Vantage or 911?
Author
Discussion

bludger

Original Poster:

112 posts

109 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
I have BMW330ci coupe and am planning to change, hopefully this year. My initial thoughts were 435i, more or less straight replacement. However, I can't quite settle on this and am not really happy with this and have gradually drifted towards a 911. In another thread an AM Vantage owner made the remark that the 911 was a fairly anodyne car and that he preferred the Vantage and this is something I had never thought of.

I do 5000 miles a year; this is a DD and I'm not interested in tracking or exhaust noise etc etc. Is the Vantage a possible alternative and I'm thinking of spending around £40K on an automatic.

Thoughts/ advice?

RDMcG

20,920 posts

238 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
As a long term Porsche owner (admittedly the edgier versions) I would say that ,given your usage and not planing to track the car, the Aston might be a better choice. Nice car to drive on the road, nicely appointed, feels a bit more special than a Porsche that comes in a thousand different versions. I say this as a Porsche loyalistsmile

M5MarkM

1,686 posts

202 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
Wrong place to come for an unbiased opinion smile HOWEVER... If it were me I'd take the 911 over the vantage (ducks!) for that money. However if the budget is £40k you'll get a much newer and better equipped car in the 435.....

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all

By asking your question on this forum, you will already know our answer.

They are certainly special cars, not the fastest, but considered to be very high up in the beautiful stakes. Admired by so many road users, that it is remarkable how often other drivers stop to let an Aston Martin out of a side turning. Only a small thing, but an interesting aspect.

The Top Gear magazine sums up the Vantage well. The car that took on the Porsche 911 and lost, but the Aston is a brogue compared to the Porsche two a penny trainers.

You need to fully understand your word automatic. The Sportshift is an automated manual, and is Marmite. Some love it, others hate it. The usual suggestion here, is drive a Sportshift (test in stop/start traffic and slow manoeuvring), and a manual. Your price range will be the Sportshift 1 version. It has been improved in later models. You might find the manual clutch pedal quite heavy, but it can be upgraded to a twin plate clutch with a very light pedal, but will cost about £3,000 because the rear gearbox layout means a lot of labour is involved.

There are quite a number of people here who use their cars as DDs.

Have a look at depreciation. Vantages have been very steady for several years, even rising slightly recently.
My BMW is worth nothing. I should have bought an early M3.









Edited by Jon39 on Wednesday 31st January 18:57

wtdoom

3,742 posts

239 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
bludger said:
I have BMW330ci coupe and am planning to change, hopefully this year. My initial thoughts were 435i, more or less straight replacement. However, I can't quite settle on this and am not really happy with this and have gradually drifted towards a 911. In another thread an AM Vantage owner made the remark that the 911 was a fairly anodyne car and that he preferred the Vantage and this is something I had never thought of.

I do 5000 miles a year; this is a DD and I'm not interested in tracking or exhaust noise etc etc. Is the Vantage a possible alternative and I'm thinking of spending around £40K on an automatic.

Thoughts/ advice?
I'm a huge porsche and aston fan and have to say for 40k you will get a better porsche AUTOMATIC than an aston AUTOMATIC . 911 all day long for a 40 grand automatic daily driver

David W.

1,952 posts

240 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
I’ve got both. Had a trip from Cambridge to Norwich and back today and took the 911 without hesitation. Aston is nice when you want something pretty/posh to take out on a “occasion” but to drive the 911 wins any day of the week.
DW

davek_964

11,381 posts

206 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
I was the person in the other thread that the OP mentioned.
All I can say is that I enjoy driving my Vantage far more than the 911 turbo it replaced.

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
A friend of mine is a 911 fanatic, he had most of them. I drove all of what he had and for me they are sterile. Only the Turbo did something for me, other than that it was soul- less and pretty boring. Think: park car and look back as you walk away. With an Aston you would, with a Porsche? why would you?

Edited by macdeb on Wednesday 31st January 22:24


Edited by macdeb on Wednesday 31st January 22:25

juddcampbell

65 posts

117 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
I had a 996 Turbo prior to the DB9. totally different driving styles. I would track the Turbo but would not think of tracking the DB9

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
DB9? Question was Vantage,,,,

Phil74891

1,086 posts

164 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
I used to have a BMW 330 CI sport about 15 years ago. It was a manual and I hated it. It was just so boring. My wife had an S 2000 and we used to fight over it. Would never buy another BMW because of that car. My daily driver is an RS4. Magnificent apart from the fuel bills.

Anyway back to your question. If an automatic box is high on your list, then forget the Vantage. It’s stick shift or paddle shift (Sportshift) manual only. The paddle shift has an auto mode but it’s really ste. Sportshift box is excellent if you learn how to use it with the paddles.

