Scrambling to get an S1000 RS
Discussion
For a little while now I have been toying with the idea of getting rid of my Ducati Scrambler and replacing it with another bike.
There have been a few reasons behind the change, appalling suspension, poor build quality and it's not quite a quick as I would like it to be.
After narrowing it's replacement to a Superduke R, Speed Triple and S1000 RS a 300-mile test ride on the S1000 a couple of weekends ago made my mind up for me.
So this coming Thursday I pick this thing up.

And quite frankly I cannot wait.
There have been a few reasons behind the change, appalling suspension, poor build quality and it's not quite a quick as I would like it to be.
After narrowing it's replacement to a Superduke R, Speed Triple and S1000 RS a 300-mile test ride on the S1000 a couple of weekends ago made my mind up for me.
So this coming Thursday I pick this thing up.
And quite frankly I cannot wait.
black-k1 said:
Congratulations on the new bike. I hope you have many happy miles together.

Just so you know, in BMW speak, the S1000R Sport is not the same as an S1000RS. They don't make a S1000RS which is a shame as it would likely be a bike I'd be very interested in.
Agreed, I purposely didn't call it an S1000R Sport as it feels a bit like saying, `Hey guys, look at my new 116D M Sport. It's an M Sport you know and that's very very important'
Just so you know, in BMW speak, the S1000R Sport is not the same as an S1000RS. They don't make a S1000RS which is a shame as it would likely be a bike I'd be very interested in. I agree though if they did release a true RS version I'd be very interested too.
podman said:
Very nice mate, I couldnt wait to pick that up either.
Out of interest, in what particular way did you not think the quality of the Ducati was that great?
I don't want to go on a Ducati bash here but ...Out of interest, in what particular way did you not think the quality of the Ducati was that great?
The build quality of the Scrambler is very poor imo and that has been my biggest bug bear with the bike.
In the 7500 miles, I have covered over the past year, the amount of screws and fixings that have vibrated and rattled loose is disappointing. Bear in mind that 100% of my riding has been on road too.
The cowl around the headlight is starting to bubble already and looks very shoddy.
The suspension is pretty crap.
Ground clearance is limited, I've almost ground right through the exhaust header pipes. And it's not a fun feeling having the weight taken off the tyres when pressing on through corners.
This is not a fault of the bike, but I didn't find it exciting to ride. It was fun, but not exciting in any way.
Overall the bike feels cheap, and it's not really a cheap bike in a way that your typical Jingaling bike is.
airsafari87 said:
For a little while now I have been toying with the idea of getting rid of my Ducati Scrambler and replacing it with another bike.
There have been a few reasons behind the change, appalling suspension, poor build quality and it's not quite a quick as I would like it to be.
After narrowing it's replacement to a Superduke R, Speed Triple and S1000 RS a 300-mile test ride on the S1000 a couple of weekends ago made my mind up for me.
So this coming Thursday I pick this thing up.

And quite frankly I cannot wait.
These are a fantastic bike! I've had mine a month and I have had it in Dynamic mode since new, it's good however after the first service it feels a whole lot better, such an easy bike to ride. There have been a few reasons behind the change, appalling suspension, poor build quality and it's not quite a quick as I would like it to be.
After narrowing it's replacement to a Superduke R, Speed Triple and S1000 RS a 300-mile test ride on the S1000 a couple of weekends ago made my mind up for me.
So this coming Thursday I pick this thing up.
And quite frankly I cannot wait.
I popped my first roll on wheelie too, I didn't mean to, a 'very fast' Astra with tyres squealing tried an undertake off a roundabout, I rolled on the throttle and up went the front, very controlled and left trouble behind, fabulous.
airsafari87 said:
I don't want to go on a Ducati bash here but ...
The build quality of the Scrambler is very poor imo and that has been my biggest bug bear with the bike.
In the 7500 miles, I have covered over the past year, the amount of screws and fixings that have vibrated and rattled loose is disappointing. Bear in mind that 100% of my riding has been on road too.
The cowl around the headlight is starting to bubble already and looks very shoddy.
The suspension is pretty crap.
Ground clearance is limited, I've almost ground right through the exhaust header pipes. And it's not a fun feeling having the weight taken off the tyres when pressing on through corners.
This is not a fault of the bike, but I didn't find it exciting to ride. It was fun, but not exciting in any way.
