Discussion
Suppose you have an old high mileage but generally reliable car which your happy to keep running indefinitely as long as nothing major breaks. Worth say £1000 if you were to sell it, but worth more to you because it's reliable and has a known history.
How big an impending bill makes it worth saying 'it's been fun' and getting a fresh car? I know someone who has just spent £500 on fixing a Focus worth £900 as a trade in.
How big an impending bill makes it worth saying 'it's been fun' and getting a fresh car? I know someone who has just spent £500 on fixing a Focus worth £900 as a trade in.
Dr Jekyll said:
I know someone who has just spent £500 on fixing a Focus worth £900 as a trade in.
£500 in repairs on a £900 car is VERY borderline.I might do that if I knew the ENTIRE provenance of the car (i.e. my gran did the first 30,000 miles, then my dad did the next 50,000, and I'd driven it every mile since).
Otherwise, it's a case of kicking it into the weeds.
nyxster said:
A 900 quod car with the benefit of a 500 quid repair is better than a 900 quid banger that needs a 500 quid repair. If you change you've got no certainty whatever you buy won't need work doing so sometimes better the devil you know.
Exactly this.A few years ago I spent about £500 on a mot/service which included replacement clutch, brake pads and tires for my old Mk1 Focus. It would have been about 12 years old, 130k miles on the clock. If something out of the ordinary had cropped up afterwards I'd have been quite willing to shell out another £500 to fix it rather than taking a gamble on some ropey old shed.
I've several times spent £400+ on MOT work for cars worth less than a grand. If the car is otherwise tidy and drives well I'd rather spend £500 than take a gamble on another shed that might blow up the next day. I only do essential repair work though, if you start chasing niggles then Bangernomics doesn't work.
Anyone bangernomics bikes? I'm currently trying to minimise my commute spend and I'm really trying to justify replacing my 51 plate Monster M600, but its got 30k miles on it, it's a bit dented, it's fairly cheap to run and service and its just been faultless and apart from having no wind protection I can't really justify the change!
If you're sure a £500 repair bill is going to keep it on the road for another year, then it's not to bad value. The assumption of a £900 value is presumably based on it working, so when needing the repair bill done you're probably only going to get £400 for it. I'd trust a car I know the history of and have just spent money fixing more than I would a £900 car straight off e-bay.
Appleby said:
Anyone bangernomics bikes? I'm currently trying to minimise my commute spend and I'm really trying to justify replacing my 51 plate Monster M600, but its got 30k miles on it, it's a bit dented, it's fairly cheap to run and service and its just been faultless and apart from having no wind protection I can't really justify the change!
Not sure if it's bagernomics but I bought an 08 Bandit 1250 for £3k in March last year and have done 20,000 miles on it already commuting. It never gets cleaned particularly (chain etc aside), it's scruffy and I wouldn't get much more than a grand back I reckong so I'm kinda thiking I'll just keep using it until it dies. E36GUY said:
Appleby said:
Anyone bangernomics bikes? I'm currently trying to minimise my commute spend and I'm really trying to justify replacing my 51 plate Monster M600, but its got 30k miles on it, it's a bit dented, it's fairly cheap to run and service and its just been faultless and apart from having no wind protection I can't really justify the change!
Not sure if it's bagernomics but I bought an 08 Bandit 1250 for £3k in March last year and have done 20,000 miles on it already commuting. It never gets cleaned particularly (chain etc aside), it's scruffy and I wouldn't get much more than a grand back I reckong so I'm kinda thiking I'll just keep using it until it dies. I run an old 1990 vfr750 I bought for 530 quid a few years back. I've done a lot of stuff to it but nothing expensive, just labour. It's brilliant for commuting all year round.
Appleby said:
Anyone bangernomics bikes? I'm currently trying to minimise my commute spend and I'm really trying to justify replacing my 51 plate Monster M600, but its got 30k miles on it, it's a bit dented, it's fairly cheap to run and service and its just been faultless and apart from having no wind protection I can't really justify the change!
Yeah, but because I had no money! Sub 1k bikes have been:Yamaha xj700x (good if you like that sort of thing)
Cx500 (pre-hipster tax)
CB400 (not a bad bike, but I didn't get on with it)
GPZ500R mine was ropey as f
k but was a good bike. zzr600 s
t.My Starfire was £1350, but a good wee bike for what it is. Not many 48 year old British 250s will happily cruise at 60.
Now, there's a caveat to all this...
I bought the VFR so I didn't get the xr400 (SM) dirty riding in the wet.
I bought the xr400 (SM) so I didn't get the Fireblade dirty riding in the wet.
I've now stripped and rebuilt the vfr and just this morning won a carbon hugger for it.
I ain't bin well.
I bought the VFR so I didn't get the xr400 (SM) dirty riding in the wet.
I bought the xr400 (SM) so I didn't get the Fireblade dirty riding in the wet.
I've now stripped and rebuilt the vfr and just this morning won a carbon hugger for it.
I ain't bin well.
Edited by Vincefox on Saturday 15th July 10:45
Vincefox said:
Now, there's a caveat to all this...
I bought the VFR so I didn't get the xr400 (SM) dirty riding in the wet.
I bought the xr400 (SM) so I didn't get the Fireblade dirty riding in the wet.
I've now stripped and rebuilt the vfr and just this morning won a carbon hugger for it.
I ain't bin well.
You big tart.I bought the VFR so I didn't get the xr400 (SM) dirty riding in the wet.
I bought the xr400 (SM) so I didn't get the Fireblade dirty riding in the wet.
I've now stripped and rebuilt the vfr and just this morning won a carbon hugger for it.
I ain't bin well.
Edited by Vincefox on Saturday 15th July 10:45
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





