Discussion
The whole thing seems to be a witch hunt with both the UK Government and HMRC conveniently and intentionally blurring the lines between legal avoidance and evasion. I think it's a disgrace to be honest. Everyone is entitled to structure their tax affairs in order to legally pay the least amount possible. The UK government and HMRC have now come up with the "spirit of the law" which is nothing but a different way of saying we know it's legal but we don't like it, so we'll try to make out it's not. Having an affair is "morally repugnant" however it's not illegal.......unless you ask HMRC, then they'll say it is.
At what point did morals and spirit supersede the law of the land ? I think it's a very dangerous area when HMRC can basically say we don't like it, can't prove it's illegal, but pay up anyway......and that's exactly what they're currently doing.
Still, at least "tax dodgers" would appear to have good taste ;D
At what point did morals and spirit supersede the law of the land ? I think it's a very dangerous area when HMRC can basically say we don't like it, can't prove it's illegal, but pay up anyway......and that's exactly what they're currently doing.
Still, at least "tax dodgers" would appear to have good taste ;D
steveatesh said:
Was it about tax avoidance or tax evasion?
I avoid tax by isa’s and I have an Aston.... lol....
It was a bit borderline; the sort of schemes that involve people being paid via Mauritius and then having the offshore company “lend” them the money backI avoid tax by isa’s and I have an Aston.... lol....
I’m a sensitive soul, I don’t want to get out of my car and have anyone think “tax dodger” (or more worryingly have them key the car because of a bad rep)
RobDown said:
It was a bit borderline; the sort of schemes that involve people being paid via Mauritius and then having the offshore company “lend” them the money back
I’m a sensitive soul, I don’t want to get out of my car and have anyone think “tax dodger” (or more worryingly have them key the car because of a bad rep)
Tax dodger or not, the sort of scummer who would scratch someones car is more than likely somebody who's never actually paid a penny in tax themselves but who thinks it's "outrageous" that wealthier people don't pay more.I’m a sensitive soul, I don’t want to get out of my car and have anyone think “tax dodger” (or more worryingly have them key the car because of a bad rep)
To be clear I'm not saying I agree with not paying what you should at all, indeed everyone should do that, but that's the issue really....pay would you legally have to, not a copper coin more. None of us offer to pay more for a service than we have to and the same principle applies. The issue I have is the media trying to make out that perfectly legal tax structures which reduce the sum owed are somehow illegal. By all means change the law to make these structures illegal, but don't try and tell the world that people are dodging tax when they're actually doing nothing wrong from a legal perspective (I appreciate that doesn't apply to everyone, some are dodgy b
ds
)Also, just how hypocritical are out government. I hope that some real juicy info comes out about some MP's. They act holier than thou when in fact they're worse than most. When Osborne was Chancellor he wasn't quite so vocal about telling the world how his own father sold his share in the Osborne & Little wallpaper firm to an offshore trust in full knowledge that this would avoid the UK Treasury getting what they should on a property transaction. Oh sorry, i'm sure according to Georgie Boy that would have been Tax Planning........if you or I did it he would call it "morally repugnant avoidance"...........funny that.
I know i'm ranting now but I detest the media witch hunt when it comes to this stuff, ruining peoples reputations on misinformation and false truths..........

RobDown said:
I would agree with some of what you say and disagree with other bits
Apple are entirely legal with their tax structures. But at some point there becomes a moral argument that they should be looking to pay a fair share (3.6% of profits isn’t that).
Oh I agree, but you can't throw somebody under the bus because the HMRC, the Treasury and the UK Government can't sort their sApple are entirely legal with their tax structures. But at some point there becomes a moral argument that they should be looking to pay a fair share (3.6% of profits isn’t that).
t out and make what they're doing no longer legal.Nobody in their right mind is going to cough up more in tax than they legally have to and why would they. Apple can't say to their shareholders we don't actually owe this, but we'll pay it anyway as we're nice.
They need to get law makers to close these loopholes and promote tax fairness that way, not by naming and shaming people they think should just pay more because they have more money, but who are actually not doing anything wrong. Again I know that some structures are as dodgy as they come and fair doos, they probably are illegal, but there are many that are not and are 100% legal and would stack up in any UK court. HMRC are fully aware of this, hence why so many structures are not tackled, because HMRC know they would loose in court.,
As I said, the issue I have is that the story the media, HMRC and the UK Government tell is about people not paying enough tax..........the bit they're not very keen to say is that based on current tax law, they don't actually owe it.
I work on the basis that if i live and work in this country then I pay my taxes. But that maybe just me it seems 
But my point was more that I hope that post that programme there’s no longer term detrimental impact on the brand. Because it did seem that virtually all of the off-shorers were bringing money back to buy Aston Martins

But my point was more that I hope that post that programme there’s no longer term detrimental impact on the brand. Because it did seem that virtually all of the off-shorers were bringing money back to buy Aston Martins
Don't forget all those dodgy people who fiddle their tax obligations, by using a tax loophole called the Income Tax Personal Allowance.
It really is disgraceful, that most of the UK poplation are now using this sneaky trick, to avoid giving more of their own money to the government. Don't they realise that the government want more money, and they always spend it so wisely. Using any kind of tax loophole is now deemed morally wrong, but there seem to be ever more people paying 0% income tax. Something should be done about this, to clamp down on these tax dodgers.

