Love / Hate Huewen, Ryder and the rest of the BT sports team
Love / Hate Huewen, Ryder and the rest of the BT sports team
Author
Discussion

Hungrymc

Original Poster:

7,452 posts

168 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Thread to discuss the good and bad of BT sports commentary.

If we keep it here, the GP threads can stick to the races, teams, riders etc.

I'll start.... I flip from liking them to getting annoyed when they miss what's happening in front of them. Generally, I like the enthusiasm.

ollie05

709 posts

251 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Can't stand them, part of the reason I stopped watching.

Bsb is my fave anyway, racing and commentary!

Jazoli

9,707 posts

281 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
I don't mind them, Heuwen is a bit annoying at times, and they tend to miss a lot of whats going on because they are either arguing or consulting some stats, Toseland needs a haircut and doesn't bring anything of note, Hodgson is a cool bloke, I would prefer Parrish and Whitham to be the lead commentators to be honest, I think Suzi is ok and she has been around the paddock a few times, I also like Colin's input when he is there.

The coverage is good though.

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Ive said before, I think they're great.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Perry. Useless. Cannot sound professional. Talks as if Rossi is the only rider that matters! Cannot fill if they need to. Was ste on BBC F1 and they decided not to retain her when they went to CH4. Tells you everything! Also only seem to parachute in at the last part of the weekend. never does the full 4 days. Traded entirely on her looks in the old WSBK days. Now they've faded (like all of us) there's no actual ability there! Should not be employed by BTSport IMO

Huewen. There's not enough time to list his faults. Bottom line is he comes VERY close to making me get a MotoGP season pass for the website! Clichés, shouts over everyone, misses moves or names dropping out of the race. Assumes facts instead of being humble. mentions his race career as if he was even half way decent and not a journeyman!

Ryder. Good, but I get the feeling he's a bit set in his ways. He was alsways the straight man to Toby Moodys enthusiasm. But hes being destroyed by Huewen.

Emmett. Brilliant. It helps that he worked for Dorna for years as he knows everyone. comes across brilliantly, could easily be anchoring the whole shebang. Knowledgeable without being cocky. Best person on the show. The guy Id want to go and listen talk about MotoGP for 3 hours

Hodgson and Edwards. Never expected them to do so well, but they are both great. Great riders perspective. Not pretentious, their names get them stories and insights other broadcasters can only dream of. Hodgos grid walks are far less embarrassing than Martin Brundles

Toseland. He's hamstrung by Perrys inane questions and general incompetence. But he makes do.

Doyle. Not around so much this year, but I like him. he had good chemistry with Colin. Can fill and being irish isn't afraid to ask questions and generally chew the fat.

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
I like the coverage and the commentating. Admittedly, Huewen and Ryder seem to be chatting between themselves missing some key parts but otherwise very informative and well based. Gavin and Neal on pitlane are epic. EPIC. Edwards, is very cool but Toseland is a waste of airtime. I think that BT think that MotoGP is a bit too exciting so bring on Toseland to dull it down. He is SHYTE! Too concerned with how he looks to camera and his monotone voice is a sure cure for insomnia.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Hewin i just about tolerate him, missing stuff, mistakes and his love for ask things Sam Lowes and Rossi. He means well.
Jules and Gavin are great. Hodgson does an ok job, his gridwalks are legendarily poor and random but i like him
Sadly Jules and Keith's heydey as a commentary pairing was sky wsb in the 90s

Edited by sjtscott on Tuesday 23 May 20:35

Yoda.

2,260 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
I think they're both st.
I've never really liked Ryder if i'm honest, and Huewen is just an addition brought on by the braying masses that wanted that old magic back when they commentated as a team back in the...90's wasn't it?

There's no other option, so I just put up with it for 1 1/2 hours or thereabouts. At least I rest peacefully in the knowledge that I no longer indirectly pay their wages.

Give me Neil Hodgson over those two any day!

