Bike gearbox for an inline car engine?
Bike gearbox for an inline car engine?
Author
Discussion

roadrunner750

Original Poster:

3 posts

294 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Hi all, I'm a car guy (sorry) and wanted to know if there is a bike gearbox around from an inline engined bike with shaft drive, that could be adapted to fit an inline car engine with driveshaft to rear.
The gearbox must be dog engagement and sequential.
Thanks in advance.
RR

HustleRussell

26,708 posts

191 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
I reckon the bike engine won't like car engine torque.

T6 vanman

3,569 posts

130 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
I have no engineering knowledge of this adaption but maybe Triumph Rocket??

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Various Moto Guzzi models would fit the bill, but the durability would be a big question mark as most are only about 50bhp, with a very different torque curve to your average car motor.

moto_traxport

4,265 posts

252 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Inline in what manner? I would have thought orientation might be more important - I am just guessing though.

T6 vanman said:
I have no engineering knowledge of this adaption but maybe Triumph Rocket??
This is a good idea as it would cope with the torque but it's a inline longlitudinal motor (I've turned spell check off my phone, this is a rare occurence when I need it!). If you want a transverse inline application you could try a Yamaha FJR1300 or a Yamaha V Max 1200 (although this is a transverse V4 - does this really matter to the gearbox when used separately?).

Spill the beans a bit more. A mate of mine does loads of dyno work and a good third of his work is bike engined cars and cars with bike throttle bodies so he sees lots of weird applications / race cars / grass track cars / hillclimb stuff / trikes etc. I could ask him and see which laugh I get.

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
I think you may struggle. On any transverse bike engine, and that includes typical v-twins the drive to the shaft to the gearbox is a bevel drive after the box itself so use if the input is on the same axis as the output. Of course in line motors like BMW boxers, current rocket 3, Moto Guzzi don't need the bevel device, but for about the last 50 years oeerty much everyone Bar Harley has switched to unit construction so there isn't a separate gearbox case - it's all in the same crankcase as the motor itself, and typcailly shares the same oil so there just isn't a separate gearbox there. No doubt you could cut the gearbox part of the casings out and weld/adapt something but lots of work. I can't see that being particularly viable, and that's before we start talking about clutches and connecting it all up.

So as above about the only manufacturer I can think of that still uses a physically separate box is Harley and then only on the big v twins not sportsters. Now lots of folks build bikes and trikes of all sorts using Harley or Harley clone motors such as Revtech and S&S and find out what they're using. Probably limited in torque though, but you could mount it at 90 degrees so on line with the motor and drive shaft. But some of the boxes will have concentric input and output shafts i.e.the output shaft sleeves the input shaft and both come out the same side. But still challenges of connecting it up a these boxes will expect input and output by belt it chain.

In summary if you want a mammoth and complex engineering challenge then go for it. If you want something that's relatively easy to fit then forget it. Buy a ford rocket box or whatever and buy a set of sequential internals.

roadrunner750

Original Poster:

3 posts

294 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies guys. Sorry, didn't make myself quite clear enough.
When I said 'inline', I actually meant longitudinal engine.
The car in question is very light, 450kg with the driver.
The engine only produces about 100bhp and 100 torques.
So can a bike gearbox cope with that?
Thanks again. RR.

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Yea I got all that and a bike box will cope with that torque/power, but just about everything in the last 50! years except Harleys has the gearbox in a single unit with the engine. Unless you have a hacksaw you ain't going to separate them. It's nothing like a car setup with a box bolted to the engine with a clutch in-line in between. Next time you pass a bike in a parking lot have a look. With VERY few exceptions the crankshaft, oil pump, clutch (typically wet, apart from Ducatis and the like), gearbox and shift linkages are all inside a single set of crankcases (all in 'the block' in car terms). There is no separate gearbox unit in anything remotely modern....although happy to be corrected. As above google the boxes folks use with Revtech and S&S motors are these are about the only pre-unit boxes still fitted new.

Globs

13,847 posts

262 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
roadrunner750 said:
Thanks for the replies guys. Sorry, didn't make myself quite clear enough.
When I said 'inline', I actually meant longitudinal engine.
The car in question is very light, 450kg with the driver.
The engine only produces about 100bhp and 100 torques.
So can a bike gearbox cope with that?
Thanks again. RR.
The last of the big aircooled BMW 1100GS and 1200GS has a dry clutch, and may therefore be suitable.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 4th September 2017
quotequote all
Globs said:
The last of the big aircooled BMW 1100GS and 1200GS has a dry clutch, and may therefore be suitable.
Probably the closest thing the OP is going to find to his requirements. One thing to be aware of is that unlike a RWD car gearbox, the output shaft is offset to one side which might pose a problem if he wants to mount it within a transmission tunnel.

Steve Bass

10,756 posts

264 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
In short, the answer is no.

Why?

2 Fold.

As said earlier, 99.9% of bike gearboxes are part of the overall engine casing and cannot be separated. Neither can you input the drive from a conventional car clutch bell housing.
Also, the reciprocal weight of a typical car crank, pistons & rods, flywheel and clutch is far higher than a bike gearbox can take. The car uses it to smooth out the power and delivery and retain momentum in the engine when off the gas or coasting. Bike gearboxes have far less inertial mass to manage and as such are far smaller in comparison.
Perhaps a US spec HD/ Chopper sytye separate box is a remote possibility but as for dog engagement, very unlikely.
Best option for a car that you describe is to fit the entire engine & gearbox from a bike such as a Hyabusa or ZZR1400/Blackbird.
All your wishes and better power to weight.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
OP as others have said bike gearboxes are in the engine itself - think original mini. Again I'd suggest you'd be better off with a large CC bike engine/box and junk your engine wink Hayabusa 1300cc approx should do it, if thats not enough slam on a turbo, kits available.

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
Bike engine cars where the motor is 'non-unit' construction use car gearboxes - think of the new Morgan and people fitting BMW flat twin motors to 2CVs, they use Mazda & Citroen gearboxes accordingly.

Like someone said above, once power is transmitted top the gearbox, the output is seriously offset to clear the back wheel, even more so now with bikes having wider back wheels..

That's not to say someone could figure a clutch & drive to a Harley type gearbox mounted sideways with a UJ type output from the sprocket carrier - but the again the bigger Harleys have the gearbox input & output on the same side (unless you go aftermarket - Baker Right Hand Side?).

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
graham22 said:
Bike engine cars where the motor is 'non-unit' construction use car gearboxes - think of the new Morgan and people fitting BMW flat twin motors to 2CVs, they use Mazda & Citroen gearboxes accordingly.
Not all, e.g. the Triking uses a Moto Guzzi engine and gearbox.

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
graham22 said:
Bike engine cars where the motor is 'non-unit' construction use car gearboxes - think of the new Morgan and people fitting BMW flat twin motors to 2CVs, they use Mazda & Citroen gearboxes accordingly.
Not all, e.g. the Triking uses a Moto Guzzi engine and gearbox.
Being offset obviously helps here as they have 1 rear wheel. (mucks up my thought on the Morgan though!).

podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
Not much help im sure but on a similar theme, spotted this Dutch registered Munch Mammoth today up around Scotch corner...Not seen one in the flesh before, kinda cool in a weird looking (Bender?!) way..











Turn7

25,783 posts

252 months

Tuesday 5th September 2017
quotequote all
Not sure if Ive misunderstood, or if it would work, but a lot of HD Chops/Customs have pre unit type gearboxes - quite what the ratios etc are Ive no idea........