There is most definitely a witch hunt by both the BBC and some people with de-stabalising agendas.
I'm sure not all of the people going to be, or currently exposed are 100% clean, but most of the ones reported so far in the Paradise Papers seem to have done nothing legally wrong other than utilise legitimate and legal ways of avoiding paying a lot of tax.
Lets not forget that these so called tax havens are created specifically to be just that. Its not an accident or a loop hole, but a deliberate policy of low taxation to attract business and people to conduct their business and hold cash in these often small countries with otherwise very little means of generating a natural national income. It has been this way for a very long time, yet now suddenly these things are being portrayed as morally wrong.
I'm not personally wealthy enough to bother with the cost of implementing such schemes, but I do use ISA's, and tax efficient investment share schemes and even just pensions with UK businesses all of which are 100% legitimate and work well at my level of wealth to help ease the tax burden. All are HMRC aware and approved and I have no issues in declaring all of them on my tax return. What happens when those people seeking to change public opinion begin to focus on these things too - will I, like millions of other legitimate tax efficient savers be also then be labelled as a tax avoider? The line should be drawn on what is legal and what is not - end of.
I smell a rat, and it isn't those people who are working hard to save money by legal and legitimate means!
As for the impact on AM - well if the well off become less well off because they all now have to pay more tax then for sure some luxury goods sales will suffer. One has to ask is that good for the economy overall and for all those people that work for the luxury goods manufacturers and their onward supply chain?
I'm sure not all of the people going to be, or currently exposed are 100% clean, but most of the ones reported so far in the Paradise Papers seem to have done nothing legally wrong other than utilise legitimate and legal ways of avoiding paying a lot of tax.
Lets not forget that these so called tax havens are created specifically to be just that. Its not an accident or a loop hole, but a deliberate policy of low taxation to attract business and people to conduct their business and hold cash in these often small countries with otherwise very little means of generating a natural national income. It has been this way for a very long time, yet now suddenly these things are being portrayed as morally wrong.
I'm not personally wealthy enough to bother with the cost of implementing such schemes, but I do use ISA's, and tax efficient investment share schemes and even just pensions with UK businesses all of which are 100% legitimate and work well at my level of wealth to help ease the tax burden. All are HMRC aware and approved and I have no issues in declaring all of them on my tax return. What happens when those people seeking to change public opinion begin to focus on these things too - will I, like millions of other legitimate tax efficient savers be also then be labelled as a tax avoider? The line should be drawn on what is legal and what is not - end of.
I smell a rat, and it isn't those people who are working hard to save money by legal and legitimate means!

As for the impact on AM - well if the well off become less well off because they all now have to pay more tax then for sure some luxury goods sales will suffer. One has to ask is that good for the economy overall and for all those people that work for the luxury goods manufacturers and their onward supply chain?
Oh come on!
People hide behind the "oh but I use an ISA or pension" excuse. That's a government sponsored scheme to encourage people to save
Don't tell me you can't see the difference between that and some BBC employee paying themselves via a Mauritius Trust and then loaning the money back to themselves to avoid paying income tax (with the loan being non-repayable)? Yes it might technically be legal but only because the accountants and lawyers are more numerous and faster at finding loopholes than the understaffed HMRC are at closing them (what has it come to that I feel the need to defend HMRC!)
It is immoral even if it isn't illegal. This is not a victimless 'crime'. With a wife who works in the NHS I can see very clearly the impact of austerity and what its doing. I have no doubt that that very same BBC employee who is happily laughing at the rest of us for being mug enough to pay our contribution to society will also happily be using the NHS services etc
As I said, if you cant distinguish between that and a pension, then heaven help you
Rant over
People hide behind the "oh but I use an ISA or pension" excuse. That's a government sponsored scheme to encourage people to save
Don't tell me you can't see the difference between that and some BBC employee paying themselves via a Mauritius Trust and then loaning the money back to themselves to avoid paying income tax (with the loan being non-repayable)? Yes it might technically be legal but only because the accountants and lawyers are more numerous and faster at finding loopholes than the understaffed HMRC are at closing them (what has it come to that I feel the need to defend HMRC!)
It is immoral even if it isn't illegal. This is not a victimless 'crime'. With a wife who works in the NHS I can see very clearly the impact of austerity and what its doing. I have no doubt that that very same BBC employee who is happily laughing at the rest of us for being mug enough to pay our contribution to society will also happily be using the NHS services etc
As I said, if you cant distinguish between that and a pension, then heaven help you
Rant over

