Anyone here use a MS Surface laptop?
Discussion
I need to spec-up some laptops for a small business customer. I'm heavily Mac these days but this customer needs windows and I don't keep that close an eye on the windows world - especially laptops which are always changing models/specs etc.
I've started looking a bit closer at MS surface laptops and just wondered if anyone here uses one as their daily and what they make of it? I realise these things aren't that repairable, so are they reliable and is that fabric keyboard better to use than it looks? Main criteria is a general purpose windows laptop that is light and thin and also has enough connectivity for external screen/keyboard at the office. Budget is around £1000 so it will be the lower end model. Also considering a surface pro but to be honest I wasn't massively impressed with the last one I worked on which was a V3 I think. If you've used both models as daily computers then I would be interested to here which one you prefer.
Thanks in advance
I've started looking a bit closer at MS surface laptops and just wondered if anyone here uses one as their daily and what they make of it? I realise these things aren't that repairable, so are they reliable and is that fabric keyboard better to use than it looks? Main criteria is a general purpose windows laptop that is light and thin and also has enough connectivity for external screen/keyboard at the office. Budget is around £1000 so it will be the lower end model. Also considering a surface pro but to be honest I wasn't massively impressed with the last one I worked on which was a V3 I think. If you've used both models as daily computers then I would be interested to here which one you prefer.
Thanks in advance
Surface Pro is a tablet with a keyboard attached.
Imho the Surface laptop is the nicer design.
The alcantara keyboard feels great, though I wonder how good it will look after 3 years of daily use. That said, both my aluminium laptops looked horrible after a year or two anyway (MBP & Samsung, both smooth at the wrists and scratched from watches).
The keyboard is personal preference. I prefer it over the MB keyboard, but it's not as good as the XPS/MBP keyboard (imho).
Portable and ports don't mesh these days though.
At your price point and requirements I'd have the Inspiron 13" 7000 series.
http://www.dell.com/en-uk/shop/laptop-and-2-in-1-p...
Much better connectivity and spec. Probably slight compromise in portability and build quality though.
Edit: looked it up:
Surface vs Inspiron
Weight: 1,25kg vs 1,45kg
Dimensions:
14.5 x 308.0 x 223.2mm
vs
15.5 x 309.6 x 215.7mm
Hardly a compromise.
Imho the Surface laptop is the nicer design.
The alcantara keyboard feels great, though I wonder how good it will look after 3 years of daily use. That said, both my aluminium laptops looked horrible after a year or two anyway (MBP & Samsung, both smooth at the wrists and scratched from watches).
The keyboard is personal preference. I prefer it over the MB keyboard, but it's not as good as the XPS/MBP keyboard (imho).
Portable and ports don't mesh these days though.
At your price point and requirements I'd have the Inspiron 13" 7000 series.
http://www.dell.com/en-uk/shop/laptop-and-2-in-1-p...
Much better connectivity and spec. Probably slight compromise in portability and build quality though.
Edit: looked it up:
Surface vs Inspiron
Weight: 1,25kg vs 1,45kg
Dimensions:
14.5 x 308.0 x 223.2mm
vs
15.5 x 309.6 x 215.7mm
Hardly a compromise.
I used the SP3 as my main professional machine when I was working in SA. I changed it to a laptop after 9 months only because the screen is a bit straining if you're looking at it all day and evening every day. If you're desk based then you can also connect to a monitor. I only chose laptop over connecting SP3 to screen because the monitors at the place I was working were too low resolution.
I now have an SP5.
These are effing awesome machines. Very reliable, very quick, very quiet, very connectable. The keyboards are great actually, all backlit and the new more fabicky looking ones feel very nice. My old SP3 has gone to OH as her main machine and she uses it around the house and connects to a 30 inch monitor in the study.
There aren't many things in life I fall in love with. This is one of them. - OH, and the facial recognition on the new model is really very impressive.
I now have an SP5.
These are effing awesome machines. Very reliable, very quick, very quiet, very connectable. The keyboards are great actually, all backlit and the new more fabicky looking ones feel very nice. My old SP3 has gone to OH as her main machine and she uses it around the house and connects to a 30 inch monitor in the study.
There aren't many things in life I fall in love with. This is one of them. - OH, and the facial recognition on the new model is really very impressive.
I use a Surface Pro 4 i5, 8gb ram, 256gb SSD with one of the alcantra keyboards which is probably the best I've used in the last 20 years.
Love the device itself, clear screen, easy to use and actually prefer it now over a tablet for general internet browsing. I also love the detachable/foldable keyboard when sometimes just wanting to sit back and read documents which you can't do with a normal laptop.
Things that do bug me a little bit are the battery life and tablet mode ironically!