Overall the bike feels cheap, and it's not really a cheap bike in a way that your typical Jingaling bike is.
After 2 years and 5000 miles mine is pretty much as new... Number of screws and fixings that have unwound themselves is zero. Warranty claims are limited to a fractured bracket on the rear mudguard at 4,500 miles. Replaced without quibble by the dealer. I did hit a pheasant at around 115mph, but that was my own fault and a pair of front mudguard brackets and a new Evotech headlight protector undid the work of the dastardly bird (thumbs up to Evotech BTW, the headlight protector was bent and the headlight unmarked! The build quality of the Scrambler is very poor imo and that has been my biggest bug bear with the bike.
In the 7500 miles, I have covered over the past year, the amount of screws and fixings that have vibrated and rattled loose is disappointing. Bear in mind that 100% of my riding has been on road too.
The cowl around the headlight is starting to bubble already and looks very shoddy.
The suspension is pretty crap.
Ground clearance is limited, I've almost ground right through the exhaust header pipes. And it's not a fun feeling having the weight taken off the tyres when pressing on through corners.
This is not a fault of the bike, but I didn't find it exciting to ride. It was fun, but not exciting in any way.
Overall the bike feels cheap, and it's not really a cheap bike in a way that your typical Jingaling bike is.
).The front suspension is non-adjustable and the rear only for preload, really the issues are resolved by swapping out the spring on the rear shock for a weight-matched item (Hyperpro do them) and the quality of oil in the front forks is poor, change it and you'll feel the standard forks working much better. Also the steering and suspension both benefit from a 4mm drop through the front forks. If you're feeling flush then swap out the rear shock for an Ohlins and put a cartridge kit in the forks.
If you've ground away the headers then you're doing well... the heatshield on the silencer is the first thing to touch down, followed by the standard Ducati bash guard (if fitted) on the RH side. A Racefit Growler fixes this issue, and with the baffles fitted makes a stunning noise. You're not going to unseat the tyres by scraping the silencer though, and the standard Pirellis are sticky little buggers... at 7500 miles you're probably on your third rear and second front by now? If you've sprung for a Rexxer remap and bypassed the lambdas then I'd be surprised if you're finding it slow, and if you are then a bit of a tinker with the final drive when you bin the poor OEM chain and sprockets will fix that nicely.
A Scrambler could be had for under £7k at launch, an S1000R Sport was £11.4k at launch (basic model just under £10k). It's not an apples vs. apples comparison really. The Scrambler was designed to get a new audience to come and buy a Ducati, and has been hugely successful for the company. Everyone's different and cares for their bike differently, but with a dose of ACF-50 periodically I can say that corrosion hasn't been a problem and the bike is a *huge* amount of fun for the money. I've tinkered with mine a bit, but haven't gone crazy with the mods, bloody love the thing. S1000R Sport is a mega bike, but one that lives in a different budget and category to a Scrambler.
For reference, I'm a 42 year old child who's been riding since I was 16. I also have regular access to more "serious" Ducatis, a GS for holibobs and an '11 Fireblade. The Scrambler is just a brilliant bit of fun that can bimble or act stupidly dependent upon mood.
The main thing I'd say about the Scrambler is that the performance from the proven 803cc twin is massively ACCESSIBLE and that you can pin the thing on twisty country roads, enjoy feeling the bike get a little out of shape and loose and just giggle yourself daft while carving graceful lines everywhere. Mini roundabouts, o' mini roundabouts...

If you're seeking superbike performance then yes you've been on the wrong bike, but I can guarantee that you'll (more safely) exploit a greater percentage of the available capability of a Scrambler Ducati than an S1000R Sport on British roads. The BMW will deliver a premium experience, premium performance and with premium quality but definitely at a premium price in comparison. More toys and rider-aids, definitely faster, likely better finished to a higher standard.
To the OP, enjoy the new bike, Airsafari87, not denying your experience mate but presenting an alternative view. Horses for courses.
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:14
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:19
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:21
fire3500 said:
After 2 years and 5000 miles mine is pretty much as new... Number of screws and fixings that have unwound themselves is zero. Warranty claims are limited to a fractured bracket on the rear mudguard at 4,500 miles. Replaced without quibble by the dealer. I did hit a pheasant at around 115mph, but that was my own fault and a pair of front mudguard brackets and a new Evotech headlight protector undid the work of the dastardly bird (thumbs up to Evotech BTW, the headlight protector was bent and the headlight unmarked!
