Heated grips or heated gloves?
Heated grips or heated gloves?
Author
Discussion

Davemc37

Original Poster:

37 posts

110 months

Sunday 8th October 2017
quotequote all
This will be my first winter commuting by bike and I've noticed it's starting to get a bit cooler in the mornings.

I'm wondering what's the best option for keeping my hands warm.

At the moment I've got a reasonably thin pair of gloves and I've got some thermal liners I can wear under them. My bike also has hand guards which keeps the wind off. It also has a 12v socket.

What's the best next step though heated gloves or hand grips ? Do people got for heated gloves because they don't want the faff of replacing grips and wiring them in, or do they go for the gloves cos they don't have a 12v socket on their bikes?

Any advice welcome so I don't end up buying both eventually.

Gnits

1,156 posts

232 months

Sunday 8th October 2017
quotequote all
I have commuted alll year for a number of years and my now favoured solution is:
Bike has heated grips anyway
Summer gloves with good armour for decent feel - I really hate bulky 'winter' style feeling gloves
Silk liner gloves too for really cold days
Barkbuster handlebar muffs - make a huge difference

My commute is about 45- 60 mins so that is plenty of time to get cold but so far this has worked for me.

martyn850

69 posts

152 months

Sunday 8th October 2017
quotequote all
Some of the heated gloves I’ve looked at previously have said that you can’t use the heated bit in the rain. Kinda defeated the purpose for me, so I went down the heated grips route.

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Sunday 8th October 2017
quotequote all
Heated gloves as they heat your whole palm and finger tips if you get decent ones like a set of Gerbings rather than just your palm like heated grips.

The only other decent option is as above, grips plus muffs to keep the heat in.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 8th October 2017
quotequote all
tom_e said:
Heated gloves as they heat your whole palm and finger tips if you get decent ones like a set of Gerbings rather than just your palm like heated grips.
How's that work then? You ride with your palms flat against the top of the grips or something?

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Crossflow Kid said:
How's that work then? You ride with your palms flat against the top of the grips or something?
My apologies allow me to rephrase.

"Rather than just heating the inside of your hand like grips"

Which then leaves the bit actually being frozen by the wind chill still cold unlike gloves which heat both the front and back of the hand and all the way down the finger tips which are nowhere near the heated grip if you're in stop start riding the clutch commuting traffic.

Harry H

3,765 posts

187 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Having been an all year commuter for the best part of 30 yrs. I'd say if you really want to go for it you need both.

Heated grips are fine for spring/autumn and the occasional times when you make the mistake of wearing summer gloves but it turns out colder than you think. When the temperature really drops though nothing beats heated gloves.

For heated grips I really recommend the ones from Winding Roads. Basically you just buy the heating elements and fit them under your existing grips. They come with a really neat little switch that can be mounted discreetly on most bikes. The hardest bit is finding a switched live feed to run them off. They don't get hyper hot but enough to take the chill off. Personally I'm not a fan of massively hot sweaty palms with freezing outer hands anyway.

If you're going for heated gloves don't bother with the wire heated ones. Yes they're cheap but for everyday commuting they won't last. The wires break. Go for the Gerbing mesh heating element jobbies. Cost a bit more but with most things in life you get what you pay for. Warm as you like, waterproof and they last. Mine have done 6 winters and still look like new Just run the lead straight off the battery. If you're a proper woose like me you can add a heated inner jacket as well. I've been toasty warm in -5c. Scare sttless about ice but at least warm.

Hand guards make fk all difference in my experience.

The only other alternative and a lot cheaper is to forget the heated gloves, go for the heated grips and fit muffs which do make a difference. Personally though I can't get on with them and they seem to add to the width of the bars which makes wiggling though stationary traffic harder.

boyse7en

8,237 posts

196 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Having ridden in winter temps down to -8deg C I'd recommend heated grips and bar muffs (I've got Givi ones)

Heated grips are really only any good to take the chill off. Anything below about 5 deg C and the back of your hand gets painful anyway. Bar muffs look rubbish but do a great job of keeping wind chill off. Toasty.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
tom_e said:
Crossflow Kid said:
How's that work then? You ride with your palms flat against the top of the grips or something?
My apologies allow me to rephrase.

"Rather than just heating the inside of your hand like grips"

Which then leaves the bit actually being frozen by the wind chill still cold unlike gloves which heat both the front and back of the hand and all the way down the finger tips which are nowhere near the heated grip if you're in stop start riding the clutch commuting traffic.
Ah, much more sense, and I'd agree.
I get by with a combination of heated grips and hand guards.

pozi

1,725 posts

218 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Gerbing heated gloves everytime, not overly bulky and waterproof.

Plus if you change bikes the gloves and bike harness are easy to move over assuming you use the standard kit which just connects to the battery and any convenient earthing point.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
pozi said:
Gerbing heated gloves everytime, not overly bulky and waterproof.

Plus if you change bikes the gloves and bike harness are easy to move over assuming you use the standard kit which just connects to the battery and any convenient earthing point.
+1 Did all last winter on a set of Gerbing XRS12s which fit under my jacket cuffs. As long as the temp is 5deg or less they are spot on. Otherwise round town that little bit too warm on its min heat controller setting if its much above that.. nice problem to have though. I think at the coldest part of winter I needed to use 50% setting for a few days - I haven't even unlocked the 75% and 100% levels which are locked by default settings as they arn't needed.
Having warm fingers when they need to spend 95% of my commuting trip to work covering levers is really really good.

Cbull

4,483 posts

202 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Only gone through 1 winter on the bike so far but I got the Keis Heated Motorcycle Inner Gloves. They're fantastic, work very well indeed and in the rain too. All be it, they are a bit of a pain feeding the wires through the jacket, connecting to the bike and they'll need to fit inside your normal gloves (which will probably stretch a little and make it a bit tight). Regardless of the temperature and the mentioned cons they do the job very well.

2wheelsjimmy

624 posts

128 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Are those gerbing x12 waterproof. SBS reviews aren't so good

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
2wheelsjimmy said:
Are those gerbing x12 waterproof. SBS reviews aren't so good
100% waterproof.. I managed to leave them on/plugged-in in the rain and didn't die nor did the bike wink

obscene

5,180 posts

216 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
sjtscott said:
2wheelsjimmy said:
Are those gerbing x12 waterproof. SBS reviews aren't so good
100% waterproof.. I managed to leave them on/plugged-in in the rain and didn't die nor did the bike wink
As above. Road through torrential rain with them, no problems. Can't recommend them enough.

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

174 months

Monday 9th October 2017
quotequote all
Rode through last winter in all kinds of stinking weather using Gerbing heated gloves. No problems and outstanding bits of kit.

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Tuesday 10th October 2017
quotequote all
I use the Gerbring X12 as well as above totally waterproof and kick out enough heat on the top 2 settings to give you serious burns unless it's well in the minus figures.