Africa Twin vs Multistrada 950 vs Tracer 900 vs F800GS
Discussion
I'm looking for my first 'proper' bike and this is my current shortlist. I think I've ruled out nakeds (Monster, RNine T,XSR900 etc), sportsbikers and sport tourers don't interest me and I like the look of the above options.
At the moment I've got a TDM850 which does the job but the gearbox is clunky and I'd like ABS (and a shinier and newer bike...) . It's primarily going to be used for commuting about 20KM a day each way with the majority on motorway and about 2K of town/city riding at each end but with the odd weekend ride and I'm hoping to be able to head off on some longer trips a couple of times a year. I'm a new rider if that makes a difference.
I've ridden the Multistrada 1200 and fell in love with the sheer insanity of it, but it's total overkill for me and I'd have to buy a bike a few years old as opposed to new or ex demo for the top listed options.
So, the crux of my concern - no question at all the Tracer is the sensible option as I'm not going to be off roading (I assume it's illegal here, like most things including filtering through traffic) so with their 21" front wheels I'm concerned the AT and GS are the bike equivalent of urbanites buying a Land Rover Defender to go shopping and take an annual trip to Cornwall.
With a lack of experience and knowledge of what's good and not I'm going mostly on looks and image (or what I think of the looks and image
) . The dash on the GS is ugly, the Tracer doesn't really do it for me on an emotional level but it's 15-20% cheaper than the others, the AT feels like it'll be too off road focused for general use but DCT might be nice, and the Multistrada is probably my favourite but it's also the most expensive and there's a part of me which feels bad at the thought of using a Ducati to commute. I know it's just a bike and it's not that expensive in the grand scheme of things but it's still bothering me a little bit.
So, any owners, any experience of riding some of them back to back? I know I need to arrange test rides but it's be good to go in with some views to prove or dis-prove.
At the moment I've got a TDM850 which does the job but the gearbox is clunky and I'd like ABS (and a shinier and newer bike...) . It's primarily going to be used for commuting about 20KM a day each way with the majority on motorway and about 2K of town/city riding at each end but with the odd weekend ride and I'm hoping to be able to head off on some longer trips a couple of times a year. I'm a new rider if that makes a difference.
I've ridden the Multistrada 1200 and fell in love with the sheer insanity of it, but it's total overkill for me and I'd have to buy a bike a few years old as opposed to new or ex demo for the top listed options.
So, the crux of my concern - no question at all the Tracer is the sensible option as I'm not going to be off roading (I assume it's illegal here, like most things including filtering through traffic) so with their 21" front wheels I'm concerned the AT and GS are the bike equivalent of urbanites buying a Land Rover Defender to go shopping and take an annual trip to Cornwall.
With a lack of experience and knowledge of what's good and not I'm going mostly on looks and image (or what I think of the looks and image
) . The dash on the GS is ugly, the Tracer doesn't really do it for me on an emotional level but it's 15-20% cheaper than the others, the AT feels like it'll be too off road focused for general use but DCT might be nice, and the Multistrada is probably my favourite but it's also the most expensive and there's a part of me which feels bad at the thought of using a Ducati to commute. I know it's just a bike and it's not that expensive in the grand scheme of things but it's still bothering me a little bit.So, any owners, any experience of riding some of them back to back? I know I need to arrange test rides but it's be good to go in with some views to prove or dis-prove.
Africa Twin is a lovely machine, very pleasant to ride and feels quality. The engine is a little on the sensible side for me, nothing wrong with its delivery per se, just my thoughts. DCT works well enough as long as you put it in Sport. Great in town too.
Tracer is a cheap bike and you notice it when you spend some time with one (I bought one recently), but for some reason because you know its a budget-ish machine you almost let it off those cheap aspects. Namely soft suspension, crap screen, seat that gets painful after an hour and many owners report a speed wobble (low c of g, tall bike, dirty aero) but its usually at well above mway speeds.
I'm quite happy with mine so far though, very pleasant to ride, light clutch, agile handling, good riding position, great mpg (60mpg) gives a decent range (200miles some claim).
Wide bars make filtering a tricky exercise, the turning circle isn't great and I get a slight buzz through the bars at 60mph.
Tracer is a cheap bike and you notice it when you spend some time with one (I bought one recently), but for some reason because you know its a budget-ish machine you almost let it off those cheap aspects. Namely soft suspension, crap screen, seat that gets painful after an hour and many owners report a speed wobble (low c of g, tall bike, dirty aero) but its usually at well above mway speeds.