But the point is Rob that many of these schemes are not using loopholes - they are legitimate schemes setup because these tax havens specifically invite such business by flexing their independence and right to set lower rates of tax. (I should add that I haven't actually watched the Panorama program yet - just read many of the specific stories in the press over the last day or so.)
The areas that are grey and do indeed exploit loopholes are a different matter and I would agree that these are morally wrong. My point was that an lot of the examples in the press so far seem to fall into the former category of legitimate tax efficiency using the system as it was designed to be used by those who setup the lower tax rates in the "havens". There is a very thin line between this and things such as ISA's, taper relief or exemption on CGT gifts of property to children etc, etc... all of which seem currently to be morally acceptable.
An interesting article (also by the BBC) on the Isle of Man. Worth a read...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/the_isl...
The areas that are grey and do indeed exploit loopholes are a different matter and I would agree that these are morally wrong. My point was that an lot of the examples in the press so far seem to fall into the former category of legitimate tax efficiency using the system as it was designed to be used by those who setup the lower tax rates in the "havens". There is a very thin line between this and things such as ISA's, taper relief or exemption on CGT gifts of property to children etc, etc... all of which seem currently to be morally acceptable.
An interesting article (also by the BBC) on the Isle of Man. Worth a read...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/the_isl...
Edited by AdamV12V on Tuesday 7th November 12:43
SL500UK said:
The super rich don't pay much tax. How did the Duke of Westminster get away with leaving a £9b estate tax-free relatively unscathed by the press? If he was just a normal 'rich' person, the estate would have paid 40% IHT, just short of an entire year's worth of IHT.
It depends upon the definition of your word, 'much'.
Private buyers of Vulcans would have each paid £300,000 tax.
With Valkyrie, probably £500,000 each.
Does that put it into perspective. With sales taxes, at least we pay it more a little more willingly, than income tax and that second income tax (NI).
If you don't want to pay IHT, that is easy. Give away your property, then try to stay alive for 7 years.
Many country estates have elderly mummy or daddy, living in a small cottage on the estate. They need to pay commercial rent on the cottage, but they don't own the estate at death. If you want to consider doing that, you have to hope the juniors don't divorce, take to the bottle, start gambling, or worse.
I think one point with all this, is how the world has changed so dramatically, since the 1950s or 1960s.
Who would then have thought then, that we would now purchase a product whilst sitting at home. The seller can be based anywhere in the world now, it makes no difference to the customer. The item is manufactured on the other side of the world, we are invoiced from Luxembourg, our payment seems to go via Eire, then on to goodness knows where. Every country has different fiscal rules.
The problem with these complex global changes, is that the taxation rules of individual countries cannot deal properly with it. It is as if the legislators still think we just go to a local shop, to buy a product made in Birmingham.
Do I have a point ?
Made me laugh this morning watching Piers Morgan and Co.
Alan Sugar was speaking about his £58+ million cheque he wrote to HMRC along with a picture of it.
When talking he admitted that he pays his taxes and also said that he sent this large payment in 2015 so as to avoid the rate increases that were imminent.
He then said that he saved about 6-7% or so by doing so.
Is this immoral, is he avoiding payments?? According to the strict morals of some he is but in my books he isn't.
I think that if taxation was more 'fair' then maybe the revenue would collect more.
Note: edited to remove parts.....would no doubt cause argument one way or the other!
Alan Sugar was speaking about his £58+ million cheque he wrote to HMRC along with a picture of it.
When talking he admitted that he pays his taxes and also said that he sent this large payment in 2015 so as to avoid the rate increases that were imminent.
He then said that he saved about 6-7% or so by doing so.
Is this immoral, is he avoiding payments?? According to the strict morals of some he is but in my books he isn't.
I think that if taxation was more 'fair' then maybe the revenue would collect more.
Note: edited to remove parts.....would no doubt cause argument one way or the other!
Edited by AMTony on Tuesday 7th November 14:26
There are always laws that sanction the small fish but loopholes that allow the whales to carry on .....nothing to see here....get worked up about the single mum with four kids.
It's all tomorrow's fish and chip paper.
Capitalism based on altruism....I don't think so.
However we do appear to be reaching some sort of tipping point....maybe.
Brexit....randy MPs....greedy corporations...North Korea....etc.etc.
1984...Brave new/old World.
Cynical.....moi ?
Forget it ....go for a drive in your Aston.
It's all tomorrow's fish and chip paper.
Capitalism based on altruism....I don't think so.
However we do appear to be reaching some sort of tipping point....maybe.
Brexit....randy MPs....greedy corporations...North Korea....etc.etc.
1984...Brave new/old World.
Cynical.....moi ?
Forget it ....go for a drive in your Aston.
Edited by avinalarf on Tuesday 7th November 13:40
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff







