AM Ext. warranty - is it really worth after my claim case?
Discussion
Hello everyone,
I need your advice and opinions on my case. I am a lucky owner of two Astons: V8V (MY 2008) and DBS volante (MY 2011). Both are in perfect conditions, both under extended warranty. I decided to pay for the extended warranty considering it is a good insurance policy if something serious goes wrong. So far there were no serious issues with my cars ... until now.
The story is as follows:
Long weeks ago my DBS started vibration and shuddering during braking at any speed. It was frustrating enough to consult the issue with my local Aston Martin dealer. The dealer did an inspection and did not find anything irregular to the brakes (rotors perfectly bedded, pads worn in 50%). I started a big, painful and costly process of balancing my wheels - I have replaced 2 times all 4 tires, refurbished all alloy wheels and entirely replaced one alloy wheel at the front.
I also was trying to consult my case on 6speeedonline with no luck (https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/aston-martin/419936-ccm-brakes-no-joy-dbs-any-longer.html#post4712298).
The vibration and shuddering did not stop, so I pushed hard my dealer to take the CCM rotors off and inspect them further. Suddenly I received a call that one bolt in the CCM rotor was missing its bolt head, which could indicate to me the whole rotor could fall-apart if other bolts are of similar quality (see pictures). I started panicking as I have never seen anything like that before, even in cheap Italian Fiats, which I used long time ago. It was clear to me that lacking of the bolt head has unbalanced the whole rotors, which caused vibrations, but more importantly I concluded the rotors are simply too dangerous as other bolts could completely malfunction my brakes putting me and my family members at life risk. As I have the warranty coverage for all my Astons I quickly consulted the issue with my lawyers and afterwards asked the local dealer to initiate a warranty claim. I left my car for the whole day for warranty inspector from DEKRA, who unofficially said this kind of failure was a pure factory defect and was a serious life threatening question.
Two days ago I received an information from my local dealer, that the claim has been rejected arguing "the broken bolt is a regular wear and tear of the rotor" (!) Hmm, I asked myself if it means that after 6 years and 52k km on the clock I should expect any or all bolts to be broken, putting at risk my life? Rather not. If this is a wear and tear effect, how could I then understand the brembo statement saying the CCM brakes should "last the lifetime of car"? Aston Martin in the official documentation (service bulletins) clams that CCM rotors should not be replaced at all as they are solid enough to survive the car lifetime. I also could not find any simple word in the service bulletins nor service manuals by AM recommending the rotors replacement due to wear and tear. After consulting the pictures of the broken rotor with different parties I have received a common opinion that this kind of failure is life threatening and could potentially be subject to US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration or European Transport Safety Council proceedings.
Please advise what do you think I should do with this. I am so disappointed with the warranty outcome. I am trying to escalate my case to the extended warranty manager (car care plan). Do you think I should email Mr. Palmer or directly Brembo or perhaps I should do a legal claim against AM?
During last 6 months I spent on my DBS 25 000 EUR (yes, I am not mistaken, this is a bill of refurbishment (I had no accident, just decided to refurbish) my car needed after 6 years – new headlights, carbon slitter and diffuser, wheels, etc).
Roughly, my two Astons' paid in cash cost of the extended warranty was 20.000 euro (8 years for V8V, 2 years for DBS). If I put the money at 3% pa interest rate,I would have today ca 23 000 euro. And now, the Aston Martin expects me to pay for the front brakes another 15 000 EUR. I love Aston Martin brand and the cars and do not want to change it, however I feel really bad with this.
I would appreciate any input and opinions.
Thanks and best regards.


I need your advice and opinions on my case. I am a lucky owner of two Astons: V8V (MY 2008) and DBS volante (MY 2011). Both are in perfect conditions, both under extended warranty. I decided to pay for the extended warranty considering it is a good insurance policy if something serious goes wrong. So far there were no serious issues with my cars ... until now.
The story is as follows:
Long weeks ago my DBS started vibration and shuddering during braking at any speed. It was frustrating enough to consult the issue with my local Aston Martin dealer. The dealer did an inspection and did not find anything irregular to the brakes (rotors perfectly bedded, pads worn in 50%). I started a big, painful and costly process of balancing my wheels - I have replaced 2 times all 4 tires, refurbished all alloy wheels and entirely replaced one alloy wheel at the front.
