Add-on cruise control devices - any good?
Add-on cruise control devices - any good?
Author
Discussion

phatmanace

Original Poster:

679 posts

240 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
does anyone have one of these add on cruise control things like

This

or

This

couple of questions if you do:

- how do they disengage? - do you have to physically twist the throttle back?
- Can you "turn it off"? - e.g for town riding, can you slacken it off a bit so that it doesn't operate at all?


podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
You can achieve the same result as this one

http://throttlemeister.com/

by fitting cheap aftermarket grips..

Speed addicted

6,336 posts

258 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
This looks a lot cheaper and easier https://www.scottoiler.com/uk/Accessories/Crampbus...
My mate uses one on his Ducati 996 with good results.

podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
This looks a lot cheaper and easier https://www.scottoiler.com/uk/Accessories/Crampbus...
My mate uses one on his Ducati 996 with good results.
Now those I have tried, we ( 4 of us) bought them for a European tour back in 2013 I think, mine lasted until the first services where it went in the bin, couldnt get on with it at all and throttling off whilst braking was really awkward, the others didnt last much longer.

You can get them for a couple of quid of eBay so not a lot to lose if you wanted to give them a go.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
How is this cruise control? It's just jamming the throttle in place.

I don't think I'd trust any of those things.

This looks more like what i'd go for;

https://www.mccruise.com/collections/honda

trialsta

90 posts

220 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
podman said:
Now those I have tried, we ( 4 of us) bought them for a European tour back in 2013 I think, mine lasted until the first services where it went in the bin, couldnt get on with it at all and throttling off whilst braking was really awkward, the others didnt last much longer.

You can get them for a couple of quid of eBay so not a lot to lose if you wanted to give them a go.
To provide a completely contrasting view....
I've used a crampbuster for probably 10-15k miles worth of touring over the past 3 or 4 years and it makes a huge difference for long distance, high speed miles. You then just pivot it out of the way for the more interesting roads.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
podman said:
You can achieve the same result as this one

http://throttlemeister.com/

by fitting cheap aftermarket grips..
Or by letting the wind blow over your poorly supported sidestand wise Aprilia Falco which then lands on the throttle side clip on and bends it just enough to require you to have to remove throttle manually to slow down always. Visually looked fine!

podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
trialsta said:
podman said:
Now those I have tried, we ( 4 of us) bought them for a European tour back in 2013 I think, mine lasted until the first services where it went in the bin, couldnt get on with it at all and throttling off whilst braking was really awkward, the others didnt last much longer.

You can get them for a couple of quid of eBay so not a lot to lose if you wanted to give them a go.
To provide a completely contrasting view....
I've used a crampbuster for probably 10-15k miles worth of touring over the past 3 or 4 years and it makes a huge difference for long distance, high speed miles. You then just pivot it out of the way for the more interesting roads.
There ya go..has to be worth a punt for a few quid....

phatmanace

Original Poster:

679 posts

240 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
How is this cruise control? It's just jamming the throttle in place.

I don't think I'd trust any of those things.

This looks more like what i'd go for;

https://www.mccruise.com/collections/honda
did a bit more research and I'm starting to agree - but on the other hand I dont think I'm going to pay a grand for a 'proper' cruise control - so we'll just leave it there for now,

Thanks for all the replies though - will just have to put on the tick list if I ever change my bike smile

Speed addicted

6,336 posts

258 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
My Triumph Explorer has cruise control, I've had it for a while now but t still feels very weird when the bike takes over.
Great on long boring roads though, it stops me gradually upping the pace without noticing.

fire3500

88 posts

158 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
phatmanace said:
does anyone have one of these add on cruise control things like

This

or

This

couple of questions if you do:

- how do they disengage? - do you have to physically twist the throttle back?
- Can you "turn it off"? - e.g for town riding, can you slacken it off a bit so that it doesn't operate at all?
I've got a Kaoko. They're easy to fit and to use, but as others have said it's just holding the throttle in place. OK on the flat but going up or down hills or with wind variances etc. you'll still speed up or slow down. They're handiest for when it's really bloody cold and you're trying to tuck everything behind your clocks and flyscreen, you can hold onto the triple tree instead of the bar ends...

freddytin

1,184 posts

258 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all

I remember returning from Cyprus with a bad vibration from a damaged front tyre and after a few hours, my throttle hand was decidedly numb. Not ideal to say the least.

From my emergency tool kit, I took a mahoosive tie wrap and secured it around the outer edge of the throttle grip with the tail cut off just below the brake lever so as I could maintain a healthy cruising, speed hands-free.

It worked surprisingly well all the way back to the UK. Can't say as I've tried it since as its almost impossible to travel any sort of distance around here at a constant speed ...But if I ever find a traffic-free environment again,.....

phatmanace

Original Poster:

679 posts

240 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
I haven't had a ton of experience riding bikes at motorway speed (I've only had my 650 for ~1 year, before that it was 125's)

One thing I've noticed is that its harder to keep a constant speed on a bike than in a car - unless of course you're staring at the speedo all the time. I guess a combination of less weight and more engine braking means you can lose or gain 10/15mph pretty quickly - (sorry if that's stating the obvious)

That said, normal cruise control in car's isn't all that useful as there is too much traffic in the UK to maintain a constant speed.

CAPP0

20,881 posts

234 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
My Triumph Explorer has cruise control, I've had it for a while now but t still feels very weird when the bike takes over.
Great on long boring roads though, it stops me gradually upping the pace without noticing.
Yeah, my BM has it too. You're right, first few times you use it, it's weird, but now I use it every day. Stops speed creeping up on the motorway, means you can just relax your hand, and around town it's useful where you need to stick to speed limits, eg the 50mph average on the A102. Disengages with either brake, the clutch, or by twisting the grip backwards. I'm now in the habit of just dabbing the rear brake to disengage. Highly recommended.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Wednesday 12th July 2017
quotequote all
phatmanace said:
One thing I've noticed is that its harder to keep a constant speed on a bike than in a car - unless of course you're staring at the speedo all the time. I guess a combination of less weight and more engine braking means you can lose or gain 10/15mph pretty quickly - (sorry if that's stating the obvious)
The thing is with these cheap devices won't do that either.

As I said before it isn't cruise control. If you are simply locking the throttle in place, if you come to a slight hill on constant throttle, the rpm drops, and you'll slow down. Coming down the same hill, your speed will increase. Unless it's a very flat, long, empty road, it won't work as "cruise control". You're still going to have to be watching your speed and making adjustments.

These device may be good for saving wrist ache, not a lot a lot else.




phatmanace

Original Poster:

679 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th July 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
The thing is with these cheap devices won't do that either.

As I said before it isn't cruise control. If you are simply locking the throttle in place, if you come to a slight hill on constant throttle, the rpm drops, and you'll slow down. Coming down the same hill, your speed will increase. Unless it's a very flat, long, empty road, it won't work as "cruise control". You're still going to have to be watching your speed and making adjustments.

These device may be good for saving wrist ache, not a lot a lot else.
Very true. It's also what I concluded after reading the reviews of these gadgets as well as this thread.