V12 Vantage Manual or sportshift
Discussion
How good/bad is the sportshift in the V12? I have been driving an F430 with the F1 gearbox (paddles) and although not as good as the 458 wet clutch system, I still prefer it to a manual 430.
Now maybe looking to get a V12 Vantage and would like some opinions on which gearbox to choose. My head says 'manual' but there are fewer of them. If the sportshift is very good then maybe that's the choice?
Discuss...
I have had both (roadsters) and love them both in different ways. The SS3 is a great gearbox if used as a manual and I never use “D”.
I think the manual will hold its value better than the SS cars in the shorter term but the SS is the better sorted car with adaptive damping and the improvements that Aston build into their cars each year.
If I was you I would drive both and make your own mind up. It doesn’t really matter what others think it’s what you enjoy most that counts!
I think the manual will hold its value better than the SS cars in the shorter term but the SS is the better sorted car with adaptive damping and the improvements that Aston build into their cars each year.
If I was you I would drive both and make your own mind up. It doesn’t really matter what others think it’s what you enjoy most that counts!
Pretty much echo Ian’s comments.
I went from a Manual V8S ( SP10 ) to a 2015 V12S SS 3.
Both are / were driven daily.
The SS is much nicer if caught in traffic - much more relaxing and easier - paddles are fine 100% all the time although if I were speccing again I might go for the longer ones.
When pushing on the SS is great - slight toe curl when going a bit slower and changing gear but no need when driving hard.
Noise fabulous - especially with secondary decat.
It is an automated manual and clearly not technically the finest but think manual with no clutch and you won’t go far wrong.
Haven’t driven the manual V12 so cannot comment.
Have fun in choosing.
I went from a Manual V8S ( SP10 ) to a 2015 V12S SS 3.
Both are / were driven daily.
The SS is much nicer if caught in traffic - much more relaxing and easier - paddles are fine 100% all the time although if I were speccing again I might go for the longer ones.
When pushing on the SS is great - slight toe curl when going a bit slower and changing gear but no need when driving hard.
Noise fabulous - especially with secondary decat.
It is an automated manual and clearly not technically the finest but think manual with no clutch and you won’t go far wrong.
Haven’t driven the manual V12 so cannot comment.
Have fun in choosing.
Worth point out that the V12 Vantage was only available in 6spd Manual. The V12 Vantage S replaced it (and came with a whole raft of other improvements, such as increased power and 3 stage adaptive suspension too) and was initially only available in 7spd SSIII, and in the final year of production a 7spd (dogleg) manual joined the lineup, and finally the AMR V12 Vantage available in both 7spd (dogleg) manual and SSIII.
The V12 Vantage and V12 Vantage S SSIII were produced in similar numbers, but the SSIII cars are more available on the 2nd market because they are newer and havn't yet fallen into the hands of long term keepers as they will do in a few years. The 7spd doglegs are the rarest having only been produced for the final year of production. You max budget will largely decide which category you can choose to fall into.
As for which is better, well there are huge fans of all 3 types and each person here who owns one of the types will tell you that they believe their's is the best. The hard truth is of course is that the 7spd dogleg is the best!!!
(Opps, that's the one I own!
)
The answer really is to drive them all and decide for yourself which suits you. The SSIII is the best version of SS that AM have produced, I think we can all agree on that, but it is a semi-automated manual, not a full automatic or dual clutch system, so it takes some skill to get the best out of it and to drive it smoothly, hence why some reviews can be a little negative. Im not familiar with the F1 system in the 430 - is that a semi-automated manual too perhaps? Personally I wouldn't own a full auto or a dual clutch system car, but I would have bought a SSIII - that was until the dogleg manual was announced.
So, book them test drives and make your own mind up!
The V12 Vantage and V12 Vantage S SSIII were produced in similar numbers, but the SSIII cars are more available on the 2nd market because they are newer and havn't yet fallen into the hands of long term keepers as they will do in a few years. The 7spd doglegs are the rarest having only been produced for the final year of production. You max budget will largely decide which category you can choose to fall into.
As for which is better, well there are huge fans of all 3 types and each person here who owns one of the types will tell you that they believe their's is the best. The hard truth is of course is that the 7spd dogleg is the best!!!
(Opps, that's the one I own!
)The answer really is to drive them all and decide for yourself which suits you. The SSIII is the best version of SS that AM have produced, I think we can all agree on that, but it is a semi-automated manual, not a full automatic or dual clutch system, so it takes some skill to get the best out of it and to drive it smoothly, hence why some reviews can be a little negative. Im not familiar with the F1 system in the 430 - is that a semi-automated manual too perhaps? Personally I wouldn't own a full auto or a dual clutch system car, but I would have bought a SSIII - that was until the dogleg manual was announced.
