Beginners guide to shedding
Beginners guide to shedding
Author
Discussion

milb001

Original Poster:

62 posts

98 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Due to some bad-luck with a business venture, I'll be joining the shed fraternity within the next month or two.

It's been quite some time since I owned an older car and those I have owned have usually ended poorly (MX-5 - killed by rust, W124 lost lots of money on because no one wanted to buy it).

I'll be looking in the sub-£1500 category and using it almost solely for motorway commuting (around 60 miles round-trip daily).

I'm not overly fussed about running costs, but would like reliability, a degree of comfort and space. An estate would be nice, but not essential. I'm focussing on petrol cars to avoid the woes of older-diesel engines.

Cars which have caught my attention include;
-Skoda Octavia Estate (2005 ish, petrol, 110-150k)
-Saab 9-5 (2003 ish, petrol, 100-130k)
-Volvo V50 (2005 ish, petrol, 100-130k)
-Vauxhall Omega Estate (2000 ish, petrol or diesel, sub-100k)

These seem, to me, to tick the boxes of reliability and all seem that they should have enough life left in them to last me for a few years. My main questions are;
-Are there any particular makes/models which I should be looking at or avoiding
-Other than the usual used-car buying advice, is there anything to help make sure I buy a decent shed?


Stuart12

75 posts

132 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
It’s not pretty or luxurious in any way but our 15 year old Corolla estate costs pennies to run, never breaks down and refuses to die!!

MorganP104

2,605 posts

152 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Don't be afraid to look at the "premium" manufacturers with a £1,500 budget.

A bit of research and careful shopping around will net you a lovely E39 530i/540i Touring, for example. Similarly, if you can find a non-rusty Mercedes estate for £1,500, chew the seller's arm off, and there are some pretty sensible deals to be done on bigger engined Audi A4s and A6s.

The reason I'm recommending larger petrol engined cars is twofold.

1) Non-enthusiast used car buyers shy away from big sixes and V8s - they'd prefer a sensible four pot, preferably with a turbo. This keeps the prices of large-engined cars low, relative to their "lesser" brethren.

2) Larger engined cars usually came better specified from the factory. The theory here is that if the original buyer is splashing out for a straight six/V6/V8 engine, they are more inclined to specify leather, sat nav, upgraded stereo, heated seats, climate control, etc. However, this isn't always true, so don't just assume that a BMW/Merc V8 will have all the toys as standard - do your homework first.

KarlMac

4,616 posts

163 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Saab.

Saab every time.

anonymous-user

76 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
KarlMac said:
Saab.

Saab every time.
This, the 9-5 aero or estate is a excellent option, might I recommend 2.0T flavour.

Or a E39 528i/530i

smile

milb001

Original Poster:

62 posts

98 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
MorganP104 said:
Don't be afraid to look at the "premium" manufacturers with a £1,500 budget.

A bit of research and careful shopping around will net you a lovely E39 530i/540i Touring, for example. Similarly, if you can find a non-rusty Mercedes estate for £1,500, chew the seller's arm off, and there are some pretty sensible deals to be done on bigger engined Audi A4s and A6s.

The reason I'm recommending larger petrol engined cars is twofold.

1) Non-enthusiast used car buyers shy away from big sixes and V8s - they'd prefer a sensible four pot, preferably with a turbo. This keeps the prices of large-engined cars low, relative to their "lesser" brethren.

2) Larger engined cars usually came better specified from the factory. The theory here is that if the original buyer is splashing out for a straight six/V6/V8 engine, they are more inclined to specify leather, sat nav, upgraded stereo, heated seats, climate control, etc. However, this isn't always true, so don't just assume that a BMW/Merc V8 will have all the toys as standard - do your homework first.
Thanks. I think I was just trying to avoid unnecessarily expensive repair bills. Most of the above which I've looked at in my budget are higher mileage and have more toys on them (to go wrong). I'm trying to be sensible because I can't really afford any expensive bills for the next year or so.

There's plenty of W210 mercs in budget, but I know they can rust really badly and I know (from experience) that some terminal rust is just impossible to spot until it's too late. Do they hide anything bad, or is it mainly just front arches which rust on these?

milb001

Original Poster:

62 posts

98 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
KarlMac said:
Saab.

Saab every time.
Yes - they do seem popular with shedists, but I've heard lots of stories about Saabs having reliability issues. Is this not the case?

