Is there such a thing as too safe?
Discussion
Looking at getting back on a bike after about 6 years off.
When I rode last time I did it on a shoestring.. £1k bike, second hand lid from a mate, £30 jacket from eBay etc
Now I'm older and wiser, I'm a bit more aware of my mortality. I also have a decent chunk of money to throw at it this time. I now have a wife and kids so feel it's responsible, if for no other reason than the wife's peace of mind that I do the best I can to ensure I'm as safe as I can be.
So now I'm looking at kit. I had already decided on quality kit. Looking at £400 helmets and good quality jacket and trousers.
So, in browsing sites like Sports Bike Shop i found back protectors. Never really been something I considered before.
What appeal are the vest style ones that also have chest protection.
Like this https://www.sportsbikeshop.co.uk/motorcycle_parts/...
Are these totally over kill for me? I'm going to be riding as a hobby on sunny days with mates, and the occasional B road fair weather commute... I won't be tracking or anything.
Basically, is this too much for my needs? Are they for track day nutters, or is it the safer the better on the roads nowadays?
When I rode last time I did it on a shoestring.. £1k bike, second hand lid from a mate, £30 jacket from eBay etc
Now I'm older and wiser, I'm a bit more aware of my mortality. I also have a decent chunk of money to throw at it this time. I now have a wife and kids so feel it's responsible, if for no other reason than the wife's peace of mind that I do the best I can to ensure I'm as safe as I can be.
So now I'm looking at kit. I had already decided on quality kit. Looking at £400 helmets and good quality jacket and trousers.
So, in browsing sites like Sports Bike Shop i found back protectors. Never really been something I considered before.
What appeal are the vest style ones that also have chest protection.
Like this https://www.sportsbikeshop.co.uk/motorcycle_parts/...
Are these totally over kill for me? I'm going to be riding as a hobby on sunny days with mates, and the occasional B road fair weather commute... I won't be tracking or anything.
Basically, is this too much for my needs? Are they for track day nutters, or is it the safer the better on the roads nowadays?
If you are painfully aware of your mortality, then don't buy another bike; no matter what kit you wear, the potential for death or at least life changing injury is significantly higher than driving a car.
If, however, you have a grip on yourself and are willing to accept a bit of risk for your leisure pursuits, then buying the best kit you can afford makes a lot of sense.
Back protectors won't help much if you're run over by a cement lorry, but might make a difference sliding down the road and into a kerb.
You might also consider extra training to reduce the chances of an accident in the first place...
If, however, you have a grip on yourself and are willing to accept a bit of risk for your leisure pursuits, then buying the best kit you can afford makes a lot of sense.
Back protectors won't help much if you're run over by a cement lorry, but might make a difference sliding down the road and into a kerb.
You might also consider extra training to reduce the chances of an accident in the first place...
Don't come off and you can go out in your birthday suit if you like.
And you are the one that has by far the greatest influence on whether you do come off or not.
As you're starting out (and it rains a lot here) get yourself a two piece textile kit and a separate lightweight back protector. You can decide what you feel comfortable wearing at any time. Jeans are fine if you feel like it.
And you are the one that has by far the greatest influence on whether you do come off or not.
As you're starting out (and it rains a lot here) get yourself a two piece textile kit and a separate lightweight back protector. You can decide what you feel comfortable wearing at any time. Jeans are fine if you feel like it.
All depends I think on your riding style. If you aren't interested in pushing it at all, won't be filtering through traffic etc, then probably save your money and just invest in a decent jacket, trousers, gloves and boots.
Agree with earlier comments thou, get some training. That'll do more for your safety than anything else because ultimately you can do more as a rider to protect yourself than any piece of kit or gadget.
Agree with earlier comments thou, get some training. That'll do more for your safety than anything else because ultimately you can do more as a rider to protect yourself than any piece of kit or gadget.
If money is no problem, I'd buy the absolute best airbag leathers or textiles you can afford. They're not cheap, but you can put a price on safety.