I also was trying to consult my case on 6speeedonline with no luck (https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/aston-martin/419936-ccm-brakes-no-joy-dbs-any-longer.html#post4712298).
The vibration and shuddering did not stop, so I pushed hard my dealer to take the CCM rotors off and inspect them further. Suddenly I received a call that one bolt in the CCM rotor was missing its bolt head, which could indicate to me the whole rotor could fall-apart if other bolts are of similar quality (see pictures). I started panicking as I have never seen anything like that before, even in cheap Italian Fiats, which I used long time ago. It was clear to me that lacking of the bolt head has unbalanced the whole rotors, which caused vibrations, but more importantly I concluded the rotors are simply too dangerous as other bolts could completely malfunction my brakes putting me and my family members at life risk. As I have the warranty coverage for all my Astons I quickly consulted the issue with my lawyers and afterwards asked the local dealer to initiate a warranty claim. I left my car for the whole day for warranty inspector from DEKRA, who unofficially said this kind of failure was a pure factory defect and was a serious life threatening question.
Two days ago I received an information from my local dealer, that the claim has been rejected arguing "the broken bolt is a regular wear and tear of the rotor" (!) Hmm, I asked myself if it means that after 6 years and 52k km on the clock I should expect any or all bolts to be broken, putting at risk my life? Rather not. If this is a wear and tear effect, how could I then understand the brembo statement saying the CCM brakes should "last the lifetime of car"? Aston Martin in the official documentation (service bulletins) clams that CCM rotors should not be replaced at all as they are solid enough to survive the car lifetime. I also could not find any simple word in the service bulletins nor service manuals by AM recommending the rotors replacement due to wear and tear. After consulting the pictures of the broken rotor with different parties I have received a common opinion that this kind of failure is life threatening and could potentially be subject to US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration or European Transport Safety Council proceedings.
Please advise what do you think I should do with this. I am so disappointed with the warranty outcome. I am trying to escalate my case to the extended warranty manager (car care plan). Do you think I should email Mr. Palmer or directly Brembo or perhaps I should do a legal claim against AM?
During last 6 months I spent on my DBS 25 000 EUR (yes, I am not mistaken, this is a bill of refurbishment (I had no accident, just decided to refurbish) my car needed after 6 years – new headlights, carbon slitter and diffuser, wheels, etc).
Roughly, my two Astons' paid in cash cost of the extended warranty was 20.000 euro (8 years for V8V, 2 years for DBS). If I put the money at 3% pa interest rate,I would have today ca 23 000 euro. And now, the Aston Martin expects me to pay for the front brakes another 15 000 EUR. I love Aston Martin brand and the cars and do not want to change it, however I feel really bad with this.
I would appreciate any input and opinions.
Thanks and best regards.
Your extended warranty docs should give a clear list of what parts are covered, and what aren't. (...and I've never seen any extended warranty that covers brake rotors.)
I assume it's a third-party warranty from http://carcareplan.com/product-warranty.html
Your DBS is seven years old, so I don't think you'd have any luck complaining to AM about a "manufacturing defect".
I assume it's a third-party warranty from http://carcareplan.com/product-warranty.html
Your DBS is seven years old, so I don't think you'd have any luck complaining to AM about a "manufacturing defect".
Brakes are usually not covered by any warranty (as stated by previous post) & are seen as wear & tear items
I agree it is unusual for the bolt head to brake off like this & wonder why it may have happened (I would want to try & get that explained) - the bolts themselves are not wear items in the sense they do not "wear down" like pads do. Is one bolt head shearing life threatening - most likely not, and as has happened it has provided warning by shuddering which you have eventually had correctly diagnosed.
Is the bolt(s) an item you can replace - that is replace all the bolts & continue to use the rotor? Perhaps it can be sent to Brembo by the AM dealer & some sort of shared cost deal be done? I'd want to pursue this course to its end before trying legal avenues as I dont think a legal challenge would be successful (based on my understanding of the laws in my country - yours may differ)
Good luck with resolving this
Graeme
I agree it is unusual for the bolt head to brake off like this & wonder why it may have happened (I would want to try & get that explained) - the bolts themselves are not wear items in the sense they do not "wear down" like pads do. Is one bolt head shearing life threatening - most likely not, and as has happened it has provided warning by shuddering which you have eventually had correctly diagnosed.
