Misting Lights
Author
Discussion

spyker138

Original Poster:

930 posts

255 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Sorry to bring this up again - it's been discussed a lot I know. My question is about what should be covered by warranty.

I bought a V12V from top notch heritage independent dealer for top notch price (part of a complex exchange) with all the usual promises of inspections, checklists and a year's warranty. Both rear lights showed condensation in the first rain, and the front ones are now bad given the weather is colder. From what I have read it seems accepted wisdom on here and AMOC forum that the front ones do that, and there is a technical bulletin to stuff dessicant in them, while with the rears it is a fault that should be fixed as eventually the lights do fail to work.

The dealer is saying the lights are not faulty, but merely have problems, so are not covered. I am getting nowhere with discussing this with them amicably, they seem to be happy to lose a customer (of heritage Astons as well as Gaydon) rather than replace the units.

What am I missing? Am I being unreasonable to expect a V12V with 20k miles on it from a dealer to have lenses that are not misted up?


RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
In my experience the front ones do all most up, from the DB5 right up to the new AMR. I’m guessing the outer “shape” just isn’t airtight (the DB5 faired-in lens leak water when the car is washed)

Tbh on all the cars I’ve just decided to live with it; I’m not going to put silica in there as it’s only going to cure the problem for about 5 minutes.

I’ve never had a set of rears that mist though. Maybe someone on here can comment on what damage that might do longer term if left?

Big Ry

1,682 posts

150 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
I've seen the rears go......

Issue you're going to have is that I suspect AML cover this as more of a goodwill issue as it happens so often. The fact that you bought from an independent may well mean that they're correct.....in that the item isn't technically broken.

Still, if it’s a proper heritage dealer then I’d have expected that their in house warranty should mirror that of AML’s..........but maybe I’m deluded.

Edited by Big Ry on Monday 19th February 16:23

steveway

947 posts

115 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
fronts mist up but then at Haynes last week and there was a McLaren with exactly the same problem

Big Ry

1,682 posts

150 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
However the dealer saying they’re not broken, they have problems...........that’s the kind of crap you expect to hear from car supermarkets, not heritage dealers.

So if your car only starts 50% of the time, would they say it’s not broken it just has problems and refuse to fix it.

If what you’re saying is true, then it does seem a bit off, but I guess it comes down to small print and interpretation of the warranty.

Perhaps take it to a MD and ask if it would be covered under an AML warranty or not. If yes, then that may give you some leverage with the Indy.

northernmedia

1,988 posts

169 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
I got my clear rears replaced under warranty, no quibble.
Noticeable droplets / misting etc.

I think the car was then 2 1/2 years old.

I bought from an Indy but have a good relationship with my local main dealer.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
When you bought the car the dealer should have supplied you with the warranty policy. Just ring the underwriter and ask them if the lights are covered?

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Surprised to hear this about this dealer !

spyker138

Original Poster:

930 posts

255 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
cayman-black said:
Surprised to hear this about this dealer !
I'm not naming the dealer, just checking if my expectation is out of sorts with reality! It's not really about checking the fine print of a warranty policy either - I may be old fashioned but when you do deals in the multiple six figures with an outfit purporting to be gentlemanly then it comes as a bit of a surprise to be short changed on something fairly basic. May as well buy for price alone (or go to auction) and underwrite the warranty myself...

dbs2000

2,756 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
Put a call into AM HQ.
The lights will eventually take in water, so you'll see it sloshing around which in turn will cause them to fail. All 4 of the Aston's I've owned have had condensation issues.

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
spyker138 said:
I'm not naming the dealer, just checking if my expectation is out of sorts with reality! It's not really about checking the fine print of a warranty policy either - I may be old fashioned but when you do deals in the multiple six figures with an outfit purporting to be gentlemanly then it comes as a bit of a surprise to be short changed on something fairly basic. May as well buy for price alone (or go to auction) and underwrite the warranty myself...
I fully agree with you, hence the surprise.

divetheworld

2,565 posts

166 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
Have a wander round a main dealers outside stock and note how many have the 'issue'. It's not a matter of faulty lights, more a matter of design and physics.
Condensation forms when warm, moisture laden air comes in contact with a cool surface. Just like breathing on your windows at home on a cold day. The issue is prevalent with many fared headlights. It's just physics.
When the outside temperatures are low, you assume the inside will be the same even when the car has been stood. However, the inside is black and behind a clear cover. The sun shines on the light and the IR is absorbed by the black plastic inside and the temperature is raised. Greenhouse!
Warm gas is able to hold more water vapour than cool air. This can be likened to a sponge - the warmer the gas, the larger the sponge. If you warm the air more, it can hold more water. As that air hits the cold outer 'glass' it forms condensation. Artificially heating the gas inside does not fix the issue. If you warm it sufficiently, you warm the glass and condensation is inhibited from forming, but the water vapour is still there. Actually, its worse as there is more water inside due to the larger 'sponge'. The moment you stop heating the gas, the condensation comes back worse than ever.
What we are talking about here is dewpoint and gas saturation. If you want to stop condensation, you need to either reduce the water vapour saturation or change the dewpoint.
The misconceptions are that if you blow air through the light, you dry it out. This is not so unless you blow through with dry air. Blowing atmospheric air through only changes the temperature because its just as wet as the air inside. Here's the kicker. If you do dry it our with dry air, the moment you stop blowing air through, ambient air with all that water vapour rushes in. You cant stop it unless you make the light air-tight and seal in the dry air. And if we did this, then when the light is warmed up, the air inside expands and the light has pressure related 'issues' like cracks.