I'm quite happy with mine so far though, very pleasant to ride, light clutch, agile handling, good riding position, great mpg (60mpg) gives a decent range (200miles some claim).
Wide bars make filtering a tricky exercise, the turning circle isn't great and I get a slight buzz through the bars at 60mph.
I looked at the Tracer 700 and that really does feel like a cheap bike, the 900 felt better but I was seeing it next to the 700 rather than a GS.
Since I wrote the post I've read a couple of group tests of the Africa Twin which all seem to say it's a great road bike irrespective of its off-road capabilities. Filtering here is illegal, so the bar width isn't such a concern, although there is a particular bit of motorway where everyone does it the road is fairly wide there. At the moment the Honda and Ducati are at the top of my list and I can actually find an AT for only a few hundred quid more than the Tracer too. Initially I was concerned the AT was going to be too compromised as a road bike, if not now in a year or so when I've got some more miles under my tyres, but my mind has at least partially been put at rest on that front now.
Since I wrote the post I've read a couple of group tests of the Africa Twin which all seem to say it's a great road bike irrespective of its off-road capabilities. Filtering here is illegal, so the bar width isn't such a concern, although there is a particular bit of motorway where everyone does it the road is fairly wide there. At the moment the Honda and Ducati are at the top of my list and I can actually find an AT for only a few hundred quid more than the Tracer too. Initially I was concerned the AT was going to be too compromised as a road bike, if not now in a year or so when I've got some more miles under my tyres, but my mind has at least partially been put at rest on that front now.
Craiglamuffin said:
Don't forget the Triumph Tiger. I've just got an 11 plate 800cc model after looking at tracers and am really pleased with the look and feel of the whole thing. It burbles nicely too which makes me smile on the way to work.
I'd agree, pus IMO it's the best looking of the lot.I did consider the Tiger, but most of the reviews I've read seem to say it's OK in isolation but not as good as the competition so I'd discounted it. I do also have a friend with one but his view is that he bought it because it was cheap rather than it being better than the others he considered.
The Crossrunner looks interesting, and more road biased than the Africa Twin so I will have a look at that too - no DCT option but a V4 engine looks fun (I've never ridden a V4 so don't know what it's like). Price wise it's comparable with the others I'm looking at too.
Nobody got any views on the F800GS? They seem relatively popular over here but maybe less so in the UK?
The Crossrunner looks interesting, and more road biased than the Africa Twin so I will have a look at that too - no DCT option but a V4 engine looks fun (I've never ridden a V4 so don't know what it's like). Price wise it's comparable with the others I'm looking at too.
Nobody got any views on the F800GS? They seem relatively popular over here but maybe less so in the UK?
Edited by jamiebae on Sunday 9th July 07:53
jamiebae said:
I did consider the Tiger, but most of the reviews I've read seem to say it's OK in isolation but not as good as the competition so I'd discounted it. I do also have a friend with one but his view is that he bought it because it was cheap rather than it being better than the others he considered.
The Crossrunner looks interesting, and more road biased than the Africa Twin so I will have a look at that too - no DCT option but a V4 engine looks fun (I've never ridden a V4 so don't know what it's like). Price wise it's comparable with the others I'm looking at too.
Nobody got any views on the F800GS? They seem relatively popular over here but maybe less so in the UK?
The F800GS is a good tough bike, usual BMW stuff like integrated heated grips, on board co outer ABS etc and it's brilliant off road, however it's been around a while now and feels it, it's like the Landrover Defender of bikes, better off road than on road. I had the road version an F800ST which uses the same engine and the reliability was iffy. I think you can buy better for the money. The Africa Twin is a much superior bike.The Crossrunner looks interesting, and more road biased than the Africa Twin so I will have a look at that too - no DCT option but a V4 engine looks fun (I've never ridden a V4 so don't know what it's like). Price wise it's comparable with the others I'm looking at too.
Nobody got any views on the F800GS? They seem relatively popular over here but maybe less so in the UK?
Edited by jamiebae on Sunday 9th July 07:53
The 21" front will make it handle slower than a bike with a 17" front, that's just the laws of physics. It's ok once you get used to it though.
What about a KTM? The new 1090 adventure might be out your price range but the 1050 can be picked up very cheap now. The new tiger sport is meant to be very good too.
What about a KTM? The new 1090 adventure might be out your price range but the 1050 can be picked up very cheap now. The new tiger sport is meant to be very good too.
Tall_Paul said:
The 21" front will make it handle slower than a bike with a 17" front, that's just the laws of physics. It's ok once you get used to it though.
