How easy is it to replace front upper wishbone (2006 V8V)?
How easy is it to replace front upper wishbone (2006 V8V)?
Author
Discussion

davek_964

Original Poster:

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
Car is in for a service.

They have listed a few items, most of which I intend to do myself. However - they've mentioned that the o/s/f upper wishbone needs replacing because the bush moves in the arm. (Not enough to cause an MOT failure 2 weeks ago).

I can do stuff to the car but I've never messed about with wishbones. How hard is it to change one? Any guides online? (Search didn't find one)

sundayjumper

531 posts

313 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
Apart from the usual caveat about seized fasteners I can't see it being too difficult ?


PatCub

250 posts

147 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all

davek_964

Original Poster:

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
Thanks a lot.

I think that might have convinced me I don't want to do it on my drive!

BamfordMike

1,192 posts

188 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
Car is in for a service.

They have listed a few items, most of which I intend to do myself. However - they've mentioned that the o/s/f upper wishbone needs replacing because the bush moves in the arm. (Not enough to cause an MOT failure 2 weeks ago).

I can do stuff to the car but I've never messed about with wishbones. How hard is it to change one? Any guides online? (Search didn't find one)
Bush creep on any of the 4 upper / 4 lower wishbone arms will occur at some point in time (sooner if driven more spiritedly, later if the car is GT cruiser) on pretty much every Gaydon era non AMG car ever built.

MOT test can’t really fail the arm because there is no play, so it’s no surprise that it’s passed MOT but 2 weeks later is spotted on inspection.

There is no safety critical risk, there will be no play, no clonk or bang and nothing will fall off. The arm walks to one side of the mounting plate and the bush the other until hard-stop is reached and can creep out no more. Cars with bush wear will be slow to change direction at speed because of the slack in the arm / bush. There will probably be creaking over speed bumps and steering geometry will progressively go out of spec.

The upper arms is an Easy job though, it’s the lower arms which can be a swine and needs a geometry set up afterwards

davek_964

Original Poster:

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
BamfordMike said:
Bush creep on any of the 4 upper / 4 lower wishbone arms will occur at some point in time (sooner if driven more spiritedly, later if the car is GT cruiser) on pretty much every Gaydon era non AMG car ever built.

MOT test can’t really fail the arm because there is no play, so it’s no surprise that it’s passed MOT but 2 weeks later is spotted on inspection.

There is no safety critical risk, there will be no play, no clonk or bang and nothing will fall off. The arm walks to one side of the mounting plate and the bush the other until hard-stop is reached and can creep out no more. Cars with bush wear will be slow to change direction at speed because of the slack in the arm / bush. There will probably be creaking over speed bumps and steering geometry will progressively go out of spec.

The upper arms is an Easy job though, it’s the lower arms which can be a swine and needs a geometry set up afterwards
Thanks, very useful info.

S1-NOS

116 posts

107 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
I take it you can’t remove the upper arm, press the bushes out and replace them, rather than change the whole arm? Or are the bushes not available separately?

davek_964

Original Poster:

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
S1-NOS said:
I take it you can’t remove the upper arm, press the bushes out and replace them, rather than change the whole arm? Or are the bushes not available separately?
From a thread I read earlier - no. They're not available and you have to do the entire arm.

S1-NOS

116 posts

107 months

Tuesday 6th March 2018
quotequote all
Fair enough smile