I went for the i5 over the i7 due to people reporting a much better battery life of around an extra 2 hours but even then I normally only get about 6-8 hours out of a full charge which is no where near as advertised and it's not like I'm using it for streaming Netflix or anything. Tablet mode is pretty crap to be honest. There doesn't seem to be much point in it as the apps don't alter to be tablet like if you get my drift.
My brother has a MBP (brand new) and although it looks nice doesn't float my boat. (and all my programs are for MS).
Love the device itself, clear screen, easy to use and actually prefer it now over a tablet for general internet browsing. I also love the detachable/foldable keyboard when sometimes just wanting to sit back and read documents which you can't do with a normal laptop.
Things that do bug me a little bit are the battery life and tablet mode ironically!
I went for the i5 over the i7 due to people reporting a much better battery life of around an extra 2 hours but even then I normally only get about 6-8 hours out of a full charge which is no where near as advertised and it's not like I'm using it for streaming Netflix or anything. Tablet mode is pretty crap to be honest. There doesn't seem to be much point in it as the apps don't alter to be tablet like if you get my drift.
My brother has a MBP (brand new) and although it looks nice doesn't float my boat. (and all my programs are for MS).
I've used a Surface Pro 4 for about 18 months (i5, 128gb ssd). I've a docking station in the office with 2x external monitors, ethernet etc and the same at home. Use the original keyboard/cover.
For the first 3 months it was a bit ropey with the external monitors, until the firmware was updated. Since then its been very good, other than some freezing issues when under battery power. This is a known issue and can lead to them being replaced under warranty.
For the first 3 months it was a bit ropey with the external monitors, until the firmware was updated. Since then its been very good, other than some freezing issues when under battery power. This is a known issue and can lead to them being replaced under warranty.
Thanks for the replies. Surprised no-one here is using a Surface laptop, but I suppose it's still quite a new product. I think I had better revisit the latest Surface Pro as that clearly has some fans although I still think the kickstand thing is a bit naff! Will check out Dell in more detail too.
Bikerjon said:
Thanks for the replies. Surprised no-one here is using a Surface laptop, but I suppose it's still quite a new product. I think I had better revisit the latest Surface Pro as that clearly has some fans although I still think the kickstand thing is a bit naff! Will check out Dell in more detail too.
I meant to post over the weekend.Surface Pro.
This is my current "laptop". I'm a big fan. The kickstand, far from being naff is a brilliant piece of engineering. In tablet mode, just browsing or consuming content, it allows you to rest it on virtually anything, crossed legs, cushions, lying in bed etc. Crucially without holding it (therefore negating it's weight disadvantage to say an iPad - doesn't weigh more if you don't need to hold it).
With keyboard attached, on a desk the kickstand allows you to have the device at any angle.
I also use the pen a fair bit (much more than I thought I would) to draw simple diagrams in online meetings and such. This works well with the device almost flat.
Where the Surface Pro falls down is as a pure laptop i.e. on you lap (desk top is fine). Despite what Microsoft may say, they are uncomfortable to use on the lap. the kickstand forces you to have the keyboard tucked up way too close, making for a poor experience.
It's just about fine if you only need to spend a few minutes working, but wouldn't want to do more than that.
Surface Laptop.
Not got a huge amount of experience of these. My daughter bought one for Uni and I've only had a small amount of time to have a go. Primarily because she loves it and is rarely off it. What I have seen is that is has that Apple premium feel. I like to just close the lid as there is a beautiful snap when it closes. This also means that I can also re-open it to see the Windows Hello retina scanning login, which is very impressive. Open the laptop and by the time you've got your hand down to the keyboard, you're logged in and ready to go.
powerful i5 and i7 processors, means it's well up to most average computing tasks.
sgrimshaw said:
I have a Surface Laptop, been using it for around a year.
It is a seriously nice piece of kit, but then it should be for the price.
Great screen, keyboard is nice to use .... must admit, I very rarely unclip the screen, so I don't have much experience of using it as a tablet.
Sounds like you've got a Surface Book if it's got a detachable screen and you've had it a year? The Laptop (basically a Surface Pro with a fixed keyboard) was released in the summer.It is a seriously nice piece of kit, but then it should be for the price.
Great screen, keyboard is nice to use .... must admit, I very rarely unclip the screen, so I don't have much experience of using it as a tablet.
I've had a mid spec SP4 (i5/8GB/256GB) for almost 2 years and really like it. As others have said, it's not so good using the keyboard on the lap when you are sitting, but with your legs stretched out on the sofa or in bed, it's good. I don't use the pen much, but do swipe the screen to scroll around spreadsheets, for instance. The track pad is good (though I haven't much experience of Apple laptops which are supposed to be better).
sgrimshaw said:
I have a Surface Laptop, been using it for around a year.
... I very rarely unclip the screen,...
No you don't, you have a Surface Book! ... I very rarely unclip the screen,...

