Never mind the horsepower, feel the torque
Never mind the horsepower, feel the torque
Author
Discussion

tvrolet

Original Poster:

4,771 posts

313 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Had the bike on a dyno yesterday - 115ft/lb at the rear wheel. OK, actually 114.58, but 115 is the nearest whole number.

So that's shout ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN FOOT POUNDS OF TORQUE AT THE REAR WHEEL smile

...and 90 horsepower.

But hey my Z900 was the fastest thing pennies could buy in 1976 and felt a mighty powerful beast, and it was only rated at 82hp, so 90hp will do me...until someone comes out with more go-faster goodies for the bike. But for the time being, no rice pudding has a skin that is safe.

...and in truth I just needed something to post with a picture as all my PhotoBucket stuff has gone awol [bast@rds] and I've switched to Flickr...which in terms of the upload/hosting experience is loads better. Remains to be seen if I can link to photos and other folks can see them though - but here goes:

vvvvv



^^^^^

Can you see what it is yet?

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Is it a Diesel looking at the revs? biggrin

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
No replacement for displacement...

Higgs boson

1,105 posts

184 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
'never forget my first spin on a Z900.
I was riding 37 brake of 400-4, and a friend had bought the Kwak. Mind blown! biggrin

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Its a big Indian ? smile

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
bogie said:
Its a big Indian ? smile

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
Had the bike on a dyno yesterday - 115ft/lb at the rear wheel. OK, actually 114.58, but 115 is the nearest whole number.

So that's shout ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN FOOT POUNDS OF TORQUE AT THE REAR WHEEL smile
At the rear wheel or at the flywheel? If you want more torque at the rear wheel just drop down a gear or tow...

tvrolet

Original Poster:

4,771 posts

313 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
tvrolet said:
Had the bike on a dyno yesterday - 115ft/lb at the rear wheel. OK, actually 114.58, but 115 is the nearest whole number.

So that's shout ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN FOOT POUNDS OF TORQUE AT THE REAR WHEEL smile
At the rear wheel or at the flywheel? If you want more torque at the rear wheel just drop down a gear or tow...
or tow? Yup, I probably could tow a small caravan.

Anyway - I believe like most [all?] dynos what the roller(s) actually measured is power. From measured power on the roller and measured engine rpm the dyno calculates torque...'cause as you know twice the horsepower at the same revs means twice the torque, but the same horsepower at half the revs also means the same twice the torque. So it doesn't have to be concerned with knowing the actual gear ratios - it just needs the crank speed and power.

But the point is unlike a crank dyno (and more importantly, manufacturers figures) the measurement is made after transmission losses so the torque is stated at a lower figure than you'd actually get at the crank. So not as good as the manufacturer might advertise (with my setup Indian would suggest 130+ ft/lb) but real world, and of course comparable from bike-to-bike with others that have also been dyno'd.

I've had the Tuscan dyno'd [for sale - read the classified - 500hp and 525 ft/lb] and they can try to compensate for transmission losses by doing a run where the clutch is disengaged at speed and the dyno then tries to measure transmission losses by how the now-free-spinning transmission slows down. But I don't believe they do that on bikes - so power/torque figures are after transmission losses, so maybe 10-15% lower than what you could actually measure at the crank...which is nice.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
or tow? Yup, I probably could tow a small caravan.

Anyway - I believe like most [all?] dynos what the roller(s) actually measured is power. From measured power on the roller and measured engine rpm the dyno calculates torque...'cause as you know twice the horsepower at the same revs means twice the torque, but the same horsepower at half the revs also means the same twice the torque. So it doesn't have to be concerned with knowing the actual gear ratios - it just needs the crank speed and power.

But the point is unlike a crank dyno (and more importantly, manufacturers figures) the measurement is made after transmission losses so the torque is stated at a lower figure than you'd actually get at the crank. So not as good as the manufacturer might advertise (with my setup Indian would suggest 130+ ft/lb) but real world, and of course comparable from bike-to-bike with others that have also been dyno'd.

I've had the Tuscan dyno'd [for sale - read the classified - 500hp and 525 ft/lb] and they can try to compensate for transmission losses by doing a run where the clutch is disengaged at speed and the dyno then tries to measure transmission losses by how the now-free-spinning transmission slows down. But I don't believe they do that on bikes - so power/torque figures are after transmission losses, so maybe 10-15% lower than what you could actually measure at the crank...which is nice.
That was my point really, the chart actually shows engine torque, minus any transmission losses. Directly quoting rear wheel torque would be pointless because it would depend entirely on the gear used e.g. if you measured in in first gear you could have V8-like torque numbers.