I've always had £400 helmet, £200 gloves, £350 boots, £100 back protector and £800 leathers. I'm looking to buy a set of airbag leathers for next year at 2.5K
Personally, I fall off a lot as I'm racing round a track and pushing the limits, so I want the best stuff I can afford. I couldn't give a s
t if I turned up to a bike meet on a weekend and people thought I was all the gear and no idea. Buy the absolute best you can afford.
I've always had £400 helmet, £200 gloves, £350 boots, £100 back protector and £800 leathers. I'm looking to buy a set of airbag leathers for next year at 2.5K
Personally, I fall off a lot as I'm racing round a track and pushing the limits, so I want the best stuff I can afford. I couldn't give a s
t if I turned up to a bike meet on a weekend and people thought I was all the gear and no idea. Buy the absolute best you can afford. Thanks for the replies. Totally accept some training will help.. that's on the cards, I used to be TraffPol so have a few mates who run the BikeSafe scheme down this way, so will definitely be doing at bit of that.
And as for realising my mortality.. it's not a case of being s
t scared, I'm just more aware than I used to be. Back in the day it was head down arse up triple figures without a care in the world. That's not going to be my thing now, hence why I'm going for a naked bike to enjoy the B road twisties.
I think my thoughts are summed up above... if for whatever reason, my fault or not, I find myself sliding along the tarmac, I think I'd rather have as much protection as I can.
And as for realising my mortality.. it's not a case of being s
t scared, I'm just more aware than I used to be. Back in the day it was head down arse up triple figures without a care in the world. That's not going to be my thing now, hence why I'm going for a naked bike to enjoy the B road twisties. I think my thoughts are summed up above... if for whatever reason, my fault or not, I find myself sliding along the tarmac, I think I'd rather have as much protection as I can.
A point not raised which affected me, is income protection insurance. My last accident (not caused by me) caused me to be off work, then off overtime/shifts, which affected my income severely. Good kit may stop road rash, but if you break your leg or arm in the fall, and you're off for weeks/months, depending on your work and how generous a sickness package you get, income protection may be something to look at if you're worried about accidents occuring.
KingNothing said:
A point not raised which affected me, is income protection insurance. My last accident (not caused by me) caused me to be off work, then off overtime/shifts, which affected my income severely. Good kit may stop road rash, but if you break your leg or arm in the fall, and you're off for weeks/months, depending on your work and how generous a sickness package you get, income protection may be something to look at if you're worried about accidents occuring.
Yes this, definitely worth the £30/month it costs, and you don't need a £400 helmet, more importantly you need one that fits.If you're looking at safety equipment then the best thing you can do is stop asking unknown people on the internet and look at the CE approval system. Then buy kit that has the highest CE approval rating you can afford.
Make sure any clothing you buy is fully CE approved. Lot's of clothing is NOT CE approved but simply contains CE approved armour.
Any decent CE approved clothing will contain its own armour (also CE approved) thus extra back protection won't be required.
If you're happy to spend lots of money then get some made to measure CE level 3 kit like BKS leathers.
Make sure any clothing you buy is fully CE approved. Lot's of clothing is NOT CE approved but simply contains CE approved armour.
Any decent CE approved clothing will contain its own armour (also CE approved) thus extra back protection won't be required.
If you're happy to spend lots of money then get some made to measure CE level 3 kit like BKS leathers.
All weighing up the risks.
I wear full leathers and boots for going on long and/Or spirited rides as the risk is higher. But I have been out in just a jacket and normal jeans and trainers for short runs.
The minimum I'll wear is a good helmet, jacket and gloves. That minimises a lot of the injury for lots of different accident scenario. You can't protect yourself against every accident, you just have to find a level you are comfortable with.
Agree with further training 100%. Avoiding an accident is the easiest way not to get injured!
I wear full leathers and boots for going on long and/Or spirited rides as the risk is higher. But I have been out in just a jacket and normal jeans and trainers for short runs.
The minimum I'll wear is a good helmet, jacket and gloves. That minimises a lot of the injury for lots of different accident scenario. You can't protect yourself against every accident, you just have to find a level you are comfortable with.
Agree with further training 100%. Avoiding an accident is the easiest way not to get injured!

