V8V clutch/transmission, just reporting!
V8V clutch/transmission, just reporting!
Author
Discussion

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
So... bought a splendid V8V from Aston Cheltenham as previously described. A couple of things to be sorted from the inspection, all amicably agreed.

On the way back noticed that the gearchange into first and a bit into second was stiff when cold, as expected, but actually was also stiff when well warmed up too but... it was ok changing whilst slowing to a stop but once stationary for a few moments in neutral then try to engage, very stiff and needs a good shove. Did 750 mixed miles and thought ‘nah, this isn’t right’.

Booked it in to get the couple of things sorted and raised the issue with Cheltenham, in the meantime popped into Aston Chiltern specialists (great place to visit, and really helpful chaps, my local specialist I suppose) for an opinion as this is my first Aston who said that yes, it shouldn’t be like that, it was the spigot bearing or the clutch. Odd, clutch only 7,000 mile old, fitted by supplying dealer... and what is the spigot shaft?

When the time came Cheltenham guys changed the transmission oil as a first port of call (ta; that was due next service) but still sticky. Left it with them, and 4 hour train ride home!

They tested the linkage and tried bleeding the clutch. In the end they changed the clutch, and offered for me to pay the difference for an AMR clutch. Of course, yes please.

So got it back today, very helpfully delivered. Brilliant clutch, so light and easy to drive. Engine revier when changing, more responsive on the change and a much lighter pedal. I like!!!

Still a little baulky 1st selection even when hot but loads better, I suppose I am in ‘they all do that, sir’ territory. And a funny mechanical meshing noise when pottling around at very low speed and slightly worse going uphill. Doesn’t seem to be coming from the rear particularly, and the dealer happy with the results and for me to have it back. I suppose that will be the clutch bedding in or somesuch. But wow, such a difference.

Rather glad I got a main dealer used car, I have to say. Oh, and they did give me the service records after the PO kindly gave his go ahead and it seems it had new plugs and coil packs at the same time as the clutch, so a cheap 8yr service for me now! Hoorah!



bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
Nice to hear they sorted it out for you.

The noise you are hearing, might be the torque tube chattering, which runs from front to rear under the car. You can occasionally hear it at low speed when maneuvering.

The dealer or specialist should be able to a ride in it and listen to put your mind at rest re the noise.

David W.

1,952 posts

240 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
Almost exactly the same as my experience with the BR dual plate upgrade. Still not Porsche precision around 1st / 2nd but very snickerty snick in all the other gears. Lighter pedal feel, nice engagement point and the engine spins up more quickly.
Its a shame they are not “all like that Sir”
DW

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
Bogie, that makes sense, the noise does seem to be along the car and has a resonance tingle to it. I’m not too worried, good to hear it’s not unusual and it is just when pootling.

If anyone does get their clutch done, I’d say it’s well worth the extra £480 over stock. Oh yes! It almost disproportionately adds to the pleasure of the car and gives a much more sporting feel particularly when pressing on.

Indeed DW, not quite Porsche, but I ‘get’ this one too!! My Cayman was more precise but I have not looked back...

Edited by vernierMike on Thursday 21st December 19:16

V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
The "mechanical meshing noise" you describe does sound as if it is gear/clutch/prop-shaft chatter which they all do to some extent but is generally regarded as more common/prominent with a twin plate clutch (perhaps because of the lighter flywheel but I'm just guessing). It is completely benign and not a "fault" so nothing to worry about at all. Just try to stay in the top half of the rev range and you'll not hear it often smile

Edited by V8V Pete on Thursday 21st December 21:00

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Thursday 21st December 2017
quotequote all
I'm assuming that the 'new' AMR clutch may be a twin plate, if so are they spring loaded? I've seen many that are not and if this is the case that would explain any 'meshing' as described noises at low speeds/high gears especially. These plates are harder on the transmission, just a thought. Just don't labour under 2k revs and you should be ok.

Edited by macdeb on Thursday 21st December 19:51

V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Friday 22nd December 2017
quotequote all
macdeb said:
I'm assuming that the 'new' AMR clutch may be a twin plate, if so are they spring loaded? I've seen many that are not and if this is the case that would explain any 'meshing' as described noises at low speeds/high gears especially. These plates are harder on the transmission, just a thought. Just don't labour under 2k revs and you should be ok.
The AMR clutch is definitely a twin plate but I'm afraid you're going over my head when you start asking about whether or not it is "spring loaded". Is this springs keeping everything in compression in the basket or the little springs in the plates (shown below) that "cushion" the initial contact with flywheel/coverplate?


vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Friday 22nd December 2017
quotequote all
Well it’s the AMR clutch they had in stock for road use, please don’t read too much into ‘new’, just that it wasn’t second hand! I did ask at the time and yes it has twin plates.