Out of interest how much heavier is this bike than your Z900, which was quite a lump itself?

tvrolet

Original Poster:

4,771 posts

313 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
That was my point really, the chart actually shows engine torque, minus any transmission losses. Directly quoting rear wheel torque would be pointless because it would depend entirely on the gear used e.g. if you measured in in first gear you could have V8-like torque numbers.

Out of interest how much heavier is this bike than your Z900, which was quite a lump itself?
We don't want any of this steenkin' power-to-weight talk in here...

But some googling suggests the Z900 was 248Kg wet, and I think the Indian is claimed as 378Kg eek I'm guessing the Indian carries more fuel and oil than the Kawasaki in terms of wet weight....but weight-wise like a Z900 with a fat passenger and luggage. On the Indian I wouldn't really notice a fat passenger or luggage. And remember the Indian is being weighed with bags/panniers, screen, crash bars etc. And of course it's an 1800 - more capacity in 1 cylinder than the Z900 had in all 4.

But the Z900 was the top-dog sports bike (yea, sports bike with high-wide bars) of its day and not a heavyweight tourer. More googlng suggests a Kawasaki 1400GTR is 304Kg and a K1600 is 348Kg. So while I'd love another Z900 for old times sake, I've put more miles on and gone further on the Indian than any other bike I've had year-on-year.

Anyway, big heavy bikes are where it's at - if I wanted light I'd buy a Motobecane smile

Birky_41

4,667 posts

215 months

Friday 11th August 2017
quotequote all
catso said:
bogie said:
Its a big Indian ? smile
Ffs laughlaughlaugh

Mad Jock

1,272 posts

293 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
Anyway - I believe like most [all?] dynos what the roller(s) actually measured is power. From measured power on the roller and measured engine rpm the dyno calculates torque...'cause as you know twice the horsepower at the same revs means twice the torque, but the same horsepower at half the revs also means the same twice the torque. So it doesn't have to be concerned with knowing the actual gear ratios - it just needs the crank speed and power.
Actually, it's the other way round. A dynamometer measures torque, and the power is calculated. teacher

buzzer

3,621 posts

271 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
I always thought the Laverda Jota was the fastest bike in 1976?

tezzer

984 posts

217 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
buzzer said:
I always thought the Laverda Jota was the fastest bike in 1976?
138.89mph according to Bike magazine's figures..........not seen that table for years, but that figure etched on my brain, for eternity.

tvrolet

Original Poster:

4,771 posts

313 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
Mad Jock said:
tvrolet said:
Anyway - I believe like most [all?] dynos what the roller(s) actually measured is power. From measured power on the roller and measured engine rpm the dyno calculates torque...'cause as you know twice the horsepower at the same revs means twice the torque, but the same horsepower at half the revs also means the same twice the torque. So it doesn't have to be concerned with knowing the actual gear ratios - it just needs the crank speed and power.
Actually, it's the other way round. A dynamometer measures torque, and the power is calculated. teacher
Not sure if you're just being pedantic on this...

Yes, I agree there is no metering device or similar that measures simply 'power'. But the measure of torque alone has no value unless the speed/rpm is known - 100ft/lb with the roller doing 10rpm is very different from 100ft/lb with the roller doing 1000rpm. So in addition to torque is must measure rpm of the roller. So it measures torque and rpm....which is the definition of rotational power. Now depending on the units being used you may divide (or multiply) by a constant - divide by 9.55 from nm to Kw, or 5252 from ft/lb to hp. Presumably though since this is part of the larger calculation in the dyno to resolve crank power/torque it doesn't actually need to calculate an independent value of power at the roller - but it is measuring torque and rpm...which in my book is power. [cock waving]It's been nearly 40 years since I did Mechanical Engineering at Uni (and got a degree in it), but some things did sink in[/cock waving].

This would be like coming up with a speedometer based on a GPS measure of distance and a timer, so it can calculate and show mph. This would be a speedometer, and it would be disingenuous to say it just measures distance (which it would do) as opposed to accepting it 'measured' speed.


tvrolet

Original Poster:

4,771 posts

313 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
tezzer said:
buzzer said:
I always thought the Laverda Jota was the fastest bike in 1976?
138.89mph according to Bike magazine's figures..........not seen that table for years, but that figure etched on my brain, for eternity.
Probably for 'full year' 1976, but at the time I bought the Z900 (which Bike tested at 132...I've still got the issue somewhere in the attic) the Jota either hadn't been launched, or it certainly wasn't generally available/known. When I rode the 900 out the showroom no-one had heard of a Jota, so for me at least the Z900 was the fastest thing my pennies (loan actually) could buy. I even recall it was in the Guinness Book of Records (Kawasaki, not the Jota) as the fastest bike, but again it measures a snapshot in time and not the whole year.