).
The front suspension is non-adjustable and the rear only for preload, really the issues are resolved by swapping out the spring on the rear shock for a weight-matched item (Hyperpro do them) and the quality of oil in the front forks is poor, change it and you'll feel the standard forks working much better. Also the steering and suspension both benefit from a 4mm drop through the front forks. If you're feeling flush then swap out the rear shock for an Ohlins and put a cartridge kit in the forks.
If you've ground away the headers then you're doing well... the heatshield on the silencer is the first thing to touch down, followed by the standard Ducati bash guard (if fitted) on the RH side. A Racefit Growler fixes this issue, and with the baffles fitted makes a stunning noise. You're not going to unseat the tyres by scraping the silencer though, and the standard Pirellis are sticky little buggers... at 7500 miles you're probably on your third rear and second front by now? If you've sprung for a Rexxer remap and bypassed the lambdas then I'd be surprised if you're finding it slow, and if you are then a bit of a tinker with the final drive when you bin the poor OEM chain and sprockets will fix that nicely.

A Scrambler could be had for under £7k at launch, an S1000R Sport was £11.4k at launch (basic model just under £10k). It's not an apples vs. apples comparison really. The Scrambler was designed to get a new audience to come and buy a Ducati, and has been hugely successful for the company. Everyone's different and cares for their bike differently, but with a dose of ACF-50 periodically I can say that corrosion hasn't been a problem and the bike is a *huge* amount of fun for the money. I've tinkered with mine a bit, but haven't gone crazy with the mods, bloody love the thing. S1000R Sport is a mega bike, but one that lives in a different budget and category to a Scrambler.
For reference, I'm a 42 year old child who's been riding since I was 16. I also have regular access to more "serious" Ducatis, a GS for holibobs and an '11 Fireblade. The Scrambler is just a brilliant bit of fun that can bimble or act stupidly dependent upon mood.
The main thing I'd say about the Scrambler is that the performance from the proven 803cc twin is massively ACCESSIBLE and that you can pin the thing on twisty country roads, enjoy feeling the bike get a little out of shape and loose and just giggle yourself daft while carving graceful lines everywhere. Mini roundabouts, o' mini roundabouts...
If you're seeking superbike performance then yes you've been on the wrong bike, but I can guarantee that you'll (more safely) exploit a greater percentage of the available capability of a Scrambler Ducati than an S1000R Sport on British roads. The BMW will deliver a premium experience, premium performance and with premium quality but definitely at a premium price in comparison. More toys and rider-aids, definitely faster, likely better finished to a higher standard.
To the OP, enjoy the new bike, Airsafari87, not denying your experience mate but presenting an alternative view. Horses for courses.
Wow! I feel like my criticisms hit a bit of a nerve there?
).The front suspension is non-adjustable and the rear only for preload, really the issues are resolved by swapping out the spring on the rear shock for a weight-matched item (Hyperpro do them) and the quality of oil in the front forks is poor, change it and you'll feel the standard forks working much better. Also the steering and suspension both benefit from a 4mm drop through the front forks. If you're feeling flush then swap out the rear shock for an Ohlins and put a cartridge kit in the forks.
If you've ground away the headers then you're doing well... the heatshield on the silencer is the first thing to touch down, followed by the standard Ducati bash guard (if fitted) on the RH side. A Racefit Growler fixes this issue, and with the baffles fitted makes a stunning noise. You're not going to unseat the tyres by scraping the silencer though, and the standard Pirellis are sticky little buggers... at 7500 miles you're probably on your third rear and second front by now? If you've sprung for a Rexxer remap and bypassed the lambdas then I'd be surprised if you're finding it slow, and if you are then a bit of a tinker with the final drive when you bin the poor OEM chain and sprockets will fix that nicely.
A Scrambler could be had for under £7k at launch, an S1000R Sport was £11.4k at launch (basic model just under £10k). It's not an apples vs. apples comparison really. The Scrambler was designed to get a new audience to come and buy a Ducati, and has been hugely successful for the company. Everyone's different and cares for their bike differently, but with a dose of ACF-50 periodically I can say that corrosion hasn't been a problem and the bike is a *huge* amount of fun for the money. I've tinkered with mine a bit, but haven't gone crazy with the mods, bloody love the thing. S1000R Sport is a mega bike, but one that lives in a different budget and category to a Scrambler.