I've got a Surface Laptop and I really like it. I've been a Mac person for the last 5 years, but was drawn over to the dark side by the hardware. The biggest downside of the thing is Windows. If OSX has a Windows Ink equivalent and ran on this hardware, it'd be the ultimate computer!
I occasionally use the (£100!!) pen and it works well. Windows Ink is genuinely good and a nice intuitive experience. Not quite as natural to use as the Surface Pro tablet form factor, but handy still for occasionally scribbling over diagrams and so on. Nicer to use on a laptop form factor than you would expect.
The keyboard is genuinely nice. As good or better than a Macbook Air keyboard. Nice key travel and comfortable to type on. It doesn't 'flex' like the Type Cover keyboard on the Pro. Two months in the alcantara is still looking brand new. Trackpad is on par with Apple stuff.
The single biggest selling point of the Laptop over the Pro for me was the keyboard being attached and the 'traditional' laptop form factor. You can use it like a normal laptop (rest it on your lap etc) rather than the faff of the kickstand and fold out keyboard on the Pro. But you still have the fantastic screen and the option of the pen.
All the other 'ultrabook' stuff is good. It's light, great screen, good battery life etc. The 'surface connector' sucks. I'd pay £200 right now to swap it for a USB-C interface. (MS are apparently building an adaptor 'soon') It's just a useless standard that makes you an orphan in the accessories world.
All that said, I think it's in kind of a niche. For 'corporate' users, just get them a Dell XPS13. If people regularly want a tablet form factor and will use a pen then a Surface Pro is probably a better choice.
If you want the laptop form factor, but still to draw on the screen then I think it's the best choice. The other options are the HP Spectre x360 or the Lenova Yoga family. But I (obviously!) think the MS Surface Laptop is the 'nicest' of the bunch.
In the corporate world they haven't been that popular because of numerous issues - reliability, robustness, manageability etc. Depending on your company's requirements it might be better to look at the normal business models from Dell, Lenovo (Thinkpads) etc, especially if you are on the hook for supporting them
Thanks for the further responses. I can't help feeling that the Surface range is a bit muddled. The book should be called the Pro, the laptop should be called the book and the pro should be just called "surface" !
I think I'm going to play it safe and go with the cheapest Dell XPS. From a purchasing point of view it makes a lot of sense to be be able to order everything from one place, plus the 3yr onsite warranty is one less thing to worry about. Either that or just get Macbook Airs and install windows in the hope that they fully migrate to OSX one day!
I think I'm going to play it safe and go with the cheapest Dell XPS. From a purchasing point of view it makes a lot of sense to be be able to order everything from one place, plus the 3yr onsite warranty is one less thing to worry about. Either that or just get Macbook Airs and install windows in the hope that they fully migrate to OSX one day!
Except "Surface" was the ARM-based first two generations, and the Atom-based 3rd generation one (which I'd love them to bring back).
A colleague has the Surface Laptop and likes it - it does seem better at being a laptop than my Surface Book. It's fine much of the time but for things like on-lap usage it's a bit "top heavy" with too much weight in the screen. And I detach the screen to use the pen so infrequently that I don't think I'd miss it. You can still use the pen on the Laptop, but obviously it's a more awkward experience writing on a near-vertical screen. For avid pen-users though I think the Pro is a much better choice as it's so easy to just flip the keyboard out of the way and write.
What I do really like about all Surface devices is the squarer screen (the extra vertical height is really nice) and they do get regular driver updates - plus there's no need for vendor-specific tools like you do with Lenovo and the like.
The Dell XPS are nice but I couldn't live with that stupid webcam placement.
A colleague has the Surface Laptop and likes it - it does seem better at being a laptop than my Surface Book. It's fine much of the time but for things like on-lap usage it's a bit "top heavy" with too much weight in the screen. And I detach the screen to use the pen so infrequently that I don't think I'd miss it. You can still use the pen on the Laptop, but obviously it's a more awkward experience writing on a near-vertical screen. For avid pen-users though I think the Pro is a much better choice as it's so easy to just flip the keyboard out of the way and write.
What I do really like about all Surface devices is the squarer screen (the extra vertical height is really nice) and they do get regular driver updates - plus there's no need for vendor-specific tools like you do with Lenovo and the like.
The Dell XPS are nice but I couldn't live with that stupid webcam placement.
zippy3x said:
If I asked you to spec a windows laptop and you recommended a £1000 5 year old MacBook air with a s
t screen, you'd be leaving with a flea in your ear and your support contract (metaphorically at least) sticking out of your arse.
It’s a small business and two of them are avid Macbook users (for personal use). If I suggested they could consider Macbooks of any age or spec for work then they would be absolutely delighted. Call me crazy, but I do try and give the customer what they want! There’s actually only a couple of applications that stand in the way, but I suspect we will go Dell for now.
t screen, you'd be leaving with a flea in your ear and your support contract (metaphorically at least) sticking out of your arse.Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


