Soup as a main meal?
Author
Discussion

C0ffin D0dger

Original Poster:

3,440 posts

171 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
So I get home from work last night ravenous as usual, the wife has been making soup and has a loaf of bread baking in the bread machine. Not unusual in itself, just thought she'd made it for lunch this week or something. Bit later on having put the kids to bed I come down and enquire as to what's for dinner? She looks at me in a strange manner and says what do you think were having? "Just soup?" I say and then start to protest that soup isn't really a main meal, maybe a starter, she seems put out by this so now I have to start backtracking saying that I'm sure it'll be okay and that soup will be nice enough for dinner rolleyes

So that was my dinner last night, a bowl of soup and a couple of slices of bread. It was nice enough but I was left wishing we'd had something more substantial. Is this acceptable as a main meal or should I start the divorce proceedings? biggrin

I had to stop for a cooked breakfast on the way into work just to make up for it yum

carreauchompeur

18,308 posts

230 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Soup is not a meal. You're quite correct. My mum shares this soup meal delusion.

If I have soup for lunch, even lots of it, I'll be shaky and out of energy within a couple of hours.

joshleb

1,549 posts

170 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
My misssus does the exact same.

We tend to split dinners during the week, so I'll cook a couple of nights and hers the others.

I'll do a nice meal with meat and stuff in, so it adds up a bit, then she'll go and do leak and potato soup and bread. What's that £1 max?
And then there's the hunger I feel later too!

I'm with you with it not being a proper meal, as a starter or maybe, just maybe as a lunch on a cold winters day.

LordGrover

34,112 posts

238 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
There's soup and there's soup.
A thin miso style or a hearty thick soup with beans and rice and plenty between. I make a chilli style soup which is pretty substantial.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

152 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Soup certainly can be a meal.

You'd be happy with a stew or curry as a main meal, wouldn't you? Bit more liquid in, maybe whoozh it to smooth the lumpy bits out - it's soup... Put some thin or small pasta in with it, plenty of chunky croutons, or a thick doorstep on the side - you've got carbs, too.

arfur

4,012 posts

240 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
My other half often makes hearty soups. I don't mind this as evening meal as they are very substantial .... possibly more of a stew than a soup !

kowalski655

15,186 posts

169 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
My OH makes a lovely lentil,ham,carrot,leek,potato,etc soup(well,*I* do most of the work, she gives her orders smile) Very substantial with thick crusty bread, and a couple of bowls fills you up
So it certainly can be a meal, but can also be barely enough for a starter,just depends on whats in it

J4CKO

46,323 posts

226 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Oh oh, she is trying to slim you off !



Steviesam

1,422 posts

160 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Soup is for old people who cant chew.

You will likely spend your last couple of years sucking soup through a straw, so no need for it now.

RizzoTheRat

28,494 posts

218 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Acceptable as a light meal, say instead of a sandwich for lunch when you're planning on having a bigger meal in the evening, but much as I love a nice soup it's not a main meal. Luckily my wife is of the same opinion smile

HTP99

24,873 posts

166 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
I don't like soup particularly, ok I'll eat it if presented to me but when it comes to soup, it's all a bit meh for me.

Hoofy

79,681 posts

308 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
Did it have lots in it ie was it a stew? Or was it more like a starter?

Women do go through soup phases when they worry about their weight and just eat "healthy soup" forcing it onto others but stacking the calories up in "healthy bread" and a ton of butter so end up eating just as many calories but feel good about themselves while leaving the rest of their family starving and wondering about sneaking out to a McDonalds.

robinessex

11,916 posts

207 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
I occasionally make a huge quantity of Tomatoes based chunky vegetable soup. All fresh stuff. Then fry up some Pork or Beef Mince separately. Stuff the whole lot in the Fridge, Mix and eat as desired. My whole family love. With lovely fresh stick loaf, very filling.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

152 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
HTP99 said:
I don't like soup particularly, ok I'll eat it if presented to me but when it comes to soup, it's all a bit meh for me.
That sounds like you've only ever tried meh soup.

You like curry and stew, I presume?

HTP99

24,873 posts

166 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
HTP99 said:
I don't like soup particularly, ok I'll eat it if presented to me but when it comes to soup, it's all a bit meh for me.
That sounds like you've only ever tried meh soup.

You like curry and stew, I presume?
Yep I love curry and stew, I just don't want to drink my meal, I've never seen the fuss with soup.

Truckosaurus

13,078 posts

310 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
The OP is Kenny Bania and I claim my Five Pounds...


hman

7,497 posts

220 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
She's telling you to lose weight i reckon.


Of course you could have grilled some chicken, added some curry powder to the soup plus a few choice spices, then mixed the whole lot together with some pilau rice - hey presto a bodgers curry!

KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

201 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
If you cant chew it, its not a meal.

And in no fking world is a proper stew and in way shape or form "a bit like soup" hehe

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

152 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
KrazyIvan said:
And in no fking world is a proper stew and in way shape or form "a bit like soup" hehe
<shrug> Your loss, not understanding basic cookery.

We often turn the leftovers from a stew or curry into a really thick, filling and tasty soup - simply add a bit of stock, heat, whoozh.

popeyewhite

23,008 posts

146 months

Thursday 14th September 2017
quotequote all
OP?