Help with Wifi.....Ubiquiti Unifi??
Help with Wifi.....Ubiquiti Unifi??
Author
Discussion

33q

Original Poster:

1,630 posts

154 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
Help me with my wifi……

Background

• I have a Virgin Media Hub 3 on 200 Mbps

• I have lots of devices….Echos, CCTV, TVs, TP Link switches, Hive heating etc plus laptops, tablets, Phones etc….so quite a bit of demand

• To improve internet speed and drop outs I have installed several Powerline extenders to give Wifi and additional ports for TV etc. All the extenders are ‘cloned’ to the same name/password as the VM hub.

• Ipads and Iphones tend to hang onto on particular connection until grim death before switching to another connection. Android devices seem better able to switch connection to get a better signal.

Despite trying to create an improved service throughout my house my internet connections are still not that good.

I’m prepared to spend a reasonable amount on getting a really good service around the house, garden and of course my garage/workshop….this is Pistonheads after all!!

Because lots of switches are set to the VM hub and its clones I’d like to construct a system that I could gradually transfer devices as time and need permit.


My proposal is to buy a Unifi AP AC lite and plug this into a spare port on my Modem/Router….but leave the VM Wifi still transmitting. Also leave the Hive, CCTV and the TP link extender plugged in too.

This should create me a new network….perhaps a bit sapped of performance ….but at least working.

An Alternative is to buy a Unifi Mesh device, connected as above, then adding additional APs as/if required

When I have switched over all devices to the Unifi kit I would insert a switch between the VM Modem and the Unigi kit and switch off the router/wifi elements. Maybe I should do this initially???

Your comments and advice welcome

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
My network was previously a mixture of Apple Airports, Airport expresses, powerlines adapters, etc.

None of it really worked properly, so I replaced with 2 x Unifi AP LR, keeping the Airport Extreme as the router but with wifi off. I ran an ethernet cable outside from study to the loft so that the second AP LR was hardwired.

The whole system is brilliant - now have fast wifi everywhere in the house and also covers most of the garden. Like you, I'd also planned on eventually replacing the router, but haven't bothered as what I've got now works perfectly well.

I'd recommend looking at the LR over the Lite if you want decent coverage across your garden.

megaphone

11,723 posts

282 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
If you're using Unifi then the APs really need to be hard wired back to the router, or run through power line adaptors. The newish Unifi mesh products are really designed for outdoor deployment, I'm waiting for a proper indoor mesh AP.

Have a look at alternative mesh products, BT do one or Google. I've heard good reports

33q

Original Poster:

1,630 posts

154 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
ladderino said:
My network was previously a mixture of Apple Airports, Airport expresses, powerlines adapters, etc.

None of it really worked properly, so I replaced with 2 x Unifi AP LR, keeping the Airport Extreme as the router but with wifi off. I ran an ethernet cable outside from study to the loft so that the second AP LR was hardwired.

The whole system is brilliant - now have fast wifi everywhere in the house and also covers most of the garden. Like you, I'd also planned on eventually replacing the router, but haven't bothered as what I've got now works perfectly well.

I'd recommend looking at the LR over the Lite if you want decent coverage across your garden.
Good advice thank you.

Did you give your 2 APs the same name/password or do you still have to manually change your phone etc to the two separate APs?

Paper Lawyer

251 posts

260 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
Just to add my positive feedback for the Ubiquiti AP set up:

I was previously using a Netgear R6300 router in my lounge and a repurposed additional router as an additional access point on my first floor (both hardwired to a switch in my loft). I also used a BT powerline wifi hotspot to extned wifi to the garage. I was annoyed with the handoff between APs and so I bit the bullet at Christmas and bought the AC Pro (well, actually I bought the LR but the POE injector appears to fail after a few weeks so I returned to Amazon (zero hassle) and upraded to the Pro).

I also repurposed a raspberry pi lying around, unused, to act as the Unifi controller so I could have the stats dashboard (it is possible to set up the APs simply by using a mobile app). I used the Netgear router simply for DHCP purposes (relocating it and the Openreach modem to the loft space, just so all the boxes deemed "ugly" by my wife are out of sight).

