Aston Martin to halt production in the event of hard brexit
Aston Martin to halt production in the event of hard brexit
Author
Discussion

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
I know not everyone reads the FT (lucky you). But just FYI, there's a write-up with some comments from UK car manufacturers about the impact of a 'no deal' Brexit.

Aston Martin are essentially saying they will need to halt production temporarily. Albeit its not clear whether that's due to an issue with parts supply (given the components coming from Germany/Italy) or because they simply won't know what they need to do in order to be able to export cars (they may need to ensure a higher percentage of components are of UK origin, which may not be achievable on a short time frame).

So mind out if you order a car and think it might be delivered in 19Q2!

(And as an aside, other car manufacturers are suggesting prices will need to rise on average by 10% here, that's just a basic tariff thing though. Guess currency impact will be on top)

Happy Thursday everyone frown

Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all

RobDown said:
Albeit its not clear whether that's due to an issue with parts supply (given the components coming from Germany/Italy) or because they simply won't know what they need to do in order to be able to export cars ...

(And as an aside, other car manufacturers are suggesting prices will need to rise on average by 10% here, that's just a basic tariff thing though. Guess currency impact will be on top)

My understanding Rob, is it was explained by the AML CFO to a Parliamentary committee, that the present vehicle UK certification would not be recognised in EU countries.

Is your 10%, the anticipated increased cost of imported cars (including currency movements) ?
I thought WTO tariffs have a maximum of 4%.

You have probably heard talk about the extra tariffs on vehicle components when moving between countries.
I think WTO tariffs only apply to finished goods.

Whether Sir James Dyson can be believed or not, I do not know. All his manufacturing is in some far flung country, and so his sales in all EU countries including UK, have been subject to tariffs for a long time.

3 Henrys, or 1 Dyson is another question. _ wink




Edited by Jon39 on Thursday 16th November 09:02

The Surveyor

7,624 posts

268 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Jon39 said:

My understanding Rob, is it was explained by the AML CFO to a Parliamentary committee, that the present vehicle UK certification would not be recognised in EU countries.

..........
If we're going for a 'hard Brexit' then that sentiment should be reciprocated. EC certifications no longer being recognised in the UK.

It's just a negotiation tactic.

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
The 10% figure was from Honda I believe. Not sure how it was calculated, albeit the comment seemed to be based on the WTO tariff (but as you say they’ve seemingly added something in).

Surveyor - not sure how much choice we’re going to get in the long run. The investment in the UK motor industry has already dried up post referendum. Guessing the only way the mass market producers can stay here longer term is if costs fall sharply (currency plus wages). Will be interesting to see how flexible the Unions are in agreeing cuts or wages linked to productivity improvements

BamfordMike

1,192 posts

188 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
The Surveyor said:
Jon39 said:

My understanding Rob, is it was explained by the AML CFO to a Parliamentary committee, that the present vehicle UK certification would not be recognised in EU countries.

..........
If we're going for a 'hard Brexit' then that sentiment should be reciprocated. EC certifications no longer being recognised in the UK.

It's just a negotiation tactic.
This^^^^

It’s very clear the unknown in the article is just contained to whether the VCA type approval will apply to cars made in UK sold in EU but the reciprocal didn’t get a mention. I can see that regulatory unknown would worry the hell out of a low volume luxury sports car maker more than a global high volume road car automaker, not just because of the regulatory standards, but just the change to facing-off with TUV instead of VCA will be unsettling.

Taken from SMMT registrations data, year to date cars made in the EU sold in UK is approx. 1,069,332, not an insignificant figure, but I guess UK government playing hardball using those >1M levers as bargaining chips to the benefit of the UK getting a fair deal would not be the done thing and be very wrong??!!

I’ve read JLR do, the lesson is to source a greater majority of parts made in UK and return the UK to having some form of production parts manufacturing industry that is productive for UK jobs and economy. Of course, daring to make a greater % of your car from parts sourced in your own territory would put a manufacturer offside with global rules concerning where a certain % of the cars makeup of parts comes from to enable sales entry into a certain territory.
There are a ton of similar examples to use, but this one will do. The new (BMW) Mini engine (joint development between Chrysler / BMW) was produced in Brazil mainly to use the engine production of origin to gain sales entry into Americas avoiding punitive tax. Swerving that punitive tax took thousands of production jobs both in terms of parts supply to make the engine and staff needed to screw the engine together away from the UK. In return, what punitive measures does UK insist on others to balance the UK books?? Lost GDP and a lost industry due to it being hallowed out and disappeared is all that came of that portion of Globalisation for the UK?