If you delve into the KSI stats chest injuries are one of the most common causes of death in moto accidents so I bought myself a forcefield flite vest as it's level 2 front and back. It might look a bit bulky at first but it is very comfortable and I wear it every day on my commute (above 30c I'll think about it but usually it stays on). I wore it on track yesterday and it didn't interfere even when really getting into the bends. I'd love the Dainese airbag jacket but sadly out of reach. I'm sure eventually these things will be standard for riders. Who wouldn't want to have more of a chance of surviving a spill? Obviously you can't deal with every scenario but for me it's just part of the gear drill and takes literally 5 seconds to put on before I put my jacket on.
mckeann said:
If money is no problem, I'd buy the absolute best airbag leathers or textiles you can afford. They're not cheap, but you can put a price on safety.
I've always had £400 helmet, £200 gloves, £350 boots, £100 back protector and £800 leathers. I'm looking to buy a set of airbag leathers for next year at 2.5K
I'd second the airbag system, although as stated the key is to not crash, fall off or be knocked off, no gear is ever as good as staying on. I've always had £400 helmet, £200 gloves, £350 boots, £100 back protector and £800 leathers. I'm looking to buy a set of airbag leathers for next year at 2.5K
There's also another factor - bikes get you out into the open air and if that's the main thing you want to achieve you may want to try a convertible car before you take the bike route - if nothing else but to discount it. Lots of nice Jags, BMWs etc around at keen prices and you could take the family too.
Another route to safety is to avoid speed and other vehicles and get a lightweight scrambler for off roading. Gives you an excuse to buy a van too and go on trips to interesting places. You can still damage yourself but you're unlikely to be crushed under a lorry tyre at 100psi riding around a dirt road. The downside is that better dirt roads are on the continent but Wales is pretty good for it.
Have a look at my "ouch" thread on here... I got some nasty gravel rash due to wearing normal jeans. They have made my recovery slightly longer, due to the pain from the gravel rash.
That said, "proper" trousers wouldn't have saved me from my broken femur, pelvis or wrist. The decent gear I was wearing helped mitigate/reduce the other injury risk. I'd have Ben much worse off without decent jacket, gloves and boots.
Having been through it once, and got away with it lots of times (t shirt, jeans, helmet) I think my riding will be more defensive and I'll be "all the gear, all the time". Decent jeans and jackets can be had that you can happily wear down the pub.
That said, "proper" trousers wouldn't have saved me from my broken femur, pelvis or wrist. The decent gear I was wearing helped mitigate/reduce the other injury risk. I'd have Ben much worse off without decent jacket, gloves and boots.
Having been through it once, and got away with it lots of times (t shirt, jeans, helmet) I think my riding will be more defensive and I'll be "all the gear, all the time". Decent jeans and jackets can be had that you can happily wear down the pub.
Helmet I would always buy new, but textiles, leathers, back protectors can all be found for a fraction of the new price on Gumtree or EBay.
I've just picked up mint Dainese two piece leathers locally off gumtree for £100, the trousers were too big so I've sold them on for £65, so I've ended up with an unmarked perfect Dainese jacket for £35.
I've just picked up mint Dainese two piece leathers locally off gumtree for £100, the trousers were too big so I've sold them on for £65, so I've ended up with an unmarked perfect Dainese jacket for £35.
+1 for wearing the best you can afford: back protector and airbag included.
BikeSafe, IAM, RoSPA or better still Rapid Training are good. However, if you're ex-TrafPol, then I'd either go out with any mates who are Class 1 riders or Rapid.
sergi1987 said:
Agree with earlier comments thou, get some training. That'll do more for your safety than anything else because ultimately you can do more as a rider to protect yourself than any piece of kit or gadget.
Rubin215 said:
You might also consider extra training to reduce the chances of an accident in the first place...
papa3 said:
do some refresher training and a bike safe course.
If you're ex-TrafPol, then your roadcraft must be good.BikeSafe, IAM, RoSPA or better still Rapid Training are good. However, if you're ex-TrafPol, then I'd either go out with any mates who are Class 1 riders or Rapid.
Edited by SVS on Sunday 6th August 21:28
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



