. We do fairly regular trips to Vung Tau and Mieu Ne as well asfurther afield for weekends as well as cutting around the city if she's working the weekend. SWMBO generally uses Grab bike for work though and I have company taxi and site vehicles or normal transport.
For teh Northern trip, the plan is to train us and the bikes up to Hanoi and ride back over 7 days as well as shorter trips to Phu Quoc and Dalat. The GSA is only on the radar due to costing comparatively less like for like than the GS normal.
And I've just been on ADVRider looking at Ankor Wat and the roads are predominately dirt or gravel which is a tick against the RS

I did borrow an older GSA for the weekend however and whilst the traffic wasn't such a problem, the tight parking would be....
Yes, It could be done on a shonky Honda Wave but I have to be at work every Monday morning bright and breezy ready to start shouting at everyone

Edited by Steve Bass on Sunday 14th May 14:00
I rode from HCMC to Hanoi via some detours + HCM Trail in about 2008. Put bike on train on way back, it's quite efficient. Not sure how long you have been in VN but I'd really stay off major highways on any bike as much as possible as large trucks, bikes and the additional heavy vehicle lane which can sometimes appear out of the invisible to everybody except the truck driver, don't mix.... the amount of squeezed out bits of biker brain I've seen on the tarmac tells me this.....
Must look into an A2 if I move back to VN, it must have become easier to get. Forget about the comment about loading the GSA onto small boats... thought you were riding from SA so you would have to prepare for everything, but you would need to go really off the beaten track in VN/Cambodia/Laos to need to do that.
Must look into an A2 if I move back to VN, it must have become easier to get. Forget about the comment about loading the GSA onto small boats... thought you were riding from SA so you would have to prepare for everything, but you would need to go really off the beaten track in VN/Cambodia/Laos to need to do that.
Edited by creampuff on Sunday 14th May 14:04
creampuff said:
I rode from HCMC to Hanoi via some detours + HCM Trail in about 2008. Put bike on train on way back, it's quite efficient. Not sure how long you have been in VN but I'd really stay off major highways on any bike as much as possible as large trucks, bikes and the additional heavy vehicle lane which can sometimes appear out of the invisible to everybody except the truck driver, don't mix.... the amount of squeezed out bits of biker brain I've seen on the tarmac tells me this.....
Must look into an A2 if I move back to VN, it must have become easier to get. Forget about the comment about loading the GSA onto small boats... thought you were riding from SA so you would have to prepare for everything, but you would need to go really off the beaten track in VN/Cambodia/Laos to need to do that.
We've been here coming up for a year now.... Generally loving it.Must look into an A2 if I move back to VN, it must have become easier to get. Forget about the comment about loading the GSA onto small boats... thought you were riding from SA so you would have to prepare for everything, but you would need to go really off the beaten track in VN/Cambodia/Laos to need to do that.
Edited by creampuff on Sunday 14th May 14:04
As you say, the highways are a nightmare with the buses and trucks. We recently rode back into HCMC on the QL55 from Mieu Ne and it was shyter than shyte...
But there's been a few changes I guess since your last foray. Foreigners can get a2 licenses. Foreigners can register new bikes in their name so a legit Blue Card is a reality!! Foreigners can pay twice the going rate for "on the spot fines"
or maybe that's as it ever was!!If i was sticking to Vietnam the RS would be the choice. But Laos & Cambodia changes the picture a little.
^ I've never had to pay an 'on the spot fine'... suspect this is a bigger problem for locals. I have been detained at a VN army base though. If you are riding around near the Cambodian border, away from an official crossing, which could realistically happen on a day ride from HCMC and you start to see signs in both Khmer and Vietnamese while you are near the border - turn around. The last 1 or 2 km to the border is restricted without a permit and is patrolled. I learned that while having tea at the army base.
Am surprised you're looking at a beemer for that sort of trip. I'd want reliability and far less weigh so would lean towards any suitable Jap bike. My own experiences with the GS was that it broke too easily so binned it a few months after buying one - and it also had a far lower level of electronics than the current ones pack.
What about a Hyperstrada ?
Not full on touring bike of course , but I have kitted mine out quite well for doing quite a few "click's" in Vietnam. Good bike for the city too. Mine will be up for sale soon and has full papers.
I've been here 10 years, but to be honest I've seen the driving standard get progressively worse. And until they start doing something serious to stop the drunk driving and truck drivers whom think that they can drive the wrong way down any road . The overtaking on blind bends or around any corner, or the sleeper buses that race each other from A to B then my biking days in VN are over I'm afraid. Too many close calls of late, and seeing the daily news reports / reading the Tuoi Tre News on accidents has sealed it.
Good luck and ride safe
Not full on touring bike of course , but I have kitted mine out quite well for doing quite a few "click's" in Vietnam. Good bike for the city too. Mine will be up for sale soon and has full papers.
I've been here 10 years, but to be honest I've seen the driving standard get progressively worse. And until they start doing something serious to stop the drunk driving and truck drivers whom think that they can drive the wrong way down any road . The overtaking on blind bends or around any corner, or the sleeper buses that race each other from A to B then my biking days in VN are over I'm afraid. Too many close calls of late, and seeing the daily news reports / reading the Tuoi Tre News on accidents has sealed it.
Good luck and ride safe
Se7enheaven said:
What about a Hyperstrada ?
Not full on touring bike of course , but I have kitted mine out quite well for doing quite a few "click's" in Vietnam. Good bike for the city too. Mine will be up for sale soon and has full papers.
I've been here 10 years, but to be honest I've seen the driving standard get progressively worse. And until they start doing something serious to stop the drunk driving and truck drivers whom think that they can drive the wrong way down any road . The overtaking on blind bends or around any corner, or the sleeper buses that race each other from A to B then my biking days in VN are over I'm afraid. Too many close calls of late, and seeing the daily news reports / reading the Tuoi Tre News on accidents has sealed it.
Good luck and ride safe
Interesting.... maybe drop me a line on 0916960996. We're up in Q3 Ly Chinh Thanh. Not full on touring bike of course , but I have kitted mine out quite well for doing quite a few "click's" in Vietnam. Good bike for the city too. Mine will be up for sale soon and has full papers.
I've been here 10 years, but to be honest I've seen the driving standard get progressively worse. And until they start doing something serious to stop the drunk driving and truck drivers whom think that they can drive the wrong way down any road . The overtaking on blind bends or around any corner, or the sleeper buses that race each other from A to B then my biking days in VN are over I'm afraid. Too many close calls of late, and seeing the daily news reports / reading the Tuoi Tre News on accidents has sealed it.
Good luck and ride safe
Might be an alternative worth looking into.
What have you done to it??
The GS and the GSA are exactly the same when it comes width on filtering. The bars are the same width and the engine sticks out the same.
The GSA carries its bulky in its belly between the bars and the engine with that big tank. Adds to the road presence, give better protection to the body from the elements, and of course extends your tank range by another 100 miles or so.
I've had both, but purely for road riding, and not commuting. Put both bikes together and id have the GSA every time... Even though its typically more money like for like. If you can get one at the same price as a standard GS then bite their hand off with that deal.
The GSA carries its bulky in its belly between the bars and the engine with that big tank. Adds to the road presence, give better protection to the body from the elements, and of course extends your tank range by another 100 miles or so.
I've had both, but purely for road riding, and not commuting. Put both bikes together and id have the GSA every time... Even though its typically more money like for like. If you can get one at the same price as a standard GS then bite their hand off with that deal.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