The rule book needs rewriting and afterward there should be no sympathy for car companies who don’t use in territory derived parts and labour. Not possible you say? Use those >1M import levers and make it happen??!!

Manx V8V

482 posts

113 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
As someone old enough to remember a pre EU UK, I'm quite relaxed and confident that the sun will not go out and the sky will not fall in.

The perceived challenges are no greater than most large business CEO's already handle on an almost daily basis, there will be work to do, but life will carry on.

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Unfortunately Manx I think the global economy has moved on since those days

I hope you’re right, but without revealing anything about my job, I fear you’re notfrown

The real hope here has to be that the EU needs our money for their budget. With luck we can get a pay-for-access deal that doesn’t cripple the economy too badly

Edited by RobDown on Thursday 16th November 10:54

The Surveyor

7,624 posts

268 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
RobDown said:
The 10% figure was from Honda I believe. Not sure how it was calculated, albeit the comment seemed to be based on the WTO tariff (but as you say they’ve seemingly added something in).

Surveyor - not sure how much choice we’re going to get in the long run. The investment in the UK motor industry has already dried up post referendum. Guessing the only way the mass market producers can stay here longer term is if costs fall sharply (currency plus wages). Will be interesting to see how flexible the Unions are in agreeing cuts or wages linked to productivity improvements
I think you are over-thinking this from the bottom of a half-empty glass. There will be changes for sure, but they won't automatically all be so negative. Manufacturers are simply levering for concessions (hence the threats), the EU is levering for a stronger divorce, the money markets are levering for extra profits (as they always do), and the media are whipped up into a frenzy.


Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all

RobDown said:
Unfortunately Manx I think the global economy has moved on since those days

I hope you’re right, but without revealing anything about my job, I fear you’re notfrown

The real hope here has to be that the EU needs our money for their budget. With luck we can get a pay-for-access deal that doesn’t cripple the economy too badly

I appreciate Rob, that there are different difficulties about authorisation for financial services, which of course is a very big part of the UK economy.

'.. the EU needs our money ...'
Anybody's money, and the more the better it seems.

I cannot see them giving anything in return for money though, because they are probably very worried about other member countries leaving. PM Blair agreed to more payments in exchange for changes to the CAP. Paying the money, but still waiting for the promised CAP changes.

What puzzles me, is the performance of the manufacturer Dyson.
Factory outside the EU, selling around the world, including into the EU, therefore paying WTO tariffs.
2010 = 5 million machines and 2,500 employees.
2016 = 13 million machines and 10,000 employees.







66MK

375 posts

138 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
RobDown said:
Unfortunately Manx I think the global economy has moved on since those days

I hope you’re right, but without revealing anything about my job, I fear you’re notfrown

The real hope here has to be that the EU needs our money for their budget. With luck we can get a pay-for-access deal that doesn’t cripple the economy too badly

Edited by RobDown on Thursday 16th November 10:54
Moan moan moan, whinge, whinge, whinge.

So fed up with this doom and gloom sentiment, if you have nothing positive to say then please don't bother - it's happening so why not get behind your country and ensure it's success rather than try your hardest to talk it down so you can in some twisted way say 'I told you so'.

Not a political forum either and I'm not going to carry it on beyond this comment.

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
66MK said:
Moan moan moan, whinge, whinge, whinge.

So fed up with this doom and gloom sentiment, if you have nothing positive to say then please don't bother - it's happening so why not get behind your country and ensure it's success rather than try your hardest to talk it down so you can in some twisted way say 'I told you so'.

Not a political forum either and I'm not going to carry it on beyond this comment.
1. There’s only one whinging here
2. I’m doing my best to support the UK (not actually my country but don’t that get in your way) by buying British cars
3. The post was to signal the potential stoppage in Aston Martins
4. Feel free to bury your head in the sand. We’ve all had enough of experts after all smile

hornbaek

3,846 posts

266 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
66MK said:
RobDown said:
Unfortunately Manx I think the global economy has moved on since those days

I hope you’re right, but without revealing anything about my job, I fear you’re notfrown

The real hope here has to be that the EU needs our money for their budget. With luck we can get a pay-for-access deal that doesn’t cripple the economy too badly

Edited by RobDown on Thursday 16th November 10:54
Moan moan moan, whinge, whinge, whinge.