Is the bolt(s) an item you can replace - that is replace all the bolts & continue to use the rotor? Perhaps it can be sent to Brembo by the AM dealer & some sort of shared cost deal be done? I'd want to pursue this course to its end before trying legal avenues as I dont think a legal challenge would be successful (based on my understanding of the laws in my country - yours may differ)
Good luck with resolving this
Graeme
Sorry to read about your problem.
When one bolt head broke off, at least you had a warning that a fault had occurred. Presumably all the bolts would not break at the same time, so possibly no need to worry about your life being at risk.
The warranty claim rejection process that you have described, seems to justify my decision several years ago, not to buy an extended warranty. Only a sample of one, but for me, it worked out OK.
Perhaps fitting a full set of new bolts to all disks would be sensible. Maybe originally there was a batch of lower quality bolts.
I don't understand how bolt replacement would cost 15,000 Eur.
Edited by Jon39 on Thursday 24th May 12:51
The CCM discs will not last the lifetime of the car, we've seen quite a few at the end of their lives before 30,000 miles (granted a couple have been tracked)
It's hard to see from the photo but it looks like the surface of your disc is no longer smooth and probably near the end of life. There is a guide somewhere saying that the rotors should be weighed to determine how much life is left in them.
If they pass the weight-in then maybe just replace the bolts as others have said.
It's hard to see from the photo but it looks like the surface of your disc is no longer smooth and probably near the end of life. There is a guide somewhere saying that the rotors should be weighed to determine how much life is left in them.
If they pass the weight-in then maybe just replace the bolts as others have said.
Interesting one this, I would assume the clamping forces woulld be spread evenly over all the bolts, so if one has broken it was either defective or over tightened, if defective then the others are also on their way to the same fate.
The only other reason I could think of for one bolt shearing is if the head had been subjected to impact from something getting trapped in there, a stone or piece of debris flicked up.from.the road.
I would also go with the idea of swapping out all the bolts for new, and get the sheared bolt closely inspected.to see what type of force has been applied, ie sideways leverage or over torque shearing/twisting forces, an expert will tell very quickly by inspecting the break.
The only other reason I could think of for one bolt shearing is if the head had been subjected to impact from something getting trapped in there, a stone or piece of debris flicked up.from.the road.
I would also go with the idea of swapping out all the bolts for new, and get the sheared bolt closely inspected.to see what type of force has been applied, ie sideways leverage or over torque shearing/twisting forces, an expert will tell very quickly by inspecting the break.
Jon39 said:
The warranty claim rejection process that you have described, seems to justify my decision several years ago, not to buy an extended warranty. Only a sample of one, but for me, it worked out OK.
So, been chucking £150 into an account monthly and guess what - this covers EVERYTHING. No forms to fill or arguments to have either

But back to your point - a bolt is not a wear and tear item in anyone's book. Friction surfaces yes, but not bl0ody BOLTS! Don't let them get away with it...
Ken Figenus said:
But back to your point - a bolt is not a wear and tear item in anyone's book. Friction surfaces yes, but not bl0ody BOLTS! Don't let them get away with it...
Don't think OP will be very happy with just a replacement bolt...I suspect the "wear and tear" thing is a something of a red herring and the warranty will expressly exclude brake linings, discs and other friction surfaces.
When I fitted CCM brakes to my early DB9, I bought a set of front discs with many broken bolts like the one here, the bolts are not a service item and cannot be bought from AM or Brembo.
I sorted it by buying a set of cheap used discs to get the bolts, all CCM users should ispect theire bell to disc bolts.
I sorted it by buying a set of cheap used discs to get the bolts, all CCM users should ispect theire bell to disc bolts.
Dear All,
I would like to thank you for all input and I am very happy to inform you that today I received from Aston Martin an update resolving my issue. They decided to fully cover the rotors replacement as a goodwill. What a fantastic customer care! I love the brand and their customer approach where they listen to their customers' argumentation and react so quickly. No I can understand why I have decided to keep the extended warranty for my cars.