More recently, I've been annoyed that the dashboard does not include latency and throughput figures so I bought the Unifi Security Gateway as well.

Right now I'm eyeing up the ceiling on the 2nd floor of my house as the AP is located on the 1st floor in the centre of the house and I'd like to improve the signal up here and also give some signal to my drive (for setting up Waze when I get in the car and snycing my bike rides recorded on my Wahoo Elemnt). I also like the idea of a second AP on the dashboard...it is addictive...

PS One SSID for all APs and both 2.4 and 5Ghz channels - the APs will auto select.

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
33q said:
ladderino said:
My network was previously a mixture of Apple Airports, Airport expresses, powerlines adapters, etc.

None of it really worked properly, so I replaced with 2 x Unifi AP LR, keeping the Airport Extreme as the router but with wifi off. I ran an ethernet cable outside from study to the loft so that the second AP LR was hardwired.

The whole system is brilliant - now have fast wifi everywhere in the house and also covers most of the garden. Like you, I'd also planned on eventually replacing the router, but haven't bothered as what I've got now works perfectly well.

I'd recommend looking at the LR over the Lite if you want decent coverage across your garden.
Good advice thank you.

Did you give your 2 APs the same name/password or do you still have to manually change your phone etc to the two separate APs?
Same SSID and same password, the software lets you bridge. Devices automatically shift between the two APs.

I've also barely touched it since I set it up, all just works.

33q

Original Poster:

1,630 posts

154 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
Many thanks. I've ordered a Pro and an LR

That's my wet bank holiday sorted.

Murph7355

42,082 posts

287 months

Friday 30th March 2018
quotequote all
The LR isn't the best buy and is suited to limited use cases (I speak as someone who made the mistake of buying 4 of them...).

They work fine, but are more expensive and don't really give you "long range" - your devices have to have strong radios to talk back at long distance wink

You're better having more, normal APs.

As a poster notes above, Unifi don't really do a full on mesh product, which is a shame. They half implemented one through Zero Handoff. But that didn't work that well.

Fast Roaming that they now have works OK. But it's not true mesh - which I'd regard as APs working together to give not only seamless coverage but also the best coverage and performance for the APs deployed automatically.

The kit is very robust and stable. And aesthetically looks great (considering these things will be on display, that's not to be ignored). It's significantly better than relying on an inbuilt wifi/modem/router for more than the smallest houses IMO (I have a Draytek Vigor, widely regarded as a very good device, with better aerials fitted and it barely covered a third of my house - I now have full coverage), but I still have nagging doubts that I'm getting the most out of my set up. Unfortunately I don't have enough spare time to experiment and test things more empirically.


andyb

147 posts

315 months

Saturday 31st March 2018
quotequote all
I've used homeplugs for years. Usually work brilliantly for anything static (TV, desktops, NAS, consoles etc), but wifi was a bit hit and miss. Good router plus multiple homeplug wifi extenders 'works' but whether you use different SSIDs or set them all to be the same, there is a tendency for phones and laptops to be connected to the wrong access point and get slow speeds.

With ever more wi-fi connected devices in our home, decided to bite the bullet and move to a mesh solution. Netgear or Linksys seem to come out top, but the shape of my house means need quite a few mesh routers and that would have worked out very expensive.

So went with BT whole home - 4 access points for £200 isn't cheap (and BT isn't the best of the options)... but the reviews had it as 'pretty good' and relative value for money.

So far been very happy with it - 30Mbps everywhere in the house, auto connection to the best band / connection point - plus the homeplugs still used for anything really static or needing faster connection.

Paper Lawyer

251 posts

260 months

Tuesday 3rd April 2018
quotequote all
The Unifi Cloud Key (i.e. the purpose built controller) is down to £67.80 on Amazon - pretty much the lowest it has ever been according to CamelCamelCamel - I took advantage of the "£5 off if spending £25 offer" amazon Assistant offer (see HotUKDeals) to chip the price down further - now sitting on my desk, awaiting my return home.

told you it was addictive....

