New bike thoughts please
New bike thoughts please
Author
Discussion

SpydieNut

Original Poster:

5,959 posts

254 months

Sunday 20th August 2017
quotequote all
Having ridden sports bikes for the last 20+ years I'm now looking for a change. The plan is to sell my current bike (RSV Mille) and buy a tourer or sports/tourer, or something like that.

In order of importance the requirements are;

Comfortable position and riding (especially for the pillion) for long distances
Reliability
Able to carry luggage (and to take them off if not needed)
Something with a bit of 'character'.

I'd like it also to be capable of being enjoyed on a spirited ride if I'm on my own and want to take it along some winding roads. I'm not talking knee down, but some fun in the corners is nice.

Budget - say up to £10k.

I was looking at a BMW 1200GS, but also thinking about things like the BMW 1000R, the Aprilia Tuono, KTM 990, Ducati Multistrada.

Now I've not ridden any of these, but before I go out looking to test ride some, I'd like to hear some views and suggestions.

Many thanks thumbup

Birky_41

4,667 posts

215 months

Sunday 20th August 2017
quotequote all
Multistrada is a very capable bike with character. Great range, fast, handle well and enough sockets and plugs to keep any gadget geek happy

I'm not sure on a Tuono unless you went RR with the more pillion friendly rear seat. Even still not sure it ticks all the boxes for what you want

Can't comment on the rest

Andybow

1,177 posts

149 months

Sunday 20th August 2017
quotequote all
SpydieNut said:
Having ridden sports bikes for the last 20+ years I'm now looking for a change. The plan is to sell my current bike (RSV Mille) and buy a tourer or sports/tourer, or something like that.

In order of importance the requirements are;

Comfortable position and riding (especially for the pillion) for long distances
Reliability
Able to carry luggage (and to take them off if not needed)
Something with a bit of 'character'.

I'd like it also to be capable of being enjoyed on a spirited ride if I'm on my own and want to take it along some winding roads. I'm not talking knee down, but some fun in the corners is nice.

Budget - say up to £10k.

I was looking at a BMW 1200GS, but also thinking about things like the BMW 1000R, the Aprilia Tuono, KTM 990, Ducati Multistrada.

Now I've not ridden any of these, but before I go out looking to test ride some, I'd like to hear some views and suggestions.

Many thanks thumbup
Gs, fantastic do everything bike, v comfy, fast enough, handles beautifully
S1000r, great but you'll ride like a 🔔 as it's really v similar to a sports bike with more comfort, wouldn't be brilliant for pillions touring, similar for tuono, Multi is great to ride, real wolf in sheeps clothing, I had a nightmare with mine, was always in the dealers being fixed, I know loads of people have never had a problem!, My brother has a smt 990 and it's brilliant, No problem keeping with us on a mt10 and a s1000r on this years tour!, comfy, quick good for pillions, best price at of all above as it's been out a while!
Also try triumph tiger 1050 sport from 2016, I thought it was brilliant on a test
I personally wouldn't go for multi out of warranty but that's me!, also have a look at tracer as that may be a great buy new!

spareparts

6,796 posts

258 months

Sunday 20th August 2017
quotequote all
SpydieNut said:
Having ridden sports bikes for the last 20+ years I'm now looking for a change. The plan is to sell my current bike (RSV Mille) and buy a tourer or sports/tourer, or something like that.

In order of importance the requirements are;

Comfortable position and riding (especially for the pillion) for long distances
Reliability
Able to carry luggage (and to take them off if not needed)
Something with a bit of 'character'.

I'd like it also to be capable of being enjoyed on a spirited ride if I'm on my own and want to take it along some winding roads. I'm not talking knee down, but some fun in the corners is nice.

Budget - say up to £10k.

I was looking at a BMW 1200GS, but also thinking about things like the BMW 1000R, the Aprilia Tuono, KTM 990, Ducati Multistrada.

Now I've not ridden any of these, but before I go out looking to test ride some, I'd like to hear some views and suggestions.

Many thanks thumbup
The GS LC is the best out of those you've listed, given the priorities you've stated. By far. They are the same reasons buyers have made it the best selling bike in Europe.

Rick_James

10 posts

112 months

Sunday 20th August 2017
quotequote all
My dad just picked up a KTM 1190 adventure that's nice to ride, with removable boxes for storage.