Phil Dicky

7,193 posts

285 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Just sold an E320 with 197,000 miles on the clock and was still going strong, so worth a mention and consideration.

VPXavier

115 posts

102 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
milb001 said:
... and have more toys on them (to go wrong). I'm trying to be sensible because I can't really afford any expensive bills for the next year or so.
That why I always look for manuals. Probably someone will disagree on that.

Gurgel used to say: What the car dont have cant go wrong.

MorganP104

2,605 posts

152 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
milb001 said:
MorganP104 said:
Don't be afraid to look at the "premium" manufacturers with a £1,500 budget.

A bit of research and careful shopping around will net you a lovely E39 530i/540i Touring, for example. Similarly, if you can find a non-rusty Mercedes estate for £1,500, chew the seller's arm off, and there are some pretty sensible deals to be done on bigger engined Audi A4s and A6s.

The reason I'm recommending larger petrol engined cars is twofold.

1) Non-enthusiast used car buyers shy away from big sixes and V8s - they'd prefer a sensible four pot, preferably with a turbo. This keeps the prices of large-engined cars low, relative to their "lesser" brethren.

2) Larger engined cars usually came better specified from the factory. The theory here is that if the original buyer is splashing out for a straight six/V6/V8 engine, they are more inclined to specify leather, sat nav, upgraded stereo, heated seats, climate control, etc. However, this isn't always true, so don't just assume that a BMW/Merc V8 will have all the toys as standard - do your homework first.
Thanks. I think I was just trying to avoid unnecessarily expensive repair bills. Most of the above which I've looked at in my budget are higher mileage and have more toys on them (to go wrong). I'm trying to be sensible because I can't really afford any expensive bills for the next year or so.

There's plenty of W210 mercs in budget, but I know they can rust really badly and I know (from experience) that some terminal rust is just impossible to spot until it's too late. Do they hide anything bad, or is it mainly just front arches which rust on these?
In terms of "expensive repair bills", fixing an older BMW or a Merc shouldn't cost any more than a "lesser" brand, as long as you steer well clear of franchised dealerships. Most independent garages will happily fix older premium cars at a similar price to anything else (barring complicated things like air suspension systems, etc.)

If you want the inside scoop on old Mercs, head over to the "Best Smoker Barges £1-5k" thread, as there's M-B beardage apently over there. thumbup

SebringMan

1,774 posts

208 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
VPXavier said:
That why I always look for manuals. Probably someone will disagree on that.

Gurgel used to say: What the car dont have cant go wrong.
You forgot about DMFs and cars with concentric slave cylinders then wink.

Pretty decent advice really. I'd keep your options open and get something petrol based. For me the collateral for a derv to go wrong is a bit too high for £1.5k. My friend was saying this about his Mk3 Mondeo. If anything goes wrong on it like the Turbo, injectors, injection pump etc. it'll cost basically what he paid for the car, which was £1k and it's not like they are unknown for going.



RSTurboPaul

12,716 posts

280 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
MorganP104 said:
A bit of research and careful shopping around will net you a lovely E39 530i/540i Touring, for example.
Are these not a bit unicorn, though? A look at AT and PH classifieds always seems to reveal a lot of very expensive, low-mileage cars, but only rarely a private sale at a price under a couple of grand!

Haddock82

563 posts

160 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Mondeo

I was in the same situation recently and needed a cheap car

Mondeo was really something i didn't want to do but I had slim pickings locally, so went to see one and test drive.

Admittedly they are fairly dull but it drives well, very comfy and should prove to be a reliable horse.

At £1500 you will have plenty to choose from! Some MK4 (high mileage) are slipping into the £1500 category too

Just look for service history, check the MOT history and buy the best condition you can find

I just bought 2004 (54 plate), FSH, 2 owners, very good condition, 1.8 petrol - £650

With the MK3 try to go post 2003 (when the did some revisions) and better than LX spec (LX, Zetec, Ghia, Ghia X) - Although mine is LX spec and OK!

Newer Shape MK4


Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

283 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Don't rule out French diesels - Particularly 407SW and Citroen C5 estates 1.6 is only marginally more economical than the 2.0 and only has a 5sp box compared to 6sp.

Comfortable and reliable if maintained sympathetically.

kurt535

3,560 posts

139 months

Tuesday 2nd January 2018
quotequote all
Toyota. They are out there and they will run and run.