Which automatic chain lube system
Which automatic chain lube system
Author
Discussion

TNJ

Original Poster:

434 posts

193 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Having looked at the state of my chain after 3k miles of London commuting so far this year, I have decided I am going to get an automatic chain oiler - but which one? Bike is a Monster 821, doing 30-40 miles across London each day in all weathers.

I have been using the MuckOff dry chain lube but it just seems to result in all kinds of dirt and grime sticking to the chain, so an auto system may be better.

I have looked at Scottoilers (why so complicated for such a simple function??), Torturo (looks good but not cheap) and Loobman (cheap and similar to Torturo).

Any experience or recommendations on the above or alternatives? I should also say that I am fairly useless mechanically so just looking at the online instructions for the Scottoiler had me running for the hills!

Jazoli

9,705 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
I've only used Scottoilers and not for some time (although I am considering one for my latest bike), they are not too hard to fit, you only need to tee into a vacuum line, the rest is just fitting it in the right place and keeping it neat and tidy, once setup the chain should not need any maintenance, apart from filling the oil reservoir, you can use chainsaw oil rather than their own oil as its pretty much identical but half the price, it will also help with protecting the rear of the bike from corrosion.

I did try an early Tutoro thing which you had to switch on and off manually, it was st.

2wheelsjimmy

624 posts

128 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
My scottoiler has been fit and forget since I put it on 25,000 miles ago.

I mean, I need to remember to fill up the oil but otherwise it's worked.

Bikesalot

1,890 posts

189 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
TNJ said:
Having looked at the state of my chain after 3k miles of London commuting so far this year, I have decided I am going to get an automatic chain oiler - but which one? Bike is a Monster 821, doing 30-40 miles across London each day in all weathers.

I have been using the MuckOff dry chain lube but it just seems to result in all kinds of dirt and grime sticking to the chain, so an auto system may be better.

I have looked at Scottoilers (why so complicated for such a simple function??), Torturo (looks good but not cheap) and Loobman (cheap and similar to Torturo).

Any experience or recommendations on the above or alternatives? I should also say that I am fairly useless mechanically so just looking at the online instructions for the Scottoiler had me running for the hills!
I've got a scottoiler kicking about if you want it

kennydies

201 posts

149 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
I have the latest Tutoro on my versys and it works very well. The trick is getting it set up initally correctly then it takes car of itself...

trialsta

90 posts

220 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Another vote for Scottoiler. No they aren't cheap but mine have been fit and forget for about 30k miles over the last 4 years.

Jazoli

9,705 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Bikesalot said:
I've got a scottoiler kicking about if you want it
If he doesn't I would smile

Bikesalot

1,890 posts

189 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Jazoli said:
If he doesn't I would smile
Whoever wants it can have it.

I'll take some pictures later of what's what - half used bottle of oil too I think

TNJ

Original Poster:

434 posts

193 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies. I am going to have a look at the bike and the Scottoiler installation videos before deciding, but the consensus seems to be that Scottoiler is probably the way to go.

Bikealot - thanks for the offer of the Scottoiler - as I haven't decided yet, if Jazoli wants it, then that is no problem.

TwoStrokeNut

1,713 posts

272 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
I've had scottoilers on quite a few bikes when I was commuting. They work well and I would use one again on a commuter.

Be careful with the installation though. Make sure the unit is shielded from the sun and do check the settings when the temperature changes.

A dealer installed one on mine which was exposed to the sun. On a sunny but cold winter's day, it pissed oil all over the rear tyre. Once moved, it was fine for another 25k+ without issues.

Are there any electronic ones out there that will have a fixed dispensing rate?

HughiusMaximus

737 posts

157 months

Wednesday 6th September 2017
quotequote all
Bikesalot said:
Jazoli said:
If he doesn't I would smile
Whoever wants it can have it.

I'll take some pictures later of what's what - half used bottle of oil too I think
I love that about this site.

Well played sir.



RizzoTheRat

29,143 posts

223 months

Thursday 7th September 2017
quotequote all
I've had scott oilers for years, currently got the touring reservoir that fits behind the number plate, only need to fill it up about every 6k mile service. They also make an electric one but it's about 3 times the price. Bear in mind there are two types of oil, blue and red, which are intended for different ambient temperatures. Annoyingly the threshold temperature is somewhere around UK average temperatures though.

A mate had a loob man which looked to be a good idea, simple to fit as no need to connect to vacuum or electrics, just squeeze the bottle before setting off for a ride. But you still have to route the feed line and attach the nozzle so hooking up a scott oiler to the vacuum line isn't much more hassle.

Cbull

4,483 posts

202 months

Thursday 7th September 2017
quotequote all
I have a scottoiler on mine but disabled it. Think it's an older/cheaper version as it only does one side of the chan. I don't use it because the state of the cogs, chain and around the inner case of the front cogs was in a right state, it took allot of effort to clean it all. Not sure if the bloke who sold me the bike had used normal oil in it plus it'd been installed in view of the sun.

So overall a poor installation, possibly wrong oil, complete mess and only one side of the chain is lubed helped me decide not to use it. Saying that it would have been perfect for me in theory as I do a fare few miles.

TwoStrokeNut

1,713 posts

272 months

Thursday 7th September 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
I have a scottoiler on mine but disabled it. Think it's an older/cheaper version as it only does one side of the chan. I don't use it because the state of the cogs, chain and around the inner case of the front cogs was in a right state, it took allot of effort to clean it all. Not sure if the bloke who sold me the bike had used normal oil in it plus it'd been installed in view of the sun.

So overall a poor installation, possibly wrong oil, complete mess and only one side of the chain is lubed helped me decide not to use it. Saying that it would have been perfect for me in theory as I do a fare few miles.
It's worth persevering with as you already have it, if you have the patience. Put some of the correct oil in, set it very low and work from there.

The older type with one feed is fine. I did over 50k miles on those and they lube the whole chain very effectively.

When set correctly, the chain is perfectly oiled pretty much all of the time. It's pretty cool to just glance back a the chain every few weeks and see it's perfectly oil, practically zero effort required.

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Thursday 7th September 2017
quotequote all
My commute has shot up to anything from 60 to 100 miles of motorway plodding recently so I really should drag the 2nd hand Scottoiler that's been sat in my shed for the last 2 years out and actually look at fitting it as my chain was dryer and shinier than a shiny thing when I lubed it tonight.

Cbull

4,483 posts

202 months

Monday 11th September 2017
quotequote all
TwoStrokeNut said:
It's worth persevering with as you already have it, if you have the patience. Put some of the correct oil in, set it very low and work from there.
Actually might give it a whirl at some then if that's the case. May only need a longer tube to hide it under the cowl.

Not sure how it manages lubes the other side though. Will have to research that a little more I think.

TwoStrokeNut

1,713 posts

272 months

Monday 11th September 2017
quotequote all
The lube just spreads across the chain perfectly well.

They made their name using one feed for decades.

myvision

2,132 posts

167 months

Monday 11th September 2017
quotequote all
I've got scottoilers on my bikes they work well around 500 miles to a reservoir.
I think I may have them set too high though.
Really easy to fit.

yellowstreak

638 posts

183 months

Tuesday 12th September 2017
quotequote all
I've used a PD oiler. Only complaint is that I don't find it easy to fill.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Sunday 24th September 2017
quotequote all
trialsta said:
Another vote for Scottoiler. No they aren't cheap but mine have been fit and forget for about 30k miles over the last 4 years.
Hugely overpriced and overcomplicated junk.