So, book them test drives and make your own mind up!

Edited by AdamV12V on Tuesday 9th January 10:31
AdamV12V said:
Worth point out that the V12 Vantage was only available in 6spd Manual. The V12 Vantage S replaced it and was initially only available in 7spd SSIII, and in the final year of production a 7spd (dogleg) manual joined the lineup, and finally the AMR V12 Vantage available in both 7spd (dogleg) manual and SSIII.
The V12 Vantage and V12 Vantage S SSIII were produced in similar numbers, but the SSIII cars are more available on the 2nd market because they are newer and havn't yet fallen into the hands of long term keepers as they will do in a few years. The 7spd doglegs are the rarest having only been produced for the final year of production. You max budget will largely decide which category you can choose to fall into.
As for which is better, well there are huge fans of all 3 types and each person here who owns one of the types will tell you that they believe their's is the best. The hard truth is of course is that the 7spd dogleg is the best!!!
(Opps, that's the one I own!
)
The answer really is to drive them all and decide for yourself which suits you. The SSIII is the best version of SS that AM have produced, I think we can all agree on that, but it is a semi-automated manual, not a full automatic or dual clutch system, so it takes some skill to get the best out of it and to drive it smoothly, hence why some reviews can be a little negative. Im not familiar with the F1 system in the 430 - is that a semi-automated manual too perhaps? Personally I wouldn't own a full auto or a dual clutch system car, but I would have bought a SSIII - that was until the dogleg manual was announced.
So, book them test drives and make your own mind up!
This. The V12 Vantage and V12 Vantage S SSIII were produced in similar numbers, but the SSIII cars are more available on the 2nd market because they are newer and havn't yet fallen into the hands of long term keepers as they will do in a few years. The 7spd doglegs are the rarest having only been produced for the final year of production. You max budget will largely decide which category you can choose to fall into.
As for which is better, well there are huge fans of all 3 types and each person here who owns one of the types will tell you that they believe their's is the best. The hard truth is of course is that the 7spd dogleg is the best!!!
(Opps, that's the one I own!
)The answer really is to drive them all and decide for yourself which suits you. The SSIII is the best version of SS that AM have produced, I think we can all agree on that, but it is a semi-automated manual, not a full automatic or dual clutch system, so it takes some skill to get the best out of it and to drive it smoothly, hence why some reviews can be a little negative. Im not familiar with the F1 system in the 430 - is that a semi-automated manual too perhaps? Personally I wouldn't own a full auto or a dual clutch system car, but I would have bought a SSIII - that was until the dogleg manual was announced.
So, book them test drives and make your own mind up!

There are lots of pro's and con's with all models. I have a manual V12V and I love it - but I can see why others like the new V12S. Would say drive one and see.
Chris.
Or what’s the best shade of grey?
OP they’re all brilliant. My take:
Original 6 speed manual. Purest and safest long term bet.
V12VS SSIII. Best car by far.
V12VS 7 speed manual. Stick is a workaround to use the same 7 speed SSIII box.
I think you’ll find SSIII very similar to the F430 box.
Can’t beat being clamped into the car in lightweight seats, both hands on the wheel, banging up and down the gears with the paddles and listening to it roar.
Secondary decat is a must and use the parcel shelf to put parcels on in the garage.
Imagine how much fun you’ll have driving all three. I suggest in the above order and you’ll know which one is for you. I wouldn’t hang about too long.
OP they’re all brilliant. My take:
Original 6 speed manual. Purest and safest long term bet.
V12VS SSIII. Best car by far.
V12VS 7 speed manual. Stick is a workaround to use the same 7 speed SSIII box.
I think you’ll find SSIII very similar to the F430 box.
Can’t beat being clamped into the car in lightweight seats, both hands on the wheel, banging up and down the gears with the paddles and listening to it roar.
Secondary decat is a must and use the parcel shelf to put parcels on in the garage.
Imagine how much fun you’ll have driving all three. I suggest in the above order and you’ll know which one is for you. I wouldn’t hang about too long.
Great feedback......
The F430 F1 is a single plate dry clutch powered by an actuator...not ideal but faster changing than a manual. Sounds like the SSIII may be the best option. As for the seats (lol) I would prefer sports seats, but Mrs GG will say she wants the more comfortable ones
And finally, Grey doesn't float my boat... I kinda like lairy colours, :-)
GG
GG33 said:
Great feedback......