What about a KTM? The new 1090 adventure might be out your price range but the 1050 can be picked up very cheap now. The new tiger sport is meant to be very good too.
Yeah, I guess it's just acclimatisation. The TDM has an 18" front wheel, the Multistrada 1200 has a 17" and did feel much more eager on turn in and when I tried the R Nine T Urban GS (19" front) I really noticed the turn in. However, I've been testing bikes on various mountain passes and most of my riding is in town or on the motorway so I'm trying not to base the decision too much on these experiences.What about a KTM? The new 1090 adventure might be out your price range but the 1050 can be picked up very cheap now. The new tiger sport is meant to be very good too.
For whatever reason, KTM just don't really flick my switch. A couple of people have suggested them but they don't really excite me that much.
The 1090 is just about in budget (comparable with the Ducati) so might be worth a look. www.motoscout24.ch/4468047
I don't really like orange though
The 1090 is just about in budget (comparable with the Ducati) so might be worth a look. www.motoscout24.ch/4468047
I don't really like orange though

laurenz said:
Maybe consider a BMW R1200RT? Combo of weather protection, handling, comfort, features and low insurance group are second to none. Just about to have my second delivered this week. Build quality is superb, too.
The RT just doesn't do it for me looks-wise unfortunately. I do like the 1200 GS but for my budget I'd be on a 2014 bike with 25k KM on the clock. Insurance isn't a concern really, the prices I've seen vary from about £200 a year on a Tracer 700 up to £500 for a Multistrada 1200 which I can live with happily enough.Any thoughts on running cost of the various bikes? I guess they're broadly similar in terms of service frequency, fuel economy etc?
Andybow said:
Tiger 1050 2016-17 is a cracking bike, really is a do everything bike, Not lacking in power anywhere in the rev range, comfy, quick, sounds good, economical, I loved it when I tested one, it's just like a comfy speed triple, really is good fun, You should definetly try one
Price-wise they seem the most expensive of all though, even more than the KTM or Ducati and I'm afraid I'm not so keen on the way it looks eitherjamiebae said:
The RT just doesn't do it for me looks-wise unfortunately. I do like the 1200 GS but for my budget I'd be on a 2014 bike with 25k KM on the clock. Insurance isn't a concern really, the prices I've seen vary from about £200 a year on a Tracer 700 up to £500 for a Multistrada 1200 which I can live with happily enough.
Any thoughts on running cost of the various bikes? I guess they're broadly similar in terms of service frequency, fuel economy etc?
What's wrong with a GS with 25,000km on it? They'll do a lot more than that. Any thoughts on running cost of the various bikes? I guess they're broadly similar in terms of service frequency, fuel economy etc?
Also, the Tiger XC is a significantly better road bike than the F800GS. I'm biased as I love mine, but I've ridden and owned a lot of bikes and the Tiger punches well above it's weight and spec.
I rode the Tracer 900 after obsessing over them for months. I came away feeling 'meh'. The screen being the biggest of its issues, it was terrible but im 6ft1 and sat just above it. Built to a budget but didn't blow me away in ride quality or motor performance. I ended up buying a BMW s1000xr but again that's overkill for you if the Multi1200 was too much.
Have you considered something like the Honda CBF1000? Takes the motor from the CB1000R/old Fireblade (correct me if i'm wrong there). Honda took a load of power from the top end and gave it a little more bottom end grunt. Similar power to the Tracer900. Good solid bike that won't let you down. Load of potential for touring and still a quick capable bike. In your price range you can get a 2016 version quite easily.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2017...
My only criticism is that this is a little dull imo
Have you considered something like the Honda CBF1000? Takes the motor from the CB1000R/old Fireblade (correct me if i'm wrong there). Honda took a load of power from the top end and gave it a little more bottom end grunt. Similar power to the Tracer900. Good solid bike that won't let you down. Load of potential for touring and still a quick capable bike. In your price range you can get a 2016 version quite easily.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2017...
My only criticism is that this is a little dull imo
A lot of these bikes mentioned vary quite significantly in price if I am not mistaken.
KTM 1190 SA 14k
BMWGS 14k
Africa Twin 11K
Tracer 8.5k
Tiger 800 ???
I have just roughly guessed the relative prices. I would just say when judging the Tracer remember the cost of the machinery its up against.
KTM 1190 SA 14k
BMWGS 14k
Africa Twin 11K
Tracer 8.5k
Tiger 800 ???
I have just roughly guessed the relative prices. I would just say when judging the Tracer remember the cost of the machinery its up against.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