As I understand it, the springs in your pic within the friction plate protect the transmission (and your neck muscles) when the drive is taken up when you release the clutch as the inner spline plate and outer friction material float with the springs connecting them. As a pure racing version, I can see that you could omit these and take the hit with shock to a transmission and less than comfy take-up, particularly with professionals driving, although personally I have not seen one with no springs.

The other springs, in the pressure plate, are kinda necessary, as when the release bearing pushes onto them they pivot to pull the pressure plate back and release the friction plate.

Are there any others, particular to the twin plate maybe?

I imagine mine does have all the springs, thus I would not think increased shock to the transmission. It does feel very progressive and smooth...

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Friday 22nd December 2017
quotequote all
That's them Peter, if so it blows my theory scratchchin

V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
macdeb said:
That's them Peter, if so it blows my theory scratchchin
Apart from the fact that the picture is of my OEM single plate clutch that was removed to make way for my BR twin plate. I don't have a picture of the plates from my twin plate clutch, just the whole assembly (below), so I'm not sure if they are sprung or not. Will ask Mike when I next see him. However, I do know that the bite point is now more progressive and smoother than it was with the old clutch so "harshness" is certainly not an issue.

Have done a little bit of reading and some of the noises made specifically by twin plate clutches are due to the intermediate plate rattling in the basket when the clutch is "unclamped". Don't think I hear this with mine but I certainly hear what I interpret as prop shaft chatter/resonance at low engine speeds which is very common and benign as mentioned earlier.



Edited by V8V Pete on Saturday 23 December 18:49

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
The plot thickens. Link below is exploded view of the AMR clutch and a complicated thing it is! The two friction plates don’t seem to have these springs but the separating plate does, great big meaty ones.

http://www.astonmartin.com/en/accessories/amr/amr-...

VH02 AML

109 posts

245 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
The standard single plate clutch as an additional torsional vibration damper which eliminates/reduces driveline rattle. The replacement twin plate clutches do not have this additional damper and therefore once fitted then driveline and gear rattle will be the result.

Very few people talk about this when upgrading to the twin plate, but it should be no surprise.

This is the reason that AML have stuck with the single plate clutch because the vibration damper is not available in a twin plate.

You may ask why does the V12V not rattle with the twin plate, but it’s down to the firing order and torsional inputs from the V8 which are more severe than the V12.

I’m afraid there is no solution available other than returning to the oem single plate clutch. On the positive side, there is no risk of damage from the rattle.

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
VH02 AML said:
The standard single plate clutch as an additional torsional vibration damper which eliminates/reduces driveline rattle. The replacement twin plate clutches do not have this additional damper and therefore once fitted then driveline and gear rattle will be the result.

Very few people talk about this when upgrading to the twin plate, but it should be no surprise.

This is the reason that AML have stuck with the single plate clutch because the vibration damper is not available in a twin plate.

You may ask why does the V12V not rattle with the twin plate, but it’s down to the firing order and torsional inputs from the V8 which are more severe than the V12.

I’m afraid there is no solution available other than returning to the oem single plate clutch. On the positive side, there is no risk of damage from the rattle.
Well it’s certainly a price worth paying, as you say it’d be good for this to be better known as a potential consequence, so upgraders can anticipate this effect. I’m happy; it’s all character and as said above, encouragement to enjoy other noises from higher revs! I can relax and enjoy...

V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
VH02 AML said:
The standard single plate clutch as an additional torsional vibration damper which eliminates/reduces driveline rattle. The replacement twin plate clutches do not have this additional damper and therefore once fitted then driveline and gear rattle will be the result.

This is the reason that AML have stuck with the single plate clutch because the vibration damper is not available in a twin plate.
That's very interesting. Thank you for that explanation. As someone who is not an engineer but has a bit of an engineering brain I like to know how these things work. Do you have a picture of the "additional torsional vibration damper" so I can see how it works?

Also, is there a fundamental reason why this item cannot be fitted to a twin plate clutch or is it just something like space/weight considerations?

VH02 AML said:
I’m afraid there is no solution available other than returning to the oem single plate clutch. On the positive side, there is no risk of damage from the rattle.
Personally, I'm very happy to put up with the noise as the performance benefits of the twin plate totally outweigh it for me. I think all most people want is to know that there isn't an "issue" and get an engineering explanation of what generates it. Thanks for clarifying on both of those.

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
V8V Pete said:
Personally, I'm very happy to put up with the noise as the performance benefits of the twin plate totally outweigh it for me. I think all most people want is to know that there isn't an "issue" and get an engineering explanation of what generates it. Thanks for clarifying on both of those.
Agreed, many thanks to all who have responded. There is so much experience and deep knowledge on this forum, it is amazing. The dealer also hadn’t mentioned this aspect of fitting the upgrade and I would have been puzzling about it... It’s interesting and reassuring to know the engineering behind ‘why’.

I was wondering whether Aston owners are more engineering minded than other Marques? Just a thought...