Re running costs and depreciation I’m guessing the Vantage at this level will be the better bet.

I would test drive your three options in this order. Porsche, Aston, BMW.

You should quickly know. If I was only doing 5k miles a year the Aston would be an easy first choice. If I was doing 20k miles a year then the Aston would also be my first choice.

See if you can try both gear boxes in the Aston too.

Great choice to have!




HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Wednesday 31st January 2018
quotequote all
Aston! You feel like James Bond every time you drive one, as opposed to ??????

bludger

Original Poster:

112 posts

109 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
Many thanks for all your replies; as expected, intelligent and well informed and which have given me much food for thought, especially as regards the transmission issue (Sportshift). I think I'll add the AM to my saved searches on AT for the time being.

tgclowes

198 posts

147 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
I personally don't think I could DD my AMV8, would do my nut in.

davek_964

11,381 posts

206 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
tgclowes said:
I personally don't think I could DD my AMV8, would do my nut in.
Why?

Mine isn't a DD I guess, but I do sometimes use it as one for a week or two at a time. I think I'd be happy with it as a DD, apart from being paranoid about finding suitable parking spaces.

bludger

Original Poster:

112 posts

109 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
Why?

Mine isn't a DD I guess, but I do sometimes use it as one for a week or two at a time. I think I'd be happy with it as a DD, apart from being paranoid about finding suitable parking spaces.
This is a very relevant issue. On Youtube there's a guy who had a 911 which he loved but eventually got rid of it because it was a car that he became "anal" about. By this he meant he was always worrying where to park it or whether it would get stolen or keyed etc. His conclusion? Sell the 911 and get a cheaper but sprightlier car and reduce the "anal" factor.

djmac56

207 posts

207 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
I have a 2007 Vantage which I’ve had about 6 years and my wife has a 2005 Boxster S. The Porsche is much easier to drive around town (both cars are manual). In stop start M25 traffic in the Aston I have wanted to scream before because of the heavy clutch.

I used to have an additional car as a daily, but now just use the Aston as my daily so it can be done.

The Porsche (I know it’s not a 911, but still the same from the front seats forward) is much less tiring for me and extremely accomplished and gives confidence when driving.

The Aston is a nicer cabin, a much better sound, looks better and even after all these years feels “special” to arrive in at places. The Porsche doesn’t.

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
I've had 911's and now have a V8 Vantage S but none have been daily drivers.

Personally for a daily I'd go for the Porsche just because it will do the daily duties so well.

I think a lot of the stick 911's get for being a bit dull is just because they are so good at everything, they handle brilliantly and just by owning one you can tell everything is brilliantly engineered, ergonomics are great etc, etc.

I'm really enjoying my Aston but in a way it's because it isn't brilliant. It's loud (great for weekend hoons, maybe not for leaving the house at 05:30am to go to work), it has quirks, the handling is very good but not as refined as a 911, some of the interior design and features are anything but logical and I'm still not sure if and when it's going to break down again! Those things in a way make it more special.

As a daily I'd want 911 but as a weekend car the Aston tops my list.

davek_964

11,381 posts

206 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
bludger said:
davek_964 said:
Why?

Mine isn't a DD I guess, but I do sometimes use it as one for a week or two at a time. I think I'd be happy with it as a DD, apart from being paranoid about finding suitable parking spaces.
This is a very relevant issue. On Youtube there's a guy who had a 911 which he loved but eventually got rid of it because it was a car that he became "anal" about. By this he meant he was always worrying where to park it or whether it would get stolen or keyed etc. His conclusion? Sell the 911 and get a cheaper but sprightlier car and reduce the "anal" factor.
Whilst I would be very upset if it happened, my concerns are nothing to do with the car being stolen or keyed. My concerns with parking are simply people being careless with their doors etc. - therefore, I'm happy to park on the road (I park on the road at work, even though there is a car park) but less happy to park in car parks unless I can be sure I'm going to be able to park at the end, or away from other cars. Having said that, I did need a new front grill a year or so back because some muppet hit the front of the car when it was parked on the road in town......

steveway

947 posts

115 months

Thursday 1st February 2018
quotequote all
Prior to the V12V I had a Mitsubishi TME Evo, running 555bhp with a very heavy clutch, used it perhaps three times a week, had to be warmed up before you could actually drive it or it wouldn't go in gear. The V12V I also use three times or so but it is so much easier, the wife has a 2007 Boxter 3.4 which is a nice drive, not as quick and certainly doesn't hold the road presence as the Aston does, if I had to use the V12V every day I think it would be fine apart from the parking risks.