GT4 to V12VS, will i like the gearbox?
GT4 to V12VS, will i like the gearbox?
Author
Discussion

monaco1981

Original Poster:

146 posts

174 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Have become obsessed with the V12 Vantage S recently and looking at the market I can afford a good condition sportshift III model. I currently have a Porsche GT4, which I love. It would have to be a swap plus cash situation.

Have watched a fair few videos on youtube and it seems the gearbox is the one thing that would put me off the change. Any thoughts on this and what do people think about changing a mint GT4 (with all of the options) for a similar aged Vantage. I am guessing that both cars will likely hold their value at a similar rate, although I don't mind a bit of depreciation if the experience is better.

Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
This is going to be good!
Do you like the gearbox in your Porsche? If the answer is yes, you will hate the AM gearbox and wonder how they could dare to put it into a 21st Century car.
I went through the same process after a Ferrari 458.
My advice. Get a manual

Gday2

219 posts

154 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Just try it for at least a couple of hours to get familiar with it, then make your decision.
Just my two cents
Christian

PS: I love it smile

Felonious

392 posts

205 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
It's a personal thing, but I love the gearbox in my V12VS SSIII. I have never driven in auto - always on the paddles - and find it smooth, adequately fast and genuinely delightful to use. Sure, it's not as fast as a PDK 'box, but that doesn't worry me at all.

jonby

5,367 posts

188 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Ex Boy Racer said:
This is going to be good!
Do you like the gearbox in your Porsche? If the answer is yes, you will hate the AM gearbox and wonder how they could dare to put it into a 21st Century car.
I went through the same process after a Ferrari 458.
My advice. Get a manual
I'm assuming though tht the Porsche has a manual box ? Did GT4 have a PDK option ?

If so, arguably the SS in V12VS is closer to a manual box than a PDK in terms of how you drive the car

Also, the one criticism of the GT4 is the gearing - no such criticism in V12VS

Having said that, no question that it feels antiquated. But not necessarily in a bad way

As others have said, no question you must take out an extended test drive to find out for yourself as it really is so subjective and personal

monaco1981

Original Poster:

146 posts

174 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Felonious said:
It's a personal thing, but I love the gearbox in my V12VS SSIII. I have never driven in auto - always on the paddles - and find it smooth, adequately fast and genuinely delightful to use. Sure, it's not as fast as a PDK 'box, but that doesn't worry me at all.
This is what I am hoping for. Not driven an Aston before so will have to take one for a test drive.



IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Get yourself a test drive. Do not drive in “D” use the paddles and think of it as a manual lifting very slightly as you change gear. It is a very analog car and the noise it makes is fantastic. It is even better if you decat it and then get a remote switch to keep the valves open all the time. If you love noise consider the roadster version. Oops, perhaps I have moved on a few steps smile

Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
I assumed OP was moving from a double-clutch.
If he's moving from a manual, it will be interesting. I tested after my 458's double-clutch which was superb and could not get over just how poor the Sportshift was in comparison.
If I'd tested after my R10 manual, I might have thought differently.
(Not knocking it before I get the hate! Just telling it as I felt it)

GT8-V12SM

13 posts

103 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Last year I drove a GT4 and a V12SM through summer. The GT4 was nearly track use only, the V12S is daily driver.
This year i only wanted one manual car. So i sold the GT4 and kept the V12SM.

The Gt4 is much more smoother and more precice to shift than the one in the V12. It is also faster and easier.
But i like the amshift also a lot and the reward you get from the car. I did now about 15Tkm with the Vantage...

The GT4 was no keeper, the V12SM is it for sure!

Felonious

392 posts

205 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
IanV12VR said:
Get yourself a test drive. Do not drive in “D” use the paddles and think of it as a manual lifting very slightly as you change gear. It is a very analog car and the noise it makes is fantastic. It is even better if you decat it and then get a remote switch to keep the valves open all the time. If you love noise consider the roadster version. Oops, perhaps I have moved on a few steps smile
Yes! All of this. Well, I bought a coupe, but Bamford Rose removed two clearly unnecessary cats and a remote switch thing from cccharger acts as a nice volume control. It has two options: 'wonderful', and 'my god, that's gorgeous. And quite loud, too.'

Back to the gearbox, I was previously in a Maserati Granturismo running 599 GTO TCU software and in my humble the SSIII is every bit as good. Admittedly not as fast on high revs full-throttle upshifts, but it's in no way to the detriment of the driving experience.

