V8V Sportshift gearbox issues
V8V Sportshift gearbox issues
Author
Discussion

JevoH

Original Poster:

4 posts

193 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
This is my first post so please bear with me. I've been a lurker since last summer and took the plunge and got myself a 2009MY V8 Vantage in December. All has been fine so far except a few small usual issues. The car went in for a routine service at an AM main dealer almost two weeks ago, with my only concerns being a squeak coming from the rear at slow speeds which I believed was the usual handbrake needing an adjustment. To my surprise after having the car for 4 days they eventually got in contact with me with a list of various bit that they recommended needing doing. Most of them small unnecessary or cosmetic things.

The major one that concerned me was the gearbox/clutch needed further investigation into 'poor shift quality while driving' and 'slight clutch judder'. This came as a surprise as the car shifts smoothly on the paddles (used 99% of the time) and even on the occasion times I've used the car in D mode I've not noticed anything untoward. I have occasionally noticed some very slight clutch judder when pulling away however (doesn't seem to do it in creep mode). The car does have 3rd party warranty cover which includes main dealer labour rates and single claims up to the cost of the car. It is also worth noting the car has done 32K but the clutch was replaced by the previous owner at 23.5K. They tried telling me a gearbox oil change would hopefully sort it, but then got back to me to say it needed to be taken apart to investigate further as they suspected potential gearbox component wear.

I'd accepted the fact that it may need a new clutch already and if it was any more sinister then the warranty should take care of it. Today after 12 days of them having the car I've had to chase them for further answers. They eventually got back to me this afternoon saying that they'd begun to strip the gearbox but it looked like it was okay and it appeared to need an upgrade to some of the components. These include the 'propshaft speed sensor', 'SB-07-0315V4 sportshift driveability procedure' and 'new brake pedal switch with new type wiring modification'. I do have a limited knowledge of the car but this is above mine.

The dilemma I'm facing is that they've now suggested 3 different solutions, all of which are very different. Has anyone heard of having these last mentioned components changed? I'm reluctant to keep throwing money at diagnostics if the warranty company turn around and say its not covered.

Thanks for reading and any help or recommendation is appreciated.



macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
First impression is, they are yanking your chain. Who gave the go ahead to strip the gearbox to find no fault?

BamfordMike

1,192 posts

188 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
To find root cause of the symptoms you state is a laptop only job.

A gear position plot and relearn (called Octopus test on the AMDS) informs if anything is a miss with gearbox mechanicals and sensor, but that’s got nothing to do with clutch / pull away or judder!! But more to do with how well the system will select each gear. So if you’ve never experienced missed gears, then suspecting base gearbox is your problem doesn’t make too much sense.

Next, there are laptop parameters which inform slave cylinder travel required for clutch to kiss flywheel, and then stroke of slave cylinder required to operate the clutch. Analysis of these numbers will calculate a total wear figure / reference if problem is within clutch assembly.

The above diagnostic takes no longer than 1hr on laptop, a ramp is not needed and the data will inform what to do - done this countless times, so from experience reading the approach your car is going through, doesn’t seem data driven or logical given the symptoms, but if the car is on the ramp and stripped, you’re kind of already at their mercy unfortunately

JevoH

Original Poster:

4 posts

193 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for your reply Mike. In terms of 'missed gears' I have two occasions had a situation where I'd accelerated moderately in 3rd gear and the car hesitated, almost like it briefly disengaged the gear before re-engaging split seconds later. It happened on a full fuel tank and hasn't happened since so I thought it may be the fuel vapour line.

I am hoping that AM would have used AMDS to diagnose initially, but nothing would surprise me with this garage to be honest. It appears they have also broken part of the of the ignition dock where the ECU slots in since its been there. I may be in contact with you shortly Mike.