Thank you Aston Martin for the way you do! You have another loyal customer waiting for the new DBS to discover.
With best regards,
I would like to thank you for all input and I am very happy to inform you that today I received from Aston Martin an update resolving my issue. They decided to fully cover the rotors replacement as a goodwill. What a fantastic customer care! I love the brand and their customer approach where they listen to their customers' argumentation and react so quickly. No I can understand why I have decided to keep the extended warranty for my cars.
Thank you Aston Martin for the way you do! You have another loyal customer waiting for the new DBS to discover.
With best regards,
chrzesm said:
Dear All,
I would like to thank you for all input and I am very happy to inform you that today I received from Aston Martin an update resolving my issue. They decided to fully cover the rotors replacement as a goodwill. What a fantastic customer care! I love the brand and their customer approach where they listen to their customers' argumentation and react so quickly. No I can understand why I have decided to keep the extended warranty for my cars.
Thank you Aston Martin for the way you do! You have another loyal customer waiting for the new DBS to discover.
With best regards,
Well done and I think a justified result !!I would like to thank you for all input and I am very happy to inform you that today I received from Aston Martin an update resolving my issue. They decided to fully cover the rotors replacement as a goodwill. What a fantastic customer care! I love the brand and their customer approach where they listen to their customers' argumentation and react so quickly. No I can understand why I have decided to keep the extended warranty for my cars.
Thank you Aston Martin for the way you do! You have another loyal customer waiting for the new DBS to discover.
With best regards,
A good result, but one thing I don't understand :
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
chrzesm said:
one bolt in the CCM rotor was missing its bolt head
I had this on my V12V a couple of years back, was very lucky to get away with replacing just the single disc at my cost as the other was in perfect condition.Sounds like I should have pushed harder as it clearly isn't the isolated incident suggested by the dealer I was dealing with.
Edited by JaseB on Thursday 24th May 12:40
davek_964 said:
A good result, but one thing I don't understand :
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
I'm not sure the original vibration issue has actually been resolved, just the replacement/cost of rotors by AM due to sheared bolt head.It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
It wouldn't surprise me if the issue was still there afterwards, but I'm hoping it gets fixed and everyone's happy.
davek_964 said:
A good result, but one thing I don't understand :
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Wheels aren't balanced on the car - they are usually balanced off the car so cant account for the imbalanced rotor?It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Good result OP - story #2 this week of AM really looking after customers (the other one was about a V8 that had thrown a rod...). And then you think how Porsche treat people with scored bores at 15k miles...)

Ken Figenus said:
davek_964 said:
A good result, but one thing I don't understand :
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Wheels aren't balanced on the car - they are usually balanced off the car so cant account for the imbalanced rotor?It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Good result OP - story #2 this week of AM really looking after customers (the other one was about a V8 that had thrown a rod...). And then you think how Porsche treat people with scored bores at 15k miles...)


davek_964 said:
A good result, but one thing I don't understand :
It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Yes, the wheel was fully re-balanced, however the issue was outside the wheel, ie in the rotor itself, which lost its balance. When I started complaining about the vibration, the dealer checked brakes and wheels saying "brakes are ok, do the wheels balancing". I started with rims (alloy) regeneration as they had some white spots. It did not work. Then I bought new Pirelli set of tires, which were very difficult to balance even using Hunter balancer. The guys recommended to replace the tires, so I bought Michelin (btw way much better compared to Pirelli) and it did not work as well. The last bit was to replace suspected front rim and I did it. For sure all the process made my wheels perfectly balanced and indeed, I did not feel the vibration during drive any longer, however I did when braking. I was told, I should avoid balancing the entire wheels "on the car" as it will be a short-term effect, ie each wheel must be fully balanced outside the car, and I need to find a source of the vibration within the car. I pushed my dealer to take the rotors off and inspect all suspension. Then, the broken bolt was found...:-(It makes sense that losing the bolt head would unbalance a previously balanced wheel. But according to the original post, you then spent a lot of time (and money) trying to get rid of the vibration - including re-balancing the wheels. Whilst I realise it wouldn't have resolved the underlying issue - I don't understand how re-balancing the wheel didn't compensate for the missing bolt head. Why did vibration continue if the wheel had been re-balanced after the bolt head was lost?
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