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
GT8-V12SM said:
Last year I drove a GT4 and a V12SM through summer. The GT4 was nearly track use only, the V12S is daily driver.
This year i only wanted one manual car. So i sold the GT4 and kept the V12SM.

The Gt4 is much more smoother and more precice to shift than the one in the V12. It is also faster and easier.
But i like the amshift also a lot and the reward you get from the car. I did now about 15Tkm with the Vantage...

The GT4 was no keeper, the V12SM is it for sure!
Thought the OP was after an SS3 car not a manual Aston?

alscar

10,088 posts

244 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Trying to compare the 2 cars is pretty difficult let alone whether manual or automated manual.
I think Ians comments pretty much sum up the SS3 box.
Fwiw I have a manual GT3 and a ss3 V12S but its the whole experience and noise not just the physical changing of gears that Aston brings to the table.
If I had the GT4 and had to choose one of them to keep then for me the Aston would win hands down.
Drive one and see but don't drive for 5 minutes and decide.
Either's hardly a terrible problem so have fun deciding.

J12KJR

2,860 posts

274 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Felonious said:
It's a personal thing, but I love the gearbox in my V12VS SSIII. I have never driven in auto - always on the paddles - and find it smooth, adequately fast and genuinely delightful to use. Sure, it's not as fast as a PDK 'box, but that doesn't worry me at all.
I have to agree totally with the above, mines only been used in auto during its test drive to check that it actually worked. Really like the fact that an amount of interaction is required to get the best out of the SSIII box

monaco1981

Original Poster:

146 posts

174 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
The GT4 is indeed a manual. I will test drive the v12vs for as long as possible and see how I get on with the box. I love an old school car and is something I want to keep for as long as possible prior to them being killed off and replaced with electric/hybrid technology. Will come back with a view of the SSIII when I have driven it.

PantsFire

519 posts

111 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
I moved from a 991 Carrera S to the older Vanquish with the old 6-speed transmission; is it as good? No. But it's different, just now driving back from lunch on a good B road I went between 30 and whistle several times without changing out of 3rd gear or going past 5000rpm. Does it matter how fast the gear box is when a V12 means you don't need to change gear? biggrin

quench

564 posts

177 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
IMO most of the 'disappointment' people have had with Sportshift stems from an expectation that a paddleshift car must behave like a dual clutch or modern torque converter automatic.

As you know, Sportshift is a manual transmission without a gear stick or clutch pedal. Try to imagine driving your GT4 as if it were configured in such a way, and you will have a pretty good idea of whether you are going to get along with Sportshift, before you have even tried it.

jonby

5,367 posts

188 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
quench said:
IMO most of the 'disappointment' people have had with Sportshift stems from an expectation that a paddleshift car must behave like a dual clutch or modern torque converter automatic.

As you know, Sportshift is a manual transmission without a gear stick or clutch pedal. Try to imagine driving your GT4 as if it were configured in such a way, and you will have a pretty good idea of whether you are going to get along with Sportshift, before you have even tried it.
This, without question, sums it up

As I've said before, a lot of criticism, albeit often misplaced, could be avoided if they just didn't have a 'D' option in SS cars - if you want to drive in auto mode, don't get a single clutch automated manual

CSK1

1,833 posts

155 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
A bit late to the party but here's my input.
I love SportshiftIII, I only use the paddles, slight lifting of the toe to change gear unless going for it where it goes into Hypershift mode and you do not need to lift, after some time you get to master impeccable shifts which is part of the fun, you actually have to interact to get the best out of it unlike a double clutch or a torque converter auto.
I have tried the manual and I didn't like it so horses for courses, it is all very personal and others will rave about the 7 speed manual.
Just don't use the D button ever, D stands for DON'T! smile
You won't be disappointed.
Happy hunting!

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
CSK1 said:
D stands for DON'T! smile
laugh Oh so true!

cypriot

516 posts

130 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
OP - in case you are thinking about getting the manual, I can tell you that the shifting is far more precise in the GT4. But, that doesnt mean the shifting in the v12s is bad, its just looser, and doesnt like to be rushed. In the GT4, you can really bang through the gears, something you can't do in the v12s. But I think that suits the whole character of the v12s anyway, so its not really a bad thing! Its also one of those weird things where literally anyone can drive a manual 981 cayman/boxster very easily as the clutch and gearbox are so easy to operate. by comparison, the v12s shifter needs to be learnt, and thats great!

Cant comment on the ss3 as I have never driven one...