Vantage coupe v Roadster as everyday car ?
Vantage coupe v Roadster as everyday car ?
Author
Discussion

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
In my ongoing search for the right vantage I have really started to narrow down the search after driving a few.

It will be used as my everyday car ( 12k a year) I have other's such as defenders and other sports cars but this will be my main daily car.

It will be a sportshift ( drove a couple yesterday and was very happy with that for what I want) I really liked a coupe I drove but also looked at a roadster ( didn't drive it)

Has anyone lived with a roadster day to day? Mine will be left out in all weathers ( otherwise I won't use it !)

Basically, budget has been set to £40k sportshift, black, silver or grey with black or black and red interior and there are a few about.

Lastly is silver a popular colour or not i.e. are they harder to sell on ? Not planning on reselling but just seeing how colour sensitive they are ?

Thanks

Phib

nw28840

1,009 posts

210 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
I had a 55 plate Coupe for a year back in 2011, only sold in March 2012 as I bought a 2008 Roadster. Both were Tungsten Silver with obsidian interior, both had a manual gearbox.
The Roadster I owned exactly 4 years, bought at 48k miles and sold at 68k miles.
Both were private purchases and were sold privately with no delays or hassle. I sold the Roadster too cheap in hindsigh, but was happy enough with the deal and the buyer was more than happy.

I did run a second car for the last year, a £500 Alfa 147 as I got tired and frustrated by the supermarket car park dings - after watching people open car doors on two separate occasions into the Aston.
Both times I actually saw it happen , both times the people involved were scum of the lowest order and couldn’t have given a t*ss. Sad reflection on society but the cars were wonderful.

I’m not powerfully built’, used to joke with HWM Aston Martin that I was probably their poorest customer. I don’t have a garage so both cars lived outside all year round in allocated parking spaces.

I keep the Aston warranty running on the Roadster for the first 2 years , roof module and rear clear lamp replaced under warranty. I couldn’t put the car on a trickle charger when I was away for more than 10 days or so, flat battery meant a call to Aston assist and then also a trip to HWM to get the door mirrors reprogrammed (that used to grate a little after about the 5th time).

Both fantastic cars.......




johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
I’m not a fan of the sportshift, but the advantage is that they’re cheaper than a comparable manual, so you’ll get more for your money.

I’ve gone from coupe to roadster, and am pleased I did - more sense of occasion. With the hood up it’s quieter/more refined than the coupe (extra “stuff” around the rear arches/behind the seats). No leaks from the hood, so no reason it’s any less useable day to day except for there being less boot space.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
I ran a coupe for 83k miles and used it daily for a couple of years, even when not daily I was doing 3-6k miles in it. Had a Roadster for 18 months now and put 20k miles on it. I love the Roadster, its a different car with the roof down. No issues other than a MIL coming on shortly after buying it.

Not noticed any difference in daily use to be honest, apart from fair weather days where a few hour commute home becomes the scenic route, roof down and a smile on my face. The Roadster roof is really nice. Great design and with it down the car is one of the best looking out there.

Im not an sportshift fan, both manuals, with manual Roadsters being particularly rare you have to wait for the right car to come along.

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
Hi guys thanks for the swift and very comprehensive responses.

I have had a quick look at a couple of roadsters in the week / yesterday.

Really can’t live with a manual and I actually quite like the sportshift. There seems to be quite a difference in good ones and bad ones ( not sure if that’s just clutch wear though)

Like anything when you start narrowing down search you actually end up with very few cars ( heated seats seem to have been a bit of a rarer option)

There are two I quite like

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/...

And

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/...

Any thoughts?

Many thanks

Phib

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
Definitely the black car ....it will be harder to keep looking clean, but thats about the only downside. Its had a recent clutch which is great and better spec overall with premium audio and the carbon bits. The silver car is a more basic spec, you are paying a few grand more because of low miles...not necessarily a good thing - you may pay more just to have a clutch go sooner.

Yep, get the black one, looks spot on smile

Likeomg

164 posts

129 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
Phib from def2? wavey

We just wen't from a coupe which we had for 5 years to a roadster albeit as the Sunday car...

I loved our coupe, only thing due to the sub being under the passenger seat taller people could sometime struggle... i did plenty of long journeys in the passenger seat but anything taller than me would be a issue..

and the roadster also, passenger seat im slightly tighter again, only managed about 30 miles in it before back to work but can't wait for April...


My impression would be the coupe would be a better everyday car..

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
Thanks, yes phib from defender 2, I am planning on using my defender 50th for car parks etc and have just bought the oh an evoque so have most bases covered.

I need to drive the black car, made an appointment went to see it 50 mins away and the dealer didn’t want me to drive it as the roads were a bit muddy !!!

Also didn’t have the receipt for the clutch, hopefully he will be able to prove it’s had a clutch and also recent service stamp missing will drive this week. If it checks out

Thanks

Phib

justin220

5,764 posts

235 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
I've also ran both as my only car. Both for around 2 years each and the only real downside to the roadster is the smaller boot.

On the plus side taking the roof off makes it feel like a completely different car.

Coupe sounds better than the roadster when the roof is up, roadster sounds better when the roof is off.

alan powley

262 posts

163 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all


Roadster the only way to go .

Edited by alan powley on Sunday 21st January 19:20

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
I must get out and drive a roadster this week.

Re roadster pricing, looking at the moment, there is hardly anything in the prices between a roadster and a coupe. Is this normal ?

Or do the prices of roadsters increase relatively as the sun comes out ?

Phib

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 21st January 2018
quotequote all
phib said:
I must get out and drive a roadster this week.

Re roadster pricing, looking at the moment, there is hardly anything in the prices between a roadster and a coupe. Is this normal ?

Or do the prices of roadsters increase relatively as the sun comes out ?

Phib
I think the market is just slow at this time of year, so the prices converge a bit. I’ve been watching prices for the past 6 months during both selling and buying and would say that like-for-like you'd pay 10% extra for a Roadster, so £4k at your max budget. However, this may be just the rarer manual....not sure as I filtered out sportshifts in my searches.

Edited by johnnyBv8 on Monday 22 January 08:31