Edited by Paper Lawyer on Tuesday 3rd April 15:29

Dr Doofenshmirtz

16,952 posts

231 months

Tuesday 3rd April 2018
quotequote all
I've got 3x Unifi AP's in the house - no issues with it.
If you get the Pro version, they have a second network port which you can daisy chain to another AP etc.

Paper Lawyer

251 posts

260 months

Tuesday 3rd April 2018
quotequote all
Yes, I used the daisy chaining capability yesterday - I had an existing Cat5E cable run externally down the side of the house to a socket on the ground floor. I wanted to mount a second AP in the same room as the socket so I cut the cable running down the wall, ran it into the ceiling void (a nervous 20 minutes when I couldn't fine the access hole within the ceiling and thought I may have miscalculated and drilled into the room above....), installed the AP, ran a new cable from the secondary port back out and down the wall, back into the wall socket. I believe the secondary socket is not PoE though (which was fine for my purposes).

maccas99

1,849 posts

219 months

Tuesday 3rd April 2018
quotequote all
Another Unifi user here, 2 x AP Lite's cover the house (bungalow with solid walls) and I have one in my garden office which now provides Wi-Fi for the rear garden.

Never experienced any issues, the management software is a bit restrictive (i.e. locked to a specific device), that's the only (small) negative.

silentbrown

11,027 posts

147 months

Tuesday 3rd April 2018
quotequote all
Very happy with my Unifi setup here:
1 x Cloud Key (ebay bargain smile
1 x Unifi Security Gateway
1 x Unifi AP-AC-LR

Cloud Key and AP powered by a D-Link POE hub.

I had a couple of the previous gen LR's which used 24v POE. The new model is much improved.

I tried adding a Unifi mesh unit but found that it actually made connections slower!

dhutch

17,960 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
Looking to go down this route myself, Scan have the AC-Lite on for £74 so I am thinking of getting two, which will hopefully cover house garden and garage. Worst case I get a third.

They also do a £60 version, which I can find little about online, but ringing them they have got back to confirm its basically a 2.4 GHz only AC-Lite.

Cloud key is £72.50 at which point I think I will set it up via the software from what I have read.



Daniel

S6PNJ

5,867 posts

312 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
Funny you should bring this up, I'm just looking at Ubiquiti as well - Lambda Tec have them slightly cheaper - I've used Lambda Tec in the past, so a reputable site.
https://www.lambda-tek.com/Ubiquiti-Networks-UAP-A...

dhutch

17,960 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
S6PNJ said:
Funny you should bring this up, I'm just looking at Ubiquiti as well - Lambda Tec have them slightly cheaper - I've used Lambda Tec in the past, so a reputable site.
https://www.lambda-tek.com/Ubiquiti-Networks-UAP-A...
I must say that for £2.50 I think I would just buy them from Scan, who are excellent in every way.

Have found them on ebay sold as new for £55 by sellers with a reasonable number of reviews, which is tempting but you would kick yourself if it went pete tong.


Daniel

Somebody

1,767 posts

114 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
dhutch said:
Cloud key is £72.50 at which point I think I will set it up via the software from what I have read.

Daniel
You don't need cloudkey. If you have a spare raspberry pi you can install the controller software on that.

Or you could buy the UAP from broadbandbuyer to include a 3-Year Hosted Cloud Controller.

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
Or just run it on a PC. Unless you're making changes or doing time-based things (like having a kids SSID that switches off at certain times) the software doesn't need to be running all the time for the APs to work. I just run it up if I'm changing or updating something.

dhutch

17,960 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
sjg said:
Or just run it on a PC.
Broadband buyer are charging £80 vs ££72 so I guess that's £12 for three years on, no idea if that's a worth while spend having never used the software.

15yo me would likely have had a Raspberry Pi but 31yo me with a full time job, too many hobbies and a house project just wants there phones wifi to work.


Daniel