SpydieNut

Original Poster:

5,959 posts

254 months

Monday 21st August 2017
quotequote all
Thanks guys thumbup

I was leaning heavily towards the GS myself, but wanted to make sure I wasn't overlooking anything (obvious or otherwise smile ). I love the look of it and and know it'll tackle whatever we may come across - road, gravel, off-road (if needed) and it's a comfortable, reliable machine. I also apparently handles very well, so I can have a bit of fun on it on my own if needed. The addition of panniers and a top box means it'll also hold enough for trips for two cool

It will have to live outdoors, but I'll be liberal with my ACF-50 and take good care of her.

No snap decisions though - we'll go test a few, as I do like the look of the KTM 1190 and the Multistrada (although I had a monster S4R in the past and wasn't overly enamoured with build quality and reliability)

Ceeejay

505 posts

182 months

Monday 21st August 2017
quotequote all
I'm currently riding a GS... And as much I love it.. Its not doing it for me on the fun side.. So I took out its young sibling for a demo at the weekend.. The S1000XR.

Comfort wise, a combination of a slightly lower seat, and pegs further back, folds your legs up a little more, but not so as to cause discomfort, just a bit different the first time you set of. The screen isn't great coming from a GSA.. but its not horrendous. Controls are identical to the GS, displays slightly different, losing the analogue speedo, leaving just rpm on a needle. Otherwise the same tech, heated grips, riding modes, selectable preload, cruise control, wheel for satnav. So a slight downer on comfort.

Performance... Well I was expecting great things, with a detuned RR engine, and wasn't disappointed. Quickshifter very smooth, cable operated clutch, not so great. Standard exhaust gives plenty of playful noises when using the quickshifter, the overrun on down changes being addictive. The power and torque were just awesome... its a different world to the GS. Suspension in road mode ok... Again I have to compare to the GS which is a bit more compliant on bumpy bits. Didn't get to rag it much in dynamic mode much, but no issues to report. Experienced slight vibes from the bars at around 70 in tope gear, but nothing unpleasant, just noticeable. May be different on a long day out.

Overall assessment.. Its a drop slightly in comfort but made up for 3 times over in performance. I'm currently trying to negotiate a trade in !! I'll always have a soft spot for the boxer engines, but I have been seduced by the litre inline4.

308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Monday 21st August 2017
quotequote all
Ceeejay said:
I'm currently riding a GS... And as much I love it.. Its not doing it for me on the fun side.. So I took out its young sibling for a demo at the weekend.. The S1000XR.

Comfort wise, a combination of a slightly lower seat, and pegs further back, folds your legs up a little more, but not so as to cause discomfort, just a bit different the first time you set of. The screen isn't great coming from a GSA.. but its not horrendous. Controls are identical to the GS, displays slightly different, losing the analogue speedo, leaving just rpm on a needle. Otherwise the same tech, heated grips, riding modes, selectable preload, cruise control, wheel for satnav. So a slight downer on comfort.

Performance... Well I was expecting great things, with a detuned RR engine, and wasn't disappointed. Quickshifter very smooth, cable operated clutch, not so great. Standard exhaust gives plenty of playful noises when using the quickshifter, the overrun on down changes being addictive. The power and torque were just awesome... its a different world to the GS. Suspension in road mode ok... Again I have to compare to the GS which is a bit more compliant on bumpy bits. Didn't get to rag it much in dynamic mode much, but no issues to report. Experienced slight vibes from the bars at around 70 in tope gear, but nothing unpleasant, just noticeable. May be different on a long day out.

Overall assessment.. Its a drop slightly in comfort but made up for 3 times over in performance. I'm currently trying to negotiate a trade in !! I'll always have a soft spot for the boxer engines, but I have been seduced by the litre inline4.
The XR probably had more character mainly via loads more hp. But the GS has more torque and is almost definitely more comfortable for the pillion, plus has more luggage capacity and *some* extra capability (I'd only ever have the GSA, personally). Were I looking again, I'd have a much closer look at the Multistrada than I did when buying the XR. Be warned, the XR will make you ride like a tt. biggrin

Bailey93

524 posts

137 months

Monday 21st August 2017
quotequote all
Tracer 900 ?