I do actually remember the Jota being released - or at least being picked up by the bike comics - and that was after I had the Z900. It was allegedly faster, but being 1 cylinder and 2 silencers down I was more than happy on the Z900. There was actually an Italian test-ride day I went to - must have been in 1977 I guess - where I did ride a Jota and a Demo 900SS back to back...and hated them both. I'd just hopped off a smooth, refined (for its day) and 'light to ride' Kawasaki and these things felt like tractors. Move forward 40-odd years and I now appreciate character, handling finesse and the whole visceral experience thing, but then I was just left unimpressed. What I'd give to have that silver with blue stripes desmo SS in the garage now! Even quite fancy a Jota now too, but as a yoof I was a Kawasaki guy through and through - still got an '84 GPz1100.

Mad Jock

1,272 posts

293 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
Mad Jock said:
tvrolet said:
Anyway - I believe like most [all?] dynos what the roller(s) actually measured is power. From measured power on the roller and measured engine rpm the dyno calculates torque...'cause as you know twice the horsepower at the same revs means twice the torque, but the same horsepower at half the revs also means the same twice the torque. So it doesn't have to be concerned with knowing the actual gear ratios - it just needs the crank speed and power.
Actually, it's the other way round. A dynamometer measures torque, and the power is calculated. teacher
Not sure if you're just being pedantic on this...

Yes, I agree there is no metering device or similar that measures simply 'power'. But the measure of torque alone has no value unless the speed/rpm is known - 100ft/lb with the roller doing 10rpm is very different from 100ft/lb with the roller doing 1000rpm. So in addition to torque is must measure rpm of the roller. So it measures torque and rpm....which is the definition of rotational power. Now depending on the units being used you may divide (or multiply) by a constant - divide by 9.55 from nm to Kw, or 5252 from ft/lb to hp. Presumably though since this is part of the larger calculation in the dyno to resolve crank power/torque it doesn't actually need to calculate an independent value of power at the roller - but it is measuring torque and rpm...which in my book is power. [cock waving]It's been nearly 40 years since I did Mechanical Engineering at Uni (and got a degree in it), but some things did sink in[/cock waving].

This would be like coming up with a speedometer based on a GPS measure of distance and a timer, so it can calculate and show mph. This would be a speedometer, and it would be disingenuous to say it just measures distance (which it would do) as opposed to accepting it 'measured' speed.
No, I wasn't trying to be pedantic, merely brief!

I also have a degree from 40 years ago, in Automotive Engineering and Car Design, but I didn't want to wave my willy. smile

Mad Jock

1,272 posts

293 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
Mr2Mike said:
That was my point really, the chart actually shows engine torque, minus any transmission losses. Directly quoting rear wheel torque would be pointless because it would depend entirely on the gear used e.g. if you measured in in first gear you could have V8-like torque numbers.

Out of interest how much heavier is this bike than your Z900, which was quite a lump itself?
We don't want any of this steenkin' power-to-weight talk in here...

But some googling suggests the Z900 was 248Kg wet, and I think the Indian is claimed as 378Kg eek I'm guessing the Indian carries more fuel and oil than the Kawasaki in terms of wet weight....but weight-wise like a Z900 with a fat passenger and luggage. On the Indian I wouldn't really notice a fat passenger or luggage. And remember the Indian is being weighed with bags/panniers, screen, crash bars etc. And of course it's an 1800 - more capacity in 1 cylinder than the Z900 had in all 4.

But the Z900 was the top-dog sports bike (yea, sports bike with high-wide bars) of its day and not a heavyweight tourer. More googlng suggests a Kawasaki 1400GTR is 304Kg and a K1600 is 348Kg. So while I'd love another Z900 for old times sake, I've put more miles on and gone further on the Indian than any other bike I've had year-on-year.

Anyway, big heavy bikes are where it's at - if I wanted light I'd buy a Motobecane smile
OK, I'll wave my willy for this one - I bought a new Laverda Jota 120 in 1982 , which was the dogs bks for about 5 minutes (OK, 2 years) until Kawasaki spoiled everything with the GPZ 900. Not every Jota fan's favourite, but it was way smoother than the180 degree crank version. It was also as rare as hen's teeth - I had the only one in Scotland at the time.

RemaL

25,103 posts

265 months

Saturday 12th August 2017
quotequote all
HAHA what about big torque and lots of HP?

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Sunday 13th August 2017
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
We don't want any of this steenkin' power-to-weight talk in here...

But some googling suggests the Z900 was 248Kg wet, and I think the Indian is claimed as 378Kg eek
Clucking bell. Don't drop it biggrin