Biker 1

8,614 posts

150 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Hewen & Jules are st & almost unlistenable. Toseland MUST get a haircut - its getting really gay now. A shame, as he seems to know his shizzle. Suzy is long past her sell by date - even Genny Gowe would be better, especially with her penchant for nice shoes.
Hodgson the best of the bunch: knows his st, does a great demo lap with commentary on the track, & his grid walk interviews are OK. He even looks quite cool, for a Northerner..... getmecoat

mckeann

2,996 posts

260 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Huewen = utter garbage.

Ryder = was ok with Toby moody, but just argues with huewen.

Gav = awesome
Hodgy = awesome
Colin = awesome

Suzi = ste, but doesn't complete ruin the program for me. Not a patch on Craig Doyle.

Toseland. Utter garbage.


If I were BT sport, I'd go back to the good old Eurosport days of moody, Ryder and spalding in the commentary booth. Gav could run the program and do all the features, Colin and hodgy could do midrace pitlane reporting like randy mamola

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
mckeann said:
Huewen = utter garbage.

Ryder = was ok with Toby moody, but just argues with huewen.

Gav = awesome
Hodgy = awesome
Colin = awesome

Suzi = ste, but doesn't complete ruin the program for me. Not a patch on Craig Doyle.

Toseland. Utter garbage.


If I were BT sport, I'd go back to the good old Eurosport days of moody, Ryder and spalding in the commentary booth. Gav could run the program and do all the features, Colin and hodgy could do midrace pitlane reporting like randy mamola
Moody was crap, forever telling everyone what the racers were thinking during the race.
Spalding and Mamola were good, but in the end I wouldn't be that bothered who was commentating if they would just do a bit less of it. I want to listen to and watch the bikes, not their incessant bullst supposition. Why tell me something I can clearly see because I am not yet blind.
The new guy on World Superbike has done OK, and I'm not talking about Michael Guy (he can fk off too).

abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Huewen is utterly terrible. The old Sky WSB coverage is where he should have ended TV, er, contribution.

Moody was dire, glad he's gone. He started out with very little knowledge at all on two wheels and would freely admit it. He got better over the years, but all the gladiatorial references got tiresome as did his comments that they should race in the rain on slicks. Clueless.

Quite like Jules. Randy was good too. Toseland is improving, still not sure about Hodgson though.

motorizer

1,543 posts

202 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
cmaguire said:
Why tell me something I can clearly see because I am not yet blind.
Half the time they don't tell you what you can clearly see, they spot it a lap later.....

Blah Blah.....nadgery stuff....OOOOOH!!! oh... it's a replay.....

lucido grigio

44,044 posts

194 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
I only get to see the channel 5 highlights ,so only Huewen and Ryder.

Garbage the pair of them.

I preferred the pairing of Nick Harris and Gavin Emmett in the comms box ,they used to do the English language worl commentary

when it was shown on BBC red button service.

At Le Mans race this weekend they were disagreeing over when Yamaha last won in France ,where the race was ,Ricard or LM,

Ryder mentioned Catalunya ,which isn't France at all ,just annoying.

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Toseland shouldn't have to improve, he should do it, and he doesn't. He is shyte. Hodgson does good job and one that Toseland clearly couldn't do. BRING BACK COLIN!!!!!

Yoda.

2,260 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd May 2017
quotequote all
Coming to think of it. Yes, where is Colin?


Hungrymc

Original Poster:

7,452 posts

168 months

Wednesday 24th May 2017
quotequote all
The only common ground seems to be Colin ! Everyone enjoys his contribution.
And Hodgson is pretty unanimous as well.

I do understand why people don't like Huewen and Ryder. But I enjoyed them in World Superbikes "back in the day" and I do still enjoy them now. The idea of an experienced racer and a more analytical student of the sport should work really well.

bigralphie

25 posts

114 months

Wednesday 24th May 2017
quotequote all
None of them can hold a candle to the Cock that was Charlie Cox biggrin

Hungrymc

Original Poster:

7,452 posts

168 months

Wednesday 24th May 2017
quotequote all
bigralphie said:
None of them can hold a candle to the Cock that was Charlie Cox biggrin
That's shot the fox.

Its a nightmare in a bubble car.

Mr. Potato Head

1,182 posts

250 months

Wednesday 24th May 2017
quotequote all
The commentary and the coverage is ace.
Hope Toseland grows a Bon Jovi just to annoy fools.