For reference, I'm a 42 year old child who's been riding since I was 16. I also have regular access to more "serious" Ducatis, a GS for holibobs and an '11 Fireblade. The Scrambler is just a brilliant bit of fun that can bimble or act stupidly dependent upon mood.
The main thing I'd say about the Scrambler is that the performance from the proven 803cc twin is massively ACCESSIBLE and that you can pin the thing on twisty country roads, enjoy feeling the bike get a little out of shape and loose and just giggle yourself daft while carving graceful lines everywhere. Mini roundabouts, o' mini roundabouts...

If you're seeking superbike performance then yes you've been on the wrong bike, but I can guarantee that you'll (more safely) exploit a greater percentage of the available capability of a Scrambler Ducati than an S1000R Sport on British roads. The BMW will deliver a premium experience, premium performance and with premium quality but definitely at a premium price in comparison. More toys and rider-aids, definitely faster, likely better finished to a higher standard.
To the OP, enjoy the new bike, Airsafari87, not denying your experience mate but presenting an alternative view. Horses for courses.
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:14
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:19
Edited by fire3500 on Tuesday 11th July 01:21
Of course each bike is different, but the issues I pointed out there were issues I had with my bike, not everyone will have the same issues of course.
For clarity though, the bike was ridden right up until December and brought back out again in Feb. And even ACF50 couldnt prevent the corrosion.
I changed the OEM shotgun termi for an SC Projects exhaust pretty early on. And this is how the headers look now. Which is a compliment towards the handling rather than a criticism.
Finally you'd have to be a lunatic to believe that the Scrambler and S1000 were comparable bikes, or bikes in the same bracket. They arent, but then I never suggested that.
I'm pleased you're clearly loving your Scrambler, apologies if you took offence to the criticisms I made from the experiences I have had with my bike, but as I said, each bike is different and they were based on the time I've spent with my Scrambler.
airsafari87 said:
For clarity though, the bike was ridden right up until December and brought back out again in Feb. And even ACF50 couldnt prevent the corrosion.
The BMW will dissolve in front of your eyes over the same period of riding. Really. If you want to mitigate it, buy the stainless bolt/fastening kit which is available for these and have the dealer fit them - replace everything below about knee level, the standard ones rust as though its a design feature; and bathe it in ACF-50 in about November - not by the dealer but by an ACF-50 specialist who takes at least 2 hours to do the job. Then don't wash it again until its next ACF treatment, in around March.Ask me how I know this.
Edited by 308mate on Tuesday 11th July 08:54
airsafari87 said:
I don't want to go on a Ducati bash here but ...
The build quality of the Scrambler is very poor imo and that has been my biggest bug bear with the bike.
In the 7500 miles, I have covered over the past year, the amount of screws and fixings that have vibrated and rattled loose is disappointing. Bear in mind that 100% of my riding has been on road too.
The cowl around the headlight is starting to bubble already and looks very shoddy.
The suspension is pretty crap.
Ground clearance is limited, I've almost ground right through the exhaust header pipes. And it's not a fun feeling having the weight taken off the tyres when pressing on through corners.
This is not a fault of the bike, but I didn't find it exciting to ride. It was fun, but not exciting in any way.
Overall the bike feels cheap, and it's not really a cheap bike in a way that your typical Jingaling bike is.
I do hope you haven't got a surprise coming. BMW Bikes are nowhere near as premium as the badge would have you believe. Having come from a Honda Fireblade my S1000R Sport feels a bit cheap. Switch gear is crap, moves a little on the bars, mirrors are useless, bike is buzzy as hell, sump has corroded despite never being out in the rain. Bar ends have rust bubbles and flaking paint despite never having been dropped or having got wet. The build quality of the Scrambler is very poor imo and that has been my biggest bug bear with the bike.
In the 7500 miles, I have covered over the past year, the amount of screws and fixings that have vibrated and rattled loose is disappointing. Bear in mind that 100% of my riding has been on road too.
The cowl around the headlight is starting to bubble already and looks very shoddy.
The suspension is pretty crap.
Ground clearance is limited, I've almost ground right through the exhaust header pipes. And it's not a fun feeling having the weight taken off the tyres when pressing on through corners.