So its a lost cause? Well, no, not exactly. Combinations of things can reduce or virtually eliminate the condensation.
1. Seal the light as much as possible. This prevents any moisture but relative humidity getting in. If you have seen a Gaydon light outside the car, you will see this is a difficult proposition.
2. Let the light breathe. Using a hydrophobic membrane will allow pressure differentials and water vapour to escape but not let much in. Much like Gore-Tex clothing.
3. Reduce the IR effect on the light. Coat the lens with heat reflecting coatings. Reduce the black inside and properly heat-sink the light producing element.
4. Dry the air inside the lamp. Silica and other absorbents can help but only for a short term or polishing effect and only work once. Dry air can be found and piped in but this is often a bit of a mission. Sources are from the AC or cabin or from a separate air-con.

We make 'stuff' for a number of markets, one of which is systems for sub-sea and defence applications. As part of these operations, we designed a product we patented which is essentially a small solid state air conditioner that is about the size of a packet of cigarettes. Even with this device fitted, we still get condensation forming when the car is parked and it is turned off.

sundayjumper

531 posts

313 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
spyker138 said:
The dealer is saying the lights are not faulty, but merely have problems...
Sorry, I shouldn't laugh, but that has made me chuckle !

I guess what they mean is that the lights light up, therefore they are not faulty. You'd need them to actually fail to work before it's a warranty issue.


spyker138

Original Poster:

930 posts

255 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
sundayjumper said:
I guess what they mean is that the lights light up, therefore they are not faulty. You'd need them to actually fail to work before it's a warranty issue.
That's it exactly. Clearly (!) aesthetics are not important.

spyker138

Original Poster:

930 posts

255 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
divetheworld said:
It's not a matter of faulty lights, more a matter of design and physics.
Condensation forms when warm, moisture laden air comes in contact with a cool surface. Just like breathing on your windows at home on a cold day. The issue is prevalent with many fared headlights. It's just physics.
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I understand that it's about design and physics, and I'd assert it's also about quality of manufacture; but that affects all parts of getting a car to perform and applies to all manufacturers. My kids Subaru, Jetta and Mini all have sealed lights that do not mist up. None of my other cars over the past twenty years have done so. AM need to do better.

That aside, I am even willing to accept that there is a design or manufacture flaw that gradually causes this to happen over time. What I do not accept is that I should have it on a car supplied fresh from a reputable dealer, where I did not negotiate on the price and paid top whack. Nor do I think in such a situation where it is pointed out that said dealer should start quibbling about the wording of a warranty. But I'm getting over it.

I'm now looking for an MGB GT V8 now as a potential replacement!! The rear light lenses have rubber seals that stop them misting.

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
MGBGTV8 my boss had one of those in 1980, bright orange and in perfect condition, i loved it.

Cold

16,750 posts

121 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
spyker138 said:
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I understand that it's about design and physics, and I'd assert it's also about quality of manufacture; but that affects all parts of getting a car to perform and applies to all manufacturers. My kids Subaru, Jetta and Mini all have sealed lights that do not mist up. None of my other cars over the past twenty years have done so. AM need to do better.

That aside, I am even willing to accept that there is a design or manufacture flaw that gradually causes this to happen over time. What I do not accept is that I should have it on a car supplied fresh from a reputable dealer, where I did not negotiate on the price and paid top whack. Nor do I think in such a situation where it is pointed out that said dealer should start quibbling about the wording of a warranty. But I'm getting over it.

I'm now looking for an MGB GT V8 now as a potential replacement!! The rear light lenses have rubber seals that stop them misting.
The fronts will mist as a feature, as explained - and it's only temporary. The rears are leaking and shouldn't be. Their seal has failed.

LordBretSinclair

4,306 posts

208 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
cayman-black said:
MGBGTV8 my boss had one of those in 1980, bright orange and in perfect condition, i loved it.
I had one the same and loved it smile



spyker138

Original Poster:

930 posts

255 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
LordBretSinclair said:
I had one the same and loved it smile


Yep I am after that colour too - Bracken. I miss my DB4 more than I like the V12V so figure maybe the MG will scratch that itch for a 20th of the price and of course I can play with it without panicking too much.

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Tuesday 20th February 2018
quotequote all
LordBretSinclair said:
I had one the same and loved it smile


Yes , lovely!