Vanquish vs DB11
Author
Discussion

moveover

Original Poster:

370 posts

194 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
So my 2013 Vanquish is back with the dealership and will be for a while yet ... long story. In the meantime, I have a spanking new DB11 V12 in my driveway. So after a few days with johnny-come-lately, here's a brief comparison:

Looks:
Vanquish wins. Too many nooks and crannies in the bodywork of the DB11. The lines get progressively worse the further back you go. The rear is most odd. The Vanquish will look good for decades to come, more muscular and with more coherent curves. The vents on the DB11 are an excellent conduit for mud, water and road grime thrown up by the tyres; a bit like driving next to a muck-spreader.

Interior:
Again, the Vanq wins. Admittedly I had a light interior in the Vanq, which gave it a more airy feel, whereas the black interior of the DB11 makes it feel more cramped. The speaker grills in the DB11 wouldn’t look out of place in Tandy. The Vanq’s B&O might be overkill, but at least it looks the part.

Tech:
No question the DB11 wins on tech, but I want a car, not a £150k ipad. The adage ‘less-is-more’ springs to mind.

Engine:
The DB11 is blisteringly quick. But I disagree with the auto press’ observations about lack of turbo lag. Yes, it’s not as bad as my 530d BMW, but there is still a distinct lack of progressiveness in the acceleration. I don’t think I could live with the sudden ‘jolt’ at about 4-5k revs. Vanq wins.

Noise:
I drive with the window down in the Vanq. The window has been up in the DB11. Enough said.

Chassis:
DB11 wins. It really is excellent. Compliant over rough surfaces (low road noise too), and stiff when you need it to be, but still without compromising comfort too much (even with dampers on track mode).

Gearbox:
Slightly unfair comparison, ZF 6 speed in Vanq vs. 8 speed in DB11. The 8-speed is great, and changes are noticeably more rapid. But I drive almost exclusively with the paddles, and have yet to select anything above 5 in the DB11, so what’s the point of the other 3.

Boot:
OK, so practicality is not really on the agenda with cars like this, but I can fit two sets of clubs and kit bags in the Vanq. Trying to get anything into the DB11 is a massive faff, and there’s much less space. Everything has to go in low from boot level, rather than in from above which makes it much less accessible. And perhaps I haven’t worked it out yet, but you can’t open the boot any other way except with the key … wft! And no leather pull on the inside to close it again. Vanq wins.


I want my Vanquish back!

ruaricoles

1,243 posts

256 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
If it's a newish DB11 it should have foot-swing to open the boot... With the key in your pocket swing your foot under the middle of the back bumper a couple of times and it should pop. A bit easier anyway! Hope your car gets sorted quickly.

waremark

3,297 posts

244 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
ruaricoles said:
If it's a newish DB11 it should have foot-swing to open the boot... With the key in your pocket swing your foot under the middle of the back bumper a couple of times and it should pop. A bit easier anyway! Hope your car gets sorted quickly.
And they all have a button on the driver's door to open the boot.

waremark

3,297 posts

244 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
I find most of the DB11 interior is gorgeous (possible exception is the iPod like screen, would much prefer to see it integrated). I really have not noticed the 'sudden jolt at 4k-5k'.

I find the engine pleasantly progressive once past 2k - there is a pronounced change at 2k which my V12V didn't have. And in GT mode the exhaust valve opens about 3k if the throttle is far down. To avoid that sudden change (of sound, not pace) don't use GT mode.

The DB11 is finally an Aston with a radio which works well - I find it incredible that it has taken them so long.

AstonV

1,657 posts

137 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Unfortunately the turbo V12 will never sound as good as the NA V12. Sad.

Westlondondriver

385 posts

103 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Whilst I’d agree my DB11 doesn’t sound as good as my old DB9 it still sounds better than almost every other car on the road. Also I can now actually hear the radio and have a conversation in the car ! Admittedly my old ‘05 Volante was probably a bit less refined than a later model coupe but the DB11 is a much easier car to live with in a daily basis. If you just want a bit of fun for an hour or two on a Saturday afternoon I think most people would agree - buy a Vanquish but for regular use the more modern car is way ahead.

Will be interesting to hear the new DBS when they release it