So fed up with this doom and gloom sentiment, if you have nothing positive to say then please don't bother - it's happening so why not get behind your country and ensure it's success rather than try your hardest to talk it down so you can in some twisted way say 'I told you so'.

Not a political forum either and I'm not going to carry it on beyond this comment.
If it was only that simple. If we end up with a Hard Brexit, how AML will fare will be the least of our problems.

GTIAlex

1,935 posts

197 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
RobDown said:
The 10% figure was from Honda I believe. Not sure how it was calculated, albeit the comment seemed to be based on the WTO tariff (but as you say they’ve seemingly added something in).

Surveyor - not sure how much choice we’re going to get in the long run. The investment in the UK motor industry has already dried up post referendum. Guessing the only way the mass market producers can stay here longer term is if costs fall sharply (currency plus wages). Will be interesting to see how flexible the Unions are in agreeing cuts or wages linked to productivity improvements
Any sources to back up?
My experience since I work in the sector is that wages are on the up and up and investment levels are huge.

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Look no offence but I posted this thread because I thought people might be interested in Aston Martins potential production hiatus. Not to be attacked by keyboard warriors

So you’re enquiry might be genuine, if so apologies. Just google investment in the uk automotive industry. 30 seconds. You’ll find the numbers

And with that “I’m out” (in best Duncan Bannantyne accent)

Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all

I have purposely tried to make impartial comments on this topic, and also have no idea whether the CFO was being serious about stopping production.

Perhaps all we should be doing on Rob's topic, is just discuss any information related to those comments.

Last year AML produced just under 4,000 cars.
About 600 of those went to EU countries (excl. UK)


( Why is the abbreviation Brexit being used anyway? I thought the United Kingdom is the EU member, not Great Britain. )








V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Friday 17th November 2017
quotequote all
Jon39 said:
3 Henrys, or 1 Dyson is another question.
I prefer Hetty. She sucks better smile


CSK1

1,832 posts

155 months

Friday 17th November 2017
quotequote all
I'm a Belgian national, my company is based in London and live in France.
Just saying I'm sad you are leaving Europe as I am a true believer in European unity.
There's not much to gain in isolating yourself from Europe which has its flaws but all said and done has many advantages too.
What I can say is that I haven't had a British client since the Brexit vote, I was surprised at the pro-European pro-business result of the French Presidential elections and am seriously considering moving my head office to France, there's a positive vibe in France that used to be present in the UK. I'm a very small operation but there are major investments from big multinationals that have been put on hold until there's a clearer view on what's going to happen when Brexit takes effect in 2019.
Anyway I love Britain, I love the cars, I support the UK as an Anglophile buying many British products (we own 3 British cars) and will continue to do so.
We have a passion in common, don't let politics ruin our unity here on PH!
I'm out too! smile

Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Friday 17th November 2017
quotequote all

V8V Pete said:
Jon39 said:
3 Henrys, or 1 Dyson is another question.
I prefer Hetty. She sucks better smile


Love the eye lashes.
Hope my Henrys don't see your Hetty. They could easily fall for her.
That could never happen with a Dyson.
Those machines might look at home in a chemistry laboratory, but no soul, and utterly bagless. wink

Early coffee break here. Beautiful sunshine, but digging is tiring.
Did you spot the Valkyrie AMR Pro announcement yesterday ?
25 cars, £3,000,000, and all sold.






steveatesh

5,384 posts

195 months

Friday 17th November 2017
quotequote all
Jon39 said:

Love the eye lashes.
Hope my Henrys don't see your Hetty. They could easily fall for her.
That could never happen with a Dyson.
Those machines might look at home in a chemistry laboratory, but no soul, and utterly bagless. wink

Early coffee break here. Beautiful sunshine, but digging is tiring.
Did you spot the Valkyrie AMR Pro announcement yesterday ?
25 cars, £3,000,000, and all sold.
It wouldn’t be long before Hetty was telling Henry he wasn’t sucking properly and had “missed a bit” rolleyes

Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Friday 17th November 2017
quotequote all

steveatesh said:
It wouldn’t be long before Hetty was telling Henry he wasn’t sucking properly and had “missed a bit” rolleyes

wink