This is not a fault of the bike, but I didn't find it exciting to ride. It was fun, but not exciting in any way.
Overall the bike feels cheap, and it's not really a cheap bike in a way that your typical Jingaling bike is.
Compared with the Honda which was sold at 13 years old, and still looked and felt like new, I dread to think what the s1000r will look like at a similar age. I'm unlikely to keep mine for much longer than 2 years or so for these reasons.
I've read this back, and I'm really not trying to piss on your chips OP. It is a fantastic bike, I am having a huge amount of fun on it, but if you changed bikes because of dissatisfaction with the build quality of your scrambler, then frying pan and fire springs to mind.
cbmotorsport said:
I do hope you haven't got a surprise coming. BMW Bikes are nowhere near as premium as the badge would have you believe. Having come from a Honda Fireblade my S1000R Sport feels a bit cheap. Switch gear is crap, moves a little on the bars, mirrors are useless, bike is buzzy as hell, sump has corroded despite never being out in the rain. Bar ends have rust bubbles and flaking paint despite never having been dropped or having got wet.
Compared with the Honda which was sold at 13 years old, and still looked and felt like new, I dread to think what the s1000r will look like at a similar age. I'm unlikely to keep mine for much longer than 2 years or so for these reasons.
I've read this back, and I'm really not trying to piss on your chips OP. It is a fantastic bike, I am having a huge amount of fun on it, but if you changed bikes because of dissatisfaction with the build quality of your scrambler, then frying pan and fire springs to mind.
Chips are piss free, no worries. Compared with the Honda which was sold at 13 years old, and still looked and felt like new, I dread to think what the s1000r will look like at a similar age. I'm unlikely to keep mine for much longer than 2 years or so for these reasons.
I've read this back, and I'm really not trying to piss on your chips OP. It is a fantastic bike, I am having a huge amount of fun on it, but if you changed bikes because of dissatisfaction with the build quality of your scrambler, then frying pan and fire springs to mind.
I have gone into this with my eyes open, I'm not under any illusion that bikes built by BMW are bullet proof and at the absolute pinnacle of quality.
I've looked at many many bikes before settling on the S1000. It's the bike I `want' and the one which fits in the best for my needs and hasn't been bought on perceived quality or whatever.
My circumstances have changed over the past year too, so I will no longer be riding the bike once the roads start getting salted. My commute to work is only 5 miles and a 125cc scooter has made its way into my garage which is perfect for taking up those duties. I'll still be giving the bike an ACF-50 treatment though as I have done with all of my bikes.
308mate said:
The BMW will dissolve in front of your eyes over the same period of riding. Really. If you want to mitigate it, buy the stainless bolt/fastening kit which is available for these and have the dealer fit them - replace everything below about knee level, the standard ones rust as though its a design feature; and bathe it in ACF-50 in about November - not by the dealer but by an ACF-50 specialist who takes at least 2 hours to do the job. Then don't wash it again until its next ACF treatment, in around March.
Ask me how I know this.
How do you know this?? (joking)Ask me how I know this.
Like I mentioned above, I will be giving the bike an ACF-50 treatment anyway, and won't be riding through the winter on it.
The stainless bolt option might be worth exploring anyway though, thanks. Do you have any idea what the price is on them?
Again, I will reiterate, it's a fantastic bike OP, and I forgive it its faults. Best brakes I've had on a bike, Incredibly planted, handles far better than I'll ever be able to exploit, so much torque and grunt, and docile when required. You will love it.
Edited by cbmotorsport on Tuesday 11th July 09:33
Nah, not a raw nerve. I'm just as keen as mustard on the little bugger! :-)
As I say, you're doing well to have ground the headers. I'd say that's less about poor ground clearance and more about it being very chuckable!
I'm same, pretty much year round, ACF seems to have saved the day here, well and the bash guard too.
Enjoy the BMW, I didn't mean that sarcastically. It wasn't a defensive post. Just enthusiastic about the baby Duc.
As I say, you're doing well to have ground the headers. I'd say that's less about poor ground clearance and more about it being very chuckable!
I'm same, pretty much year round, ACF seems to have saved the day here, well and the bash guard too.
Enjoy the BMW, I didn't mean that sarcastically. It wasn't a defensive post. Just enthusiastic about the baby Duc.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