The F430 F1 is a single plate dry clutch powered by an actuator...not ideal but faster changing than a manual. Sounds like the SSIII may be the best option. As for the seats (lol) I would prefer sports seats, but Mrs GG will say she wants the more comfortable ones
And finally, Grey doesn't float my boat... I kinda like lairy colours, :-)
GG
Just FYI. The F430 F1 is a single plate dry clutch powered by an actuator...not ideal but faster changing than a manual. Sounds like the SSIII may be the best option. As for the seats (lol) I would prefer sports seats, but Mrs GG will say she wants the more comfortable ones
And finally, Grey doesn't float my boat... I kinda like lairy colours, :-)
GG
Sports seats are the standard fit. Optional lightweight seats, are the one piece carbon/kevlar "bucket". Plenty of threads/opinions on which are best! My vote is for the lightweights, but make sure you adjust them correctly, ie, leaned back, steering column extended, close enough to pedals (particularly in proper manual).
Oh, and I'd go SSlll........
GG33 said:
Great feedback......
The F430 F1 is a single plate dry clutch powered by an actuator...not ideal but faster changing than a manual. Sounds like the SSIII may be the best option. As for the seats (lol) I would prefer sports seats, but Mrs GG will say she wants the more comfortable ones
And finally, Grey doesn't float my boat... I kinda like lairy colours, :-)
GG
fyi - the Sports Seats are the comfortable ones, the lightweights are the bucket seats. Some (me included) actually find them more comfortable, as sports seats can be hard to set to comfy position for some.The F430 F1 is a single plate dry clutch powered by an actuator...not ideal but faster changing than a manual. Sounds like the SSIII may be the best option. As for the seats (lol) I would prefer sports seats, but Mrs GG will say she wants the more comfortable ones
And finally, Grey doesn't float my boat... I kinda like lairy colours, :-)
GG
Lairy you said.... hmmmm, OK, any excuse!

Just completed the very same, part exed my 430F1 roadster for a Vantage V12S roadster, the gear box's on both are very similar. I liked the F1 gearbox on the Ferrari and I like the SS111 on the Vantage. This acclaim for manual gearboxes leaves me cold, the 430 was designed with the F1 gearbox in mind, the manual was an afterthought with cable connections attached. The previous 360 manual gearbox was a different (better) animal. Why does anybody want to keep pressing on a clutch, the F1 and the SS111 makes a quicker gear change so why anybody requires a manual is beyond me. The SS111 is a good box, it does everything I want it to do. I understand that it is not as good as the Porsche PPK box ( I think that is what it is called) or as good as the VAG dual clutch system but it is more than competent. As the OP has a 430 I am sure he is aware that the 430 manuals command a premium in the markets, but the ridiculous markups for these is now descending. If you look on autotrader the manual Vantage V12S also seem to command a premium, so this also may affect your decision. If you were happy with the 430 F1 gearbox you will more than happy with the SS111.
Good luck with your purchase.
Good luck with your purchase.
Well, not much to add as everything has been said before!
I love SSIII, I wouldn't want a stick. Excellent gearbox as long as you treat it as a manual gearbox which it is, use paddles only, never use the D button which stands for Don't.
Slight easing of your foot from the throttle when changing gear unless you're going for it when the gearbox goes into Hypershift mode and you can just leave your foot to the floor while upshifting, great fun and very smooth.
I love SSIII, I wouldn't want a stick. Excellent gearbox as long as you treat it as a manual gearbox which it is, use paddles only, never use the D button which stands for Don't.
Slight easing of your foot from the throttle when changing gear unless you're going for it when the gearbox goes into Hypershift mode and you can just leave your foot to the floor while upshifting, great fun and very smooth.
mick996r said:
Just completed the very same, part exed my 430F1 roadster for a Vantage V12S roadster, the gear box's on both are very similar. I liked the F1 gearbox on the Ferrari and I like the SS111 on the Vantage. This acclaim for manual gearboxes leaves me cold, the 430 was designed with the F1 gearbox in mind, the manual was an afterthought with cable connections attached. The previous 360 manual gearbox was a different (better) animal. Why does anybody want to keep pressing on a clutch, the F1 and the SS111 makes a quicker gear change so why anybody requires a manual is beyond me. The SS111 is a good box, it does everything I want it to do. I understand that it is not as good as the Porsche PPK box ( I think that is what it is called) or as good as the VAG dual clutch system but it is more than competent. As the OP has a 430 I am sure he is aware that the 430 manuals command a premium in the markets, but the ridiculous markups for these is now descending. If you look on autotrader the manual Vantage V12S also seem to command a premium, so this also may affect your decision. If you were happy with the 430 F1 gearbox you will more than happy with the SS111.
Good luck with your purchase.
One concern I have with the roadster (which would be my natural choice) is lack of boot space. We tend to do one euro trip each year and could just about manage with the 430. My guess is that the V12 roadster has a smaller boot?Good luck with your purchase.
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff







